r/MusicEd • • Dec 27 '23

Admin moved my classroom and all my stuff over the unpaid days off between Christmas and New Year’s

1.3k Upvotes

You get it. Music rooms have a lot of shit in them. Instruments, books, artwork from kids, photos, supplies, etc.

They moved everything to a new room. New room has no white/chalk boards and the SMART board hasn’t been installed. No decorations, and now all my stuff is dumped in the middle of the room. I don’t even have keys to lock the doors.

They want me to come set it all up before we bring kids back after New Year’s. I’m not. I will cancel classes (private school, so I can cancel for certain things) and get it done during the school day. I was informed THE DAY BEFORE WINTER BREAK STARTED that I would need to move classrooms “mid to late January” and “sometime in January” to give me time to prepare after the holiday craziness that is music in December.

I have personal photos, personal instruments, personal technology things in there. No sense in bringing it home when I use it there exclusively and use it there daily.

I hope they didn’t break/damage anything. Ugh.


r/MusicEd • • Mar 13 '25 Polished Gold Turd

Help with a disrespectful transphobic student

1.3k Upvotes

Asking for some help dealing with a student who makes transphobic remarks at me. I'm a 6th year teacher and have never experienced it to this level.

I am a music teacher and recently assigned a rap project. I am also a trans man. I have not discussed being trans with the students however some of them do know.

I have had a few remarks from this student like at least I know my gender etc. After disciplining disruptive behaviors. This student is in 6th grade. I have called hone and written referrals each time. The last time the student was suspended from music class for 2 days and this was their 2nd class back.

In their rap that the student submitted for a grade they wrote a line that said "You said you don't play favorites but you're actually autistic. You say that you're a man but we all know that isn't true"

I brought the assignment to my administrator. He told me to think of what I would like their consequence to be. I told him I'm not really sure it's uncharted territory for me. They are already missing out on future major events for other behavioral reasons. He told me to think about it and get back to him and I really have no idea.

I told him it doesn't upset me personally but this kind of behavior and language shouldn't be tolerated. He told me if it doesn't upset me I wouldn't have brought it to him.

What I'm worried about though is that she will think that kind of harassment is permissible and will do it to other students. Middle school is a hard time for kids especially ones struggling with their identity and I don't want this student making comments like that to vunerable students.

Her parents are a teacher in my department and on the school board.

Genuinely asking for advice on how to handle this. What should I tell my principal about the students consequences.

We went over expectations for rap topics for a LONG time and I didn't get one other inappropriate rap from the other 50 students I did this with.

Thank you

UPDATE:

Admin talked to the parent who was aparently defensive. This student is going to be removed from class until further notice and I'm going to provide work for them to do alone. Thank you all for your great advice.

ALSO:

The amount of transphobic messages I've gotten from this post is very sad. I would not expect music educators to feel this way. Music is often a safe space for gender non conforming kids and I hope that you can see that trans people existing doesn't hurt you in any way.


r/MusicEd • • Feb 05 '24

One of my students smells really bad.

1.2k Upvotes

It's so bad that it fills the whole band room by the end of the day. Some other students have approached me already. How do I approach this without hurting anyone's feelings?

I know his parents from back in the day. His dad was also smelly, so I wonder if it's genetic.

Halp


r/MusicEd • • Dec 20 '23

I teach two brothers piano, they want me to teach the third brother and I refused.

911 Upvotes

So to give context, I’m a private piano teacher at a conservatory. I’m the only one who teaches on Saturdays. This family has a three boys, ages 14, 8, and 5. I teach the 14 and the 8 year olds, and the parents just drop them off and then pick them up afterwards, which they know they’re not supposed to do.

Recently they asked me if I could start teaching their 5 year old also (I start at 5). I told them no because a) he JUST turned 5 when they asked me and b) the second I say yes, they would leave all three kids with me for an HOUR AND A HALF.

Do they accept the answer? Nope, instead, they try to go to the conservatory manager to try to MAKE me take them. Luckily she said it was only up to me.

TL,DR: Parent tried to go above me to try to get free babysitting for all three of her kids.


r/MusicEd • • Nov 28 '23

This really makes me mad…

Post image
854 Upvotes

r/MusicEd • • May 08 '26 Regret

Thoughts: Kids aren’t growing up singing and we’re seeing the effects.

795 Upvotes

I am a high school choir director, 15 years of experience. As the years pass I’m finding more and more of my incoming 9th grade students struggle to match pitch and/or find their “singing voice.” Many students don’t seem to sing outside choir, and unless they’re really passionate about music most admit they don’t listen to much music that they sing along with. I feel that many things are contributing to this: “singing culture” is virtually non existent in society these days, a lot of the music coming out now doesn’t lend itself to harmonizing or singing along, kids are isolated with their phones and Spotify accounts so they aren’t exposed to music they wouldn’t normally seek out, and their parents don’t sing. Anyone else thought about this as much as me? I have always had a boy here and there who struggles with pitch (mostly due to the changing voice) but I have many 9th grade girls who struggle to hear and identify intervals, even small ones that we drill in class often, and I’ve had to be incredibly strategic about seating charts because at least 20% of them need to be near someone who has a strong ear or they won’t sing in tune. It’s baffling to me because I don’t remember having this many kids who struggle when I first started 15 years ago.

Edited to add: I think another big problem in schools is that kids have music in elementary school, and it’s only once a week as many of you in the comments have pointed out, but also once they get to the middle levels, it’s no longer required for most schools. So they learn these fundamentals, then they don’t do any of it for two or three years, their voices change and their bodies grow, and they’re not singing during that time, then they get to high school and they want to take choir or another music class and they don’t know how to access any of those skills that they might have built an elementary school. I’m having lots of thoughts on this this morning!


r/MusicEd • • Jan 29 '24

Saw some disgusting comments about one of my middle school chorus students on Facebook from the parent of one of my other students. Could/Should I do anything about this on my end?

789 Upvotes

TL;DR: Should I react in any way to a student of mine being publicly disparaged by the parent of another student of mine on social media?

I teach middle school chorus. In my 7th grade chorus class, I have a student who has transitioned one gender to another.

I've noticed some posts on Facebook from a parent of one of my other chorus students regarding the trans student that were absolutely vile, mentioning the trans student by name (both their previous name and their current one) and calling them all sorts of insulting names/labels. I am not "friends" with this parent, but they are a "friend of a friend", and one of the parent's posts appeared in my feed (I think because my actual friend made a comment on it). It appears everything the parent posts is public, and there are similar posts talking about other specific LGBTQ+ students on their feed in very similar ways. I haven't seen anything about any of my other current or even former students.

I've not had any sort of discipline problem with the parent's child in chorus, great singer, hard worker, and never a problem for me. I've never seen them be unsupportive of the trans student, in fact, quite the opposite.

Is there anything, besides possibly at least informing administration and/or possibly a guidance counselor, that I could/should be doing regarding this situation? I feel like ignoring it or pretending I didn't see it isn't the answer, and I KNOW that commenting on Facebook is not right either (it would actually violate our school's social media policy to do so). But I'm torn as to what else I could/should do on my end.

I don't know to what extent the trans student is "out" to their family, so I'm hesitant to make direct contact to them about it.

Any advice would be warmly welcomed. Please also note that I am attempting to use the right vernacular regarding my trans student, but if there is a better way I can word anything I've stated above, constructive feedback on that would also be welcomed.


r/MusicEd • • Jan 13 '24

Would it be wrong to recommend my private student to stop school lessons?

693 Upvotes

I'm teaching a third grader private piano and flute lessons. She's currently taking flute lessons at her public school's band program but the band teacher there doesn't teach traditional music notation. (No beats, no measures, just solfege and the fingering below with a space if the note is being held out.) this system is used for all the elementary school students.

The student can already read musical notation. She knows the same fingerings for school band but her school calls G = Do, A = Re, etc. She's playing well on the Rubank elementary method book.

The problem is, now the student is now getting confused reading the teacher's system of music and is getting really demotivated because she can't read the school music well now. (particularly the rhythms. There's just spaces to mean extra beats and it's not clear) She's particularly upset cause they're "easier songs" but she can't read them.

Would it be best to recommend the student to not partake in school lessons? (They're individual flute sectionals.) The band teacher has also been teaching some of the fingerings incorrectly as well (and insisting on the incorrect fingerings.) I know the music teacher is probably trying her best but I don't want my student to develop bad habits and lose motivation to play.

Edit: the email to the elementary band teacher has been sent asking if we can discuss the curriculum. I'll be giving her a week to respond. The kid will be trying some music language games thanks to u/JohnConradKolos 's suggestion. The student is also entering a local flute choir in order to get some actual ensemble experience.

But I'm going to encourage the parents to keep their child in school lessons until the end of the year because it's a commitment. If the child wants to stop school lessons for the next year, then I'll tell the parent it's okay and we'll find some other children's ensemble setting for the child. Luckily, there's a plethora of options in our area.


r/MusicEd • • Dec 18 '23

Orchestra parent went crazy during concert!!

658 Upvotes

Hello everyone I am the Director of Music on campus. I teach Band, choir, guitar, and orchestra. We had a concert on Thursday at 6, a student in my in orchestra decided to ask me at 5:45pm if they can be on first chair. I told them no that’s no the way we rehearsed and it’s going to make your parent think you are first when your not and then the other parent will be upset that their child isn’t first anymore last 2nd when I was introducing our boosters that student then sat in 1st chair so I went over to them and told her no she cannot do that then here comes here mom(Valerie) poking the you know what out of my back saying I need to make her daughter the first Fuing chair already and I told her ma’am don’t touch me like that and 2 that’s not the way music works. Then the mom then looked at my current first chair and told the student you don’t deserve that chair you b*h I then told the parent leave my concert she walked away with her child cussing me out calling me all the names in the book( this was happening during the concert the whole place was quiet while this was going on). They then cussed out my boosters and my son who is in the wind ensemble. What do you all think of this what can I tell this parent after the break or what do I do with the student who started all of this? Please I need help this has never happened to me


r/MusicEd • • Dec 14 '23

Concert - should I let this student perform?

613 Upvotes

Hi y’all! I have this student who just does not understand anything about music. I have worked with her privately, my assistant has worked with her privately but she just does not understand music at all. At parent teacher conferences, her father said that he was against her joining orchestra because he hated music class growing up. She has stated for the past few weeks that’s she’s not gonna even put in an effort anymore with our strings class because she’s “quitting anyways”.

Well now we’re at the end of the semester with our winter concert being tomorrow. She’s missed about a week of school and finally showed up today. Should I let her perform tomorrow? She is very clearly not ready musically to perform, just playing randomly and at her own will. The other students are upset because “we sound better when she’s not here”. Help please!

Update: I asked her after class if she was feeling ready to perform because she had missed a lot of school. I offered an alternate assignment for full credit instead of a concert but she said she wanted to perform. The concert ended up being fine and you couldn’t hear her at all (I don’t think she’s rosined her bow in a while lol). However, she left right after she was done. My students are required to stay throughout the whole concert for credit. Her case was locked up in the music room so now I have an empty case and there’s a violin floating around somewhere out there (ugh!) hopefully she brings it back tomorrow in one piece.


r/MusicEd • • Oct 04 '24

“Dump Elective” kids

430 Upvotes

So I’m still working on rebuilding a 7-years-dead music program at a high school. Some of the kids were dumped in by admin because my classes “had room,” so now I’ve got 1/4 to 1/3 of each band/orchestra class having no desire to play anything at all.

Still, 90% of them are being troopers and learning and even starting to have fun. I do have a couple who refuse to do anything. They sit there on their phones, pulling chairs out of the band setup so they can be in the back corner, and they shake their heads at me when I tell them to put away the phones (first warning) or turn them in to me until end of class (second warning…school policy).

Now I have an angry parent email from one of these kids’ folks saying that their kiddo doesn’t deserve an F. I don’t feel right just giving out passing grades for refusing to participate & not doing any of the assignments. For those who’ve been here as a teacher in a new school, what’s the dance I have to play with admin & parents given that our bands & orchestras have earned “dump elective” status?


r/MusicEd • • Feb 12 '24

Update on the elementary band teacher teaching flute incorrectly

365 Upvotes

I reached out to the teacher and she finally got back to me but and explained her methods. Claims note reading is not doable at a 3rd grade level and kids should be focusing on sound production since "40-60% of the air expelled by the player goes over the instrument anyways." And since none of the students are able to consistently produce a sound at month 5, they won't be moving on to notation. These are group lessons with 5 flute students (a few have dropped). They have been playing hot cross buns since October.

Apparently, the teacher has been aiming solely on the kiss and roll technique. I offered to come in one day- maybe let students try out a pneumo-pro to talk about airstream directions. I also gave her some contacts to people with the NJ flute society because they have an outreach program with public schools. Unfortunately, she's not receptive to the idea at all.

Parent has decided to take the student out of school lessons. The student has consistently asked to quit flute at school. According to parents, middle school and high school band directors are aware- it came up at a band boosters meeting.

At the end of the day, it's out of my hands.


r/MusicEd • • Jun 11 '26 Heartwarming

Musings from a veteran 27 year teacher who is 2 months away from retirement

301 Upvotes

1)I am less rigid than when I started in 1999 .

2)Administrators come and go, teachers stay.

3)Never wish the pain in the ass kid was not in your class, because guaranteed some bigger pain in the ass will be coming around the bend.

4)Nature Hates a Vacuum - when the attention seeking kid is absent, another student who is usually not disruptive will rise up to take their place.

5)Unless you work in Special Education, when an unevaluated child, who desperately needs special accommodations or services, acts out in your classroom - YOU are a bad classroom manager. In the mainstream classroom , a child with undiagnosed autism acts out in your class while an administrator is watching - the administrator labels you as a bad classroom manager , but in special education, everyone knows the child has special needs that need to be met and accomodated. The child screaming is screaming because he/she learned they can’t hit people when they are frustrated! like they had been doing. The administrator of the special needs classroom understands this and you are not labeled.

6)I am not as important as I thought I was when I first started. Not that music education isn’t important, but if I don’t fit in with what the administrators expect/need/demand , there are many other music teachers who could take my position-though noone will quite do it like me.

7)Concerts/Assemblies are like Bulletin Boards in and out of the classroom-they show final product and are great public relations for the school, but all the real important work takes place in the classroom. I have high expectations in my class, but when we get on stage, anything could happen.

8)Related to 7-the kids could burp on stage and do very little of what I taught them and the parents would love it. They just want to see their child perform on stage.

9)Related to 6-Happy parents, make happy administration, which gives less headaches for me

10)Related to 9-Grade on a curve-create a system where the student who earns the lowest grade gets a B- or 3-, and then administer the grades up from there. Parents don’t care about what the grade means - just that it does not have a bad connotation .ie C or below. You know from your work who is at the top, middle, and bottom of the class and that is what truly matters.

11)I am too old and too tired to complain to parents about their kid’s behavior, especially since many learn the behavior from what the parents model. I will gladly call the parents of students who are showing good effort in my class.

12)Lesson plans - if you fail to plan you plan to fail

13)Your coworkers are not who you look to for fulfillment of personal friendships in your life. Be professional, be compassionate, be friendly, but remember that everyone has stuff going on outside of work that they let bleed into their professional life. At the end of the day, you need to care of yourself and your family and friends.

14)Don’t live to work, work to live-don’t let your professional life take up space in your brain off work hours.

15)Your worth as a teacher is not based off of 1 observation or 1 concert, but the mosaic that is formed from a career of giving concerts and being observed in the classroom.

16)A career in education is a marathon, not a sprint. Pace yourself. You have a bad day, go home, enjoy yourself and relax, get a good nights sleep, wake up and start all over again.

17)Know your contract and if you belong to a union, know what the union officials are planning on doing on your behalf that will affect your salary and benefits, before it actually happens.

18)Related to 7-I HATE BULLETIN BOARDS!

19)Working in a school means working in a small community where everyone has a job of importance and should be treated with the respect that comes with it, no matter if the job is teacher, administrator, paraprofessional, related service provider, custodian, nurse, parent liaison, cafeteria worker. If you work in any capacity in a school, you treat every coworker with professional respect.

20)The only thing my teacher training gave me was the license to learn how to become the teacher I was destined to be. All the coursework and hoops I had to jump through to get my MA and my license in the real world mean NOTHING. I have been in a test from the first day I started my first job 27 years ago. That is where you learn to become a teacher.

21)Teacher wisdom cannot be taught - it is the ability to know how to avoid doing stupid shit that will get you in trouble. You acquire teacher wisdom by doing stupid shit that gets you in trouble and learning not to do it again.

22)If a lesson is not working , don’t keep “beating a dead horse” - switch it up and go to your plan B (the lesson you can pull out of your back pocket and never fails).

23)Over 27 years of doing school concerts, 99% of them left me unsatisfied that I could of done better, but I was always 100% proud of my students

24)Any new teacher reading this will forget 1 or more of these life lessons, and have to learn the hard way.


r/MusicEd • • Dec 20 '23

The life of a specials teacher…

281 Upvotes

The Seventh grade team at my school decided to do something nice for their kids and do a Winter Extravaganza tomorrow during all of their specials period. Which is fine, except they didn’t tell any of the specials teachers. Even though they’d had it planned. For two weeks.

I have kids who need to make up piano work before the end of the semester on Friday. Now I have to be the bad guy and say, “No, you can’t participate in your party because you have work that you have to do. So sorry.”

And on top of it, all of the specials teachers are SCRAMBLING to make lists of these students!!!!!

Thank you, seventh grade teachers, for adding more work to our plates at the last minute.

headdesk the life of a specials teacher, I stg.


r/MusicEd • • Aug 15 '25

Musings from a music teacher entering his last year before retirement after working for 25 years.

273 Upvotes

1)I am less rigid than when I started 25 years ago..

2)Administrators come and go, teachers stay.

3)Never wish the pain in the ass kid was not in your class, because guaranteed some bigger pain in the ass will be coming around the bend.

4)Nature Hates a Vacuum - when the pain in the ass kid is absent, another student who is usually not disruptive will rise up to take their place.

5)Unless you work in Special Education, when an unevaluated child, who desperately needs special accommodations or services, acts out in your classroom - YOU are a bad classroom manager. In the mainstream classroom , a child with undiagnosed autism acts out in your class while an administrator is watching - the administrator labels you as a bad classroom manager , but in special education, everyone knows the child has special needs that need to be met and accomodated. The child screaming is screaming because he/she learned they can’t hit people when they are frustrated! like they had been doing. The administrator of the special needs classroom understands this and you are not labeled.

6)I am not as important as I thought I was when I first started. Not that music education isn’t important, but if I don’t fit in with what the administrators expect/need/demand , there are many other music teachers who could take my position-though noone will quite do it like me.

7)Concerts/Assemblies are like Bulletin Boards in and out of the classroom-they show final product and are great public relations for the school, but all the real important work takes place in the classroom. I have high expectations in my class, but when we get on stage, anything could happen.

8)Related to 7-the kids could burp on stage and do very little of what I taught them and the parents would love it. They just want to see their child perform on stage.

9)Related to 6-Happy parents, make happy administration, which gives less headaches for me

10)Related to 9-Grade on a curve-create a system where the student who earns the lowest grade gets a B- or 3-, and then administer the grades up from there. Parents don’t care about what the grade means - just that it does not have a bad connotation .ie C or below. You know from your work who is at the top, middle, and bottom of the class and that is what truly matters.

11)I am too old and too tired to complain to parents about their kid’s behavior, especially since many learn the behavior from what the parents model. I will gladly call the parents of students who are showing good effort in my class.

12)Lesson plans - if you fail to plan you plan to fail

13)Your coworkers are not who you look to for fulfillment of personal friendships in your life. Be professional, be compassionate, be friendly, but remember that everyone has stuff going on outside of work that they let bleed into their professional life. At the end of the day, you need to care of yourself and your family and friends.

14)Don’t live to work, work to live-don’t let your professional life take up space in your brain off work hours.

15)Your worth as a teacher is not based off of 1 observation or 1 concert, but the mosaic that is formed from a career of giving concerts and being observed in the classroom.

16)A career in education is a marathon, not a sprint. Pace yourself. You have a bad day, go home, enjoy yourself and relax, get a good nights sleep, wake up and start all over again.

17)Know your contract and if you belong to a union, know what the union officials are doing on your behalf that will affect your salary and benefits, before it actually happens.

18)Related to 7-I HATE BULLETIN BOARDS!

19)Working in a school means working in a small community where everyone has a job of importance and should be treated with the respect that comes with it, no matter if the job is teacher, administrator, paraprofessional, related service provider, custodian, nurse, parent liaison, cafeteria worker. If you work in any capacity in a school, you treat every coworker with professional respect.

20)The only thing my teacher training gave me was the license to learn how to become the teacher I was destined to be. All the coursework and hoops I had to jump through to get my MA and my license in the real world mean NOTHING. I have been in a test from the first day I started my first job 25 years ago. That is where you learn to become a teacher.

21)Teacher wisdom cannot be taught - it is the ability to know how to avoid doing stupid shit that will get you in trouble. You acquire teacher wisdom by doing stupid shit that gets you in trouble and learning not to do it again.

22) if a lesson is not working , don’t keep “beating a dead horse” - switch it up and go to your plan B (the lesson you can pull out of your back pocket and never fails).


r/MusicEd • • Sep 22 '26

Student death

268 Upvotes

To preface, I act as essentially assistant director to the high school band but teach music in a different position in the district.

At the first home game of the season at the end of halftime, our senior drum major broke their foot. The hospital majorly fucked up several things, including missing blood clots that traveled from the foot to the lungs. The student has been in a coma unresponsive for over a week and they have declared brain death. They are taking them off the vent today or tomorrow.

Until this past weekend, classmates did not know. They found out through family's social media posts. They assumed the student was out getting surgery and just not responding to texts. Our crises team and school board said we were not allowed to say anything to the kids or talk to them about it because the mom has not specifically called the school and given explicit permission for us to do so. Other family members including dad have and have been begging for friends to come say goodbye. But since mom (full custodial parent) has not specifically, we cant speak about it. The kids know and are miserable and want to talk to us but our hands are legally tied.

I feel fucking horrible. I have been teaching this kid for 5 years. I have watched them transform into the most amazing young person and this isnt fair. I feel horrible for leaving the kids to fend for themselves for what is for most of them the first death they have ever experienced and in such a freak way.

I just dont know what to do or how I can be there for my kids. What am I supposed to do?

To top things off they are scheduled to compete this weekend.

They dont teach you this in school.


r/MusicEd • • Jun 11 '26

First-Year Music Teacher Job Hunt Visualizer

Post image
246 Upvotes

All of these applications were in my home state. I’m interested to hear about some people’s experiences or answer any questions that anyone might have who’s currently going through this.

Not going to lie, I was so over the process by the time it ended, but I’m happy to have gotten a job at a dream location for me.


r/MusicEd • • Jul 01 '20

Teaching in Rural America is rough..

Post image
245 Upvotes

r/MusicEd • • Jan 11 '24

My mental health has plummeted since becoming a teacher.

236 Upvotes

UPDATE: Wow, I didn't expect this to have the reach that it did. This is my first time really posting on Reddit, and I can't thank you all enough. To everyone who has posted and commented, thank you. Your words have helped tremendously.

Yesterday, I felt like the only answer was to quit. However, today was an awesome day. We laughed, we groaned, we totally butchered simple warm-ups. But, it was okay, and I know I did the best I could. We all got just a little bit better, one note at a time.

Thank you, caring and compassionate educators.

-----ORIGINAL POST BELOW-----

TL;DR: I am a young teacher having trouble accepting that I am not perfect, and my mental health is suffering.

Hello,

I am a 3rd year teacher, this is my second year at my current school. I teach HS band & orchestra.

It has always been my dream to be a high school band/orchestra director. And I have had a LOT of success at my current position.

I work in a high needs school. Last year I took over for someone who didn't really care about the program. Admin wasn't supportive because they hadn't had a good band teacher in over a decade, kids would barely play their instruments, and almost everything in my classroom was broken/unusable.

Fast forward to this year, where I have recieved grants and additional district funding to replace broken equipment, DOUBLED my enrollment numbers, have had breakthroughs with admin support, and my groups sound better than the school has had in years (their words, not mine).

But I am MISERABLE. I am exhausted every day, I barely sleep, I am constantly anxious and hold stress and tension in my body. I feel like I have forgotten how to be a human being with myself and my kids.

I know the content side of my job very well, but the instruction and planning feel loose goosey. Am I pushing my kids too much? Not enough? Did I spend enough time on this concept, or too much?

Are kids supposed to groan at everything they are asked to do? Or did I do something wrong? Why aren't they playing this correctly? We went over it yesterday and the day before! I feel like I am always putting out fires in the classroom.

When I go home, all I do is worry about how I need to be better. I need to run rehearsals more effectively, and advocate for my program better. I need to find more engaging materials, or come up with new strategies to help them be more eager to learn. Or I can't stop thinking about needing to finish up the multitude of projects that were left by years of neglect.

I am trying to lower the expectations on myself and accept the progress I have made, but it is so hard when I feel like we [I, specifically] have so far to go.

I am burnt out, I am reaching the end of my rope, and I don't know what to do anymore.


r/MusicEd • • Feb 02 '20

A small joke...

Post image
215 Upvotes

r/MusicEd • • Mar 30 '26

Tired of seeing competitive HS band schedules

196 Upvotes

Jesus Christ. You should not be rehearsing for 6 hours 4 days of the week and 12 on Saturday.

If you have a kid that wants to major in music, what time do they get to practice for that?

This isn't football, there isn't a highlight reel, you're just taking away from those who have real interest in music. Just upsetting to see. I saw a post where a director said he didn't like when kids take any vacation during marching season. Man, it's just band. The only reason it is competitive is bscause you made it that way. How many kids are you turning away with that time commitment at $1800 dues? Why did you major in music ed?


r/MusicEd • • May 08 '26

Unpopular Band Director Opinion

195 Upvotes

If you are a band director that regularly yells at your students for ANY reason, you don't deserve your job, and you should be banned from EVER teaching at any school ever again.

The amount of band directors I see (atleast in Texas) that constantly berates their students about things like tonality, marching in step, technique and other things, especially during marching season is biblically insane to me. There are plenty of ways to fix these issues without the need to yell at students and belittle them because you can't control your own anger issues.

I actually have decided to teach music outside of the country because of what the music culture is turning into and my rising sense of fear of how clinically insane some of these directors are becoming. I also feel like (and take this with a grain of salt because I'm not for certain) directors go into the music field to either A: relive their DCI glory days and use the same brutal methods they learned in DCI, or B to satisfy their own ego through competition scores.

I know this is an unpopular opinion, but if you are what I described, shame on you and I pity any student that has to learn from you.


r/MusicEd • • Dec 08 '19

Well I’m also the only one, but thanks kid

Post image
186 Upvotes

r/MusicEd • • Sep 08 '26

How many mistakes can you find in 30 seconds in this AI slop?

Post image
185 Upvotes

I typed in the circle of 5ths on google and this popped up from Etsy for $20. I thought you guys would have a good laugh. Send me your favorite circle of 5th’s chart!