r/NYYankees • • Dec 07 '25 Hooray Bravo

News Twitter Links Rule Change

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

We’ve made the decision to reenable linking to twitter/x. We will continue enforcing our rules on posting quality content as it relates to twitter, only allowing links to well known beat writers, official accounts, etc. Speculation and minor news should continue to be posted in general discussion threads. Thank you.


r/NYYankees • • Jun 01 '22

Donaldson disappointed Yankees didn’t publicly support him

Thumbnail
seattletimes.com
12 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • Oct 14 '26

Judge vs Ohtani's last 8 playoff games 😳

Post image
0 Upvotes

Yeah I'm pettty


r/NYYankees • • Sep 13 '23

JP Sears (traded for Montas) has more bWAR (2.5) in 157.2 IP than Rodon, Schmidt, German, Severino, Brito, Cortes, Vasquez, and Michael King combined (1.7) across 643 IP

0 Upvotes

So every starter minimum 5 GS not named Gerrit Cole has combined to be worse than a throw in for a guy that hasn't pitched an inning this year and was worth a whopping -0.7 bWAR in 39.2 IP for us last year. Doesn't include Waldichuk, Luis Medina, or Cooper Bowman who he also traded who are till trying to figure it out, although Waldichuk looks promising.

Another L in the books for Trashman.


r/NYYankees • • Mar 18 '26 Bravo

Aaron Judge…greatest player with the least amount of clutch

14 Upvotes

Look, I love the Yankees with everything in my being but, let’s be honest, is Aaron Judge the greatest player with the least amount of clutch??!? How many great clutch moments does he have in his career? Two-maybe three? Off the top of my head, I can think of the home run off Crochet in Boston, and then against the Blue Jays in the playoffs last year? How does he consistently come up short in the biggest moments?? Genuinely baffling to me. And I have the 99 jersey right here. Just doesn’t make sense to me how he always comes up small.


r/NYYankees • • Dec 15 '23

Anyone else kinda over Ohtani already?

0 Upvotes

Yeah, he's a good player who signed an exceptionally large contract. Please r/baseball, pull your tongue out of his ass...

Also, IDK how many times I've heard on MLB Network how Babe Ruth said hitting and pitching wasn't possible and Ohtani proved him wrong. No, he didn't. These are the same asshats who say you can't compare generational players, yet here they are. Ruth pitched in an era where there were 3 man rotations and pitchers were expected to pitch complete games. Ohtani would fucking shrivel up and die if he tried to do that today. In fact, he needs a 6 man rotation to do what he does.

Is he a good player? Yes. But please, stop sucking him off already.


r/NYYankees • • Jun 13 '25

Would anyone be interested in shit-talk threads with r/redsox?

0 Upvotes

Red Sox fan here -

Would the folks at r/NYYankees be interested in some kinda pre-game (or pre-series?) thread either on here or on r/redsox? Maybe it could become a regular thing that the home team sub hosts each game/series? Instead of just existing in echo chambers of complaining about our own teams, we can do that while telling another fanbase they suck. And considering the Yankees are like 11 games up, there's plenty of shit for you guys to be talking. But anything to give a spark to this neutered rivalry.


r/NYYankees • • Apr 30 '22

Time to make a change—a rant.

1 Upvotes

I wish—more than anything—that we as a fan base would just stop writing off the season at the drop of a hat. I had to stop checking this sub for news or video highlights because I just couldn’t handle all of the “fire this person” or “f this team” posts. I equate these paper tigers to the mofos who threw trash on the field against the Guardians. We’re doing well now, we will do well many times this season after a stretch of bad luck (that’s baseball, John). So to those of you who write the season off after a bad series, kindly f yourself and have a nice day. Rant over. Downvote me to oblivion or run interference on this post, moderators. It’s whatever.


r/NYYankees • • Apr 14 '22

Non-Doomer Realism: IKF & Torres

3 Upvotes

Its early, and we still have Cole, Judge, and Stanton at primes and the best bullpen in baseball. But! A World Series winner cannot have a middle infield that is completely dead weight offensively (IKF) or looks like America’s Funniest Videos fielding (Torres).

At what point do we say IKF’s and Torres’s issues aren’t nerves and we need to make moves? RE: IKF, how soon can we bring up Perraza? RE: Torres, why not use DJ as the everyday 2nd baseman and use Torres as either the DH or trade for a catcher/SP?

Not a flame post - actually begging for some solutions. The past is the past, and we can’t get Seager or Siemen, but we do have a great nucleus and we need a few tweaks.

*Edit - Torres is an offensive threat (I get that!). But he has negative DRS every year since 2019, when he was also playing 2nd. This makes things complicated, bc DJLM is also having a good year, and has a Gold Glove at 2nd


r/NYYankees • • Sep 14 '23

I wouldn't rule the Yankees out yet, a mathematical breakdown.

0 Upvotes

Of the teams in ANY contention (above 0.3% probability) to make the 6th wildcard, the Yankees have the easiest strength of schedule by far.

Rangers future opponent weighted win %: 0.514
Blue Jays future opponent weighted win %: 0.547
Red Sox future opponent weighted win %: 0.528
and lastly:
Yankees future opponent weighted win %: 0.481

The Yankees have the easiest strength of schedule of any team in ANY contention across the MLB, but NL numbers don't really matter so I won't include them.

Also, the Blue Jays have more games left against the AL East than any other team in the MLB, with 15/16 of their remaining games being against an AL East team. The Blue Jays are notoriously bad against the AL East, with a 12-25 record against them this year.

The Rangers have 7 games left against the Mariners, who are in the 5th playoff spot. The two teams haven't played since June when the Mariners were in a worse position and the Rangers in a better, so any 4-3 split of that series will make the WC spot competitive.

Frankly. I know it is unlikely, but sports fans live for the 1 in a Million and it is definitely right in front of us, if we take it.


r/NYYankees • • Dec 09 '16

<--- Derek Jeter's number

4 Upvotes

Edit: We did it Reddit

Edit: wow this really blew up


r/NYYankees • • Dec 28 '23

What made the Yankees so confident they were getting Yamamoto?

0 Upvotes

On the next Hot Stove, I want to know why the Yankees were so confident in sighing Yamamoto to the point they led us believe they had him signed practically. Were they caught off guard by the Ohtani contract, were they led to believe something different by the Yamamoto camp and strung along or they thought the price was never going to go as high as it did for him? Because it was odd how we got a month of reports how the Yankees were heavy favorites and even Curry tried to reassure the fans that Yankees felt confident in signing him to the point we thought it was a done deal, yet everything was bs and they were almost 3rd in the sweepstakes despite how heavy favorites they were.


r/NYYankees • • Sep 10 '25

The Yankees hit too many home runs. What would you like them to do instead?

0 Upvotes

People on this sub complain about all the home run hitting until they're blue in the face.

"Too many home runs!" "Boom/bust doesn't work!" "This team sucks!"

What would you like instead? I'm genuinely curious what everyone thinks they should be doing to win ballgames. Do you want old school Ty Cobb-style baseball where they slap singles then steal a base or bunt to advance a runner? Do you want to see more doubles where the Yankees rank #18 out of 30 teams? Like what is the optimum mix?

Before you answer let me drop some numbers:

  • As a team the Yankees lead MLB in OPS, #3 in OBP

  • Team BA is .248 but the #1 Blue Jays are hitting .269, that's only 8.46% better

  • The Yankees lead MLB in total bases per game

  • The Yankees lead MLB in BBs but they're also tied for #9 in SBs

  • The team is #1 in total runs scored and average runs scored per game

  • Yankees are best in MLB in RBIs and #4 in sac flies that score a runner

  • 8 fulltime players are hitting at least league average BA of .240 or above

  • The Yankees have 6 fulltime players with an OPS above .800 and wRC+ above 125

  • 10 Yankees have at least 200 PAs this season, their combined BA is .255. But if you drop Volpe and Wells from that list that combined team BA of fulltime players jumps to .266.

  • 6 fulltime players have a walk rate above 9.5%, league average is 8.7%

How should this situation be improved?


r/NYYankees • • Oct 20 '21

Misleading/unreliable source Yankees expected to be suitor for Javier Baez if Mets don't extend him

Thumbnail
sports.yahoo.com
2 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • Dec 19 '22

Fun Fact: Jameson Taillon had exactly a 100 ERA+ in both of his seasons with the Yankees.

2 Upvotes

Literally the definition of mid, so glad the yanks didn’t extend a QO or that garbage contract the cubs signed him for


r/NYYankees • • Sep 04 '22

Oswaldo Cabrera this season in 60 PA: .211/.250/.258 slashline, 3BB/14K, 0/2 SB attempts, 0 HR, 4 XBH

0 Upvotes

He's been a spark defensively but I do find it funny that he has been getting endlessly praised in this sub for a significantly worse OPS than IKF... he's been absolutely atrocious offensively as well as having baserunning blunders


r/NYYankees • • Apr 13 '26

What motivates Hal to continue on this way?

2 Upvotes

Doomer take, but I’m just tired of the inevitable skid of June…now coming earlier. We have such a weak lineup overall and it’s not even inspiring my kid to watch since he sees they literally cannot hit.

That being said what motivates Hal and how do we move him? Well, us diehards can stop going to the games but let’s be honest, I want to see the Yanks on my birthday and really am not going to not do that nor stop watching.

We all want him to change something cause the baseball doesn’t work but the numbers (money) do. I’m thinking a letter writing campaign. A Harry Potter under the stairs letter where we make him feel embarrassed. He may read none of them, but the publicity (guy is worse than Bruce Wayne in Dark knight rises) will make him have to respond somehow. It could be in the Post, Daily News, Journal, or Times. I think he hates being in the spotlight as he’s not George, so bring it to him. It could all be our list of gripes but something like that could get him moving. We can compile it here and bam, just everyone send it.

That’s my idea, folks, cause he’s still gonna make his money anyway but if he feels like the pressure is on just maybe we get something going.


r/NYYankees • • Nov 28 '24

“Aaron Judge’s ‘odd’ approach to Juan Soto’s free agency could cost Yankees: ex-Met”

Thumbnail
nypost.com
0 Upvotes

Does anyone really believe that Judge isn’t having conversations with Soto and trying to talk him into staying? I doubt Judge isnt talking to soto.

Soto seems to knows the Yankees from being with them this short time and has built friendships with the players. Soto has proved himself to the yankees and us fans. I hope Hal has given him enough to think about and that Soto truly wants to stay in pinstripes. Our energy is unmatched.

But in sports, it’s a business.


r/NYYankees • • Jan 10 '26

Why the Yankees should pivot from Bellinger and go after Bo Bichette instead

4 Upvotes

At this point, I really think the Yankees should pivot away from Cody Bellinger and look harder at Bo Bichette.

We’ve all seen the reports by now. Bellinger is asking for too many years and too much money per year, especially for a player with recent inconsistency and a profile that doesn’t age particularly well. With that in mind, any alternative negotiation has to look better on paper. That said, the price absolutely has to be right for Bichette too. This only works if the Yankees aren’t overpaying in years or AAV. I’m just assuming that based on everything we’re hearing about Bellinger, any other deal should at least be more reasonable.

I’d also be much more comfortable giving years to Bichette given that he’s about three years younger than Bellinger.

LF also isn’t some urgent long-term need when you consider we already have two prospects who could factor in there soon, even if they’re not ready to compete immediately. If those prospects aren’t ready on Day 1, the answer doesn’t have to be a massive contract. You sign a cheaper MLB vet to fill the gap and sit on the bench when needed. Someone like Austin Hays makes way more sense for that role than locking into a long, expensive Bellinger deal.

Bichette, on the other hand, actually gives the Yankees flexibility.

Short term, he fills the SS gap while Volpe is out until April or May. Once Volpe is back, you can shift things around. People forget that Jazz played CF well with the Marlins before coming to New York, so moving him back there isn’t some crazy experiment. If Jones or Dominguez don’t look ready, you can slide Jazz to CF, Grisham to LF, and still keep Bichette’s bat in the lineup.

Long term, Bichette gives the Yankees real insurance. If Jazz doesn’t re-sign after next season or prices himself out, Bichette can move to 2B. His defense may be questionable at SS, but it’s reasonable to assume it’s more than serviceable at second.

This also gives the Yankees a backup plan if Volpe struggles offensively again. We all hope Volpe takes the next step, but if he doesn’t, having Bichette’s bat gives you options instead of being stuck.

Now, there are definitely flaws with this plan. Having someone like Bellinger would make it easier to trade Dominguez or Jones for pitching, and his versatility simplifies a lot of roster decisions. I’m not denying that.

I’m just saying that if Bellinger is truly out of our price range, and the Yankees can get Bichette at a more reasonable number, it’s not a bad idea. You get lineup flexibility, some insurance against multiple unknowns, and you’re also taking a good player away from one of your main divisional competitors in the Blue Jays. That part doesn’t hurt either.

Curious what everyone else thinks.


r/NYYankees • • Oct 24 '23

The Yankees are gonna trade Gleyber Torres and it’s gonna suck

3 Upvotes

This is the latest rumor, although it’s also just obvious, and it’s only picking up steam. And if you think it’s happening for any other reason than that Gleyber is going to make $15,000,000 next year and Oswald Peraza is going to make under $1 mil, you’ve completely lost the plot. This lineup is so desperate for anyone who can hit, and there is a tiny fraction of a percent that Peraza will ever in his whole career have as good an offensive season as Gleyber is poised to have in 2024.

If you catch yourself justifying this inevitability to yourself or to others, stop and think. Do you have a plan that makes this offense as much better than the 2023 lineup as it NEEDS to be, while also subtracting the clear second-best hitter in it and one of the best hitters at his position in the majors? How in the hell is this team supposed to score runs next year if every opposing pitcher just walks or pitches around Judge every time he comes up? Do you really honestly believe, after DECADES of futility at developing their own prospects into major league-caliber hitters, that this team stands any chance of replacing that offensive production from within? Or is the occam’s razor of it all just what we know to be true, that everything about how the Yankees operate now is not about winning but instead maximizing the corporation’s profit margin?


r/NYYankees • • Jan 10 '24

The case for the Yankees not doing anything is compelling

0 Upvotes

1)There is a reason why there are so many free agents still on the board. Stud players like Judge, Yamamoto, Ohtani, Cole, Machado typically goo off the board quickly because they are in high demand. The remaining free agents are all very flawed. Snell, Monty, Bellinger, Hader, etc. The chances are pretty strong that none of those guys will live up to the contract they will get judging by the bulk of their MLB career and current trajectory.

2) I’m really not an advocate for big trades prior to the season unless it’s for a sure fire stud like Soto. It generally makes a lot more sense for a team like the Yankees to save their prospects and deal them at the deadline. That way they can fix the parts of the team needed to make a run. Also can acquire players who are actually having a good season.


r/NYYankees • • Jul 25 '23

Anyone feel like players get too many off days??

1 Upvotes

It seems like once every 7-10 days, someone is out of the lineup for rest and “get them off their feet”. It’s been a thing for a while now with the team and I really don’t think it makes a difference.

Look at a team like the Braves. Their four best players (Acuna, Olson, Riley, and Albies) have played every single game for them this year.

Look at the Rangers. Semien played every game, and Lowe, Garcia, and Jung have missed one, two, and three games respectively.

Dodgers have Freddie Freeman playing every game and Mookie missing just three games. The Mets have Lindor playing every game, McNeil missing one, Nimmo missing two, and Alonso playing every game (while not on the IL).

Is having so many off days affecting players and preventing them from getting into a groove?


r/NYYankees • • Apr 01 '24

Hal Steinbrenner Annouces Mayoral Candidacy

Post image
2 Upvotes

New York, NY — Shock and relief. Those words are the two most common sentiments coming from inside the Yankee organization today as principal owner and Team President Hal Steinbrenner announced that he will be stepping down from his day-to-day role in order to pursue a campaign for New York Mayor's office. This announcement comes just one day after Steinbrenner's Yankees completed a stirring sweep of the rival Astros in Houston to open the 2024 season, and team officials across the organization don't exactly know what to make of the announcement, or its timing.

"It makes sense when you think about it," said manager, Aaron Boone. "He loves being in control and the Yankees employ, what, maybe 3,000 people total? New York City has a lot more people than that."

Long-time confidant and team General Manager Brian Cashman had this to say: "I wish Hal the absolute best in his quest for the Mayor's Office. I just hope he knows it'll put him over the luxury tax. [Laugh]. But seriously, it'll be great to work on the 2024 season, and I will help Mr. Hal anyway he needs me to."

With the Mayoral election not until 2025, some people are wondering why the move was made now and if Mr. Steinbrenner is being too aggressive in looking to build a campaign or if he even knows when the election is being held. He also has still to as-of-yet declare a party affiliation, but, he's a billionaire, so, we know.

When reached out to for comment, Mr. Steinbrenner released the following statement from the deck of his megayacht, 'Joke's On You':

"I just think that it's time for me to take the next step. After seeing what [Michael] Bloomberg and [Donald] Trump were able to achieve by being just pointlessly rich while being unversed in politics was really inspiring to me. That, and when I spoke to John [Henry], he was really convincing in that Beijing a billionaire doesn't mean I have to do things where I spend my own money—and that sounds like politics to me!

I also spoke with Stevie [Steve Cohen, Mets Owner] and he said, 'If it was just a civil charge for me, I woulda done this a long time ago.' So I figured that since I don't have any charges, it made sense.

And it's pretty clear that as long as you aren't a cop, you've got a shot to get some reputation in this city, and thats important to me. I don't even like the cops. It wouldn't be really cool of me to do that, would it? Especially when me and Stevie use the same company to hire out patsies and fall guys. What kind of dick would that make me?

I like to think that I'm a man of the people deep down. When my secret society has their mansion orgies in Westchester, I always invite my players to the ones that are open house. It's the polite thing to do. I don't know if any of them have shown up, but I think I might have seen Judge there once. There was a very tall man, but with the robes and masks, it's rather hard to tell. As mayor, I'd be willing to open it up to some more of the general public too. The more the merrier, I say. And we don't even hire cops to work security at these things, it's some private firm. Turns out the NYPD isn't too keen on covering their faces when they're not wearing body cams. Love 'em as much as I do, that always seemed odd to me. I don't know.

Anyway, I'll be sad to leave the Yankees daily, but this is a big, important step for myself and the city of New York. I hope the people know that I'll build them a winner!"

Ultimately, it is still too early to say what Mr. Steinbrenner's campaign will look like, with the election still 19 months away, but if anything, it can only be good for the Yankees.

"I hope he gets everything he wants," slugger Giancarlo Stanton said. "He'll be missed around here. The weekly physical check-ins going away will make the dick picks less scandalous, and I'll miss that. But I guess it will be nice to not have my X-rays be 'Return to Sender' too. [Pause]. [Pause]. [Pause]. I'm not sure who I'd vote for. It depends on where they stand on the issues, I suppose."

From today's Forbes Daily Magazine

Happy April Fools Yall


r/NYYankees • • Oct 11 '25

Mariners vs Jays?

1 Upvotes

Who you guys rooting for?
I found it hysterical that AJ Hinch pulled a Boone and made such a gigantic mistake. Had an effective reliever throwing 2 solid innings, but then he tampered with success in the 15th. Bring in an ice cold pitcher off the bench instead of sticking with an effective pitcher who was shutting them out. Boone must be giving him lessons on how to lose!