I had a conversation with someone on here regarding women’s struggles in Islam in this life. The below post (yes it’s a bit of a read but it has a lot of points that I have questioned myself through the years and I see other women raise these questions on here) was originally a comment by another user that’s resonated with me. This is for user u/wokeyoke who asked that I make the comment into a post for them to try and answer/clarify:
Here are my questions, why don’t we ever see men question the rulings of the religion the way that women do? Why? Because it feels like everything caters to them, I never see any post with a man questioning why something in Islam is unfair or why Islam favors women and makes their lives easier. It’s always the reverse, so why is that?
Why is it ok for men to blend into the crowd with the disbelievers while women have to be visibly Muslim? Are women not the weaker of the gender? Are men not the leaders and suppose to lead by example? So why aren’t they to be visibly Muslim like us? A woman’s deepest desire is to pretty herself up and dress nicely, just like a man’s deepest desire is more women. So why are their desires not suppressed like ours? They can get a second wife up to four without the permission of the first, even though the first wife doesn’t show her body to anyone but her husband. She only has eyes for him and keeps herself chaste. Does she not deserve having a man only to herself as a reward for having eyes only for him? A man can just marry a younger prettier wife when he’s bored of the first and that’s the thanks the first wife gets for keeping herself chaste only for him. And they say she can just get a divorce, completely disregarding the fact that her heart is shattered and will probably never trust marrying another man again. Just so the husband can satisfy himself with another woman which is completely unnecessary and isn’t a need, just a want.
Women are attracted to men too, the only thing is they are shamed more for being open about it. You can see in the west when women don’t have restrictions they are just as sexually provocative as men are. Not saying it’s right, but why are men allowed to wear perfume and smell good around women in public but a woman is deemed an adulterer if a man smells it and is attracted to the scent? A man can dress nicely in public and if a woman finds him attractive there’s no issue with that.
Why is the Quran always speaking to the male and female or only the male, but never the female directly? Why are men allowed to hit their wives even lightly as if she’s his child as a last resort? How are we not suppose to feel degraded by this? And there’s never a ruling if a man mistreats his wife, how she should deal with him back.
Women are just as attracted to a man’s physical body as a man is attracted to a female’s physical body, so why don’t they cover up the same? Why don’t men have to cover up in prayer like women? I see women covered head to toe in prayer while men pray in a wife beater and shorts, why is his skin allowed to be shown in prayer? Allah has no gender, so why is the woman more restricted? I just don’t understand why everything favours men or is just easier for him.
The rewards are always mentioned for men specifically but not women even though we suffer a lot and struggle for Jannah too. The Hadith is always harsh on women and not men. The Hadith about the majority of women being in jahannam for backbiting and being ungrateful to their husbands, but yet men are the oppressors and commit heinous crimes against humanity and especially against women. Why are women deemed more evil for lesser crimes? I just don’t get it.
The more I try to read and understand the more I drift away from the religion and like the sister said, we try to understand beyond trusting the wisdom so we can strengthen our faiths. We’re not trying to rant and complain, we live in the west and have to face these questions everyday.
It just makes me feel like women are second class citizens and aren’t valued to the same degree men are. Men will be praised for being men, but a woman is only praised for being a good wife, a good daughter, and a good mother. Her position is always in servitude of men. She goes from obeying her father in everything to obeying her husband, why can’t she just think for herself? She’s a grown woman. It’s partnership in marriage, not a master/slave relationship, so why does she have to obey her husband to such an extent that one of the things mentioned for her to enter through all 8 gates of paradise is obeying her husband and dying while he is pleased with her, that the satisfaction of a man grants her entry into paradise. But there’s no mention of a man taking care of his wife or dying while his wife is pleased with him to enter paradise. Men are just praised and glorified in everything, why? What is so special about them? Women today work and provide for their families while also raising children, they have proven they can do both roles and yet aren’t praised left and right. A man provides for his wife and in return gets to pretty much dictate his wife in every matter or always has final say. I’m pretty sure raising children at home 24/7 is more daunting than working a job outside, and yet some women do both. But you don’t see women praised for raising children. Ask any man if he’d prefer raising a child or working a job outside the home and see which answer he provides. I don’t understand what is so special about men that they’re constantly addressed directly in the Quran, are told their rewards, are given so much authority over their women.
Why have there only been 4 women that have perfected their deen in all humanity but countless men have? Does that not make it seem like being a woman and perfecting her religion is much harder? It just seems like everything caters to men and their desires, and makes us feel like we’re second to men in both worlds. That’s why so little women can perfect their deen.
I’ve seen countless sisters ask these questions or similar and there’s never any answer for them. It’s hard to feel this way everyday and be close to the religion, especially when people just make a mockery out of it or cry that we’re ranting instead of seeing the real issue many Muslim women have. Such an arrogant response from people to those just trying to seek knowledge and have a better understanding instead of living in doubt everyday and being driven away from the faith due to this lack of understanding on how it’s fair for certain matters.