This has been a long time coming. I've been avoiding ranting on here, because I know you're not allowed to complain on the internet without getting blitzed, but my frustration has grown to a point where I can no longer bite my tongue.
I have been playing BAP with these settings since NHL 14. in both 14 and 15, the opposing AI was easy to figure out, and my team was winning virtually every game, and I was shattering every record imaginable ten-fold. While fun, this obviously got repetitive and boring quite quick.
In no way do I think the above results should be the standard with these settings. I do expect, and think there should be, more of a challenge - and boy did I get that with NHL 16. Not only did I get a challenge, but I got the polar opposite.
My personal performance is still not an issue, as I am still scoring an unrealistic amount of goals/assists, but my team simply cannot win games, and it's because the AI seems tremendously tilted. Not only is the opposing team a bunch of super-human geniuses, but my team looks like a bunch of beer-leaguers and seem to forget what a puck is a lot of the time. It is unbelievably frustrating.
I will minimize my criticisms of the opposing AI being too good, because I welcome the increased challenge that was lacking in previous installments (even though I do think they are a little too good/smart/quick). All I will say is that I think the puck is glued to their stick just a little too much, and they have a funny way of slipping through a crowd of 3 defenders and scoring a goal, even when they really have no business even coming out alive.
With that, here are my many gripes regarding my team's AI, that almost always lead my team losing games one way or another:
Goalie sucks
Reckless deking in the offensive zone, instead of pulling up or dumping around, resulting in turnovers
Passing to me in situations when I'm clearly either going to get lit up, or stick checked (resulting in me receiving an xp penalty for a turnover)
Literally stare at loose pucks, or even worse, skate by them
Skate into me when I have the puck
They suck at physical play. Very few hits produce results, and they almost never win board play battles.
Don't even get me started with the defense taking the puck behind our own net instead of breaking out, when it's entirely unnecessary. Even when the other team is on a full line change, and there's no forecheck. Jesus.
This is one of my favorites: Coach telling me to come back to the bench when we are in the middle of zone play. We'll be buzzing in the offensive zone on a PP and he will tell me to change out. makes sense right? Even worse, we'll be defending in our own zone, and he will have me completely abandon my position to come back to the bench, giving the super-AI a mini PP. Of course, if I don't listen to him in any situation, my team play and endurance are penalized. I can't even count the number of times I've been forced to abandon the defensive zone to change out, and the opposing team scored before I even made it back to the bench, resulting in a goal for them obviously, and an undeserved -1 for me. That is absolutely unacceptable in my eyes.
Relating to the above, I also cannot count how many times I have simmed to next shift, and it puts me on the ice as the opposing team is entering our zone, and they score before I even make it to the blue line. Oh yay, another -1 I have zero control over.
Got sent down to the minors midway through the season even though I'm on the first line, lead the league in virtually everything, and am meeting expectations. WHAT??!!
**Because of all of the above, I have 203 points approaching the end of the season, yet I am still -14. Doesn't matter how responsible I try to play, how many goals I score or am on the ice for. I've been playing NHL religiously since 09, so this is far from a competency issue. Of course I get frustrated and have bad games and make reckless decisions here and there, but I know the difference between playing poor, and getting screwed.
In conclusion, it just seems like EA can't get it right. My team either wins every single game because of me like in previous games, or we can't get above .500 regardless of how unbelievable I play. In my opinion, ALL AI players on the ice should be on the same sliders in BAP. That way your personal skill, or lack thereof, will be the only true variable and will dictate your overall experience for the most part, which is how I personally think it should be. Obviously some teams are simply better others, but player ratings and attributes is a much different story than computer AI and sliders. I have no problem with the opposing team being extremely good, but I do expect my team to be able keep up with them so that we can at least have a chance - without the game engine blatantly showing its ugly face dozens of times per game, giving a Titanic tilt in favor of the opposing team.
Thanks for reading.