First of all, I want to say this is simply my opinion on this, okay? I recently posted a couple of things giving my opinion on the show, along with some early leaked images, and 80% of the comments were negative. Everyone here is a fan of this series. I, at least, have been for years, ever since I first saw the films (back in the 2000s), which inspired me to read the books. I think having followed this series for so long gives me some right, simply as a reader, to be able to think critically and admit to myself that these books, while beautiful and a big part of my childhood, aren't perfect. While it's true that they were written as children's books, which is noticeable when reading, that doesn't excuse the fact that several of them have (in my opinion) flaws that, had I known the series differently, might have made me stop reading and drop it halfway through.
Now, regarding the specific title of this post, here's my explanation:
Literally an hour ago, I finished my complete reread of The Magician's Nephew. It's the first time in years that I've reread these books. I've done it before, but it's been a long time since I've bothered to read the entire saga. I have a vague recollection of my general opinions on each book, but now I'll talk specifically about TMN, which is the basis for the first season of Greta's show (and which, for me, is also the first book in the chronicles, since whenever I reread the books, I always do so chronologically).
What I find with this story in particular is that, while it perfectly serves its purpose of being a prequel to the Pevensie siblings' "trilogy" (this is speaking once you already know their story) on its own, if a new reader comes along who hasn't read the previous five books or seen any of the movies, this latest reread made me realize that this book doesn't stand up on its own.
The problem is: The Magician's Nephew is a book with a thousand interesting plot points, but whose main idea seems to be just to give us a story with dozens of Easter eggs that are there to connect the story of the creation of Narnia with that of the Pevensies: Digory, Jadis, Aslan (obviously), the lamp post, the wardrobe...
Yet, all the points that, at least I personally, consider to be the most interesting in this book are cut off at the most interesting moments, or else aren't explored as much as they could be.
My main problem with Digory's story in particular is that, aside from the fact that he and Polly get involved in the whole magic rings thing, the story has no conflict whatsoever. Or rather: the story has no conflict IN NARNIA, which is a problem, considering it's the first book, chronologically speaking, in The Chronicles of Narnia...
After my recent reread, I can say that the first half is the most interesting part of the book. Literally, out of fifteen total chapters, the chapters with the best scenes happen from chapter one to chapter seven (What Happened at the Front Door), which is... literally one chapter before the characters travel to Narnia for the first time.
After that, the book takes a strange turn. Suddenly, it seems Digory is no longer the protagonist, but we still hear his thoughts. However, the main focus of the following chapters is completely on Aslan. Until chapter 12, when Aslan gives Digory his mission, he is no longer the center of attention, let alone poor Polly; the last interesting thing that happened to her was that her parents sent her to her room for two hours, grounded for playing in the puddles.
The creation of Narnia takes three full chapters, which makes sense if we call this book "the book of the creation of Narnia", but at the same time, it's something that loses significance when much of those three chapters could be reduced to just one (maybe one and a half) and the remaining time used to do something more productive with the two protagonists. Chapter ten (The First Joke and Other Matters) literally only deals with talking animals talking to Aslan, from which "the first joke in Narnia" comes. You could almost easily skip from chapter 9 to 11, and you wouldn't miss anything of much value.
And what’s worse: while the antagonist of this book is Jadis, and while she also loses prominence drastically after chapter eight, WE DO HAVE a moment in which the climax of the story could have developed and a confrontation between her, Digory and Polly (when Digory sees her in the garden stealing the apple), but nevertheless, they escape from there as if nothing happened, and that event doesn’t go any further. The only thing that comes out of that is that Jadis will suddenly become immortal and will be an evil that will stalk Narnia for centuries... and literally nobody did ANYTHING to stop it, not even the two people that Aslan specifically sent to that place, at that moment, on a special mission.
So, in short, yes: Greta Gerwig's show MUST modify its script if it wants to survive more than one season, because basically, a show without a climax (or almost without a conflict at all, other than the one a handful of characters accidentally ended up creating in that magical world) isn't a show at all. The writers will have to do something, similar to what the writers of Prince Caspian did when they gave us the action scenes in the second film, with the Battle of Telmar and the Second Battle of Beruna, which (if I remember correctly, but correct me if I'm wrong because I haven't reread this book yet) is only described by Caspian in the second book, but we never see it happen.
And here comes something that many might not like to read, but that fans of literary series often don't understand when they see on-screen adaptations: adaptations, whether film or TV, are just that: ADAPTATIONS. One has to adapt the story of a book for it to be productive in a new format. That page-to-screen adaptation can be more or less faithful to the original events, and that depends on the director. But writing a children's book, whose purpose isn't to create an action story but rather to culminate in a lesson for children, isn't the same as writing an adaptation of a supernatural fantasy story where the interesting thing that happens in a span of three chapters is having a lion talking to wild animals and a crow telling a joke... the screen time is different; stories should be different, faster-paced, with more movement and action. This book in particular lacks a lot of action. There's plenty of action in all the events on Charn and in the Place Between, and the Jadis sequence in London is also fun, but unfortunately, none of those scenes last very long on their own. It seems to me that the show will conclude Charn's story perhaps by the second or third episode of the season. And then what? What will we get in all the remaining episodes?
There are many small subplots in the book that can be used as motivations for the protagonists. Digory's intention to save his mother is the main one, and one of the most courageous of all. But that arc could be developed much further than simply the idea of "Mabel was saved because Digory didn't steal an apple but gave it to Aslan". Uncle Andrew should have more to do in Narnia than just be "stuck" (literally) by talking animals. And Polly should have a damn motivation in the magical world, while we're at it.
I don't know, it's just something I've been thinking about this hour, since I finished reading. And I wanted to vent here. I hope you'll take the time to read and not attack this post just because of your first impressions. As I said, many of us here have been fans of this series and these books since we were children. Many of us are adults now. That allows us to look at these stories with a much more critical eye than the first time we read them.