r/MusicCritique • • Feb 22 '19

Can we add a rule?

38 Upvotes

I see a lot of music go through this sub with seemingly nothing being critiqued, so I propose a rule: before you post a song, you MUST critique at least one other artist's song. Pretty straight forward, what do you guys think?


r/MusicCritique • • 27d ago

Seeking Feedback [feedback] Enoch - (Not) Eroto - Pop

30 Upvotes

How do I make this sound more “pop”?


r/MusicCritique • • Nov 29 '18

This sub is so weak...

27 Upvotes

Every post in this sub has like ZERO comments. It's obvious whatever system is in place for this sub doesn't work... this place needs some structure. It's just a bunch of ransoms begging for plays on their SC.


r/MusicCritique • • Dec 15 '25

Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Feelings - Noah Baughdy - IDK

23 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I hope you’re having a great Monday. This is the first song I’ve ever fully written, recorded, and finished, and I’d really appreciate a honest critique.

I’m especially looking for guidance on what would make the biggest improvement going forward, whether that’s upgrading equipment, improving vocal delivery, learning more about mixing or mastering.

Any specific feedback on what stands out most, good or bad, would be extremely helpful as I keep learning and growing.


r/MusicCritique • • Oct 04 '18

Only post stuff you want critiqued

23 Upvotes

This sub isn’t super active so I’m hesitant to criticize any form of activity, but I have run into this every couple days for a while now.

Someone titles a post —

“After sleepless nights at my dying grandfathers bedside, I completed the years long journey to find myself musically and I’m proud of the result.”

Now, if you did that, that’s awesome and I hope the best for you. But this isn’t a sub for promotion. If you post a finished product and give us an emotional title about how much you worked, it feels difficult to actually dive in and critique it genuinely. I feel like a dick saying you need to mix the annoying frequencies out or that you could get better tone on the guitar if you post like you think it’s already done and you’re good to go and just sharing it to share it.

Rant over sorry fam. I love ur music but please post earlier in the process if possible, so the critiques actually can work towards the final product rather than just bother you about something you thought was g2g.

PS - I’m only concerned because I genuinely want to help, and get help from y’all when I need it down the road.


r/MusicCritique • • Mar 19 '20

Discussion [DISCUSSION] Would the community like some sort of "Radio" or "Playlist" where we can curate tracks from users?

18 Upvotes

Obviously I think the big question would be are these tracks for critiquing or enjoying?

Personally I think that it would be cool to have a playlist of some of the best songs to come through, but have some sort of vetting process to get on the list, maybe you have to be nominated or something similar. I have seen other subs do something similar and wanted this subs opinion as we try to drive engagement.

Also I am using this post to test out the live chat feature!


r/MusicCritique • • Feb 07 '13

Post Your Work Weekly Show Off Your Best Work Thread! [Artist of the Week] [2/10]

18 Upvotes

Every week we will have a thread for people to show off their top tracks, and most upvoted tracks will be able to win artist of the week, as long as the artist has contributed to the community in a meaningful way.

The Artist of the Week will be chosen every Sunday, and their links posted in the sidebar.

Make sure you listen to and upvote other artists that you like, it's not about being selfish, it's about helping the community as a whole.

Here I'd also like to say that you guys have made this sub an incredible place only 2 days after making it, so thank you to all of the amazing users we have, and I hope we continue to grow and flourish as successful subreddit!


r/MusicCritique • • Mar 01 '19

do you care? i've been making music for about 5 years as a hobby and this is the best thing i've ever created.

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
16 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Feb 15 '19

After 11 years and literally 0 releases, my brother released his first album today. He’s been scared for so long of what people would think. Please let him know he’s an idiot.

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
16 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Feb 14 '13

Post Your Work Show off your work! [Artist of the Week] [2/17]

16 Upvotes

Same as last week! Post your best work and the winner will dethrone last weeks winner /u/t_mhjr for a spot on the sidebar! Good luck!


r/MusicCritique • • Feb 06 '13

Indie Pop/Electro Song I made, along with a Music Video (took me a VERY long time to finish). Ultimately I want to know how "moving" it is. Feedback please.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
16 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Feb 14 '26

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Mar$hen - Understand - Hip-hop

15 Upvotes

Feedback is much appreciated , harder in headys - created w/ bandlab


r/MusicCritique • • Mar 23 '22

Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Me...first track after 4 months doing music with no prior experience/can't sing - WOLF - Pop

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
15 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Jun 09 '19

HEAVII METAL - DEVIL'S PARADISE [Cloud Trap]

Thumbnail
heaviimetal.bandcamp.com
15 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Mar 07 '19

Met a singer on Reddit and we made a song. My first ever track that is up on iTunes and Spotify. Would love for you guys to have a listen!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
15 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Feb 22 '13

A small suggestion!

15 Upvotes

This might sound pretty stupid to some people, but i will forward what i want to say anyways..

This sub is called "musiccritique". Iv'e uploaded some tracks here, commented on some and got some feedback, but what really bugs me is when people simply downvote or upvote for that matter. Upvotes/downvotes does not really belong here unless you comment. I think everyone here should start to contribute by commenting, not voting - voting cannot be considered contributing to this subreddit (UNLESS you comment as well).


r/MusicCritique • • Feb 12 '13

ANNOUNCEMENT 1 Week Sub-reddit Anniversary! Thanks for being an awesome community!

15 Upvotes

Today marks one week since the sub-reddit opened, and we've already made huge strides, reaching 300 users! I see a lot of good feedback going around and love the direction the sub is headed in. Hopefully we keep moving in the right direction and attract a larger community of reviewers willing to help our fellow producers grow and learn.

I just wanted to say thank you for being such an incredible group of people here, and really showing some promise for this community. We're still on the lookout to give flair to our top reviewers in the sub. As a side note please make sure you are writing insightful helpful reviews and not just upvoting posts you like.

Rather than downvote posts, keep it neutral and explain in a comment why you don't like the track, when you downvote, it gets buried and the user never learns what to improve about the track.

Again, thank you so much guys, keep up the awesome work!


r/MusicCritique • • Mar 17 '20

Media [MEME] Needs More Reverb

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • May 01 '19

I hand drew my new music video flipbook-style :) Would love any feedback!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Feb 06 '13

ANNOUNCEMENT [MOD] Ideas to keep the sub in balance, and the search for new mods!

14 Upvotes

It has been brought to my attention that the biggest problem like this is that the biggest problem in this sub will be people posting their own song, and not feedback for another. So we need a few ideas to be able to make sure new posters are also critiquing other songs. I was thinking maybe giving top critics a unique flair that can be seen when they post songs. I'd love to hear from you guys on this. Also, I'm looking for a mod fluent in CSS and familiar with customizing a subreddit, so message me if you're interested. Thanks for helping this subreddit grow so quickly, I hope it blossoms into an active friendly community!


r/MusicCritique • • Jan 06 '19

Got stumped on this one. Only has a verse and chorus and couldn’t nail down a good bridge section for it..

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Sep 11 '18

Stayed up for three days writing this

Thumbnail
youtube.com
13 Upvotes

r/MusicCritique • • Nov 27 '17

Can we get some more...you know...feedback on here?

13 Upvotes

Make sure to comment on 5 posts for every post you publish. There's an entire first page of this sub without any comments and it's defeating the purpose of this community!


r/MusicCritique • • Apr 02 '20

[ANNOUCEMENT] Community Discussion - Testing a New Feature

12 Upvotes

Hey Guys!

As you all already know I have been working on improving the sub pretty much every day for the past month or so. I really like where we are at and we have a lot we can still improve on!

A change I have been doing in the background that you guys may have noticed is the flair ranking system. Some of you see newbie as your flair and some see bronze. There is a tier system explained in the sub information wiki.

As of now, the ranks past bronze are arbitrary, but you will rank up in certain increments of "quality comments" you leave on posts. Right now the threshold is set very low to give pretty much everyone who comments here now the bronze ranking.

The bronze rank will be required for posting any post requesting feedback. This means that a user will need to leave at least 1 quality feedback on a post in order to be able to post their own for feedback.

##What I need you guys to do is comment on a post or two and send a DM to /u/Instamod with the subject !Updateme and anything in the body. This will force /u/Instamod to update your rank other wise it is done once a day.

Thank you guys for helping me and please let me know if you have any feedback regarding the sub! I plan to roll out this requirement in mid April. The goal is to cut back on low effort posts. We cut a huge chunk out with filters and this would be the next step. Again, I'm not concerned with post volume I want good post quality!


r/MusicCritique • • Feb 09 '20

Is there any point posting to this subreddit? No one comments on the music

12 Upvotes

Would love to have a community to share my pretty cool compositions with but...scrolling down through new posts ALMOST NONE have even a single comment.

So...is there any use posting here?

Seems silly to see tons of posts just there with no apparent interest.

['Landing'](http://Listen to 04. Landing - Fuzzbuster by Fuzzbuster on #SoundCloud https://soundcloud.com/user-756799575/04-landing-fuzzbuster)