r/MrCruel • • May 08 '24

I have some suspension my dad is Mr Cruel

1.3k Upvotes

Update 2: yes I have been to the police and my suspicions are inline with a suspect they have in their list. This is being looked into however due to not wanting to mess with the investigation I will not update again until he is either cleared or charged

update: so I have educated myself about the case and contacted the police. The 2 names I provided were on a list. It's being imvestigated

I'm not sure how crazy this will sound but let's try and get some opinions. I was born in 1985. My memories are very vague and distant. I don't exactly remember this story on the news but as soon as I saw the photo I knew I had been face to face with it.

Anyway, let's get to my reasons. Here's my top 10

1: the locations of the assaults were all places near where my dad worked.

2: Occasionally my dad would borrow from family members a video camera but I never saw him use it.

3: He drove the same Make/Model as described in the articles I read

4: There is Violent and S/A offenders in my family history on my dads side

5: I have a blank memory from my childhood where I got out of bed to find someone and I saw something that caused me to run and my dad chased me. By the time my mother saw this I couldn't remember what I had seen. This led to my parents divorce approx 6 months later which corresponds perfectly with Mr Cruels final kill.

6: The police released many sketches over the years with different hair styles etc based on witnesses. One in particular is virtually a photo.

7: My Dad is weirdly obsessed with food. He always has been. He would always make sure he ate and everyone around him ate. He would virtually force feed. So Mr cruel always feeding victims and himself makes sense.

8: The way it is reported Mr Cruel acts, personality wise, describes my dad.

9: While he never touched me asexually, he would glare, stare and check out me and all my friends. He would insist on reaching over them to out their seat belts on.

10: My dad is deceptively intelligent. He is very good at science. He would be the sort of person to know exactly how to not leave a trace.

So, am I nuts for thinking this could be a possibility?


r/MrCruel • • Jun 12 '21

Concerned, scared and confused.... Was I raised by MrCruel?

779 Upvotes

I am the OP of this post, and originally had it posted in r/unsolvedmurders but it was suggested that I post it here, as there may be someone out there who could possibly alleviate some of my concerns or if not, then possibly put me in touch with someone who could help me share this information with the correct authorities.

Hi fellow Redditors,

Not too sure if this is even where I should be/or even if I should be posting this. Its been on my mind for many decades now. At least 30+ years and it has always terrified me. Although I have no definitive evidence, the coincidences are just too....much.

To start with, I am only mentioning all of this because I know its anonymous, and if it wasnt, then there is NO WAY I would even consider mentioning any of this in a public forum..

I grew up in an extremely abusive household. My mother displays Narcissistic personality disorder, my stepfather is a peodophile, and his oldest son is an alcoholic, a compulsive liar, and is also a peadophile. Sadly, I know this from first hand experience, and also know that I am not the only person that was afflicted by their attentions. My mother did nothing about the situation, in fact she often deliberately put me in compromising positions (leaving me in their custody, or turning a blind eye when she had undeniable evidence that something had occurred). although this group is about unsolved murders, and not other forms of abuse, this will all make sense as it is all intertwined.

When I was about 11 years old, I lived in the state of Tasmania in Australia. My eldest stepbrother had moved interstate to Victoria to join the Army, and I was just relieved for the break from his presence. When he completed his basic training, my stepfather and my mother went for a trip to Victoria to watch my step brother "march out" which is a ceremony at the end of their training to signify that they were now full serving members of the defense force.

They were gone interstate for approximately a two week period. My dates are not 100% accurate, but they were gone from about late August to somewhere mid September. I remember this clearly because once they came back to Tasmania, they had nothing but praise about mainland Australia (Tasmania is an island state) and they wanted to move there. We were packed and ready to move very fast, and were gone in just over two weeks after their return. We arrived in Melbourne on the 5th of October, 1987.

Not long after we moved to Melbourne, there was an awful case on the news about a man who was abducting young girls from their homes, and abusing them. One of his last victims that I was aware of was a young girl named Carmen Chan.

Although I was so young at the time, and often ignored what ever stories were on the news of a nighttime, this stuck with me because we often ate dinner with the television on at the same time. Whenever something came on the news about Carmen Chan, and the abductor that the media had dubbed "Mr Cruel", my stepfather would snap at me, and insist that I shut up and keep quiet while he listened. He would turn the television up louder and became very focused on what ever the news was reporting.

Mr Cruel had abducted a few girls leading up to this point, and had mostly just assaulted them before he left them somewhere where they would be discovered and returned to their families. In Carmen Chans case however, she was never returned, and eventually was found deceased.

My stepfathers abnormally intense interest in the news surrounding these cases always confused me, as he most certainly did not concern himself with my welfare, and there was plenty of violent news on television for him to absorb, so I had no idea why he was so interested in Mr Cruel.

He did have some other peculiar interests, as he used to own a collection of booklets printed about serial killers in our home library. I did not read them all, as I was too young, and really had no interest in the subject at the time, but I remember a book about Jeffrey Dahmer, and Ted Bundy etc. Of course this is not illegal to possess, and on its own, not entirely suspicious, but if you combine it with the rest of my post, then perhaps it will appear to be a little..... dubious?

Anyway, it wasnt until I was much much older that I started to question as to why my stepfather seemed so interested in Mr Cruel at the time. Thats when I started to read up on what little information the police had on the criminal/murderer.

They believed that he was in the defense force, I think because of the way he was so clean, and left behind no evidence, or minimal evidence. At the time of these abductions and murders, my stepbrother was in the army, but my stepfather was also a manic neat freak. He would make me wash the hubcaps of the car with a toothbrush when I was cleaning the car, and one day he even went on a meltdown because I left a tiny ink mark on the front page of a newspaper while I was checking to see if a pen was working. His tidyness was a compulsion. The one piece of physical evidence that apparently Mr Cruel left behind was a whisker, so the police thought that they were looking for a red head, because the whisker was red.

Both my stepfather and my stepbrother are brunette... unless they grow facial hair. They both have red facial hair.

The police also thought that their suspect was from either Tasmania or New Zealand, due to some colloquialism language that the abducted girls heard. I cannot recall the exact phrase that was released to the media, I just know that when I read it at the time, I recognised it as something my stepfather and stepbrother used. They often used colloquialisms such as "How do you like them apples" or "How does that grab you" in a sadistic condescending tone. This is just a couple of the many they used.

Also, at the time of the abductions, and abuse/murder, all of the victims were female and all of them were the same age as myself.

Lastly, the last coincidence that comes to mind at the moment is the time line. From what I read in the media, they believe that the first abductions from Mr Cruel occurred sometime in either late August to mid September 1987 (I cannot recall the exact date, I just remember how ill it made me feel to know that both my stepfather, and my step brother were both in Victoria at the time this happened), and the last victim they believe Mr Cruel abducted was either in September or very early October in 1992.

These dates are important because against my wishes, and against my stepfathers wishes, my mother insisted we move back to Tasmania, and we left Victoria on October the 5th 1992, just after Mr Cruels last apparent abduction before he went quiet in Victoria. Around the same time that we moved back to Tasmania, my stepbrother moved from Victoria to Queensland, so now both my stepfather and stepbrother were no longer in Victoria. Although, both of them had been there during the times that Mr Cruel was active.

Both my stepfather and my stepbrother have a sadistic streak, and I honestly believe that after living with them for 13 years, that either one of them was quite capable of doing those acts. My stepbrother was however, a little skittish and anxious when he was being abusive, but my stepfather always kept his composure.

At the times that Mr Cruel was active, we lived in the Northern Suburbs of Melbourne, which is where Carmen Chans body was found, and so did my stepbrother. Her body was found only a couple of suburbs away from where we resided. My stepfather does not appear to fit the physical description of Mr Cruel, as he is quite short, but my stepbrother does. It would not even surprise me if they acted (if it was them) as a pair, because each of them knew of the others fetish/sadistic behaviours, and each of them covered for each other.

At the time that Mr Cruel was active, I would also like to note that at least one of his victims stated that they could hear airplanes overhead when they were abducted. We lived in the Northern Suburbs of Melbourne at the time, not too far from an international airport, and underneath the flight path of many of the flights.

Also one of the descriptions of a room that one of the girls was kept in matches up with what I can remember from one of my stepbrothers rooms when he was living out of our home for a while. My stepbrother never lived on barracks when we moved to Melbourne, he either rented his own place, or he moved back in with us for a while. The only time I recall that he lived on a base was just before we moved back to Tasmania. At this time he was married, and was working as a chef at a communications depot. Because this depot was so small, and in a rural area, and because he was married, he was provided a house on the depot site to live in with his wife of the time. Because he was a chef, and the depot was so small, he was the only chef that I was aware of, so it was essential that he be available on site to cook breakfast, lunch and dinners, so living at the depot was pretty essential.

I also recall his really odd behaviour, which may not have anything to do with this case, but it was not uncommon to find him vacuuming his house, or hanging washing out the back to dry at 1am. This may have something to do with him being a chef and working hours that were different than most. Just getting household chores done when he could. But he was also an extreme neat freak, and I hated spending time there to keep his wife company because as a 16 year old I did not appreciate being woken up to help vacuum or hang washing up so late at night.

I mentioned all of this to a police officer years ago, all I can recall was that she was part of a task force at the time. She did ask me to get back to her, but I had a house fire, and lost her contact details. Since then, I have never been able to locate them again since, and I have no idea what her name was. I really dont remember, although i really wish I did.

I truly believe that one of them, if not both of them were involved in this whole Mr Cruel incidents. It terrifies me to think that perhaps their dislike for me, or their passion to be sadistic towards myself is possibly why they chose targets that were brunette and of the same age as myself? There is a saying in Australia, which is "you dont shit where you eat", which means if you are going to commit a crime, you dont do it in your back yard because its just too close to your home. So the thought of them lashing out at these young ladies instead of myself is just sickening. Of course, I have no definite proof on me, or they/he would most certainly be in prison as I type this. Obviously, I have nothing to do with them at all anymore.

Whenever I was abused, it was either psychological and sadistic which is just impossible to prove to authorities unless their is a non biased witness, or the abuse never left any marks on my body, which again is pretty difficult to prove. My mother once told me when I was 14 that if I ever went to the police, she would lie, and then she asked me who I thought a judge would believe, her or a teenage girl? I was terrified to go to the authorities because I thought no one would believe me, and then the aftermath would be much much worse for me.

Since then however, I have had my stepbrother charged, and he did end up spending some time in jail for some of the crimes committed against me, although most of them have gone unpunished. I dont hold any malice about that, and am impressed that the Victorian police were able to put together a case on what information they had, and that they were able to charge him at all.

This does not alleviate my concerns about the Mr Cruel cases though. There are so many coincidences that I find it frightening.

1 The intense interest in the media coverage of the cases

2 All the victims being same age and same hair colour as myself

3 Living in the approximate area where he was committing the crimes

4 Their facial hair being the same as the sample found at a crime scene

5 Their colloquialisms that match Mr Cruels patterns of speech

6 The time frames that Mr Cruel was committing his crimes matched the times that both of my

family members were in Victoria

7 Living in the Northern suburbs, we lived close to the international airport and underneath the

flight path of airplanes.

8 My stepfathers compulsion for tidiness. and my stepbrother being in the army at the time of

Mr Cruels active spree.

9 Mr Cruels activities seemed to cease when both my stepfather and stepbrother moved
interstate from Victoria

10 My stepfathers fascination with serial killers

11 My family coming from Tasmania, as the police believed that Mr Cruel was either Tasmanian
or from New Zealand

This is an awful lot of coincidences concerning one case.... or one offender.

I guess all of these coincidences dont really amount to a criminal case, but it has left me feeling ill, terrified, and with no one to talk to about this. I did try to mention it to my biological father once, a few years ago, but I think he just thought perhaps I was over reacting, as he was no aware of the abuse I had endured as a child. I had never told him about any of this. Even when my stepbrother was charged and went to jail, my biological father had no idea why, and had no idea that my mother was aware, and that his father was also a part of it all. I cant shake the horrible feeling that I feel like I was raised by a serial abuser (well, that one I know is a certainty) and a murderer, who had no problem in taking the life of a young girl. I know that either of them are capable of such actions, although if I was asked to choose which one I thought it would most likely be.... the physical attributes match my stepbrother, but the calmness of Mr Cruel is something that was more often displayed by my stepfather... so I dont really know... but I am very sure that one of them, if not both of them were involved in this case. I just dont know who to approach who will take all of this seriously. I also have a family of my own now, and I dont want them to hear about any of it. I have to be careful because I dont want to expose my children to these kinds of images/thoughts.

Lastly, I would just like to add, for those who question as to whether or not my thought processes about this situation are.... erm.... stable.. I had to be psychologically assessed as part of the legal requirements when I had charges pressed against my stepbrother. The courts need to assure that the person making those kinds of allegations are mentally aware of their accusations, and that there is no sign of mental illness where they may have misinterpreted a situation etc.

Yes, there are phycological effects... I suffer from PTSD, but honestly, if you knew the true horrors of the home I grew up in, then you would be amazed if anyone could endure such an upbringing and walk out of that home without any emotional baggage.

If anyone who reads this knows of a person amongst the Victorian police task force who would be interested in talking with me, I have no problems with this, and would appreciate a way to contact them.

As I type this, I am sitting here shaking, as I recall my old home, and what those poor girls had to endure, and poor Carmen who probably did nothing wrong other than to view his face. My heart goes out to her family, but I am so scared that her family would bear a grudge towards me. Even though I have had nothing to do with the whole situation, and was the same age as their Carmen, grief can make someone view perspectives differently. I would be ashamed to face them, unless I was able to assist in them getting some kind of justice.

I have not mentioned any names, other than that of Carmen Chan who was one of his victims, I have not mentioned exact suburbs, or exact information as if this is of interest to the police, I dont want to jeopardize any possible investigation and outcome by posting information publicly before an official investigation is done, nor do I want to cause any possible biased opinions, as this could affect the outcome of a court hearing. I am not saying that my step family member/s will ever be charged, or go to court, or that they are definitely guilty, but I will not take the risk of ruining any chances of possible justice, just so I can tell my story on Reddit.

Thanks for reading. Perhaps someone will respond with some kind of information or advice.


r/MrCruel • • Feb 20 '22

Mr Cruel Bathroom Location? Brunswick West.

Post image
217 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Apr 09 '22

Karmein Chan's remains were found 30 years ago today.

Post image
181 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Nov 01 '25

Are you f*%king kidding me, Google?

Post image
170 Upvotes

When my iPhone is on its side and charging, it shows the time and a random photo from my Google Pictures.

I've just woken up from a nap to this.

Scared the crap out of me!


r/MrCruel • • Nov 07 '22

Has anyone checked Peter Scully?

146 Upvotes

[1]: He’s old enough to have been Mr Cruel. Mr Cruel was described as being either in his 20s or 30s, and Scully, born in 1963, would’ve been in his mid-20s when Mr Cruel was active.

[2]: Most of his abducted victims were a similar age to Mr Cruel’s, with his significant exception being an 18-month-old baby.

[3]: He absolutely fits the moniker of “Super cool and super cruel”.

[4]: Mr Cruel was described as being soft-spoken and unhurried, and Scully was disturbingly soft-spoken and unhurried during his interviews and arrest.

[5]: He filmed his victims for his dark web child pornography business, No Limits Fun. Mr Cruel similarly possibly filmed his victims, as Sharon Wills recalled a wooden tripod stand being at the foot of the bed she was tied to, and even the FBI's profile of Mr Cruel states that he likely kept recordings of his victims.

[6]: After being apprehended, a fire broke out in the evidence room holding Scully's sieged laptop and videos. Some believe Scully was responsible for this by bribing a local police officer to set the evidence room alight in order to destroy any and all evidence against him. Likewise, Mr Cruel was obviously very preoccupied about the prospect of leaving any possible evidence, and vigorously ensured that no such evidence was left behind to link him to his crimes.

[7]: He abducted victims and brought them back to his lair/base to carry out his acts. We know Mr Cruel similarly did this with at least 2 of his canonical victims, Sharon and Lynas, but likely Karmein as well if she was a victim of Mr Cruel.

[8]: He murdered (or there’s roughly a 99.99% chance that it was him given he filmed himself doing it) an abducted 11-year-old girl, Cindy, in 2012, who appeared in the No Limits Fun films. Likewise, Mr Cruel murdered Karmein Chan after abducting her (although, to reiterate once again, opinions are divided on if Mr Cruel was Karmein's abductor). Albeit Scully strangled his victim with a rope rather than shooting her like Mr Cruel did.

Biggest things that I could find at this point against Scully being Mr Cruel is that, prior to fleeing to the Philippines, he lived in Narre Warren, far from North-East Melbourne where Mr Cruel's hideout most likely was. However, that doesn't mean that's where he lived indefinitely, as he could've moved to Narre Warren at any point in his life. On top of this, he was married and had 2 children, and it would be hard for a potential Mrs Cruel, or in this case Mrs Scully, not to know about her husband's antics. But likewise, I can't find anything recording specifically when he got married, meaning it could've been after Mr Cruel's activity.

I'm not saying Peter Scully is Mr Cruel, but surely he must've been investigated by someone at some point as a possible suspect.


r/MrCruel • • Jun 02 '26

Today marks 15 years since Bung Siriboon was last seen :(

Post image
127 Upvotes

Bung Siriboon was last seen on her way to school 15 years ago today.

Unfortunately this year also brought the sad news of the passing of Bung's mother.

My thoughts are with Bung's family and loved ones. I hope they get the answers they deserve soon. :(

Edit: I don't associate her disappearance with Mr Cruel, but the case had a significant impact on the same community and has been the topic of past discussions I've had here. The case is very important to me.


r/MrCruel • • Mar 28 '24

Never be solved.

127 Upvotes

It’s now 37 years since Mr Cruels first known attack. Police have no physical evidence and no DNA from the crimes . If we take an estimate of him being 30 at the first attack he would be in his late 60s.

There is no likelihood of him confessing if he is still alive or even in the country. It appears the girls have got on with their lives as best they could. We are not aware of any of them providing anything further that will help a breakthrough since their first interviews

The mongrel has got away with it.


r/MrCruel • • Apr 13 '23

The Balaclavas. Surely I'm not the only one that finds the diversity of the Balaclavas Mr Cruel seemingly owned a bit strange.

Post image
126 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Jun 14 '21

Support

115 Upvotes

Not too sure if this is where I should make this post, but I wanted to ensure as many people could see it as possible.
I made a post yesterday about possibly having MrCruel as a member of my extended family, and the support and responses where/are overwhelming.

I want to thank everyone who took the time to read my post and to send a message of support or to share their opinions or question me further. As the responses were a lot more than what I had expected, I find myself struggling to keep up with everything, so there is a possibility that I have missed a couple at present. I will get to them in time/currently.

Right now though, I wanted to take some time out to type up a thorough email so that I can send the information that I do have to the authorities, and because of this, I probably wont be responding to any further replies immediately/currently.

I do want to inform you all though, that fellow Redditors have been amazing. Anyone who can find time line faults etc in my post and who disagree with my coincidence theory, I encourage you to let me know. Any criticism is welcomed, as long as it is constructive.

I do not claim that I am completely positive that they were/are involved, I just wanted to express my concerns, and to explain why. I thank everyone who has been involved, you have all been great.

Again, I will respond to any messages I have missed in due time, just not too sure how long that will be because i know that the email I need to type up will take some time and must be as accurate and thorough as possible. Im not great at multi tasking, which is why I am going to devote my time to this email as a priority.

Thanks again.... you guys are the best!!


r/MrCruel • • Aug 22 '24

Today will mark 37 years since the Lower Plenty attack, and no suspect has ever been arrested in this case still.

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Apr 14 '21

30 years - RIP KARMEIN

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Aug 27 '26

young photo of peter scully compared to police sketch

Thumbnail
gallery
98 Upvotes

I know the majority of people have completely ruled out Peter Scully solely based on the height difference and different MO’s, but i have a few small pieces of evidence that i think make him hard to rule out completely, especially as the search becomes more and more hopeless as time goes on. We might as well consider unlikely candidates, especially considering Scully is still alive and on the non zero chance he is mr cruel could be punished for it.

  1. Scully had ginger/sandy hair in his younger years, which matches some reports of mr cruels’ hair color, pretty sure it was the girl who managed to peak at him through her blindfold??

This is also pretty important because if say he had just black or brown hair, it wouldn’t matter much because that could be so many people, but the fact they both had ginger hair narrows it down a lot.

  1. The age and area line up pretty well, mr cruel is common described as being in his 30s-40s, however, it’s not impossible for people to mistake someone in their mid 20s, for a little but older, for instance Scully was around 17-18 when this photo was taken and he clearly looks much older. As for the area, i was able to find the exact address of the house he grew up in, which is in Burwood, pretty much the exact same area of Melbourne that mr cruel operated.

  2. As for the MO’s being different, we don’t actually know if Scully was a predator during his youth in Australia, we do know that he did hard drugs and was heavily involved in crime, i also remember reading a report from someone who was his neighbour when he lived in Narre Warren in his 40s, who described him as “dodgy” and creepy to be around, once again, before any of his known sexual crimes began, also there are some similarities, both filmed their crimes, both had a soft spoken voice, although one doubt i have is that mr cruel was unfortunately very smart and meticulous, Scully seems more like an unintelligent guy who just got very lucky that he wasn’t caught sooner.

  3. One last piece of anecdotal evidence i have which could mean something but also may not, i have another young photo of scully taken around the mid to late 80s, and in it he’s wearing a grey-green tracksuit top, which was one of the pieces of clothing mr cruel was reported to have worn during his attacks.

Please give me your own thoughts on this, this is just a theory of mine, i understand it’s not very likely that scully is mr cruel, i just wanted to share these small dots i connected after conducting a lot of research. that being said, i have seen some theorising that even if scully isn’t mr cruel himself, he may have interacted with him or even knows who he is, especially as it’s likely mr cruel sold the tapes he filmed, considering they lived in the same area, and it’s very plausible scully was already a pedophile, i don’t think that can be completely ruler out either, even if them being the same person can. Thanks for reading.


r/MrCruel • • Jul 18 '24

Mr cruel survivor to speak out.

Post image
92 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Feb 26 '22

Mr Cruel Bathroom Location? Pascoe Vale.

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Apr 11 '21

Karen Chan's drawing of Mr. Cruel

86 Upvotes

This is the drawing made by Karmein Chan's other younger sister of Mr Cruel. This one is not seen as often as the other. So, both sisters drew pictures of the same figure wearing a dark balaclava holding a knife. This was before the internet, so I don't believe they could have seen any images like this to copy.

Karmein Chan WAS abducted & killed by Mr Cruel.


r/MrCruel • • Jan 13 '24

Thoughts?

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Jul 29 '26

Recreation of the sketch featured in the 2019 channel 9 piece on Mr. Cruel.

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

((DISCLAIMER: THIS IS NOT AI, EVERYTHING WAS EDITED BY ME))

Did my best to recover the photo and recreate his possible appearance if it were accurate to the description, comparing the two it doesn't seem too far off.

(Also lol I've never really posted but i thought this could interest others)


r/MrCruel • • Jun 07 '24

Police know who Mr Cruel is but not enough evidence

83 Upvotes

I got this information from someone who knew one of the victims/family and who has contacts within Victoria Police. Common consensus is that Victoria Police know who Mr Cruel is and they had him followed 24/7 trying to get evidence to arrest him. I believe he is now meant to be living overseas somewhere and the police in that country are aware of Victoria police's suspicion as to him being Mr Cruel. He is now meant to be in his 60s or 70s and so not considered a major threat any more however police always check any mew cases that could fit his offending profile. As to previous offending prior to Lower Plenty, Victoria Police believe that he may have assaulted elderly women in nursing homes as "practice" perhaps supporting a theory that he was in the medical field, maybe a nurse? (I don't know enough about their number 1 suspect so no idea who he is/what career he had). As they don't have enough evidence to convict him, it could still be someone else however they are pretty certain that it's this particular guy.


r/MrCruel • • May 02 '22

Confirmation of Eltham Man! Amazing work Pwurg!

82 Upvotes

Great to see that Andrew Rule was finally able to reveal Norman Leung Lee as Eltham Man. Myself, u/elocra, u/mjr_sherlock_holmes and u/pwurg had been trying to work out who Ron Iddles' elusive Eltham Man suspect since early last year. u/pwurg nominated Norman Leung Lee as likely him in May last year. Attempts to contact Ron Iddles to confirm proved fruitless. I was suspicious because of Lee's Asiatic features and we couldn't confirm if he had any property in Eltham at the time. We knew he lived in Kensington, had girlie bars in the Philippines and possibly multiple properties though. I tried the Eltham Historical Society, but they had no info on him living in Eltham. Then in March things hotted up after the Channel 9 episode and I tried to focus on getting more info on Lee. We worked out his family tree and tried to contact family members to no avail. We found old newspaper articles, one referred to the fact that his factory in Brunswick was built by a man named Boza Djuric. u/elocra also worked out that one of his co-conspirators in the Tullamarine job buried a vicitm in the same patch of land as where Karmein Chan was buried. I was emailing Andrew Rule at the time and decided to tell him that we believed Lee was Ron Iddles' suspect. He's obviously since gone and got in touch with Iddles and confirmed he had a property in Eltham and that Alfie Gay was the informer. So, that's the final piece of the puzzle. Whether he is Mr Cruel of course is another question. The search goes on, I'm sure there is more to come with this story.


r/MrCruel • • Nov 20 '25

Claimed eyewitness sighting of Mr Cruel

Post image
81 Upvotes

Credit to previous poster Bronfoth for alerting me to this thread


r/MrCruel • • Jul 23 '24

This guy could probably find the MC house

81 Upvotes

Have a look at this guy on Youtube. He is a professional Google maps/open source info searcher that can find literally any location even from a single tree, a cloud, a shadow, a light - anything. It is incredible.

Check this channel:
https://www.youtube.com/@georainbolt

And some of his most impressive finds here:
https://instagram.com/georainbolt

Maybe he is up for the challenge?


r/MrCruel • • Nov 29 '22

Hopefully answering any unanswered questions

79 Upvotes

Hi, I just want to start off by apologizing for my absence from Reddit. I had a bad experience with a moderator from a different sub which I felt was a personal attack and unprovoked. They attempted to use some of my posts from other subs against me, which made me apprehensive about returning. I was already finding the responses I had received for my previous posts to be somewhat overwhelming, and the stress that the moderator concerned had caused made me regret making any posts at all, which was wrong. I wont mention the sub they moderated, because it is a great sub and one bad apple should not ruin an experience for others. However, the redditors I have communicated with on this sub have been fantastic, and supportive and I feel that I owe you an apology because I should have taken that into consideration while I was avoiding logging into Reddit. So to start with, I want to apologize for not being available or around, and to thank everyone out there who was supportive to myself.

Anyway, to recap on what I had already shared. In Australia there is a television show called "Under investigation" where they have their shows based on a lot of cold cases etc in Australia. Anyway, one of the earlier shows was based on the Mr Cruel case, and at first I avoided watching it, but after a couple of months my curiosity got the better of me, so I decided to have a look.

I was surprised to learn that apparently there had been two young boys who had noticed someone suspicious before an assault took place on one of the young victims and had done a composite sketch that they aired on the show. I was also surprised to see how much that composite sketch looked like my stepfather. Except for one feature. The sketch had the suspicious man as bald, where my stepfather has always had a really high hairline. To someone who is shorter than himself, he may look as though he is bald or balding though. This show only raised more concerns on my part. I have not yet made contact with the Mr Cruel task force, as I am hoping that someone out there has a email address or some way for me to contact them via the internet, as I am not freely able to discuss things out aloud on a phone. There was one person I spoke to a while ago now on Reddit that did give me an email address to an officer that I could email, but I cannot find it at present, so if that person is reading this update or if anyone else has some contact information that they could share with me, I would really appreciate this.

As you can imagine, yes I believe that although I cannot claim for certain that I know the identity of Mr Cruel, I may have information that could help the police. Talking on Reddit where there is a fair amount of anonymity, and if there is a topic I dont feel comfortable sharing at one particular time, I can say that, or talk about a different aspect but when speaking with the police, this will not be an option and I will have to relive everything in great detail all over again, so I am sure there are some people out there who can understand that I have some apprehension. However I do completely agree that the information I have should be shared with the right authorities. So if anyone has any contact information for someone linked to the specific task force I need to speak with, that would be reaally helpful, as it will lessen the amount of police that I will have to explain my situation too, and lessen the amount of questions in detail that I will have to answer. I am hoping that someone from the task force is actually keeping an eye on things such as the r/MrCruel and that they attempt to make contact with me directly. I have however been absent from reddit for such a long time now that they may have already attempted, as I do have many many notifications to look through.
If anyone has questions that I am able to answer, feel free to ask, as that is the least that I owe after all the support I received the last time I posted on this sub. Please also understand though, that there are some questions that I may feel to uncomfortable in answering, or uncomfortable in answering in great detail. The last time I posted here, I did find the response more overwhelming than what I could have ever predicted, but for the most part I found the other redditors on this sub to be very supportive and polite, so again, thanks for everything.
I will try to check up on here as often as I can, now that I have returned to using reddit, and will slowly start going through some of my older notifications. I am so very sorry for the long wait for those who reached out to me.


r/MrCruel • • Nov 25 '24

Karmein Chan grave stone, Templestowe Cemetary. RIP

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

r/MrCruel • • Sep 26 '24

Easey street arrest should give us all hope

74 Upvotes

I must admit I almost fell off my chair when I heard that Perry Kouroumblis had been arrested over the Easey Street murders. This crime runs a close second to Mr Cruel in the list of crimes that keep me awake at night and for which I hope an arrest is made. I'm reading Helen Thomas' brilliant book; Murder On Easey Street for the second time right now, unable to remember if Kouroumblis was mentioned in detail, or just referenced in passing as the man who was in possession of the knife used in the attack, discovered by our old friend Ron Iddles.

This arrest, following arrests for Kylie Maybury's killer, Clairmont killer and well documented cases overseas should give followers of the cruel case cause for optimism, not only that science is always evolving, but that the people working on cases like these never give up. Nor should we.

I must admit that I hadn't visited, or contributed to this sub for a few months, having lost confidence that the momentum; built up in the months and years post the Golden State Killer arrest, would continue. Moments like these in the cold case world are rare, and we; as either interested onlookers, or hardcore armchair detectives, should celebrate and increase the conversations about other cases.

I never thought Easey street would be solved. And I had started losing hope that Mr Cruel would either.

But you never know. Perhaps we're closer than we think on Mr Cruel.

For those who have read this far, the others that keep me awake at night in no particular order are... Beaumont kids, the Crawford family, Maria James, Lucia Amenta, Bung Siriboon... I could go on and on.