I (29F) genuinely need an outside perspective because I feel like I am losing my mind over this situation, and it has now started affecting both my personal and professional life.
For context, we are a Muslim family, and my sister-in-law is a white revert to Islam.
My mother has cancer and recently underwent a mastectomy. When she became sick, I made the decision to break my lease early, give away my cat, and move back home so I could help take care of her. My husband also moved in with me, despite having a somewhat strained relationship with my mother. I also stepped down from my full-time job and went part-time so I could have more time to care for her while continuing my education.
My brother, his wife, and their five-year-old son live downstairs in the same house. When they originally moved in, they agreed to pay rent, but they went approximately seven months without paying anything until I finally pushed them to honor their agreement.
My biggest issue, however, is how they treat my mother.
My sister-in-law NEVER comes upstairs to spend time with my mother. When I say never, I genuinely mean never. My mother has cancer, and my sister-in-law has not once asked her how she is feeling, whether she needs anything, or offered to help her. During my mother's mastectomy, my sister-in-law left to visit her own mother.
My brother is no better when it comes to our mother. He does not come upstairs to spend time with her or help her either. I am extremely disappointed in him because this is his own mother, and he should not need anyone to remind him to check on her.
My mother has actually expressed to me how hurt she is by their lack of involvement, so this is not just me assuming that she feels neglected.
What makes me even more frustrated is that my sister-in-law constantly claims that she is sick or tired. However, she has enough energy to go out with friends, volunteer, and socialize after work. I barely even see her at home because she is constantly out.
She volunteers at the mosque's café, making iced coffees to sell, yet cannot spare even five minutes to come upstairs and ask her seriously ill mother-in-law how she is doing.
I want to emphasize that I do not expect my sister-in-law to become my mother's full-time caregiver or make the same sacrifices that I made. I am fully aware that Islam does not obligate a daughter-in-law to take care of her husband's family. My mother is my responsibility in a way that she is not my sister-in-law's.
However, Islam also encourages visiting the sick, showing mercy, and treating people with kindness. Even outside of religion, I genuinely believe that checking on someone who is seriously ill, especially someone you live with, is basic human compassion.
Even my husband, who has had a shaky relationship with my mother, agreed to move into the house with me so I could support her. You do not have to have a perfect relationship with someone to recognize that they are going through something incredibly difficult.
Another major concern I have is the well-being of their five-year-old son.
He frequently comes upstairs asking for food or attention. His diet is extremely limited, and he mainly eats hazelnut chocolate sandwiches. This is not simply me criticizing a child for being a picky eater. His doctor has actually said that he is underweight and malnourished. He also has a speech delay that requires therapy.
Despite these concerns, I have never seen either of his parents engage him in activities such as reading books, playing sports, or doing other activities that could support his development. From what I have observed, a lot of his time with his mother is spent playing video games.
What frustrates me is that my sister-in-law seems to have plenty of time to go out with friends, volunteer, and socialize after work, but I rarely see her making an effort to help her son expand his diet, read with him, or engage him in activities that could support his speech and overall development.
When she goes out, she leaves him with my brother. I understand that my brother is equally responsible for parenting their child, and I am not suggesting that a mother cannot have a career, friendships, hobbies, or time to herself.
However, when your child has already been identified by his doctor as underweight and malnourished and has a speech delay requiring therapy, I would expect both parents to prioritize addressing those concerns.
Before anyone assumes that I am simply attacking my sister-in-law and excusing my brother, I actually had a conversation with my brother about all of this BEFORE confronting her.
My brother himself admitted that his wife is no longer actively contributing to their household responsibilities. According to him, she takes frozen dinners out for him and their son, refuses to clean up afterward, and expects him to handle most of the household responsibilities because he works from home.
I want to clarify that I believe household responsibilities should be shared. I do not believe that a woman should automatically be responsible for all the cooking, cleaning, and childcare simply because she is a woman.
My brother works from home and does contribute to his household. He helps with their son and other responsibilities. However, according to him, his wife now expects him to do practically everything because she believes it is easier for him since he works from home.
Working from home is still working. It does not mean someone is automatically available to take on every household responsibility.
My brother actually blamed ME for getting his wife her job in the first place. He said that since she started working, her priorities have changed and that she is now picking and choosing which Islamic teachings she wants to follow.
He even asked me to get her fired.
I want to emphasize that this was HIS request, not something I decided to do on my own. I did not get her fired, nor was that the purpose of my conversation with her.
One of the reasons I originally helped my sister-in-law get a job was because I wanted to help both her and her son.
As a revert, I felt that she had not really immersed herself in learning about Islam, and I had concerns about how much Islamic knowledge their son was receiving. For example, I noticed that he would greet us with "hello" instead of salaam. Obviously, that alone is not a major issue, but it was part of my broader concern about his Islamic upbringing.
I worked full-time at an Islamic organization that also has an Islamic school. I offered to help my sister-in-law get a position there because I thought it would be a great opportunity for both of them.
She would have an opportunity to earn her own income, spend time in an Islamic environment, and learn more about the religion. Her son would also receive an employee discount to attend the Islamic school and benefit from an Islamic education.
She did not have a high school diploma or previous work experience, but I helped her secure the position. I was already working there and was her senior.
I genuinely did this to help her and her child. I did not get her the job so I could hold it over her head or demand that she become my mother's caregiver.
She now earns approximately $18 an hour and takes home around $2,000 a month after taxes. Before this job, she had never really had the opportunity to work or earn her own money.
Sometimes I wonder whether having her own income for the first time has changed her priorities, especially given what my brother has told me, but obviously, I cannot know exactly what is going through her mind.
Another issue is that she and my brother appear to have disagreements about their marital expectations.
Before marriage, she had agreed to their living arrangement. My understanding of Islamic marriage is that both spouses have rights and responsibilities, including financial support, cooperation, and honoring agreements made within the marriage. My brother believes that she is selectively applying religious teachings by emphasizing that she is not obligated to care for his family while dismissing other responsibilities and expectations within their marriage.
I understand that she is correct about not being obligated to care for her in-laws. I have never disputed that. However, I also believe that not being religiously obligated to do something does not mean that showing kindness is unnecessary.
There is a difference between saying, "I am not obligated to be your mother's caregiver," and refusing to acknowledge the existence of a seriously ill person living directly upstairs.
After speaking with my brother and hearing his own concerns about their household, I finally confronted my sister-in-law at work on Friday before anyone else arrived.
The reason I spoke to her at work was because I barely ever see her at home. She is constantly out, and there have been times when I only found out that she and my brother were not home because their son came upstairs and I asked him where his parents were.
During the conversation, I addressed BOTH my concerns about their son and my concerns about my mother.
I told her that I find it difficult to understand how she is always too sick or tired to spend even a minute with my mother or make more time for her son's needs, yet she regularly has the energy to go out with friends and volunteer.
I told her that my mother is seriously ill and that her complete lack of acknowledgment is hurtful. I also brought up my concerns about her son's nutrition and development.
She became rude and defensive and accused me of policing her.
I told her that I was not policing her whereabouts. I barely even know where she is most of the time. There have been occasions when I only found out that she was not home because her son came upstairs and I asked him where his parents were.
When other colleagues started arriving, I stopped the conversation because I did not want to discuss private family matters in front of everyone. I came back and sat down, intending to let the situation go.
However, SHE restarted the conversation in front of our colleagues.
She began speaking loudly about how her husband has no money, how he relies on her to order food through DoorDash because he cannot afford it, and how she would never quit her job unless he could provide her with the lifestyle she currently has.
She also said that her job was more important than her husband.
I was genuinely shocked because the conversation was originally about her son's well-being and her lack of compassion toward my mother. Somehow, it turned into a discussion about her income, her husband's financial situation, and her refusing to quit her job.
She was also exchanging glances with another colleague while speaking, which made me feel extremely uncomfortable.
She then completely changed the narrative to make it sound like I was demanding that she quit her job to become my mother's full-time caregiver.
That was NOT what I was asking.
Why would I have helped her get a job in the first place, knowing that it would provide her with income and her child with discounted Islamic schooling, only to demand that she quit?
I was asking why she could not spare a few minutes to acknowledge my mother, who lives directly upstairs and is battling cancer, and why she and my brother were not doing more to address their son's nutritional and developmental needs.
The irony is that my brother was the one who had previously asked me to get her fired, yet I am now being portrayed as the person who wants to take away her job.
What makes the workplace situation even more difficult is that this used to be my full-time job. I had worked there before my sister-in-law and was her senior.
When I worked full-time, I was essentially handling the workload by myself. When I stepped down to part-time to take care of my mother, the organization had to hire additional employees.
The workload is now distributed much more evenly because there are more employees sharing the responsibilities.
The newer employees are mostly in their twenties, and they have become close with my sister-in-law because I am not around as much anymore.
According to some of the older employees who still work there, the newer employees spend a considerable amount of time laughing, socializing, and joking around at work. This frustrates me because I remember how much work I used to handle on my own when I was full-time.
Now, from what I have seen and heard, my sister-in-law and these colleagues are spreading the version of events in which I supposedly want her to quit her job and take care of her mother-in-law full-time.
They seem to sympathize with her, and I feel like I am being portrayed as the unreasonable sister-in-law who wants to control her life.
Meanwhile, some of the older, more established colleagues who worked with me before I stepped down have told me that they understand my position and believe my concerns are reasonable.
It feels like a private family conflict has turned into workplace gossip, and I am now uncomfortable going to a job that I have invested so much time into and where I helped my sister-in-law establish herself.
To make matters worse, my brother proceeded to curse me out after the confrontation.
This is the SAME brother who had previously complained to me about his wife's lack of involvement in their household, blamed me for getting her the job, and asked me to get her fired.
Now, after I actually addressed my concerns with her, including concerns that he himself had expressed, I am somehow the bad person.
I feel like I have been put in an impossible position.
My brother complains to me about his wife and their household. My mother expresses how hurt she is that neither of them comes upstairs to check on her. My nephew frequently comes upstairs asking for food or attention, and I worry about his health and development.
But when I finally say something, I am accused of policing my sister-in-law, trying to control her life, and demanding that she quit her job.
I think what hurts me the most is that I gave up my apartment, broke my lease, gave away my cat, reduced my working hours, and rearranged my life to be there for my mother. My husband also had to make adjustments to his life despite having a complicated relationship with her.
Meanwhile, my brother and his wife already live downstairs and cannot even be bothered to walk upstairs and ask how she is doing.
I am not saying that because I made sacrifices, everyone else has to make the exact same sacrifices. I made those decisions because I love my mother and wanted to support her.
But is it really unreasonable to expect her own son and daughter-in-law to show her some kindness?
Although we are Muslim, I honestly feel like this goes beyond religion. This is about basic human decency and compassion.
I know people who would show more concern for a complete stranger with cancer than my brother and sister-in-law show toward my mother, despite living in the same house.
I also struggle to understand how someone can find the time and energy to volunteer for strangers at a mosque while completely ignoring a seriously ill person in their own home.
I am not saying that volunteering is a bad thing. It is a good thing. But I do believe that kindness and compassion should also extend to the people closest to you.
I also feel incredibly disappointed that someone I helped obtain a job, financial independence, and an educational opportunity for her child is now misrepresenting a private family disagreement in the workplace.
I feel like I have tried to help this family in multiple ways, but whenever I express concerns about what is happening, I am treated as though I am the problem.
I am now considering quitting my own job because I genuinely do not want to deal with my sister-in-law at work on top of everything happening at home. At the same time, I do not want to give up my financial independence or a job that I have worked hard at because of someone else's behavior.
I am in school, working, trying to support my mother through cancer, and dealing with the emotional stress of watching my own brother and his wife show so little concern for her.
I am exhausted, angry, and incredibly resentful.
I know I cannot force someone to care, and I know that confronting my sister-in-law at work may not have been the best decision, even though I initially tried to keep the conversation private.
I also recognize that my brother and his wife are adults and that I cannot manage their marriage for them. But I genuinely do not know how to move forward when their decisions affect my mother, my nephew, the household we all share, and now my workplace.
AITA for confronting my sister-in-law about her lack of compassion toward my mother and my concerns about her son? Am I expecting too much from her?
How do I handle the fact that she has turned this into a workplace issue and is telling people that I want her to quit her job to become my mother's full-time caregiver, when that was not what I was asking?
How do I deal with my brother, who complains to me about his wife and even asked me to get her fired, but then curses me out when I actually address the situation?
Should I consider leaving my job for my own peace of mind, or would I be making another unnecessary sacrifice because of my brother and sister-in-law?
TL;DR: My mother has cancer and recently underwent a mastectomy. I broke my lease, gave away my cat, moved back home with my husband, and stepped down from my full-time job to care for her. My brother and sister-in-law live downstairs, went seven months without paying agreed-upon rent, and never check on my mother. My sister-in-law claims she is always tired but regularly goes out with friends and volunteers at the mosque. Their five-year-old son is underweight, malnourished, and has a speech delay, and I am concerned about his care. My brother admitted that his wife no longer actively shares household responsibilities, blamed me for getting her a job, and even asked me to get her fired. I originally helped her get the job so she could earn money, learn more about Islam, and receive discounted Islamic schooling for her son. After speaking with my brother, I confronted her privately at work about BOTH my mother's situation and her son's well-being. She accused me of policing her, restarted the argument in front of coworkers, and twisted the conversation into me supposedly demanding that she quit her job to become my mother's full-time caregiver. She also publicly discussed her husband's lack of money and said her job was more important than him. Now newer colleagues are sympathizing with her version of events, my brother has cursed me out, and I am considering quitting my own job because of the situation. AITA?