Money is inherently undemocratic. Each dollar acts like a vote to influence the economic direction of society. However, because the distribution of wealth is highly variable, individuals do not have equal say over economic choices. If all individuals had an equal opportunity to influence the economy, the full intellectual capacity of society could be utilized in determining how to distribute its resources. The following describes a theory for how it may be possible to transition from a capitalist economy towards a democratic economy that uses votes as the currency for determining how resources are distributed (estimated timeframe- 30 to 60 years):
Stage 1: The development fund A new form of public investment into registered private organizations is introduced by the government that must solely be spent toward the growth of that organization. Growth can be any initiative that increases the access and public awareness of that organization. However, no expense that is part of an operating cost, such as salaries or materials, can be funded using this investment. The development fund is to be distributed via a democratic process, with every person that is pays taxes to be able to influence the amount that an organization receives. Each individual, on his or her yearly tax documents, would identify a registered organization to receive a part of the development fund. Each organization would, in turn, receive an amount proportional to the number of votes obtained. For example, if an organization receives 2.35% of all votes, that organization would receive 2.35% of the development fund. Subsequently, the receiving organizations would be required to spend that entire development sum towards growth during the next fiscal year. This program would continue to become better funded until the public is aware that through voting on which organizations receive the development fund, they are able to propel the growth of certain organizations. At this point, the development fund would be well established and stage 1 is complete. Estimated timeframe: ~7 years.
Stage 2: Taxation of Growth After the development fund is well-established, a new law is passed that taxes all organizations on all expenses related to growth, such as (but not limited to) building of new franchises, purchase of new equipment, and advertising. However, this new tax would not affect expenses that would perpetuate the business in its current form, such as operating costs. The income of this new tax would be added entirely to the pool that comprises the development fund, substantially increasing the size of the development fund. With this enlargement of the development fund, organizations would begin to realize the potential impact on their growth from this fund and tailor their public image to maximize votes. As a side-note, it will be likely that tax season would become ‘public image season’ for organizations. In addition, it would become less attractive for organizations to spend money towards growth unless they are forced to do so (such as through the development fund). In this manner, the public would begin to shape the expansion of organizations via the development fund. Popular organisations will be fast-tracked while unpopular ones will become stagnant. With the taxation of all growth expenses well established and the public aware of their power to influence the development of organizations, stage 2 is complete: Estimated timeframe: ~10 years.
Stage 3: Introduction of Purchase-Awareness The government would set up an online confidential purchase-awareness account that is linked to a scanable government-issued identification card for all citizens. In addition, public internet access centers, such as those in many libraries, would provide access to the internet if it is not domestically available. The purpose of this account is to help individuals track the amount, content and source of purchases and purchase habits, to obtain more detailed information regarding each product’s source, specifications, & features, and to provide immediate and automated recall notifications on potentially harmful products. This step requires substantial public confidence, substantial technology, research and development, and improved infrastructure that can process the information for each purchase and link it to the confidential account in a secure manner (beta testing highly recommended). It should be emphasized that use of such an awareness system allows for purchasers to be immediately notified via email, or automated call of recalls for purchased items (such as infected food or faulty technology). Once the purchase-awareness system is launched and citizens are making general use of it in a comfortable and routine manner, stage 3 is complete. Estimated timeframe: ~3 years after introduction.
Stage 4: Year-Round Unlimited Voting The confidential purchase-awareness system would be modified to enable individuals to directly vote for registered organizations to receive the development fund on a weekly basis. The confidential purchase-awareness system provides access for voting so that a seamless link can be created between the source of each product or service and the ability for individuals to vote for that source. Each individual would be allowed to vote an unlimited number of times, with each vote have a value equal to 1/(total number of votes by that individual in that week). Accordingly, an individual who votes tem times during the voting period will have a vote value of 0.1 (1/10) for each vote while an individual who votes 50 times during the voting period will have a vote value of 0.02 (1/50) for each vote. The sum of vote values for each registered organization over a voting period, divided by the total vote values of all votes from all individuals for that voting period, and multiplied by the amount of the development fund pooled for that week, would be electronically distributed to the respective organizations at the beginning of the next voting period. In this manner, voting on the development fund by individuals would be able to redirect economic growth with a maximum lag of one week. As well, organizations that are able to consistently receive votes would begin to receive a consistent growth-specific income that allows them to consistently expand. Accordingly, it will be in the best interest of each organization to tailor their products and services in a manner that enables that organization to receive the greatest possible number of votes. Soon after the launch of year-round unlimited voting, organizations may begin to allow publicized voting to become, by itself, a form of currency for the purchase of goods or services. When this transition begins to occur, stage 5 is complete. Estimated timeframe: ~10 weeks.
Stage 5: Publication of Average Past Vote Value. A law would be passed to reveal the average past vote value of an individual to an organization when that individual utilizes voting as a form of currency to pay for goods or services from that organization. For example, an individual will attempt to purchase an item by scanning his or her government issued ID card, which will reveal to the vendor the average past vote value of this individual. Subsequently, the vendor will require a certain number of votes from the individual to satisfy the price of the item being purchased and the individual may choose to submit the number of required votes (reducing his or her future average voting value), pay with money and not submit any votes (increasing future vote value), combine money and votes to pay for the item (reducing, maintaining, or increasing future vote value based on the amount of purchase covered by money and past vote value), or cancel the purchase altogether. In this stage, votes are clearly established as a form of currency that is granted weekly to every citizen. From this notion, it can be determined that a conversion factor would be derived between vote value and money so that every item would also have an equivalent monetary and vote value. Nevertheless, it is imperative that at no point in time for individuals to be able to transfer vote values amongst each other and nor for organizations to transfer any part of their development fund to another organization. By this method, individuals would have the ability to spend 1.00 vote values each week or save that value by converting it to money. When an individual can be minimally sustained in society solely on the worth of his or her vote value (i.e. without money), stage 6 is complete. Estimated timeframe: 6 months to 10 years (highly unpredictable).
Stage 6: Operational Expense Taxation and Automation Initiative The government passes a new law that introduces a tax on all operational expenses while introducing an automation initiative that is aimed at reducing operational expenses. The operation tax increases the financial cost associated with all aspects of operating a business and in turn, the collected tax money is used to fund a team of analysts, engineers, and technicians whose job is to identify operational steps that can potentially be automated and to automate them in an efficient, effective, safe, and robust manner. At first, an assessment team would develop a procedure for discerning the extent to which an organization is responsible for carrying out an essential social service, factoring in vote values received by that organization. Subsequently, the automation team would focus to automate the core organizations discerned to be essential to running society (eg. utilities, hospitals, etc.). Subsequently, the automation team would refocus its efforts towards less and less essential organizations, reducing the operational costs of each organization as the automation attempt is completed. Though automation will force many individuals from their employment positions, all individuals would be able to live in society solely based on their vote values (described in stage 6). As well, this initiative will create higher-order jobs that are much more difficult to replace (such as engineers) and encourage education and culture among citizens, liberating them from the need to work only for the purpose of working [to make money]. It is also noteworthy to mention that automation would significantly optimize the productivity and efficiency of society as a whole, contributing to people’s short-term happiness and support for the automation initiative. Eventually, the practice of automation will become intuitive and the procedure for an organization to become automated would quickly become streamlined, drawing from past experience to drive each phase of automation. Stage 7 would be complete when over 50% of society is either unemployed or employed in a higher-order position, where the purpose of employment is to fulfill a desire for betterment, pleasure, utility, expression, or creativity and that the employed individual would do the same task regardless of employment status. Estimated timeframe: 10-15 years.
Stage 7: Society changes from operating via a monetary capitalist economy to a democratic resource-based economy. Money is discontinued by lack of participation and either replaced by short-term and non-transferrable vote values for compensation via peaceful change or abandoned suddenly via violent change. If war occurs, there is the potential to revert to an entirely monetary society. Since votes and money are both currency, when some of the currency is eliminated (hopefully, money), the remainder of the currency (hopefully, votes) increases in value via a decrease in the amount of vote value required to purchase an item (price decrease). This change will increase the vote value of everyone equally since every individual has an equal overall vote value and the real change is the decrease in the price of goods and services. However, if votes are eliminated instead of money, the individuals who have the most money will benefit and individuals without money will lose all ability to direct society. Estimated timeframe: 10 years.
I look forward to your feedback.