489
u/Aviation_enthusiast8 Jul 27 '26
132
122
u/GamerEeveeInfinity I'm in 100+ fandoms bruh😭 Jul 27 '26
85
u/Deya_The_Fateless Jul 27 '26
Same with old Spongebob too!
Spongebob has always been a goofy guy and optimistic to the point of being nieve. But even he had his breaking points where he'd get annoyed or even angry.
Newer seasons, he's just an annoying, laughing buffoon...
→ More replies (1)45
u/Shrapnel_FEH Madness Combat | ULTRAKILL | Universal Orlando | Rhythm Thief Jul 28 '26
almost all of the characters from spongebob could be classed under this, like mr krabs too
he used to be the authority figure, essentially spongebob’s dad, and sure he was greedy, but it wasn’t his entire thing
now he’s just wario
→ More replies (3)15
u/Homeless_Appletree Jul 28 '26
Makes me think back to the first movie where, yes, he did not want to go on an apparent suicide mission with Spongebob and Patrick but he was the only one to call out the shady shit Plankton was doing afterwards and attempting to have him arrested to clear Mr. Crabs his name.
28
u/egemen0ozhan Jul 27 '26
Some person sad Squidward but its actually all the SpongeBob character's
8
u/AnArcticJackalope Jul 27 '26
I mean, the shows been running almost 30 years. I’d be more surprised if this didn’t happen.
→ More replies (1)3
375
u/CodaTrashHusky Jul 27 '26
Ned Flanders
253
u/PastelGoober Jul 27 '26 •
![]()
a case so bad the term was named after him
130
→ More replies (6)66
u/Accomplished-Fan5956 Jul 27 '26
With the irony being that Flanders is probably far from the worst case of Flanderization on the Simpsons now
31
→ More replies (1)6
u/gonzo0815 Jul 27 '26
All of the Simpsons characters though. I still don't get why they picked Flanders for the term, all of them got heavily flanderized.
→ More replies (2)7
u/CodaTrashHusky Jul 27 '26
I think it just rolls off the tongue nicely. Would you rather say Homerization or Apufication?
→ More replies (2)
696
u/Ubylmoen Jul 27 '26
Knuckles. He was tricked in Sonic 3 and again in Sonic Adventure as just kind of a call back to Sonic 3, and then every appearance for a decade was just about him being kind of stupid.
256
u/Red-Ink-07 Jul 27 '26
And then the Sonic movies gave us the best characterization of Knux since Adventure (the Sonic Boom TV show doesn’t count, that Knuckles is just too goated ❤️)
145
u/FarplaneDragon Jul 27 '26
(the Sonic Boom TV show doesn’t count, that Knuckles is just too goated ❤️)
Approved
111
43
20
u/_SomeRedditUser Jul 27 '26
Why do you think that?
Just curiosity, I don't have much knowledge on Sonic
→ More replies (1)31
u/Red-Ink-07 Jul 27 '26
Knuckles’s writing in Adventure and Adventure 2 is very well-done, as his character is accurate to the original vision while still expanding on things and having him grow as a person and with his teammates. The next games after this did not really have him star as an important character, so he didn’t get much until 06. That was when his “dumbass” label started being applied. Everything after that was the Meta/Boost Era, when the writing of the entire series was reduced to a Saturday morning cartoon (derogatory). Much like said (bad) cartoons, characters were reduced to one-dimensional quip or exposition machines. Knuckles’s trait was being strong. And as we all know, strong = dumb.
And that’s how it was until the Sonic 2 movie. That was a soft reboot/alternate telling for the franchise, and it allowed people who actually cared about the characters to write them.
And then after this, we got Frontiers. I like Frontiers. The character writing was good. They did Knuckles very well.
The IDW comics were always good but that doesn’t count.
→ More replies (9)7
u/Bartburp93 Jul 28 '26
Boom show knuckles is just the flanderisation taken extremely far but it just meshes with the shows humour so well that he's funny enough to not matter anyway
→ More replies (2)5
u/Glad-Alternative4593 Jul 28 '26
Eh they made his stupidity funny along with moments of him being very smart to break up the Knuckles is dumb jokes.
11
u/Red-Ink-07 Jul 28 '26
His feminist quote will forever live rent free in my head
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)3
33
20
u/Preating-Canick Jul 27 '26
a lot of Sonic characters suffer from this. Shadow, Amy, Tails...
the Amy case is so bad that when she started getting an actual personality the fans started arguing that Sega was erasing all she had
6
→ More replies (2)2
u/BirdshotEntertainmen Jul 29 '26
Besides the movies, after unleashed all sonic writing went out kf the window. In forces Tails is hiding behind sonic when BASE CHAOS approaches him. What the fuck happened to his vharacter arc from 1998???
→ More replies (1)
285
u/TheRadRadiation Jul 27 '26
26
u/I_like_fried_noodles Jul 28 '26
Is he naive though?
→ More replies (1)53
u/HatMcHatty Jul 28 '26
Very. In the movie at least he pretty much immediately trusts eggman and is pretty shocked when he gets betrayed. Same character traits in most games he’s in, but in shows like sonic boom he’s just an idiot
→ More replies (6)10
u/fioriarthur Jul 28 '26
I think the movies managed pretty well to make the characters defined by recognizable simple traits and still give them some depth, specially knuckles and shadow
151
u/SamanthaDamara Jul 27 '26
39
15
u/BigOwl526 Jul 27 '26
Maybe it's just me, but for me the dumber he got the more funny it was. I liked him a lot because at least he was nice and stupid, not like Patrick Star who's a big stupid asshole.
→ More replies (1)
252
u/Zombieslayer854 various Jul 27 '26
85
→ More replies (3)13
75
71
115
u/Superb_Carry8491 Jul 27 '26
71
u/KFrosty3 Jul 27 '26
At least live action Sanji gets to lean in on his retro cool side
44
u/Baronvondorf21 Jul 27 '26
They just made him less of pervert and kept his good traits.
35
u/Tago238238 Jul 27 '26
Sanji was definitely less weird at the beginning. Really he just started off as just a simp, which wasn’t particularly creepy because all the women seemed to quite like him doting on them. As time went on he got creepier tho.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (2)9
u/Serious-Flamingo-948 Jul 27 '26
While I think they'll keep him this way in the LA, right now Sanji is acting like he did around that time. The guy who will try to charm any and every woman but do it in a suave way instead of a 1940s caricature.
6
4
6
u/Specialist_Initial_1 Jul 27 '26
Large part is thanks to toei...... they hate him for some reason and LOOOOOOVE Zoro...
→ More replies (4)3
u/Worcestershire01 Jul 27 '26
Every time I watch the anime with my manga only friend he blows a fuse over sanji scenes that toei just added for shits and giggles. He also claims they've removed sanji scenes entirely but I could be wrong
→ More replies (2)3
u/Gmknewday1 Jul 28 '26
Toei doesn't help and arguably has limited/reduced his acutal cool moments or added moments that make him worse
111
u/Thisisanaltretard Jul 27 '26
49
u/AntComfortable5970 Jul 27 '26
This a good example as it actually includes fan personality changes that were added to a character in official media.
The uwu soft boy stuff the fans have come up with has hit him pretty hard in idw.
17
u/IronBranded Jul 27 '26
I’d say he should be soft and kind-hearted, but they need to show his dark side more often because he has a pretty messed up past (or future?) that would stick with him for the rest of his life.
7
4
u/Trodat4911P4 Jul 27 '26
I only know this character through the Sonic 06 real time fandub so I always wonder what he is really like lol
→ More replies (1)2
33
u/Sailor_Grell Jul 27 '26
5
2
u/Theredmastermind Jul 28 '26
She was my first thought when I read the title. That's saying something.
2
u/Asteroide8 Jul 30 '26
I've seen this complaint a few times and I'm always somewhat confused. She was an assistant when Apollo was the only lawyer in the office and Phoenix was a depressed hobo. Was she supposed to keep doing legal stuff even when they had 3 lawyers? Obviously the AA games have some (a lot of) problems with characterisation but I don't think this is one of them
86
u/Randomman16 Jul 27 '26
I wouldn't say one dimensional, but...Goku. Even in the original Dragon Ball he had more to him, he was naive and trusting but absolutely ruthless if he knew you were bad. He was book dumb but had some really smart ideas at times, and despite not knowing what marriage was he still agreed to marry Chi-Chi because "he promised to" and does love her. He shows a pretty good range of character traits throughout both the original and Z, and even GT to an extent. Fans made jokes about Goku not knowing how to differentiate boys and girls or being a bad father but those were mostly fan memes.
...And then Super dialed back, a lot. Now, Goku is so fight-happy he'll remind the overlord of the multiverse of a tournament where entire universes are at stake (Zeno would've wiped some out regardless but Goku didn't know that), doesn't know what kissing is and it's said that he will spend untold amounts of time training with King Kai without visiting his family. Yeah, Goku was always a bit of a doofus but it's like Super regularly goes out of its way to remind viewers "Hey, did we mention that this man is a fucking idiot?"
36
u/Noma-Caa Jul 27 '26
The one thing I want to point out here is that Goku didn’t know the tournament would give universes a chance to be saved in part because he didn’t know they were in danger in the first place. When he asked about the tournament, he had no reason to believe it was for anything other than recreational and competitive purposes. The way the show had everyone dogpiling him for things he didn’t do and couldn’t have known was insane.
→ More replies (1)17
u/Randomman16 Jul 27 '26
In defense of the characters, they also didn't know that Goku didn't know the consequences. As far as they were aware, this tournament was called to determine which universes would survive and this dumbfuck from Universe 7 is the reason they're even doing it, they didn't know that he only had like half the relevant information. It's made worse by the fact that Goku isn't exactly the negotiating type, so he wasn't really that inclined to correct anybody.
8
u/AngryInternetPerson3 Jul 27 '26
absolutely ruthless if he knew you were bad
This part was not flanderization, Goku clearly stops being ruthless after he spends time training with Kami and learns the value of a life and the value of mercy, and sparing all those enemies is what allowed him to get so many enemy to friends, friends that then helped him save the world multiples times.
6
u/Randomman16 Jul 27 '26
While I don't disagree with you at all, he does still decide that Raditz, Frieza and Cell all have to die, so he isn't merciful in all cases.
→ More replies (4)8
u/RedDiamond1024 Jul 27 '26
In the case of Raditz and Freiza that was after already showing them mercy. Cell is the exception, but that also wasn’t his fight at that time, it was Gohan’s.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)2
u/Upset_Ad_6228 Jul 29 '26
I mean, for two of those things in Super, actually false.
One, Goku just reminded Zeno of the tournament. It was just supposed to be that. Goku had no idea that universes were on the line.
And Goku not knowing what kissing is isn’t actually true. It’s supposed to be a joke that no one understood. When he was asking Trunks what he was doing, he meant “Trunks, what are you doing feeding her a Senzu mouth to mouth?” Vegeta then asks “Wait, you haven’t done that with your wife before?” Because Vegeta thinks Goku is referring to Kissing. So Goku says of course he hasn’t, because he means he has never baby birded food to Chi-Chi.
It’s actually a pretty funny joke imo, just… literally everyone didn’t understand it.
24
u/SomeonesInTheCorner TADC/Animal Hospital/Pokémon/Planetballs/Alpaca Evolution/CTS Jul 27 '26
Spunchboge?
24
47
u/LovelyLuna32684 Jul 27 '26
11
u/The-Name-is-my-Name Jul 27 '26
This isn’t flanderization, this is Fans running the Asylum plus Flanderization.
18
u/KFrosty3 Jul 27 '26
Cloud Strife in the og FF7 was more than just a brooding sourpuss. Nowadays, brooding is his defining attribute
→ More replies (3)3
u/OkNectarine9239 Jul 29 '26
Someone hasn't played the remakes where he's in the middle of a character arc and definitely has a personality beyond brooding.
→ More replies (2)
15
u/TheCookieThief35 Jul 27 '26
Caboose from Red vs Blue.
8
u/SnappleOfAllTrades Jul 27 '26
Depends when you draw that line After his brain damage he still is nuanced it just completely fades at one point
5
u/TyrantJaeger Jul 27 '26
Donut too. He used to just be naïve and optimistic. Then somewhere along the way he turned into the stereotypical token gay character.
3
u/wetstapler Jul 27 '26
My first thought too! Though I think in that case it was turning a character with no traits into a character with 1 trait
→ More replies (1)
11
11
u/SphellBrie Jul 27 '26
Tim Drake. I’m not super big on superhero media, but I have heard about the absolute lobotomy of his character.
Went from an interesting and flawed character -> fanon representation as the “bisexual smart one who loves coffee” -> new comics which don’t let him age (I think he’s younger than Damian at this point) with little character aside from dating Bernard and, you guessed it, being sidelined as the “smart Robin”
10
u/sillycryptic Jul 27 '26
Tim not aging is purely fanon tbh. He's been 21+ for years now. Damian just turned 15. The coffee thing is also fanon, in canon he likes soda. But yes he's been sidelined sadly. DC does that to a lot of their queer characters unfortunately, they only get brought out of the play box when it's time to sell pride issues in june.
2
10
10
u/Mayhemgodess227 Jul 27 '26
Any goofy comic relief character from sitcoms, top of my head would be Joey from friends
8
7
7
u/hmmliquorice Jul 27 '26
Dante and Vergil (DMC)
4
u/cheshireYT Jul 28 '26
I don't think they've really been flanderized all that much in the games.
→ More replies (2)
7
u/ShoArts Jul 27 '26
Cayde-6 [Destiny 1 & 2]
One of the three leaders for an army of immortal warriors, specifically over the pathblazing Hunters, he was originally written to be a cunning and witty gunslinger - much like his voice actor's most famous role, Nathan Fillion as Firefly's Cpt. Malcom Reynolds.
But combined with the early game stumbling on character writing and his charm in a standout expansion, The Taken King, fans really latched onto him. And the studio, Bungie, noticed.
By the sequel, he became a bit flanderized. Much more of a Deadpool meme mascot.
However, I think they recovered his character by the story's conclusion. With his "exit" in Forsaken, years long absense, and reappaeance in The Final Shape, he leveled out back to that witty but very wise mentor, going out on a high note.

6
u/Common-Truth9404 Jul 27 '26
Goku being dumb
Goku's fight being only screaming and getting angry and then powering up.
Literally goku got a rage boost ONCE fron becoming a super saiyan in the original run (which isn't even an actual way for hin to covert anger into strenght, just a trigger to super saiyan)
Then gohan had his whole schtick where he was gentle natured and could obly access his true power when angered, and people around db all went braindead "oh so anger=power, got it"

3
u/NorthGodFan Jul 28 '26
Which is insane, because literally lesson one of popo's pre-training is anger clouds your judgment and makes you a bad fighter.
11
5
5
u/CagedKage Jul 27 '26
Four from BFDI. He started becoming more than just a “funny memey” character, we got to see a more emotional side of him. But fans complained about Four being too “whiny and bitchy”, and as a result, Four went to being nothing more than a joke in TPOT. Thanks, fans!
5
u/Artistic-Airline9126 Jul 27 '26
The mane 6 from my little Pony friendship is magic.
I was sitting there watching seasons 8 and 9 like "why are we already learning lessons you learned in seasons 1 and 2? And why are you so much worse at receiving them?"
→ More replies (1)
8
u/justreading12345678 Jul 27 '26
A lot of characters who have a mean streak in early canon that gets erased in favour of something nicer/goofier later on. And it’s always characters who deserve to be a lot meaner and would‘ve honestly had all reasons to be. Often goes hand in hand with making them dumber.
E.g. Stranger Things: Steve Harrington
8
u/Fantomukage Jul 27 '26
He was so right to yell at Jonathan for the pictures in season 1. They dropped that too quickly, like sure there were more important things going on but still.
6
u/justreading12345678 Jul 27 '26
Also he freaked out when he thought Nancy cheated on him and when she DID CHEAT on him it was just never discussed and everyone acted Like SHE was too good for HIM.
Boy was owned several crash outs actually.→ More replies (1)11
u/Monsterchic16 Jul 27 '26
Ash Ketchum
I miss my sass king, he would’ve never tolerated Iris and her bullshit.
5
u/Unable_Flamingo_9774 Jul 27 '26
Ash was a case of him growing out of it in fairness with only BW being a straight up step back.
Og he was a noob and immature so he constantly got into fights and bickering with misty. The next few series are teaching him about being humble, less reckless and taking his losses on the chin and getting better.
Black and white lobotomised him for new audiences but by XY taking the other series into account he's just kind of lost his bite lol. In that series everyone's looking up to him and the one time he did kick off his girlfriend cried and threw snowballs at him.
He still bickers with misty still tho so say whatever you want about that.
4
4
u/burner678917 Jul 27 '26
Denji from Chainsaw man, going from part 1 to the ending
→ More replies (1)2
4
u/EdenAurier Jul 27 '26
Lowkey the characters from Persona in the Persona Q spin offs, not really because of the fanbase though but I imagine because of the sheer number of characters whose complex personnalities the average player of those games would already be familiar with.
9
17
u/Mimandra Jul 27 '26
14
10
u/CarefulFilm237 Jul 27 '26
I disagree. They just didn't have as much screen time so a lot of it didn't shine through. Though admittedly i think Sokka should have been more serious during the crash of the airship, but otherwise i can't see it.
→ More replies (2)10
u/Monsterchic16 Jul 27 '26
I disagree, they’re all adults now so obviously they wouldn’t be exactly the same as when they were kids and I thought they all seemed perfectly in character and the new voices did a bang on job of capturing the characters essences in their performances, especially the new guy who played Sokka.
6
3
3
3
3
3
u/me_auxilium Jul 27 '26
Chopper from One Piece was never meant to be a useless mascot character. Yet here we are, sigh.
2
u/ViridianVet Jul 29 '26
Its not just Chopper. Every character except Luffy got boiled down to a few defining traits after the time skip, and everything else about them got thrown in the trash. It lost so much of its charm for absolutely no reason. One-note characters and the fixation on haki as a replacement for devil fruit powers ruined the series.
3
3
3
u/Brave_Hamster_7219 Jul 27 '26
I could just start listing DC Comics characters but we'd be here all night. Dick Grayson is going through it in an atrocious way right now.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Lazy-Road-9479 Jul 28 '26
→ More replies (18)2
u/YoutuberCameronBallZ Jul 31 '26
Not really...
I mean, "fanon Sans" shifted a LOT in the fandom, but as far as I'm aware Undertale Sans and Deltarune Sans are pretty much the same.
Same laid back jokester with mysterious undertones and vaque awareness of the world around him.
If the fanon DID influence him, he'd either:
A: be as emotional as physically possible
Or B: be completely dead inside, never expressing any feelings ever
3
u/FedoraTheMike Jul 28 '26
He stops yelling Kakarot once he loses the mind control crown on his head and becomes fully coherent for the rest of his first movie. Even stops calling him Kakarot and calls him Goku with one exception.
Second movie, and every single piece of media afterwards even decades later he's just the guy that screams Kakarot.

3
u/OtterlySamnson Jul 28 '26
This is what happens with Shipping culture BTW lmao
Shippers get their hands on a character, strip them of everything that made them complicated and socially incompatible with other characters. And then they are romance puppet who is as flat as the paper the fan fiction is written on.
7
u/insomniac-trashpanda Jul 27 '26
7
u/Moridaar Jul 27 '26
That’s… literally a line from the book. He’s got good combat instincts, and is smarter than he seems, but he’s still an idiot (and both knows, and complains about it)
If you’re basing his characterization off of the movies, I’m disowning you, though. They were fun, but not Percy Jackson
→ More replies (4)2
u/T3mpxst- Jul 31 '26
They made him stupid, less driven to be a hero, dialed down his mythologically insane combat instincts, stripped his humor, stripped his drive to be a protector, the show was arguably almost as bad as the movies imo, but I digress.
PJO adapted should've been an anime/cartoon
6
2
2
u/2ndBestShedBuilder Jul 27 '26
Id kind of say Frisk, but only kinda
→ More replies (2)5
u/GamerEeveeInfinity I'm in 100+ fandoms bruh😭 Jul 27 '26
how??? Frisk litra doesnt "officially/cannonically" appear anywhere other than undertale so they dont even have a chance to get flanderised.
2
2
2
u/MatterInSpaces Jul 27 '26
Not sure if Teemo counts. Many people liked and used his old “war vet” canon in fandom. But the games decided he’s now a cute little Boy Scout only. That was his sorta facade but now it’s his canon, at least that is how I always viewed teemo. Maybe his war vet facade was only for one skin but it made him complex and that was cool. Now he’s like the boy from Up.
2
2
u/Misterwuss Jul 27 '26
Percy Jackson. Kid acted dumb a lot but was actually smart on his feet, actually studied latin even as a young kid because Chiron was the only teacher he liked and hwo respected him, deeply protective over people, didn't have much self-esteem but was good at faking confidence especially to annoy or inspire people and flawed but well meaning.
Then people got it into their head that he was just a dummy slacker who's just really strong but screws up everything that isn't a fight.
Now in the most recent books he's a dumbass slacker who screws everything up. He's not even really all that good at fighting anymore. Dude got flanderised hard.
2
2
2
2
u/Qixel Jul 28 '26
Loki suffered from this after The Avengers. In that movie, Black Widow tries to trick Loki into giving up his master plan (he intends to use The Hulk to destroy the airship), and some people were convinced that Black Widow had fooled Loki, the god of lies and trickery, into giving up his scheme. Except, no, by telling her that, she immediately goes to piss off Banner, setting in motion The Hulk destroying the airship. He played her like a fiddle by letting her think she had tricked him, but the fans were adamant it was the other way around. It became so popular an outlook that Loki gets made into a colossal idiot in nearly every movie afterwards and I'm still kind of bitter. xD
2
2
u/rlnn_ Jul 28 '26
Dare I say Garnet from Steven Universe, her whole personality being just "I'm a fusion" later on
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
2
u/ShadowEeveeCringe Jul 29 '26
Literally everyone in TADC. No I don’t take criticism, you’re all wrong and I’m right 🫡
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Black369Ace Jul 29 '26
Silver the Hedgehog. His 06 version was great, but his latest iterations make him out to be an uwu boy that is too soft or silly.
2
3
u/AntComfortable5970 Jul 27 '26
Lot of people are posting merely flanderized characters rather than ascended fanon characterization.
While not an exact 1:1 of the pic, doomslayer fits this quite a bit by the EPIC BADASS SILENT DEMON SLAUGHTERER being overly exentuated in fan stuff for years and years. Like in some of the doom 2 intermission stuff, it mentioned doom guy was looking forward to rebuilding and getting some rest. Id took the fan interpretation and ran with it.
3
3
u/HandsomeSwampBeast Jul 27 '26
Deadpool, because Marc Waid went on this very website in 2008
3
u/Fresh-Log-5052 Jul 28 '26
I really wish the fact that he has actual brain damage and possibly dementia (from his brain constantly dying and regenerating) was apparent in the movies.
I remember one comic where he followed a plan with 0 clue why he is doing each step, having forgotten making it. It's where the famous room-full of pancakes comes from - it saves Domino from a fall later on.
2
u/AlreadyHalfXehanort Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26
Persona characters in their original games VS Persona characters in the PQ spin-offs.
5
u/discofro6 Jul 27 '26
Akihiko Sanada in Persona 3: "I took up boxing because this is the best way to deal with my complex emotions I've decided"
Akihiko Sanada in Persona Q: P R O T E I N
2
2
u/TheSkeletalNerd Jul 27 '26
Nightwing, but only somewhat- he gets way more jokes about his butt now, and in some things, that’s all other characters seem to care about when it comes to him. It’s getting old
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Important-Win-2725 Jul 27 '26
dick grayson, jason todd, tim drake, damian wayne, Cassandra cain.... complex characters first –> ruinied by fanon –> new dc comics adapted fanon quirks and turned complex characters into caricatures of themselves
2
2































752
u/Artistic-Victory1245 Jul 27 '26
Stormtroopers went from being a genuine elite force, who had the misfortune of being worfed, to being one of the greatest cases of incompetent minions in fiction.