I donât take full credit for all of these points as Iâve been reading threads since the episode aired. But the threads have helped me formulate what I think the episode means and where I think the show is going.
Summary: Tyrell actually died/is dying, but it didnât happen the way we think it happened. Elliot isnât talking to us or Mr Robot anymore, so even though MR is our new narrator, heâs still an unreliable one.
Explanation: So to recap what we know about the third personality, Darlene told Elliot about Vera but Elliot canât recall it, nor can MR, so thus we learn Darlene was speaking to the third personality.
About halfway through Ep.404 I thought I figured it out, guessing Tyrell was the third personality. Their conversation with the gas station clerk (very strange), then losing the van (lost memory), the âsmall talkâ in the woods (confusion/babbling), the argument (irrational behavior), all of it in my mind looked like Tyrell was going to be revealed as the third. Thinking Elliot would realize heâs talking to himself in the woods. But then right after the argument, they go just around the corner on the road and discover the van. Tyrell gets shot and presumably dies.
So after the episode I thought about what else happened: Darlene meets bad Santa, and after their shenanigans, we learn/hear in Darleneâs own words the true stress that sheâs dealing with. But with Dom, we didnât really learn anything at all, we see one of Domâs nightmares but it just tellâs us the same info weâve known about Dom since Ep.401, sheâs scared and lonely.
(I donât take credit for remembering this) The day after the episode, I read somewhere that Domâs nightmare was foreshadowed in S2, in her conversation with Angela.
And it dawned on me.
S2, when Dom foreshadows her nightmare, is the same season we get the Jail reveal. Elliot has control over his surroundings, at least in the way he presents them to us. MR can control Elliotâs surroundings, like in the fantasy TV show episode from S1. So because we donât know who this third personality is, whoâs to say the third canât change our reality (Elliotâs friend) of what weâre (your) seeing?
I think the reason we see Domâs nightmare in Ep.404, and not earlier like in the premier when we first learn Dom is scared and lonely, is because the events that happen with Elliot and Tyrell in 404 are another dream or projection in Elliotâs head.
I think Tyrell dying makes too much sense. If he dies, it immediately disrupts Whiteroseâs timeline and gives Elliot a little more time to get to a phone given theyâre not going to a hospital. (Side note he also saves his baby from being used as leverage against him.)
Thinking back on all of their interactions in 404, it all felt very strange, ominous, echoing sounds coming from deep in the woods, like they were in a nightmare. Maybe Elliot and Tyrell hit the deer and crashed the van, Tyrell dies and Elliot survives, leaving him truly alone.
Imagine Elliot in this situation: a guy with severe psychological disorders, fresh off a car crash, in the middle of the woods with no internet or cell service, his best weapon is not an option, his only true friend is dead or dying, along with a dead DA operative, both of which are in a stolen DA van, and the only person who knows where he sorta-kinda is, his sister, is heading blindly into the area where the DA is presumably looking for them.
I think Elliot, or the third personality, is hiding the truth of what happened to Tyrell from us. Why else would they include Domâs nightmare in this specific episode?
Tyrell actually died/is dying, but it didnât happen the way we think it happened. Elliot isnât talking to us or Mr Robot anymore, so even though MR is our new narrator, heâs still an unreliable one.