r/Narnia • • Mar 31 '25

What im hearing better not be true?

4 Upvotes

Ive just read somewhere that Aslan will be female if thats true then this adaptation has failed already and will be the next snowwhite or maybe even worse knowing the pst movies if the director Greta Gerwug


r/Narnia • • Oct 15 '26

Discussion Surprised to see how many people think the trailer is good and are now optimistic about the movie.

14 Upvotes

Visually, the movie looks really good.

Was anyone really concerned on if the movie would look visually stunning?

However, what we can take away from the trailer, is that Gerwig is really does seem to be going with the "rock and roll" version of Narnia that she has been talking about.

I was not a fan of the music choice at all, surprised most people liked it.

Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I don't want modern Led Zeppelin rock in a medieval high fantasy movie.

So peoples fears of her "modernizing" the Narnia story seem to be coming to fruition.

I'm assuming people are going to say "its just the trailer", but I don't why she would sign off on the trailer having this music if she wasn't going to include it in the movie.

So let's say for the sake of the argument, the soundtrack is like modern rock. We are all ok with this?

An even more interesting question that I want to pose to the people who are constantly advocating for a "new", "fresh", "unique", take on the movie, if the song Aslan sings to create Narnia is some sort of rock and roll Led Zeppelin style song....y'all are going to be ok with that? Think its cool / awesome / unique?

So we didn't get much from the trailer but what we can take away is that people that were concerned that Gerwig is going to try and be unique by adding modern elements to Narnia like "rock and roll" are having their concerns well founded.


r/Narnia • • 20d ago Bravo

C.S. Lewis I don’t think Narnia is supposed to be the Christian propaganda that some people want it to be

0 Upvotes

For starters:This post is meant to encourage civilised discussion and sharing of opinions, I don’t mean to imply the superiority of any worldview and deeply respect religious diversity.
I’m also not quite sure of what flare to use, I guess this could be a Netflix discussion as well.

I KNOW that C.S. Lewis was Christian and I know he deeply wove his faith into the fabric of Narnia. That being said, I’ve seen a lot of people saying that they are scared of Greta Gerwig disregarding the Christian motives of the books, but I don’t think she betrays the spirit of the stories, if she doesn’t take it on from a Christian point of view.

I’ve grown up Christian and the only reason why Narnia was allowed in our household with all the witchcraft and magic, was because it’s a Christian story. Growing up, I’ve abandoned faith, deconstructed the doctrines I grew up with and found a new meaning for spirituality and faith, that isn’t tied to the Christian definition of it.
I’ve discovered that behind a lot of old books and movies I used to like, there are deeply indoctrinating narratives, that glorify the reproduction of exclusion and hate. Yet Narnia remains being a spiritually inspiring piece of literature to me. That’s because it was never tied to any religious institution in the first place.

Some elements of the stories are undoubtedly heavily influenced by Lewis’ socialisation and worldview (the villains of Calormen being “barbaric” dark haired dark skinned humans for example, yikes), but in the last Book I found the reason for why these stories feel so relatable and spiritually inspiring to me, even without sharing the faith of the author on a surface level.
Aslan explains that he doesn’t weigh actions by their names or supposed motives, but by what they are at their core. So, a service in the name of Tashlan can be a service done for Aslan, depending on its nature. This opened my eyes, because this is the red string that connects all the stories to one another and that allowed me to see why I don’t feel like Narnia contradicts with my present faith.

Lewis doesn’t make faith out to be set in stone by definitions and labels, but rather by actions and authenticity. And that’s why I think at the heart of the stories there is not a religion, a doctrine or a rigid ideology, but the belief in good, in love and in peace. No matter the name it bears.

I feel like I’ve seen a lot of people disregard the new adaptation out of a fear of the “unfaithful”, because in modern Christian circles the “unfaithful” is oftentimes demonised and disregarded as (more or less) blasphemous.
But Narnia was never supposed to be exclusive to a group of people. Narnia isn’t supposed to be this special piece of media, printed on a flag that people could wave around whilst shouting “look, this is Christian!” It’s a story of people discovering the light in themselves, despite living in a world full of darkness.
It’s Edmund transforming his spiteful personality to one of grace and kindness. It’s Shasta discovering his true royal self, after a life of poverty. It’s the Calormene Emeth, who has been devoted to Tash all his life, only to find out that the name of his God doesn’t matter, as long as he does the right things in service to him.

If I’m honest, I’m not looking forward to the new adaptation either. Judging by the teaser, it doesn’t feel like Narnia, it feels like it’s being used as a vessel to bring something entirely different to life. But I don’t think that is for reasons of faith, ideology or religion. I think even without a Christian narrative, this movie could have the potential to be Narnia at its core.


r/Narnia • • Sep 23 '26

As a fan of Greta Gerwig's works and Narnia movies, i implore you to hold judgement until at least trailers come out

Post image
82 Upvotes

I have seen a lot of hate for the upcoming movie all just based on screenshots, but if you haven't watched Greta Gerwig's directorial works (i have seen 2 of the 3, all except Barbie) please try and hold judgement cause she is a great writer and director.

  1. Lady Bird- written and directed by her entirely its one of the best coming of the age story i have seen, and coming of the age part fits perfectly for Narnia

  2. Little Women- its a adaptation of a very old novel, but Greta Gerwigs adaptation is much better compared to 1994 version (personally speaking ofc, its much better ending). So imo we can see her adaptation of material on display in this movie. And i trust her to adapt Narnia as much as as anyone.

Don't take my word for it, watch Lady Bird and Little Women (2019) for yourself, i personally think both are great movies.


r/Narnia • • Sep 18 '26

"C.S. Lewis is be rolling in his grave at Aslan being voiced by a woman" Meanwhile Julian of Norwich, who C.S. Lewis actually read and admired

Post image
19 Upvotes

projection is one hell of a drug


r/Narnia • • Aug 12 '25

Discussion Greta Gerwig wants to gender-swap Aslan — this feels like a betrayal to C.S. Lewis, the Christian allegory, and my entire generation’s childhood

19 Upvotes

I can’t even begin to describe how deeply The Chronicles of Narnia shaped my childhood. These weren’t just books to me — they were foundational stories that helped form my imagination, my values, and my understanding of courage, sacrifice, and redemption.

Every night, I fell asleep listening to the Focus on the Family Radio Theatre dramatizations of the Narnia tales. I knew every line, every pause, every swell of music when Aslan appeared. Those stories didn’t just entertain me — they moved me. They planted seeds in my heart that still grow today. And I know I’m not alone. For so many in my generation, Narnia was a safe place, a magical world that also pointed to something eternal.

So when I hear that Greta Gerwig is planning to cast Meryl Streep as a female Aslan, I feel like my heart is being wrung out. This isn’t just “changing a character” — Aslan is the heart of the story. He’s not a generic lion. He’s a deliberate, powerful allegory for Jesus Christ. His maleness isn’t random — it’s part of the symbolism C.S. Lewis very intentionally built.

To change that is to break something sacred. It’s to take a symbol that pointed clearly to the Son of God and muddy it beyond recognition. And it feels like such a casual decision, like it’s just another creative “twist” for the sake of modern reimagining. But this isn’t just fiction. For millions of us, this is personal.

If anyone should voice Aslan, it’s Liam Neeson — the man who already breathed life into him with such warmth, authority, and majesty. Just as James Earl Jones will always be Mufasa, Liam Neeson will always be Aslan for us.

I’m honestly grieving this news. Greta may be a talented filmmaker, but this choice feels careless, disrespectful, and disconnected from what Narnia means to so many.

If you grew up on these stories — whether you read the books, saw the films, or listened to the audio dramas — I think you understand exactly why this feels so wrong.

Am I being too protective here, or do you feel it too?


r/Narnia • • Mar 17 '25

Discussion Was I the only one that got upset when, growing up, I read that it was all a religious allegory?

0 Upvotes

I read the books as a kid and loved them. Then in high school I discovered that it was all a biblical allegory and got very upset and disappointed ('m not religious).

edit: I still love the books tho


r/Narnia • • Sep 18 '26

Discussion Everything about Greta's take on Aslan is brilliant to me. The kaleidoscopic creature textures (fur, feathers, scales) call to mind biblically-accurate angels and prophetic beasts. And the juxtaposition of a male lion with an older woman's voice feels totally unearthly, divine.

Post image
277 Upvotes

Furthermore, many people seem not to grasp that a woman voicing a lion doesn't mean the lion itself is female. First of all, let’s start with the basic fact that LIONS DON’T TALK as humans does, so there is nothing to suggest their voices would sound just like human ones.

Secondly, keep in mind that the role of Aslan—regardless of who plays it—is a voice-acting role. The fact that most international productions throughout history (shows, movies, musicals, etc) originated in English-speaking countries/lenguages might explain why many people aren't accustomed to how voice acting works. At the very least, a significant number of male characters are frequently voiced by women. This is nothing new, really.


r/Narnia • • Oct 14 '26

What Aslan Means To Me

Post image
0 Upvotes

I am a Christian, and faith has been the lifelong adventure of my life. It has not always been an easy journey, but it has been a living one.

The Bible speaks of the Holy Spirit as fully God, the Lord and giver of life: the one who awakens us, unites us to Christ, renews our hearts and minds, and dwells within God’s people. I know not everyone believes this. I can only speak for myself: He is real to me, and what Scripture says of Him has become real in my own life.

The Holy Spirit is a person, not an impersonal power or force. He is someone you can know. For a Christian, He is not merely an idea to understand, but a presence to encounter and a relationship to live.

And as with any relationship, the more I have come to know Him, the more clearly I have recognized His character. The Holy Spirit I have encountered is the one revealed in the Bible. There are many ways I could describe the personality I have come to know. But a very special and accurate rendering I have found exists within a story, embodied in a character: Aslan.

Not only in what Alan does, or what he says, but in the very nature of what Aslan is. To be near him is to feel the magnificent force of goodness: noble and true, and powerful. Yet, also utterly overwhelming, and even terrifying, while knowing without a shred of doubt he is wholly good, and most certainly I am not.

That is why The Chronicles of Narnia are so special to me. They give shape to something I have known through faith: the wonder, the cost, and the joy of encountering the holy. I believe very much that C. S. Lewis knew the adventure of faith too, and wrote from that knowledge, intimately knowing the personality of someone I know too. And that is why Aslan must always be depicted as he is meant to be: not tame, not diminished, but radiant with goodness and awe.


r/Narnia • • Sep 23 '26

Discussion Greta Gerwig's Aslan reveal

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Narnia • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion Trailer Visually appealing Visually not Narnia

15 Upvotes

1st. Uncle Andrew portrayal is so off hes supposed to be cowardly and evil messing with powers he doesn’t understand. Going into his lab during the trailer felt like I was watching Harry Potter it looked good but it’s not what it’s supposed to feel like… Charn feels like the chocolate factory from Willy Wonka or wonderland from Alice in wonderland… not what it’s supposed to look… it’s a dead world the sun is dying because the Empress Jadis spoke the deplorable word… it’s supposed to be silent no plants, no people, no bugs, nothing… the silence is so silent it’s disturbing the statues are supposed to kind of scare u… Aslan is cool so far tho


r/Narnia • • May 02 '25

Discussion Why not have a Christian helm the new films?

0 Upvotes

Greta Gerwig is NOT one. That's why she is trying to get away with things like making Aslan female. So she wants to remove the whole Jesus analogy, which is VERY important to the story. That's what happens when you take someone who made a boat load of money off a movie that belittles men and put them in charge of a franchise that needs someone who understands the material properly to make.


r/Narnia • • Sep 22 '26

HoW dO yOu KnOw YoU wOnT lIkE iT uNlEsS yOu TrY iT

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

I get the "don't judge a book by its cover" argument but we've not just been aesthetic glimpses (nearly all of them terrible so far), but have been given information on story changes so profound that the word "reimagining" is being thrown around like crazy.

When someone makes comment that they don't like the direction of the production or the changes made, which is their right to their own opinion, others dismissively counter "just give it a chance." Here is the thing, if you read something unappetizing on a menu then see the dish and the looks put you off too, how likely would you be just to "give it a chance."

But thats just me... and for those who are excited, I hope the movie is rewarding for you.


r/Narnia • • Oct 22 '25

I'm guessing this post will be downvoted by book purists who I see constantly scolding how little is known about the show so far, but here's my opinion: if they want the first season to be a success, the book's story MUST be changed. [Please, read the post].

Post image
0 Upvotes

First of all, I want to say this is simply my opinion on this, okay? I recently posted a couple of things giving my opinion on the show, along with some early leaked images, and 80% of the comments were negative. Everyone here is a fan of this series. I, at least, have been for years, ever since I first saw the films (back in the 2000s), which inspired me to read the books. I think having followed this series for so long gives me some right, simply as a reader, to be able to think critically and admit to myself that these books, while beautiful and a big part of my childhood, aren't perfect. While it's true that they were written as children's books, which is noticeable when reading, that doesn't excuse the fact that several of them have (in my opinion) flaws that, had I known the series differently, might have made me stop reading and drop it halfway through.

Now, regarding the specific title of this post, here's my explanation:

Literally an hour ago, I finished my complete reread of The Magician's Nephew. It's the first time in years that I've reread these books. I've done it before, but it's been a long time since I've bothered to read the entire saga. I have a vague recollection of my general opinions on each book, but now I'll talk specifically about TMN, which is the basis for the first season of Greta's show (and which, for me, is also the first book in the chronicles, since whenever I reread the books, I always do so chronologically).

What I find with this story in particular is that, while it perfectly serves its purpose of being a prequel to the Pevensie siblings' "trilogy" (this is speaking once you already know their story) on its own, if a new reader comes along who hasn't read the previous five books or seen any of the movies, this latest reread made me realize that this book doesn't stand up on its own.

The problem is: The Magician's Nephew is a book with a thousand interesting plot points, but whose main idea seems to be just to give us a story with dozens of Easter eggs that are there to connect the story of the creation of Narnia with that of the Pevensies: Digory, Jadis, Aslan (obviously), the lamp post, the wardrobe...

Yet, all the points that, at least I personally, consider to be the most interesting in this book are cut off at the most interesting moments, or else aren't explored as much as they could be.

My main problem with Digory's story in particular is that, aside from the fact that he and Polly get involved in the whole magic rings thing, the story has no conflict whatsoever. Or rather: the story has no conflict IN NARNIA, which is a problem, considering it's the first book, chronologically speaking, in The Chronicles of Narnia...

After my recent reread, I can say that the first half is the most interesting part of the book. Literally, out of fifteen total chapters, the chapters with the best scenes happen from chapter one to chapter seven (What Happened at the Front Door), which is... literally one chapter before the characters travel to Narnia for the first time.

After that, the book takes a strange turn. Suddenly, it seems Digory is no longer the protagonist, but we still hear his thoughts. However, the main focus of the following chapters is completely on Aslan. Until chapter 12, when Aslan gives Digory his mission, he is no longer the center of attention, let alone poor Polly; the last interesting thing that happened to her was that her parents sent her to her room for two hours, grounded for playing in the puddles.

The creation of Narnia takes three full chapters, which makes sense if we call this book "the book of the creation of Narnia", but at the same time, it's something that loses significance when much of those three chapters could be reduced to just one (maybe one and a half) and the remaining time used to do something more productive with the two protagonists. Chapter ten (The First Joke and Other Matters) literally only deals with talking animals talking to Aslan, from which "the first joke in Narnia" comes. You could almost easily skip from chapter 9 to 11, and you wouldn't miss anything of much value.

And what’s worse: while the antagonist of this book is Jadis, and while she also loses prominence drastically after chapter eight, WE DO HAVE a moment in which the climax of the story could have developed and a confrontation between her, Digory and Polly (when Digory sees her in the garden stealing the apple), but nevertheless, they escape from there as if nothing happened, and that event doesn’t go any further. The only thing that comes out of that is that Jadis will suddenly become immortal and will be an evil that will stalk Narnia for centuries... and literally nobody did ANYTHING to stop it, not even the two people that Aslan specifically sent to that place, at that moment, on a special mission.

So, in short, yes: Greta Gerwig's show MUST modify its script if it wants to survive more than one season, because basically, a show without a climax (or almost without a conflict at all, other than the one a handful of characters accidentally ended up creating in that magical world) isn't a show at all. The writers will have to do something, similar to what the writers of Prince Caspian did when they gave us the action scenes in the second film, with the Battle of Telmar and the Second Battle of Beruna, which (if I remember correctly, but correct me if I'm wrong because I haven't reread this book yet) is only described by Caspian in the second book, but we never see it happen.

And here comes something that many might not like to read, but that fans of literary series often don't understand when they see on-screen adaptations: adaptations, whether film or TV, are just that: ADAPTATIONS. One has to adapt the story of a book for it to be productive in a new format. That page-to-screen adaptation can be more or less faithful to the original events, and that depends on the director. But writing a children's book, whose purpose isn't to create an action story but rather to culminate in a lesson for children, isn't the same as writing an adaptation of a supernatural fantasy story where the interesting thing that happens in a span of three chapters is having a lion talking to wild animals and a crow telling a joke... the screen time is different; stories should be different, faster-paced, with more movement and action. This book in particular lacks a lot of action. There's plenty of action in all the events on Charn and in the Place Between, and the Jadis sequence in London is also fun, but unfortunately, none of those scenes last very long on their own. It seems to me that the show will conclude Charn's story perhaps by the second or third episode of the season. And then what? What will we get in all the remaining episodes?

There are many small subplots in the book that can be used as motivations for the protagonists. Digory's intention to save his mother is the main one, and one of the most courageous of all. But that arc could be developed much further than simply the idea of ​​"Mabel was saved because Digory didn't steal an apple but gave it to Aslan". Uncle Andrew should have more to do in Narnia than just be "stuck" (literally) by talking animals. And Polly should have a damn motivation in the magical world, while we're at it.

I don't know, it's just something I've been thinking about this hour, since I finished reading. And I wanted to vent here. I hope you'll take the time to read and not attack this post just because of your first impressions. As I said, many of us here have been fans of this series and these books since we were children. Many of us are adults now. That allows us to look at these stories with a much more critical eye than the first time we read them.


r/Narnia • • Sep 21 '26

Discussion Is it just that we haven’t gotten anything new in a long time so we’re naturally all a bit touchy or are we really such a boring fandom that we can’t handle an adaptation with a little bit of sauce?

0 Upvotes

Right now, I’m choosing to believe it’s the former and I think that’s understandable but hear me out: I totally get not being quite as hopeful about this movie as I am. I get not everyone messes with the rock opera aesthetic idea like I do and I get people may have doubts about some of the designs, I didn’t expect Jadis to look like that either, but geez louise guys, can we give it a little bit of a chance. I’ve seen people saying it’s not even a real adaptation and stuff like that which is crazy because it hasn’t even come out yet. I’m sorry it doesn’t look like the drawings you like from the book but aside from those aesthetic differences and the time period change, which I have no problem with, there hasn’t actually been a single piece of information revealed about the film to truly indicate it won’t be a faithful adaptation of the story. Adaptations are not checklists, and without some kind of fresh new take on the story, what is the point of adapting anything at all? If all you want is something exactly like the book in every way, go read the book again.
I also want to remind people that while the books are very much inspired by and at times allegorical of the Bible and those elements are certainly important to remember in adapting it, they are first and foremost fantasy stories for children. Even Lewis himself didn’t like the idea of them being read as direct allegories. I’ve seen a lot of criticisms about Aslan’s design and voice for the film coming from a place of “what Jesus is supposed to be” which makes no sense to me because no matter your stance on Jesus, while based on him, Aslan is a fictional character from children’s fantasy books!
Look, I’m not saying everyone should put all their concerns aside and get super excited about this film right now, but is it so much to ask that we be a little more open minded til we at least get a trailer?
Also , to be completely fair I do wanna say that, while overly negative, most of the discussion I’ve seen on here about it has actually been quite civil and the bulk of the issue is more with twitter and other apps.


r/Narnia • • Sep 20 '26

Discussion Is there anyone here who is really excited for the film?

29 Upvotes

I love 80s fantasy films. I love fantasy rock. I love Narnia. I've read every book countless times. I love the thematic implications of casting a woman as Aslan and basing his look off of someone famously androgynous.

I just think it looks so fantastic in just about every way. The only thing I'm iffy about is the time period change.

Is there anyone else out there who thinks this looks really good? I'd love to find a bit of positivity; I feel so good about it, but everywhere is so negative.


r/Narnia • • Aug 14 '25

There goes the rumor of Digory being half ethnic Indian

2 Upvotes

I know there was a rumor that Digory’s dad was Indian, which would’ve made Digory half ethnic Indian. This would’ve made a lot of sense even in late 1800’s England and its relationship to British colonial India. But from the casting images we’ve seen, that doesn’t appear to be the case at all. Or, at least, it doesn’t appear so.

It’s too bad. That would’ve been one change that I thought would’ve been great.


r/Narnia • • Oct 16 '26 Mindblown Bravo

Here comes the push to have Gerwig critical posts censored and removed

Post image
170 Upvotes

Proposed change 3 looks like a very obvious not back door to silence people who speak out against the changes


r/Narnia • • Sep 18 '26

Discussion meryl streep as aslan

0 Upvotes

i’ve been reading posts and comments about meryl streep voice acting aslan and there’s a lot of negativity.

personally meryl streep is one of those people who would be good in any role, including a man, watch this clip where meryl streep plays a rabbi and i didn’t even know it was her!!

voice acting is an amazing field and there’s so much media where women will play male characters and i think meryl with do an amazing job


r/Narnia • • Oct 13 '26

Discussion Don't get me wrong, but I'm starting to have a few second thoughts about the vote of confidence I was giving the new movie.

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

The trailer didn't quite leave me with a good impression, and on top of that, I just finished reading the manga adaptation of the first book.


r/Narnia • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion The 80s vibe makes total sense

5 Upvotes

So I watched and loved the trailer. One of the things I loved about it was the 80s energy because it completely fits with Narnia. Not the text itself per se, but how influential it is.

I’m a kid of the 80s, as is Gerwig. I don’t think you understand how many of our cartoons were other worlds or Talking Animals or both. It was close to 100%. My Little Pony, Smurfs, Rainbow Brite, He-Man, She-Ra…this is just the tip of the iceberg. An 80s childhood was chock full of fantasy, and that’s because the people making those stories had Narnia in their zeitgeist.

The opening line of the trailer is ‘Sometimes one story is the beginning of all the others’ and that explains it all. The shots in the trailer explore the tapestry that Narnia weaves - it is part of all the fantasy that comes after it, which in turn inspires this film. Note the reference to Lord of the Rings when Digory puts on the ring, or the clear nods to the 2005 film in the draped wardrobe and design of the White Witch.

Edit to add: let me be abundantly clear that I’m talking about the visual style. I also think 70s rock fits the energy for similar reasons though. Stairway to Heaven in the trailer was a stunning choice.


r/Narnia • • Apr 06 '25

Yo people Aslan being a female is just a rumour and probably not true

19 Upvotes

Voice acting is not gender dependant,but voice ranging dependant, most voice acting people do both male and female voice, and guess what, Meryl Streep can do Aslan voice or be trained to do it even better, she is great at voice impersonation, and acting. Also Aslan would be disappointed in you all.


r/Narnia • • Apr 03 '25

Meryl Streep In Talks To Play Aslan In Greta Gerwig & Netflix’s Narnia Movie

Thumbnail
deadline.com
18 Upvotes

r/Narnia • • Aug 27 '26

Discussion Just finished the series and I'm a bit underwhelmed

6 Upvotes

I've just finished reading The Last Battle and I feel a bit underwhelmed by the path that Lewis chose for the world building.

I've read in publication order (and I strongly think one should when reading for the first time) so I was introduced to Narnia with The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe. The book is the most magical of the seven and it balances really well enough information to keep you interested and enough lack of it to keep you wanting to come back for more.

But the first book hints Narnia as this mysterious magical world full of all sorts of magical creates where humans are rare to the point of existing a prophecy stating that once Sons of Adam and Daughters of Eve are in Narnia again this great Winter and dark times will be over.

By the end of the last book we leave a world where Narnia is a country amongst others, the magical creatures are mostly welcomed and free only in Narnia and it's lands and most of the world is inhabited by...humans?

Why make the other nations in Narnia a mirror of human civilizations? Why not make them civilizations of magical animals? There's a hole country for giants, why not one for centaurs, dwarfs, fauns and so on. It just felt like more and more wasted potential as the books moved on.

But then two books are about the dark skinned man with the bad god trying to invade and destroy, and eventually succeeding, the white skinned, good, moral Europeans - I mean - Narnians...

I still liked most of the books, I just feel like a lot was left unexplored.