TLDR: Did a 3-day trial that went well, got rejected for “lack of experience” and the dog—even though they knew both beforehand and nothing actually went wrong.
* verbatim text exchange included below *
I’ve posted in here about not being able to find a job for the last month. I don’t need to tell anybody how frustrating and stressful the nanny market is, so you can imagine how happy I was when I thought this would be it.
I was ruthlessly posting my services, experience, etc. across multiple FB groups and under parents’ listings, so I’m not sure exactly what listing she found me under, but MB messaged me saying she has a 6-month-old and would love to get in contact. We arranged a FT call.
When we had the call, including her husband, I talked further about my experience (4+ years, last 2 with one family that I’ve been with since NK was 6 months), expectations, and about their dog. A couple years ago I became afraid after a bad bite. However, she let me know the dog is old, for one, and also has one leg amputated, which made me more comfortable, as my last family also had an old dog that I quickly got used to. The leg being amputated also means it’s not as active, so although I’m really sorry for the dog, it did make me more comfortable that it wouldn’t, you know, be jumping on me while caring for the baby or anything like that. But I did say it’d take a bit of getting used to both in the initial FB convo & on the FT call… which they empathized and said they completely understood.
We agreed we’d do a trial week (3 days, as that’s how the schedule would’ve gone) and go over a contract by the end of it to ensure expectations.
I immediately fell in awe of NK. They lived in a nice area, even had a cat (with my nickname as its name 🥲). They were nice, the pay was good, and the commute wasn’t terrible. First day, I was nervous for like the first 10 minutes around the dog, but it literally just laid there or moped around, and I was completely okay after. It’d walk past me, I’d walk past it just fine. Second day, I even rubbed the dog’s belly for a few minutes and took a video of it to show my boyfriend so he could be proud of me lol. I was bit by a dog I only looked at for 4 seconds so it just takes that initial knowing that I’m not going to get bit then I’m good. I went 20 years without any fear of dogs, I know it’s not all of them.
When dad came home that day, the dog was upset because he wasn’t petting her and was focusing on the baby. They told me she does that. In midst of growling at him, she turned toward me and stepped just a little faster than I had known her to move within the DAY of knowing her. So I moved my leg over a little and turned my body and said “Oop 😅”, as my bite was in that leg and that kind of movement triggers it, but it was very subtle. I didn’t squeal or anything, nor did I have the baby in my hands—dad was home, so I was leaving. Mom was also home all three days, by the way.
Third day, the dog wasn’t even there, as it was getting groomed. At the end of the day, she told me to text her my email so I did and that they’d talk and get back to me. I was so ecstatic, thinking I found my new family. I got paid at the end of all three days (not sure if that matters, but I suggested it as I’ve been burned after a trial shift before).
The text exchange the day after the 3rd day of trial:
MB — “Hi *****, after talking it over with *** unfortunately we don’t think we are the greatest fit for each other. Mostly because I think dog could be a potential problem. But we also are thinking we need someone with a little more experience. It was great meeting you!”
Me — “Hey, thanks for letting me know. I was certainly coming around to dog, but I understand. As I’d like to improve for my next family, may I ask what exactly I could work on that you noticed?”
MB — “Dog is a big part of it. It didn’t hit me until yesterday, but with NK starting solids, I am going to feel more comfortable with someone who has more experience and has done this over and over. It’s not that you did anything, it’s just that you only have a few years of experience.”
Frustrating for a multitude of reasons. She claimed the dog is a big part of it, yet went into no further detail as to how. At first, I said I understood because I assumed the lack of experience was actually the bigger part of it, and the dog thing was being used as a crutch. But I really wish I had asked how, especially since she later turned around and said the dog was the big part of it. Literally the only instance would be me moving my leg away when I was already about to leave and didn’t have the baby in my hands. She even told me to watch out for the dog ever getting too close to the baby, so it’s not like it’s wrong to be vigilant in general. Also, I had only known the dog for a freaking day at that point…. anyone needs time to learn an animal’s behavior.
When she mentioned “a little more experience” in the first message, I was appalled because not once did she have to correct me on anything. I even got the baby to sleep when she didn’t think it would happen. Which is why I asked the question—I’d like to know what she saw that I can improve on—but she says it’s nothing, just experience.
You knew of my experience before reaching out to me yourself. I have the same little summary that I paste into FB group postings, comments, and whatnot—my experience, expectations, location, etc. So to me, it would make sense if I had claimed certain experience and then didn’t meet expectations, but that wasn’t the case. You knew beforehand and just now decided, without any provoked action, that it’s not enough.
And then she says she wants somebody that’s done this “over and over again.” So in my eyes, that’s either someone who’s bounced from family to family or someone older than me (I’m 22), which is perfectly fine. My whole confusion is, if that’s your preference and I didn’t necessarily do anything wrong to change your mind, why wouldn’t you start with that in the first place? You just thought about the fact your child wouldn’t be on milk forever?
I don’t know if maybe she thought it would hurt my feelings to correct me, but I really think she would have said something if she needed to. Though she didn’t correct me, she did chime in to let me know things about the baby that I obviously wouldn’t know without being told. I’m sure it would also be easier to say what I did wrong through text, so I believe and know there isn’t anything I did wrong. They were looking for somebody else, and I’m annoyed because I wish they started with that somebody else rather than getting my hopes up.
Then I think of my previous family, who also believe this is a silly reason. When she talked to them, they said anybody would be lucky to have me. NK was only 6 months—we met once at a coffee shop, had a 30-minute house tour, and from then on it was just me and her. Within that time, we went from milk to solids. I watched her learn how to walk and talk, and she even asks to FaceTime me sometimes lol. She’s not the only infant I’ve nannied either again, this is 4+ years outside of family members or friends.
I don’t know, it just seems like a boohockey reason. I’m just wondering what the conversation was between them, especially since the husband wasn’t there most of the time. She did mention a few times throughout the days “oh I’m gonna miss you, I don’t know how mommy’s gonna go back to work, I can’t leave this face” so it’s a long shot but a part of me assumes she’s just not ready to leave baby with a nanny yet. Idk if that sounds rude or off, just an assumption that I obviously didn’t and wouldn’t mention to them.
At the end of the day, I absolutely understand people need to be comfortable with who’s caring for their baby, but sweet darn, I really thought this was it.
Edit: of course, there’s always going to be those commenters. I’d appreciate my post and my responses being seen as two different aspects. There’s plenty of nice responses to those that have met me with a respectful tone, even if I didn’t all the way agree. They’re just all the way at the bottom because those that don’t meet me with a respectful tone, get the same in return and then further harp on that tainted response. I’m more than appreciative of the supportive comments. Just got a call from an agency and we scheduled the third interview! 🥳