At this point, I really think the Yankees should pivot away from Cody Bellinger and look harder at Bo Bichette.
We’ve all seen the reports by now. Bellinger is asking for too many years and too much money per year, especially for a player with recent inconsistency and a profile that doesn’t age particularly well. With that in mind, any alternative negotiation has to look better on paper. That said, the price absolutely has to be right for Bichette too. This only works if the Yankees aren’t overpaying in years or AAV. I’m just assuming that based on everything we’re hearing about Bellinger, any other deal should at least be more reasonable.
I’d also be much more comfortable giving years to Bichette given that he’s about three years younger than Bellinger.
LF also isn’t some urgent long-term need when you consider we already have two prospects who could factor in there soon, even if they’re not ready to compete immediately. If those prospects aren’t ready on Day 1, the answer doesn’t have to be a massive contract. You sign a cheaper MLB vet to fill the gap and sit on the bench when needed. Someone like Austin Hays makes way more sense for that role than locking into a long, expensive Bellinger deal.
Bichette, on the other hand, actually gives the Yankees flexibility.
Short term, he fills the SS gap while Volpe is out until April or May. Once Volpe is back, you can shift things around. People forget that Jazz played CF well with the Marlins before coming to New York, so moving him back there isn’t some crazy experiment. If Jones or Dominguez don’t look ready, you can slide Jazz to CF, Grisham to LF, and still keep Bichette’s bat in the lineup.
Long term, Bichette gives the Yankees real insurance. If Jazz doesn’t re-sign after next season or prices himself out, Bichette can move to 2B. His defense may be questionable at SS, but it’s reasonable to assume it’s more than serviceable at second.
This also gives the Yankees a backup plan if Volpe struggles offensively again. We all hope Volpe takes the next step, but if he doesn’t, having Bichette’s bat gives you options instead of being stuck.
Now, there are definitely flaws with this plan. Having someone like Bellinger would make it easier to trade Dominguez or Jones for pitching, and his versatility simplifies a lot of roster decisions. I’m not denying that.
I’m just saying that if Bellinger is truly out of our price range, and the Yankees can get Bichette at a more reasonable number, it’s not a bad idea. You get lineup flexibility, some insurance against multiple unknowns, and you’re also taking a good player away from one of your main divisional competitors in the Blue Jays. That part doesn’t hurt either.
Curious what everyone else thinks.