I think we should discuss the idea of removing the kicker from fantasy and replacing it with a SuperFlex position.
Here is my reasoning:
Kickers have little value. The best kicker so far is Justin Tucker with 50.9 points. That would make him the 38th best WR, just ahead of Mike Williams. He would, however, be the 20th ranked RB (how bad is RB this season, BTW). The #1 kicker this season is the #91 ranked fantasy player in terms of points.
There is too much randomness inherent in weekly scoring. More than any other position, Kickers are subject to game flow, offensive and defensive production for points. 4th and 16 on the 35? Normally that's a 52yrd FG try and great kicker points. But if that happens late in the 4th and the kicker's team is down by more than 4 the coach isn't going to send the kicker out here.
Kickers are lame.
There is very little difference between the #1 and #12 kicker. Last season Zuerlein ended #1 with 189 points, Hauschka ended with 145. That less than 2.5 points/game. The difference between WR 1 and 12 was double that. The difference at RB 1 and 12 was almost 4x that.
TL;DR: Kickers are a boring fantasy position.
Adding a Flex Spot:
I put this in the title because there was a discussion of removing a bench spot and adding a flex spot. I think this is a great idea and I'd go one step further and add a SuperFlex spot where people can start a 2nd QB.
I play in a Superflex league and it is way more interesting for a few reasons.
It makes you actually think when drafting. SuperFlex leagues can't use 90% of the rankings for predraft. They need to independently determine the values of the positions and that leads to swings in the demand for QBs in the early rounds.
Leagues that draft just following the sites projected rankings or ADP are boring. You know with decent certainty who will likely be available when you pick. Based on ADP and the Fleaflicker rankings I knew that Kamara would be there at #5 in most cases and that Gronk would be 1 of 2 or 3 guys available in round 2.
You add QBs to the mix as 1st/2nd round picks and you must rely on your own fantasy knowledge and ranks to get the players you need/want.
2) QBs are scoring so many damn points that the need for owning a top one is WAY down. Why? Because we only start 12.
It would be better if we were starting 24. The 12th ranked QB (Bortles 80pts) is #25 overall. The 24th (Alex Smith 50pts) is 98th overall. So it makes a huge difference if you have 2 good/great QBs. and that would make the position more meaningful.
3) QBs are the most important player in an offense, yet in this current format, they are mostly meaningless. This is just my opinion, but I feel that fantasy is more fun when it reflects reality. We should have importance on the things that really important to NFL teams. Make people study QBs, matchups and force them into lineup decisions based on a player who touches the ball on nearly every offensive play.
TL;DR: Superflex leagues make QBs matter more.
Anyway someone complained there wasn't enough discussion on here so I'm throwing this out there.