r/NavyBlazer • u/T49irvine • 10h ago
A few thoughts about Ivy or Collegiate Style
I realize that this sub is broader than Ivy or collegiate style, but I sometimes find myself making comments that reflect a narrow take on Ivy rather than the broader spirit of this sub. Before those of us who lived the waning years of Ivy in the fifties and sixties are gone, I thought folk might like to know how some of the preposterous ideas like brown shoes with everything but evening wear and navy suits came to be.
Every generation seems to feel a need to rebel or at least push back. As a Boomer, it was the hippy era and long hair. For younger generations it might have been tattoos. For college kids in the Ivy era it was insouciance, breaking free of the discomfort of starched collars. It was a slouchy time when the comfort of sack jackets extended to unstarched shirts and even rumpled khakis. Weejuns were adopted as the shoe of choice and worn until by the end of spring term they were held together by duct tape. Improbably combinations like rain parkas over blazers or Shetland crewnecks under Madras jackets were born of exigency, using a suitcase wardrobe to contend with fickle weather and old poorly heated and never air conditioned schools. The crazy idea of going sockless came from hasty dressing after showering when coming off the practice field and hurrying to get the heck home or to a dorm.
An image has been conjured of well turned out young gentlemen with perfectly selected (I am not a fan of using "curated" indiscriminately) outfits, but those kids, especially on vacation, were more likely wearing jeans, sweatshirts, sockless tennis shoes, and untucked shirts. Brown shoes went with everything because other than tennies, that was what they had, especially if away at school, and vigilant teachers and monitors would hand out demerits for anything other than leather shoes with socks.
As regards the bold colors and patterns of preppy fame, they were on the way but not yet there. Most Madras was somewhat, or even quite, muted, never patch, and limited to either jackets or ties at school and shorts and shirts when out of school. Shirts worn with ties at school were almost always blue or white, rarely yellow, and, especially in the Virginia schools, sometimes pink. In the sixties there was a lot of ecru (now greatly missed). Colors like green or lavender were not available. So the kids grew up never considering them. Except for kids rich enough to spend time on Nantucket, go to hell pants were not common.
So the stereotypical outfit aligns with coming from a student wardrobe that fit in a large suitcase or small trunk. The frayed collar and the cuffed and rumpled high water pants, sack jacket regardless of physique, and four in hand repp tie with Weejuns and a surcingle Canterbury belt, were all quite common.