r/MutualfundsIndia • • Sep 13 '25

Unpopular Opinion: Stop your SIPs

0 Upvotes

This is my style and has given 17% CAGR returns over past 2 years. I have no SIPs. Have invested 30L+ over last 2 years but I only buy in lumpsums whenever the markets are down due to uncertainty. I think this should be the way to invest. SIPs would often make you buy at higher NAVs.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Jun 25 '25

Avoid regular plans. Save 1%! Direct plans hi lo! Bhai, why pay commission when direct plans are there.

1 Upvotes

Every other finfluencer and social media paglu sells you this half-truth.

We’ve romanticised the idea of saving 1% so much that most retail investors don’t realise they’re bleeding wealth elsewhere.

The recent SIP data from AMFI is out.

In the heart of small-town India, SIP closures in direct mutual fund plans were 2.6x higher than in regular plans and this is despite the fact that regular plans had a bigger account base.

A large chunk of direct plan SIPs in India are DIY.

Not advised, not reviewed, not thought through. They’re done through apps that glorify ease, and completely ignore execution discipline.

When you’re just one tap away from cancelling a SIP, fear wins. It takes a single bad market month, a flashy tweet, or a dinner table comparison to throw years of compounding out the window.

I’ve seen it repeatedly.

A retail investor logs into an app, looks at returns, and thinks, let me pick the top performer. No one talks about volatility, suitability, asset allocation, or time horizon. Just performance chases on repeat.

Then the markets drop. The same investor starts doubting their decision.

The regular plan investor, the one mocked for paying commission, is still investing because there’s a human in the loop who explains the why.

That nudge, that reassurance, that behavioural anchor, that’s what retail is missing in direct and no Instagram reel or YouTube short can replace it.

This is NOT a cost issue. It’s a discipline issue.

Social media is full of half-truths where they will show you charts, CAGR returns, and TER comparisons. But no one shows you the chart of missed SIPs, panic exits, and lost compounding. That’s not sexy content, but it’s the truth.

If you can’t stay invested, nothing else matters.

Not the platform, not the fund, not even the asset class.

A 1% TER saving is meaningless if your emotions cost you 15% CAGR over a decade.

If you don’t have the time, patience, or knowledge to navigate markets on your own, get help. That’s not weakness.

Investing is NOT about knowing what to buy, it’s about knowing how to behave, and behaviour, my friend, is the real alpha no app can automate.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Jul 25 '25

Fist SIP!!! Am I cooked?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Long story short I did my first SIP on 23 July and now it looks like this. Is my mf selection bad. Please advise.

Also I am looking for a small cap fund. Please give some suggestions.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Sep 26 '26

Question Why people buy Mutual Funds instead of Index funds?

0 Upvotes

Currently I am confused whether to invest in mutual fund or in index fund. I am looking for long term like 10-15 years.

I have also heard that most fund managers are not even able to beat the index in long term but then why mostly people invest in Mutual funds instead of Index funds which have lower expense ratios as well.

I am kind of Moderate risk Investor.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Nov 25 '25

Discussion SIPs can trick you

0 Upvotes

I know it sounds great. If i tell you a mere 10k SIP every month for 21 years at a very conservative XIRR of 12% will fetch you a crore and some change.

But what if i tell you that when you consider inflation at 6% and then recalculate the real value of the above figures.

The whopping 1cr crashes down to 29L.

That alone should terrify a lot of people. It should pose a question in your mind, "Are SIPs really worth it then?" "Is it really okay to sacrifice 20+ years of your life in a SIP?"

Well the answer is still YES. But how do you do it?

First, you have to understand that the above figures mean that after 21 years, you will be able to live the same lifestyle which costs 29L today. So, ask yourself, if someone gave you 29L today, would you be able to retire? If its yes, then there is no problem.

However, and mostly, the answer will be NO. But don't worry, there is a way to tackle that as well. There is one major flaw in the above example which, sad to say, many people don't notice. Its the fact that they keep their SIP amount constant for lifetime. But if you'd just commit to increasing it yearly by 10% alongwith your income, you'd automatically beat inflation and create more wealth as well.

To simplify,
10k SIP for 21 years without increase -> 1 crore; 29L real value
10k SIP for 21 years with 10% increase -> 2.17 crore; 64L real value

Nobody’s income remains constant for 21 years — so why should your SIP?

So instead of asking, "How much should i invest?"
Ask Yourself, "Can I commit to increasing my SIP every year?"


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Dec 27 '24

Portfolio Review

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MutualfundsIndia • • May 16 '26

Discussion Long-term investors should skip diversification and go 100% into equities

0 Upvotes

This is what a recent paper on SSRN has to say, but I think their arguments are flawed.

The paper's entire premise is based on an observation that the asset with a higher expected return has, on average, a higher realized return over long horizons, but I believe that a diversified portfolio has a higher unconditional expected return than 100% stocks.

I choose diversification because it offers a higher return for the risk taken. Going 100% into a single asset class because it has the highest raw return makes me ignore my principle that one should build the highest return-for-risk portfolio.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Jan 26 '26

Discussion Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund has announced the launch of a Financial Services Fund. Should I invest?

0 Upvotes

I'll give credit where it's due, as financial services is not a bad sector right now. The Nifty Financial Services Index has delivered 17.9% CAGR over 5 years and 15.9% over the last year. The index is trading at a PE of 18.1x, which by historical standards is fairly valued. 

Banks are showing business momentum. Punjab National Bank grew advances by 10.15%, Bank of India by 15%, and UCO Bank by 17.5% in Q3 FY26. Even better, asset quality is improving.

Insurance companies, NBFCs, and capital market intermediaries are also riding tailwinds, as IT spending in banking is hitting $15 billion in 2025, and AI is cutting operational timelines by 60%. If you believe India's financialization story, this sector should do well over the next decade.

But sectoral funds are far more volatile than diversified equity funds. When you invest in a financial services fund, your entire portfolio is hostage to one industry. If banks face an NPA crisis, or if RBI tightens regulations, or if deposit rates spike and squeeze margins, your fund will tank.

Motilal Oswal is a decent fund house, but its equity funds have been mixed performers. Launching a new financial services fund in January 2026 feels like AMCs capitalizing on recent sector momentum rather than offering something unique.

If I had ₹1 lakh to deploy today and wanted financial sector exposure, here's what I'd do:

Safest

Invest in a flexicap or multicap fund. These already have 25-35% exposure to financials, so you get participation without concentration risk.

Moderate

Wait 3-6 months, then buy an existing financial services fund with a proven track record.

Tactical

You can consider direct stock picks instead of a fund. At least you control which companies you own and can adjust quickly.

Aggressive

Buy the NFO, but cap it at 5-10% of your equity portfolio and set a trailing stop-loss at 15%.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Jul 20 '25

They Said ‘Never Invest With a Loan’ — I Did It Anyway. Read This Before Judging.

Post image
0 Upvotes

On 11th June 2025, I closed my last personal loan (Rs 16.5 Lacs,10.99%, 60 mths), I had taken on 10th June 2020 — right in the middle of the COVID chaos.

Why? Because I saw opportunity in fear.

While most people were cutting costs and hoarding groceries, I decided to take a bold step: borrow money to invest.

In India, taking a loan — especially a personal loan — is considered risky, even reckless. And doing it to invest in the stock market? Practically financial blasphemy.

But I had a plan.
A system.
A blueprint I believed in.

🧩 The Plan – Leveraging Stability With a Safety Net

Before applying for the loan, I had one question in mind:

After a detailed assessment, I was confident, Yes I can..

🔒 Stable Job & Income Flow
I had solid job security, predictable increments, and performance-based bonuses. I wasn’t gambling. I was leveraging my future cash flow to build wealth faster.

Also I had back tested data about market recoveries after major falls like 2000, 2008, 2015..

🏦 PPF Maturity & Tax Strategy
My 15+5 year PPF was set to mature in 2022. That meant:

  • A tax-free lump sum was coming soon.

  • I could stop contributing to it and divert those funds into fixed-income instruments for my kids.

  • I also temporarily topped up my about to mature PPF account using the loan, allowing it to compound uninterrupted.

This gave me not just financial breathing room, but a layered safety net.

💸 Lumpsum in Dividend-Paying Balanced Fund, And Why Not SIP

Most of the loaned amount was invested as a lump sum into a strong Monthly Dividend Paying Balanced Fund - a fund with a consistent track record.

But here’s the kicker. I didn’t go the usual SIP route. Why?

🎯 Because I wanted to catch the market at knocked-down NAVs.
SIPs spread your entry over time, and during a market recovery, that means you’ll average in at higher prices.

By investing lump sum, I got immediate exposure to the full upside from day one.
Yes, it was another calculated bet a form of market timing.

But timing isn’t always about finding the bottom. Sometimes it’s about recognizing panic-driven irrational lows and acting with courage.

✅ That bet paid off too.

🔁 Why I Chose Dividends Over Growth

I didn’t want to keep selling growth fund units for money. I wanted to build a self-sustaining cashflow engine.

Most people choose growth funds for long-term investing. But I had a different goal:

My dream: a life where my monthly income comes from dividends, not a pay check.

This portfolio was my trial run, a mini version of my future retirement engine. I wanted to experience:

  • How monthly dividends behaved in real life

  • What cashflow patterns looked like through different market cycles

  • How reinvested dividends quietly added units and compounded wealth

I didn't need the pay-outs yet, so I chose automatic reinvestment, keeping the engine running and compounding in the background.

🔥 Challenging the Indian Mindset: Loans Are Not Always Bad

Let’s be honest, in India, taking loans is often associated with financial distress.

We’re conditioned to believe that loans should only be for buying a house or paying for education. Taking a loan to invest? That’s seen as a financial sin.

But here’s the truth:

Used wisely, loans can be powerful tools to build wealth, accelerate goals, and take advantage of market cycles as long as you:

  • Understand the risk

  • Have stable income

  • Don’t over-leverage

  • Respect the math and emotion involved

This wasn’t blind optimism. It was a leap of faith with a parachute.

🎯 Conclusion: The EMI Became My Monthly Income

For five years, I paid a fixed EMI.

Today, that EMI is gone.

But what replaced it?
💥 An almost identical amount — as monthly dividends from the portfolio I built using that very loan.

Let that sink in.
From liability to income.
From outflow to cashflow.
From fear to freedom.

No, this wasn’t luck.
It was belief, backed by a plan, executed with discipline.

💬 Your Thoughts? Let’s Talk

I’d love to hear what you think:

👉 Would you ever consider using a personal loan to invest — if you had a solid plan?

👉 Do we need to shift how we think about loans and financial risks in India?

Drop your thoughts below 👇
And if this story made you think, share it with someone who needs to see a different perspective.

Thanks for reading,
Here’s to bold, thoughtful moves. 🚀

Thanks to chatGPT for compiling the article with my thoughts...


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Feb 20 '25

Small caps have been doing well since yesterday. Where are all the small cap fearmongerers now ?

1 Upvotes

One info for the critics here, I also have 25% allocation to flexi caps in my mf portfolio which will be helpful for redeeming in times when smids underperform or remain sideways for a few years.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Dec 19 '25

Discussion Why 'Regular' wins over 'Direct' for many people

0 Upvotes

I'm fairly new to investing and have an unpopular opinion on the 'regular vs direct mutual fund' debate. A large majority of people, including the younger people (in their 20s), are inexperienced with 'markets' & mutual funds (unlike many of the forum regulars here).

A common response I see on reddit is: "always go with direct mutual funds". While these are obviously cheaper than 'regular mutual funds', they're not always better. This is for two reasons. First, an experienced advisor can estimate how much you can invest and stay invested with. Even with my limited experience, I see newcomers over-estimating their 'staying power' - only to stop SIPs or withdraw investments prematurely (when things start to go south). Second, a good advisor can help you build a 'portfolio' as opposed to picking the 'flavours of the month' - which are not the flavours of the subsequent month... I feel paying a small commission each year is better than making expensive mistakes or even leaving the investment scene entirely. A 'qualified' advisor can also tell you why a particular fund is doing poorly - allaying concerns on the matter.

An advisor/MFD also wins over a one-time fee-only advisor since the fee-only advisor generates a plan for you but leaves you to implement it. In cases like mine, where I don't intend to track or follow stocks/shares and MF developments, this doesn't help in the long run (unless you pay the advisor each year which is like a commission).

I wanted to share this so newcomers see a slightly different take on the regular vs direct debate - which is terribly one-sided on the site.

Perhaps 5 years down the line, with lots of experience, I'll move to direct plans but only time (and the taxes involved) will tell...


r/MutualfundsIndia • • May 05 '26

Question Is 28% cagr possible?

0 Upvotes

ChatGPT says at 28% CAGR, my 40 cr invested today can become 5500 cr. Is that true ? It would turn me into top .1 percent in the world. Is this possible? What funds will give me consistently this over 20 years. Nothing less. Even 2 percent less changes the picture. Amount is hypothetical. But is this true ? Why people invest in real estate which can only double or triple in 20 years ?


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Feb 11 '25

I know this loss is barely anything, but this money isn't mine. People are expecting Small caps to fall for a while, and we'll need this money in less than a year. I am the guarantor of this money. Should I switch to Debt & Hybrid and replenish this short loss myself?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MutualfundsIndia • • Dec 31 '25

Discussion Portfolio difference Indian mutual funds vs us stock market.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/MutualfundsIndia • • Jun 10 '26

News Every SIP investor should listen to this Shankar Sharma interview.

0 Upvotes

Not saying he's 100% correct,but definitely makes some sense.

https://youtu.be/OLPJcTNpNaY?si=vrCk0C6hrUZ5uUh1


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Oct 14 '25

I had a few shares of Tata Motors but it just dipped by 50%

1 Upvotes

So, I had 20 shares of Tata Motors that I had bought a few years ago. They were already at a loss when trading at 600Rs. However, today (October 14, 2025), I saw my portfolio again, and it has just taken a nose dive. What is wrong with this stock? I thought Tata Stocks are supposed to be good.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Sep 02 '25

We Got TIRED of Confusing Money Advice in India | So We Started Breaking It Down Ourselves

0 Upvotes

Hey r/MutualfundsIndia

We kept asking ourselves: 'Why is managing money in India so damn confusing?'

Why does every blog/article/video assume you're either a CA or a finance bro? 😩

So, we decided to take action.

Welcome to Personal Finance TV - a YouTube channel where we take all the complicated money stuff and turn it into simple, relatable content that actually makes sense (and maybe even makes you smile once in a while)

What we cover;

• Budgeting tips that ACTUALLY work

• How to get out of debt (without guilt-tripping yourself)

• Credit scores, CIBIL, and all the HIDDEN traps

• Investing basics: Mutual funds, SIPs, index funds, FDs

• Smart money habits that can change your life

• Mindset shifts for long-term wealth

Whether you’re trying to stop living paycheck to paycheck, start investing, or want to understand where your money’s going, this is the kind of channel we wish we had when we started.

We drop weekly videos, packed with real-life examples, clear strategies, and zero jargon. No drama. No fake gurus. Just straight-up financial clarity

Would love your thoughts, feedback, ideas & if you find it useful, hit that subscribe button.

Let’s uncomplicate finance, together

Team PFTV


r/MutualfundsIndia • • May 15 '26

Question Is it worth even investing in Indian mutual funds when even the best fund has not given returns?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MutualfundsIndia • • Dec 19 '25

Portfolio Review what do i do? 😭

Post image
2 Upvotes

so i’m 21 yrs old and i’m new to investing and this is my hard earned saved money. i have a conservative risk appetite so i just feel like selling 😭 it is a 100 rs per month sip bcz thats only i can manage and i just wanted to learn also i added a lumpsum of 6000 rs thats where it started going down. i’ve heard that in sip u’ll have profits in the long run thats why i switched to sip from stocks. i selected this fund on groww bcz it was the most popular. my goal is to grow my money gradually with guaranteed profits and i’m planning on investing for 5-10 yrs. what should i do should i sell or hold? is this sip fund good? is there anyone who can guide me on investing i would rlly appreciate it.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Apr 24 '25

These are some of the LIES peddled by OLD TIMERS about small cap funds

3 Upvotes

I selectively scan through both the mutual fund subs and few of their posts. I am listing down some of LIES being peddled by OLD TIMERS about small cap funds.

  1. Small cap index has lower rolling returns than Nifty 50 - LIE

  2. Small cap index has lower rolling returns than midcap index - LIE, only Nifty small cap index has lower rolling return than Nifty midcap, BSE small cap has higher rolling returns than Nifty midcap, and active small cap funds have even higher rolling returns than all of them. Small cap is a stock pickers zone where selection matters unlike the midcap index which is why active small cap funds RULE.

  3. Small cap funds have higher risk - LIE, active small cap funds have higher volatility and not higher risk since it is an actively managed portfolio of stocks.

  4. Small caps went down by 50% in 2018 - LIE, small caps went down by 15-20% in 2018 to 2019, then covid happened in 2020 and only after that they went down by 50% cumulatively.

  5. Small caps took 5 years to recover from 2018 January highs and they recovered only in 2023 - LIE, since it took 3 years and they recovered in 2021. Active small cap funds recovered even sooner.

  6. OLD TIMERS try to exaggerate the periods of sideways movement or flat markets in small caps too much like from 2009-2013. These OLD TIMERS forget to add that the small caps were sideways for those 5 years, the small caps weren't crashing. It was a flat market and the large caps during that time weren't doing great either. The small caps rose more in 2009, then stayed flat. The large caps rose less in 2009, then rose only a little during the next 5 years.

This LENGTHY post was necessary to expose some of the LIES peddled by OLD TIMERS about small caps. I have wasted quite a few minutes typing this. I HOPE the OLD TIMERS read this post and do some self reflection.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Mar 29 '26

Question Importance of valuation - see the last 6 months returns comparison

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MutualfundsIndia • • Nov 13 '25

Are mutual funds a scam or I am doing something wrong?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I see my returns are stagnant despite of choosing top performing mutual funds and most of part is in large cap with Equity to Debt roughly 65:35 ratio. The concerns I have with Mutual funds -

  1. You never get to know your actual returns MFs show absolute values. This image above might look impressive to someone but a lot of this investment started a decade ago. How do you all manage to see annual return?

  2. I see returns are bit low in most of my investements compared to index funds in same category. Is it really worth to invest in any fund and pay them TER compared to low index fund expenses?

  3. In second image a lot of this Axis Blue Chip (Now Large Cap) was invested on the day 23-March-2021 when Nifty was under 8000 but return is see really poor.

After seeing all this, I am planning to switch to completely in ETFs and consolidate all these folios into index funds. All these return seem to bother me now. Does anyone have thoughts or done this MFs to ETF consolidation, pls share strategy.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • Jul 07 '25

I have SIP worth of 5k per month. I know it is very low. I'm planning to add 2k per month SIP in new funds. Suggest funds for good long term returns. Also, How are the current ones. Should I continue with them or change the funds.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MutualfundsIndia • • Sep 10 '25

Why dont people buy debt funds instead of Fd?

0 Upvotes

Some funds are giving 15% returns and upto 11% safely. Isnt ot better than even Nifty coz its less risk.