r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 18 '20

Mythos The Wrath is starting to get stupid Spoiler

5 Upvotes

So the car can lock itself, drive itself, fight on its own, acts as Charlie's lich phylactery, and now ON TOP OF ALL THAT, it's bulletproof? You can go at its windows with a welding hammer and they're fine?

Where could Charlie have possibly gotten access to the materials to make it as tough as the car the President rides in?! And if this is all some kind of magic he's doing, why's Vic only get an ordinary bike for her knife?

This is not a remotely fair fight anymore!


r/NOS4A2 • • Aug 11 '20

Question What is going on ?

1 Upvotes

I’m late to the party , forgot about this show loved the first season. Just realized the second season came out a whole started watching it. A few minutes in and I’m like what the hell happened. The girl that uses the tiles how is she in a relationship with the FBI lady, wasn’t she a minor, like 16 or 17. I know a few years have past but what adult meats a teenage and after a few years gets in a relationship with them. Or Am I wrong I could be I don’t remember them ever stating her age. I guess I’m just kinda taken back like isn’t that ethically wrong ?


r/NOS4A2 • • Dec 14 '23

this may seem a little harsh but...

10 Upvotes

...i'm watching the tv series and i just can't escape the feeling that this story is what you'd get if you asked chatgpt to write a stephen king novel


r/NOS4A2 • • Sep 18 '19

Jahkara Smith looks exactly like MJ Rodriguez from POSE. It’s insane. New here, not sure if this has been discussed.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/NOS4A2 • • Aug 09 '20

Season 1 was better

9 Upvotes

Season 2 has many episodes that take place in one location: lake house or junk yard. Budget is obviously low.

They never show Charlie Manx aging, it’s all off screen. More low budget problems.

Hour Glass Man was 100% filler character who added nothing to the plot.

Episodes too inconsistent. We are 8 damn weeks into the show and they literally had a whole episode without the main character. No Vic in episode 7. And then they do all Vic episodes with no Manx (except maybe 90 seconds). I’d rather the episodes were mixed like season 1, where there’s a good amount of each of them in each episode.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jun 04 '19

Fuck You AMC.

17 Upvotes

Why mess with a perfect story? I’m 39 minutes into it and they’re altering so many facets of the story that make no sense at all to change.

Dammit.


r/NOS4A2 • • Aug 03 '20

Am I only one that thinks Ashley Cummings is a terrible actor in this show? It can't be just me.

7 Upvotes

r/NOS4A2 • • Nov 04 '20

iRonY

3 Upvotes

Barely on season 1 ep 5 But the irony is manx would’ve saved vic as a child she needed his saving ~


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 11 '20

Discussion Anyone else kinda ship Charlie and Victoria?

0 Upvotes

I mean he’s terrifying and creepy AF, but sexual tension just oozes from the actor. He even did the whole “mwahahaha! She’s powerful, so I shall make her my vampire bride” where he was practically proposing marriage by wanting her to come mother the children. I was disappointed he dropped that idea when he found out she lost her virginity. But it fit well. Virginal women are usually the ones that become vampire brides.

It’s a horror story, not a romance story, and I hear that it is closely following the book so she’s likely just going to kill him and be done with it (since that’s what he deserves anyway), but oh how I wish she would get to play Mother Xmas (vampire bride) for an episode because she loses her memory or does it to save her son or something.

Even though it’s twisted and wrong in so many ways, does anyone else think they’ve got awesome tension together? (mostly thanks to Charlie)

I kinda want the series to deviate from the book just so it can keep going for longer with more seasons and more creative freedom.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 27 '19

If I had met Charlie Manx when I was a kid...

10 Upvotes

I definitely would’ve gone to Christmasland. He’s saved so many kids that were just like me.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jun 24 '19

FUCK YOU AMC pt 2.

8 Upvotes

ITS NOT EVEN THE GODDAMN HOUSE OF SLEEP!!!! Why would you name the episode after a thing that isn’t even in the fucking episode... nor, I’m assuming, not in the series at all?

(EDIT: I AM AN IDIOT and was thinking of the SLAYHOUSE so yeah. I deserve every downvote you've given me. But other than that? I still have so many problems with the show but, haha, it definitely ain't the name of the House of Sleep).

Seriously AMC. You fucked up such an easy opportunity to make great, cohesive tale. Somehow you had to skull fuck it into stupidity.

I hate you.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 29 '19

Does this show get better?

5 Upvotes

On episode 5 and I'm just bored? I feel like nothing has happened and nothing is really catching my attention


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 17 '19

Why is Manx a villain?

5 Upvotes

He doesn’t need to be. His seemingly genuine desire to save children puts him in the category of anti hero or well intentioned extremist. Now I haven’t read the book and don’t intend to so maybe that skews my perspective but it seems like he’s only a villain because Hill and the show writers made him that way. He didn’t have to be controlling or this horrible person.

The fact that he kidnaps children to save them from a potentially horrible or traumatic life and takes them to this magical realm of his creation, while simultaneously feeding off their souls is interesting enough. Yes he’s saving them, but ultimately is that his decision to make? It makes him as well as his character morally gray, and Vic’s decision to stop him morally gray.

Y’all understand where I’m coming from? Why does he need to be the villain? Is it lazy writing, is it because he’s a vampire of some sort, or is there another main reason that is addressed in the book?


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 11 '22

Any NOS4A2 dreams you've had?

2 Upvotes

I just had one a few hours ago that I will detail below. But I'd be interested in hearing others dreams or nightmares, no matter how strange! 😂

Had a super fantastic NOS4A2 dream about Charlie.

I was sortof Vic in the dream. I looked like her, but I was influencing his land to look like the things I care about. Everything was pretty faerie ballerinas etc waltzing through a huge theatre-like palace or something lol.
Their dresses were so pretty and I kept wanting to go up and touch them or follow them, but wasn't sure what would happen. Faeries are inherently dangerous and can lead you astray.

Vic (aka "myself") was all banged up and drugged in the bedroom and Charlie was mad his inscape was altered in a weird way. He was slowly de-clothing me and stuff and I was letting him. But he stopped multiple times to argue etc lol. Basically, I'm literally teasing myself by having multiple interruptions so that we never go ALL THE WAY and actually have sex. (This is Zachary Quinto I have the hots for, not book!Charlie.)

I remember him leaving the room at one point and me looking out the window at the beach and the waves. It wasn't "warm" so to speak. It alternated between being sunset on the waves and total twilight and there was still snow in places. It's like my mind couldn't decide if it wanted beach and waves, but also twilight and cold, so it just did all of it and made it look like some kind of fused inscape of Charlie's and Vic's (aka "mine").

I think I dreamed myself as Vic because she's cute and short and looks like a woman, whereas I'm a tall freak and have never felt very "cute" or "feminine" despite all of my ballet and figure skating. Ironic considering Vic rides a motorbike, but because she's cute and petite I still associated her with being more feminine than myself.

But yeah, just the vividness of the dream was soooo good. The faeries were vivid. The bedroom scene was vivid. The weird beach sunset scene outside of the window was so vivid.

I lucid dream a lot, but only certain ones are super vivid like a movie or full-length book. I have written fanfics off such vivid dreams before lol.

"You’re aware that the events flashing through your brain aren’t really happening. But the dream feels vivid and real. You may even be able to control how the action unfolds, as if you’re directing a movie in your sleep."

"During lucid dreams, the sleeper is aware a dream is taking place1 but will not leave the dream state. Some further define these phenomena as dreams in which the sleeper can exercise control over different aspects of their environment, though studies have found this is not always the case, and that certain people are more predisposed to “lucid dream control” than others."

When I have my vivid dreams, I am sometimes aware it's a dream and sometimes not really. I'm more interested in what's taking place and if I can control it or not. Being aware "ruins" the enjoyment of the dream, so if I'm aware, I tend to literally shove that awareness away from me and just focus on seeing what happens next in the dream or trying to force the dream in a certain direction I want it to go. I will even do this with some nightmares if I think the "plot" is interesting lol.

Part of what makes these dreams so good is that they are REAL when I'm in them. I don't want to be aware its fake and I hate waking up from them because that means actual reality slams back in.

As for how to have these dreams? I'm never actively trying for them, so I'm excited when they happen, even though it sucks to wake up from them and realize it was all a pretty lie of my own brain.

Generally I think they happen when I've been reading/watching a lot on the subject matter, especially right before bed, and sometimes maybe if extra stress from life is occurring. I think it's a way to heal from stress or frustration by getting some "wish fulfillment" in your sleep. The stress usually has no relation to the dream in any way, it's just a good trigger for it to occur.

I really am thinking about turning this particular vivid dream into a fanfic.... NOS4A2 is sadly extremely lacking in fanfic.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jun 06 '19

Teen Drama?

6 Upvotes

Why did the products make this story a teen drama? Pretty disappointed in the first episode.


r/NOS4A2 • • Dec 29 '21

Thoughts and questions after first watch (SPOILERS) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

First, Quinto's old man voice is ridiculous to the point of distraction. How does such a good actor fail so miserably and why would the show runner allow him to use that cartoon voice? One octave higher and he'd have been Abe Simpson...

"The important thing was that I had an onion on my belt which was the style at the time."- Charlie Manx

Where does Manx's power come from? In the early flashbacks it seemed he was just a natural born loser and the wraith possessed him a'la "Christine". But in the later flashbacks (in the bar as a child) his eyes glow like a demon before he kills his mom, insinuating he was evil all along. Does the book clear this up?

And finally, does it seem like Joe Hill had a notebook full of themes and ideas and decided to try and use as many as possible in this story? Again, haven't read the book, but I don't know if it was Hill's source material or the screenwriter's who adapted it that makes this show feel like a hodge-podge mashup of King-isms.

I had such high hopes for this show but it was just a mess.


r/NOS4A2 • • Sep 01 '23

This is the funniest shit ever Spoiler

7 Upvotes

r/NOS4A2 • • Jan 19 '20

Finally watching this...it seems Joe Hill is destined to meet the fate of his father.

19 Upvotes

Piss poor adaptions of great novels.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 25 '22

Does Charlie have total control over the dreams of those in his car?

4 Upvotes

I remember that the villains he had in the backseat in the Wraith comic book were having dreams of xmasland, even tho they weren't kids.

And I believe Bing saw xmasland in his sleep even when he was in the front seat. There are other vampire stories where they have total control over the dreams of their victims, so it's not without precedent.

It doesn't seem like the dreams are a signal that Charlie is draining you, since he never seems to drain adults (front seat or back seat). It just seems to signal you're in his car and under his power?

Just had a funny thought. If Charlie always shares dreams with whoever is in his car (and he doesn't have total control over the dreams), if he got a woman in there that's attracted to him, that dream could take a startlingly turn lol.
I wonder if Charlie would panic or just go with it. He's expecting to dream of xmasland like he always does, but gets something very different because of the other person in the car lol.

Had this thought after I saw a comment on the HP board about Snape and how panicked he would be training occlumency with certain fans because he'd find memories about himself in risque moments lol. That would be one hell of a way to get him OUT of your head very fast.


r/NOS4A2 • • Dec 30 '20

BIG QUESTION about the show and books

9 Upvotes

So. I love the show Nos4a2. I watched season 1 and 2 several times. But I want to start reading the books. How many books are there. And are their other books from the author that takes place in the same universe. Like with strong creatives. And if so. What are the names of the books? In order if there is an order to read them in. Also if there aren’t anymore books other than Nos4a2, how many books of Nos4a2 are there. And what are the books to each season of the show. Does that make sense?


r/NOS4A2 • • Jan 14 '22

Jadis vs Charlie

5 Upvotes

Just had a fun thought while rereading Narnia and rewatching my favorite White Witch scenes from the movies.

In the books, Jadis bans Father Christmas (Santa) from entering Narnia during her endless Winter storm. LOL I mean on the one hand, they both clearly enjoy freezing-cold inscapes, but on the other hand, she hates Christmas! HAHAHAHAA
But hell, maybe she'd be OK with Charlie's version of Christmas since I know she'd have no problem sending the human children to him to become vampires. She doesn't want any Sons of Adam or Daughters of Eve hanging around. Children of Charlie would be just fine with her. They aren't a threat to her throne.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 01 '19

Why does this whole show feel like a shallow, poorly organized young adult novel?

23 Upvotes

I had high expectations and so far this show sucks. The plot is all over the place, huge details are not even being discussed and the actors are very bad.


r/NOS4A2 • • Jul 22 '19

The deeper the show goes the less deep Brat gets. It’s also starting to strain the actresses chops a bit. It’s a one trick pony of every scene is fluttering eyelids and almost crying trying to pass for acting

20 Upvotes

r/NOS4A2 • • Jun 16 '19

Allusions to Michael Jackson

20 Upvotes

MJ used to wear similar bellboy/chauffeur jackets. He kept kids from their parents in his theme park with a desire to be eternal children. Seduced kids with the allure of living in his magical theme park. He talked about the purity of children and how they needed to be saved. To take it a little bit darker, someone on this board already mentioned how Manx's car functions as a method of inebriating/incapacitating the kids so they are more susceptible to Manx's Christmasland seduction. Kids stated they'd become inebriated on "Jesus juice" and their guard would drop in the back of Michael Jackson's limo on their way to Neverland... and we know what happened next. Manx is the archetype of the mythical child predator. He believes children should never ever be harmed or taken physical in any way. He believes only in the challenge of seducing them to go with him. That way he justifies his actions by knowing that he did not "take" any children, rather they willingly came with him.


r/NOS4A2 • • Aug 10 '20

Question Anyone else annoyed at the changes to Charlie’s past? Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Spoilers for the Wraith prequel comic

In the comic Hill wrote Charlie’s mother is frequently abusive (even making him sleep in a coffin) and Charlie is later raped by one of her johns. The show changed that by having her as a loving mother and almost making it sound like it’s Charlie’s fault he gets abused because he convinced kids to work for the guy who later rapes him. (In the comic the just gets thrown out of the brothel and goes after Charlie for revenge).

Really annoying and kind of puzzling. It feels like the showrunner wanted to absolve Charlie’s mother of being horrible and abusive while also finding away to make Charlie less sympathetic in being a victim of sexual abuse.

Did they think it was wrong to depict a mother figure as being actually bad and Charlie being an innocent victim of abuse as a child?