In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
First, I don't believe any Muslim with a heart or conscience could read about the children of Palestine or the victims of war, rape, and persecution and not be pained by what is happening to them. The injustice and aggression that occur are not justified by Islam; rather, Islam explicitly forbids injustice, regardless of who the perpetrator or victim is.
But your problem in this post is that you assume the existence of a just and merciful God necessitates that He prevent every crime and every suffering immediately upon its occurrence, otherwise He does not exist or is not worthy of worship. This is not logical reasoning, but rather a preconceived notion of how God should manage the world.
You are judging God's existence based on your own conception of what God should do.**
You ask: Where was God when the children were killed? And why didn't He send angels to save them? And why didn't He cause the earth to swallow up the oppressors?
But before you ask why God didn't prevent all these events, you must answer a prior question: In the Islamic view, is this world a place created so that every person can have a life free from pain and injustice?
The answer is: No.
God Almighty said:
“He who created death and life to test you [as to] which of you is best in deed.” [Al-Mulk: 2] He said:
“Do people think that they will be left alone because they say, ‘We believe,’ and will not be tested? And We certainly tested those before them.” [Al-Ankabut: 2-3]
In Islam, this world is a place of trial, not a place of final recompense. This trial does not mean that God loves the suffering of people or approves of the crimes committed against them.
2. You are confusing God’s permission for evil to occur with His approval of evil.
This is a fundamental difference.
God gave humankind free will and the ability to choose, and He granted them moral responsibility for their actions. Therefore, a person can choose justice or injustice, kindness or aggression.
But the fact that God has allowed for choice does not mean that He approves of every choice.
God Himself says:
“And let not those who disbelieve think that Our granting them respite is better for themselves.” [Al Imran: 178]
And He says:
“And never think that God is unaware of what the wrongdoers do.” [Ibrahim: 42]
And in the Hadith Qudsi, it says:
“O My servants, I have forbidden injustice for Myself, and I have made it forbidden among you, so do not wrong one another.” Narrated by Muslim.
Therefore, Islam does not say that rape, murder, and oppression are acceptable because God has permitted them. Rather, it says that they are sins and crimes for which their perpetrators will be held accountable.
3. Why doesn't God intervene with a miracle to save every oppressed person?
Because you are treating miracles as if they are a permanent emergency service, as if God promised humanity that He would intervene with a miracle every time someone commits a crime.
Where did Islam say that?
The miracle of the birds of Ababil was a specific event, the miracle of Moses was a specific sign, and the angels' victory at Badr occurred within a specific context. The Quran does not promise that these miracles will be repeated to save every person from every attack.
In fact, the Quran itself tells us that God's prophets were subjected to harm, persecution, and even death, and that believers endured severe trials.
Allah Almighty says: {Or do you think that you will enter Paradise while such [trial] has not yet come to you as came to those who passed on before you? They were touched by hardship and suffering and were shaken until [even] the Messenger and those who believed with him said, “When is the help of Allah?” Unquestionably, the help of Allah is near.} [Al-Baqarah: 214]
Reflect carefully on this verse: Even the Messengers and the believers who were with them were subjected to such great trials that they wondered about the timing of Allah’s help. Was that proof that God had abandoned them? Was their suffering proof of His non-existence or lack of mercy?
Of course not. Trials and tribulations are not a new phenomenon in human life, and God did not promise His servants that they would not face injustice or harm simply because they believed in Him.
4. You say: Why didn't God punish the oppressors immediately?
Because you are confusing the delay of punishment with the absence of justice.
You are judging divine justice as if death is the end of everything, as if if a person kills a child or rapes a woman and then dies without being punished in this world, that's the end of it.
But this is not the Islamic conception of life.
God Almighty said:
“And never think that God is unaware of what the wrongdoers do. He only delays them for a Day when eyes will stare [in horror].” [Ibrahim: 42]
And He, the Exalted, said:
“And let not those who disbelieve think that Our granting them respite is better for themselves. We only grant them respite so that they may increase in sin, and for them is a humiliating punishment.” [Al Imran: 178]
And the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
“Indeed, Allah gives respite to the wrongdoer, but when He seizes him, He does not let him go.” Then he read:
“And thus is the seizure of your Lord when He seizes the cities while they are committing injustice. Indeed, His seizure is painful and severe.” (Agreed upon).
So, the fact that the oppressor is not punished before our very eyes does not mean that he has escaped justice. And the delay of the reckoning does not mean its cancellation.
And here, precisely, the importance of belief in the Hereafter in Islam becomes apparent; because this world is not the place where all rights are necessarily fulfilled.
5. And what about the innocent children who die? Did they deserve what happened to them?
No, absolutely not. And Islam does not say that they deserve to be killed, starved, or assaulted.
God Almighty says:
“And no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another.” [Al-An'am: 164]
The child does not bear the sin of his killer, nor is he held accountable for a crime he did not commit.
But there is an important question: Why do you assume that dying at a young age means that the child's life has ended in nothingness, and that there is no justice or mercy awaiting him?
This assumption is based on a materialistic view that makes death the end of existence. Islam, however, believes that life does not end with death, and that God does not neglect the rights of His servants.
This does not mean that we know the details of the wisdom behind every tragedy, or that we should reduce the death of children to a mere test. Rather, it means that the death of the oppressed does not prove that God wronged them, nor that their rights were lost.
6. What about the women, minorities, and oppressed people you mentioned?
Here I want to ask you: Why do you attribute the crimes committed by people to Islam itself, and then ignore the texts that prohibit those crimes?
You mentioned the rape of women, forced marriage of minors, honor killings, and the persecution of religious minorities.
Do you believe that the mere fact that the perpetrator of these crimes is affiliated with Islam makes his actions Islamic?
Islam does not grant Muslims moral immunity, nor does it make aggression permissible simply because the perpetrator is Muslim.
Indeed, God Almighty says:
“O you who have believed, be persistently standing firm in justice, witnesses for God, even if it be against yourselves or parents and relatives.” [An-Nisa: 135]
And He says:
“And let not hatred of a people prevent you from being just. Be just; that is nearer to righteousness.” [Al-Ma'idah: 8]
Indeed, the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
“Beware of injustice, for injustice will be darkness on the Day of Resurrection.” Narrated by Muslim.
He also said:
“Whoever kills a person with whom a covenant has been made will not smell the fragrance of Paradise.” Narrated by Al-Bukhari.
This is an explicit text warning against aggression against a non-Muslim who has a covenant and a guarantee of safety.
As for women, the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
“Treat women well.” Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim.
Therefore, one cannot condemn Islam because of crimes committed by some of its adherents without discussing what Islam itself says about these crimes.
By the way, I'm not saying that everything that happens in Muslim societies is justifiable or that every social practice has a legitimate basis. In fact, some practices may be completely contrary to the religion, even if they are carried out by people who claim to uphold its principles.
7. What about the miracles you mentioned?
You're listing the miracles of the prophets as if they were a litany of divine interventions that were supposed to be repeated in every time and place.
But a miracle in Islamic belief is not a promise that God will avert all physical harm from every person.
Look at the story of Moses, peace be upon him: he was sent with signs, yet the Children of Israel lived through years of oppression under Pharaoh's rule before relief came to them.
Consider the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) himself: he was harmed, his companions were persecuted, some believers were killed, and Muslims were forced to emigrate.
So, was the fact that not every one of them was saved by a miracle proof that God does not exist?
Indeed, the Quran mentions that some prophets were unjustly killed:
“And they kill the prophets unjustly” [Al-Baqarah: 61].
If God allowed injustice to befall even His prophets in this life, this clarifies that protection from all worldly harm was not a divine promise in the first place.
**8. Furthermore, the existence of evil does not logically prove the non-existence of God.
This is an important philosophical point.
You could say: I don't understand why God allows so much suffering.
This is a legitimate question.
But to move from "I don't understand why God allowed this" to "therefore God doesn't exist" is a logically unnecessary transition.
Our lack of knowledge about the cause of a particular event does not prove the absence of a cause or wisdom behind it.
Take a simple example: Your lack of understanding of why a doctor performs a painful operation does not prove that the doctor is acting unwisely. Of course, the example is not a perfect match for the issue of evil, but it illustrates that not perceiving wisdom does not equate to proving its absence.
Islam does not demand that you know the detailed wisdom behind every event, but rather affirms that God's knowledge and wisdom are far greater than the limited knowledge of humankind.
God Almighty says:
“And you [mankind] have not been given of knowledge except a little.” [Al-Isra: 85]
Note: I am not using the limitations of knowledge to silence the question or to claim that any explanation is beyond reproach. Rather, I am saying that our lack of understanding of a particular wisdom is not proof of God's non-existence.
9. And there is another question at the heart of your objection: On what basis do you judge that what happened was evil and unjust in the first place?
You are using concepts such as justice, human dignity, and the sanctity of innocent lives as objective standards that should not be violated.
I agree with you that killing innocent people, rape, and persecution are evil acts.
But if you adopt a purely materialistic view of the universe, you must explain the basis upon which these moral judgments are objective, binding truths, and not merely human feelings and preferences that have evolved socially and biologically.
This does not mean that an atheist cannot be a moral person, nor that a non-believer cannot distinguish between good and evil. That is a completely different fallacy.
The question concerns the philosophical basis of morality, not the ability of non-believers to practice morality.
In the Islamic worldview, good and evil are not merely a changing social convention; rather, there is a divine moral foundation whose judgments transcend human desires and interests.
10. Finally, she says: If I stand before this God, I will ask Him why He didn't save these people.
But let me remind you that the Islamic conception of the Day of Judgment is not that a person will stand before God to be held accountable for their decisions, as if they possessed judicial authority over the Creator.
Rather, every person will stand to be questioned about their deeds, the injustice they committed, and the rights they violated.
God Almighty says:
"So by your Lord, We will surely question them all about what they used to do." [Al-Hijr: 92-93]
And the wronged will have their due, even if they cannot reclaim it in this world.
The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
“Rights will be restored to their owners on the Day of Resurrection, even to the extent that the hornless sheep will be given its due from the horned sheep.”
Narrated by Muslim.
Reflect on the meaning of this: Even rights that may seem insignificant to people will not be lost with Allah. So how much more so the rights of children, women, and the vulnerable who have been subjected to murder, rape, and oppression?
The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) also told us about the bankrupt person on the Day of Resurrection: the one who comes with prayers, fasting, and charity, but who wronged this person, insulted that person, slandered another, and shed the blood of yet another. Those wronged will be given from his good deeds. If his good deeds run out, some of their sins will be taken and placed upon him. Narrated by Muslim.
This means that outward piety will not save the oppressor from the rights of others.
Finally, I want to highlight the fundamental difference between our positions:
You look at the world's tragedies and say: If God existed, He would have prevented them.
But I say: The existence of these tragedies does not prove God's non-existence, because Islam did not tell us that this world is a realm of perfect justice or that every oppressor will be punished immediately. Rather, it told us that humans are responsible for their actions, that God does not condone injustice, and that the final reckoning has not yet come.
I refuse to let our lack of understanding of God's wisdom lead us to judge His non-existence, and to hold Him responsible for the crimes of humanity, while ignoring the fact that these same humans are responsible for them.
If death is the end, then the oppressed may die without receiving justice, and the oppressor may die without being held accountable. In Islam, death is not the end of justice, and the delay of the reckoning is not its cancellation. No one's rights are lost with God.
This is the essence of belief in the Hereafter, not an attempt to evade accountability for evil and suffering.
May God guide us all.