Last week I took my vehicle to Auto Village Center on 12th Ave N in MB because the pedal was hesitating. For a $155 diagnosis, they said the #5 cylinder was misfiring and it needed a coil pack and possibly plugs and wires. Said they could fix it for $798. Sounded high but in order to avoid taking it to some other random shop (I moved here a few months ago and live in a hotel ATM), I agreed to let them do the work.
Couple days later I call, Greg says it will be ready soon then sends me a text saying it also needed plugs and wires, $907.66. That price included 3 hours of mechanic's time at $155 bringing the total labor cost to $620 for diagnostics and repair. They passed along the credit card vender fee so my total out the door price was $934, which I paid.
At the time I assumed the repair was involved but I researched it and it's a very simple job - under an hour to complete. If only I had any tools with me...
I went a few times to see if I could get them to refund some of the mechanic's time but first time was Saturday they were closed, second time Greg was not in. Finally met up with him today and asked about getting some of the mechanic's time back but that went nowhere.
I asked Auto Village Center if they charge everyone $155/hr and they said check with Firestone on 6th so when I got back to the hotel I did. They said they bill $180/hr. I also asked Firestone for an estimate to replace the coil pack, plugs and wires. They ballparked it at $350-$550 and said I could knock off $100 with a coupon. W/o me even asking they said it is a very simple job and would take under an hour billable. Eventually I told them Auto Center Village already did the work and billed me 3 hours. Firestone said they didn't understand how that is possible.
So the shop with the higher hourly could do the repairs for less than half what Auto Village Center charged.