r/Movie_Club • u/[deleted] • Apr 17 '22
[Discussion] Who you got as the worst human in the history of cinema! (Hope I did title tag right this my first Reddit post ever)
Who is the worst person(character not actor who played them), in theater?
r/Movie_Club • u/[deleted] • Apr 17 '22
Who is the worst person(character not actor who played them), in theater?
r/Movie_Club • u/[deleted] • Jul 19 '16
Yesterday I went to the cinema and there were lots of people in the room eating and making sounds and so, as always. My question is: Why is there this necessity? Where does this come from?
r/Movie_Club • u/[deleted] • Jul 21 '15
you can discuss the movie while watching in cytube, there is a little chat bar to the left, well not little at all
r/Movie_Club • u/[deleted] • Jul 23 '15
anyone share the opinion that this subreddit is becoming way too messy and deorganized, specially taking in consideration its purpose, i think the exponential growth is hurting it and it hasn´t even started yet, also all this "lets watch at the same time" is turning out too dumb of an idea, i get the point, its like going to the theater but at home, but it excludes a lot of people that just want to participate but cant because of time zones (i have to say i am one of those people) but that is my opinion, what about yours?
r/Movie_Club • u/moremelk • Aug 04 '15
I adored this movie when I was younger, it'd be nice to see it again! Plus it's my birthday on the 18th, so maybe it could be the movie for that Friday? ;)
r/Movie_Club • u/The_Social_Introvert • Jan 26 '18
If you prefer a video version, see here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvpA6F663RI&t=6s
‘It’ is the film adaption of Stephen King’s horror novel, coming after the TV mini-series starring Tim Curry as Pennywise the Dancing Clown, an entity that poses as a children’s entertainer who terrorises a group of kids in an American town in the 80’s. This version is rated R rated, and stars Bill Skarsgard as the child eater.
So we follow a group of children in a town where child-disappearances are a thing, who call themselves ‘the losers club’; they’re pretty much the outcasts of the usual high school clique, we’ve got the stutter kid, the black guy, the four eyes, the fat bastard and so on. Billy, the leader of the pack, lost his brother years ago, unbeknownst to him, to Pennywise. All of a sudden for no apparent reason, creepy stuff begins to happen all around them whenever the group is separate from each other, things that always seem to play of their own personal fears, usually a personal tragedy. The thing that is consistent in everyone’s episodes is a clown that appears. The kids eventually tell each other about these instances and do a bit of research after which they realize they are being hunted by a phenomenon that manifests itself every 27 years and wants to eat them.
It’s a very old school sounding horror plot, and it is quite an old school movie in the sense that everything is as it appears; there isn’t necessarily anything underneath the surface level, nothing wrong with that of course. But what I mean to say is a lot of the scares are generated through the visuals and jump instances. But it does lack quality elements that its predecessors excelled in. If I could momentarily compare it to John Carpenter’s Prince of Darkness, a movie which I was reminded of while watching ‘It’ – there were loads of visual scares in that film also, a man decomposing into a hoard of beetles, an undead human with its face ripped off – we see similar things in ‘It’ a headless dude chasing a kid, a giant crab-like creature, but for some reason there was something about the scares in this film that just weren’t resonating with me. I wasn’t digging it.
I think a lot of my issues were relating to atmosphere. ‘It’ doesn’t really have an identity, in terms of atmosphere. When you think of ‘The Fog’ for example, you think of cold ambience, spooky and eerie, if you are looking at Suspiria you think bright colours, bombastic and skilful style, but what is ‘It’s Identity? I don’t really feel it has one, and it takes away a lot from the movie. I guess a major factor is that the film doesn’t really take its time, despite the almost 2 and a half hour run time – it jumps straight into the horror and the clown doing his thing, going after everyone left right and centre. The movie doesn’t really feel like it has its own personality, instead it almost feels like a few set pieces of horror scenes loosely strung together. Add that to the fact that we open with a horror scene (a terrific opening, I might add), then a couple of more horror scenes of each main character being harassed by the clown, then everyone bonding, then more terror, then a bit more bonding, then a weird rock throwing fight against some bullies, then some more terror…I don’t know. I feel it all kind of lacks structure, lacks an efficient arrangement of scenes. Just take your time. We don’t need to see Pennywise popping up saying ‘BOO’ every 2 minutes – sell his appearance, build the fear, instead of throwing it at the screen.
Speaking of the scares, many of the horror scenes were rendered ineffective because there were a lot of very obvious computer generated effects, and that’s just a massive no-no, especially in horror. If it’s clear the effects aren’t real then it just ruins the immersion, any possible fear you’d feel is immediately evaporated.
So that covers the visual scares. The rest of the scares are pretty much jump scares. Nothing wrong with a good jump scare, but when they are scattered so frequently throughout the film and they become so common place each one loses its distinctiveness. I only saw the film yesterday and yet I can only really remember two jump scares, which isn’t the most confident commendation of a film whose entire shtick relies on these kind of scenes. Is ‘It’ scary? I don’t think so. Loud yes, but frightening? No. And it’s a shame, because the movie is dependant on these scares – without them, there isn’t much to come for. But they’re just not very effective. I mean, what’s the formula at work with the film? Introduce a scary set piece, have a terrified child walk up to it, unleash a CGI-filmed jump scare accompanied by the occasional seizure-like activity from the clown, and then he disappears. Rinse and repeat. But there isn’t really much else, no cake under all the sugar and icing. It’s unfortunate. To be honest I found the real life stuff more upsetting than the supernatural. Parts like a pack of bullies cutting a victim with a knife.
Pennywise himself looks pretty unsettling. The actor who played him did a great job of creating a sinister villain who, whilst is very threatening gives off the vibe that he’s simply toying with the kids most of the time and isn’t giving it his all. From what I hear from those who have read the book, this is the actual case and he will come back stronger and harder in the film’s sequel. I would have preferred an older and more innocent looking clown, one that might not stand out at a circus, but one whose tirades of evil reveal a much more physically terrifying appearance. That’s kind of the essence of a clown isn’t it? Innocent and playful, enticing to children, not immediately creepy and scary. But that’s the creative decision the film-makers went with so hay ho. Skarsgard also has a lazy eye which the director utilized quite well.
I don’t really understand the creature and what he can and can’t do. This was one of my main peeves with prince of Darkness also in that the villains’ abilities weren’t well defined. If Pennywise relies on fear and is unable to attack certain characters in pivotal scenes because they are not afraid of him, how is he able to take out Georgie in the opening scene when the kid is literally laughing and mingling with him, even being fearless enough to reach out a hand to grab his boat the Pennywise is holding? He is able to teleport anywhere grabbing victims but gets knocked out in a fist fight with a bunch of self-proclaimed losers? Why is he even engaging in a fist fight? Surely he could use one of his powers to handicap or even kill the children instantly? I don’t really get it.
Acting wise, I think all the youngsters did a fine job. The film is as much of a Stand By Me style, coming of age tale as it is a horror movie, and the Loser’s club actors played their parts effectively, coming across as genuine kids acting the way children would act. You can see what the film is go for what with the kids, the 80’s, the clown, like I said it all feels very old school but is damaged by various problems, most of which are modern day problems, like the already-mentioned CGI.
This is a bit of a spoiler, I guess. But one thing I was really bummed out by was after hearing Pennywise’s well known quote about floating and telling would-be victims that “You’ll float too” it turns out his victims do actually float. They are literally suspended in mid-air flying around after they are killed down in the sewers. That was a bit iffy really. I never thought Pennywise meant that literally, more like “you’ll float down the sewers after I’ll kill you”, not “I’ll turn you into a flying Christmas tree decoration.” It probably epitomizes one of the main problems with this film, in that everything is literal, everything is visual. None of the scares are otherworldly, none of the ideas abstract. It’s all just really roars, screams, clowns, spiders, teeth etc etc There’s a few other things here and there that had me rolling my eyes, like how the group repeats that sticking together is the key to success, but constantly and intentionally separate from each other when in the spooky house or in the sewers.
‘It’ was serviceable, it was functional, but it lacked a kick. It lacked something that I usually refer to as the ‘soul’ of the movie. Elements of it come off as artificial, rushed and lacking heart and to be honest, even with the constant barrage of Pennywise attacks and illusions…I was a bit bored really. And it made no lasting impact, which is one of the measures of an effective horror movie. I am sad to say I give it a 6/10.
r/Movie_Club • u/john3298 • Jun 20 '16
I didn't understand it all it was really confusing. At the time I watched it I didn't feel it was that good but at the end and after I got home... My god it was good. The soundtracks the confusing plot... First time I ever felt a tear over a movie (yes it sounds crazy but its true). My buddy even cried not the sound one but tears going down his face holy moly. What a movie
r/Movie_Club • u/CineRanter-YTchannel • May 03 '18
For a video version of this post, see here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFLDHCpKGMo&t=3s
Recently Jurassic Park franchise producer Frank Marshall, in regards to the special effects for the upcoming Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom, said:
I think since Jurassic Park we’ve got more animatronics than any of the other movies. Except Jurassic Park.
I saw this quote and it got me thinking. There are several things that can be taken from comments like these. First of all, it’s just blatant PR talk, propaganda to generate further interest in a movie project. ‘Film producer praises film he is producing’. What’s new? It’s also a bit ironic, seeing as though the first Jurassic World had a joke about people who think more means better are dumb consumers. That film was full of unintended critiques about itself and the producer just added to that here.
If I remember correctly the director of the last Jurassic World movie said something similar, that they would be using animatronics in the movie, that they would be shooting on film, that they would be filming on location, all things that movie-goers in general want to hear, right? And then when Jurassic World was released, we saw that there was only the one animatronic, a pathetic token Apatosaurus head that looked so poor it might as well have been scrapped for a digital version. There were CGI trees, buildings, dinosaurs, even the colour of the sky and all attacked with irritating colour correction that robbed everything of their distinct features. If there were more animatronic dinosaurs, then we clearly didn’t see them because they were ‘enhanced’, and when I mean enhanced I mean they were drawn over with CGI, which means we don’t get to see them in their glorious state and thus the fact that they were originally animatronic is meaningless.
You see this a lot, it’s fairly standard practice. Actors from Ridley Scott’s Alien Covenant in the build up to the film talked about their fear in how they were chased by men in suits whilst shooting. But as anyone who saw the final product will tell you the men in suits turned out to be men in motion capture suits, and the Xenomorphs were digitally rendered into the scenes, and rendered very poorly, I might add.
Going back to the original quote then it’s safe to say it’s the equivalent of a creepy, hairy old man coaxing you to step into his van by waving chocolate bars at you. The producer just wants your bum in the cinema seat. Another interesting thing about the producer’s quotes, and the Alien Covenant stars’ quotes, and JJ Abrams quotes on his Star Wars movie, and the quotes of so many directors, producers and actors who talk about how their upcoming blockbuster will have loads of practical effects, animatronics, will be shot on location, things like that, is that these people know what we as the audience want. There seems to be a consensus that in general Hollywood is out of touch with what movie-goers want, but here we have examples of people within the business attempting to persuade you to watch their movies by talking up aspects of the films, or even straight up lying, about things that you want to see in movies. People are always going on about wanting practical effects over CGI. So what do film-makers say in the build up to their movies? We’ve got loads of practical effects. Hollywood isn’t out of touch. Hollywood’s game is more on-point than any of us realize, with entire companies being hired to discover and decipher just what audiences are looking for in movies. They won’t necessarily include the things you want in their movies, but they sure as hell will try to convince you they have done. Comments like these are just exaggerations and lies in a long line of exaggerations and lies. And it’s weird that people seem to always fall for it, then wise up after seeing the film, and then jump right onto the hype bandwagon when the sequel begins its teaser and trailer runs. Just take a look at any Marvel, DC, Star Wars, Jurassic World film or any major blockbuster movie that you were disappointed with, and bring up a list of quotes and interviews that the cast and crew made before the release of the film, and you’ll often find them, in a way, saying exactly what you hope the film to be.
It’s also quite insulting in a way, isn’t it? Saying that a movie will have practical effects just to get us to see it. Do practical effects make a good movie? What about a good plot, a cohesive, well-written script? Efficient acting. We may be crying out for specific things like animatronics, but that doesn’t mean 2 hours of a twitching hydraulic T Rex is going to make for a decent film.
Anyway, it’s only a single sentence from a producer. Probably not worth an entire post of ranting but I saw the quote and saw the hype that it generated and it just kind of rubbed me the wrong way. We need to remember everybody promoting a blockbuster is always reading off the same hymn sheet, and it’s a sheet in the shape of a massive dollar sign.
r/Movie_Club • u/NerdByteYT • Dec 30 '15
r/Movie_Club • u/Alaharon123 • Dec 02 '17
I've been watching a bunch of movies from the Espionage showdown through the True Story showdown and it's been a great way to get movie recommendations. I was going to make a list of what I've watched thanks to showdowns, but I can't remember with some of them whether that was the reason I watched them or not so here's a list of movies from those showdowns that I watched regardless of the reason that I watched them
Amazing
Casino Royale
Kingsman: The Secret Service
Spider-Man
Die Hard
The Breakfast Club
Airplane!
Stand by Me
Moonrise Kingdom
The Perks of being a Wallflower
The Edge of Seventeen
Juno
Scott Pilgrim vs. The World
Ghostbusters
Good
Spotlight
The Shining
Jurassic Park
Jaws
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
The Princess Bride
12 Angry Men
Ferris Bueller's Day Off
Sing Street
IT
The Nightmare Before Christmas
E.T.
Hocus Pocus
The Shining
The Goonies
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
Schindler's List
The Wolf of Wall Street
Eh
North by Northwest
Citizen Kane
The Lord of The Rings: The Fellowship of The Ring
Arrival
The Lord of The Rings: The Return of the King
The Lord of The Rings: The Two Towers
Halloween
Donnie Darko
The Exorcist
Back to The Future
Raging Bull
Meh
The Godfather
Blade Runner
The Silence of the Lambs
Dr. Strangelove
Alien
Spider-Man: Homecoming
Dunkirk
So we end up with 49 movies where only 7 were actually bad and 13 blew my mind in some way with how great they were. Even the ones that fall in the middle are more good than eh. I like these odds
Here's a list of all the showdowns put together https://boxd.it/1mb2c
Edit: The odds are better than they look because other than Dr. Strangelove, all the meh movies I watched for some other reason and 5 of the amazing movies I watched purely because of letterboxd. I'm not sure exactly how many for the good and eh, but the amount is higher on good than eh on that also
r/Movie_Club • u/AutoModerator • Mar 16 '16
This is a reminder to all of our movie goers that daylight saving time has happened. What does this mean for you? Well it means our CST movies have been pushed forward one hour. Daylight savings time does not affect UTC. If you want some help remembering, we do have Automatic Reminders that will send you a message 30 min before the movie starts.
You can also always Google "[insert your time zone here] to CST/UTC"
r/Movie_Club • u/WreckPT • Aug 08 '17
We love a comedy but occasional action doesnt hurt anyone, i personally dont mind older movies but plz make a list of 1999+. We loved american pie, project x, 21 and 22 jump street and many others. We are all guys btw dont go romance on me ahahah NOT BEING SEXIST
r/Movie_Club • u/wheeledjustice • Feb 24 '25
r/Movie_Club • u/test822 • Feb 03 '16
Streaming from google drive introduces a weird choppiness to the cytube playback. This is especially noticeable during scenes with a lot of movement, or during smooth pans. Embedding the video as a custom frame plays fine though (as does previewing the file within google drive itself, so it seems to be a CyTube problem when doing google drive video synced) but embedding isn't an option because custom frame embeds can't be synced.
Youtubes and Vimeos also play fine and smooth, but to upload large files to Vimeo I'd have to pay $50 (or maybe even $200) a year, which I'd like to avoid.
I'm wondering how to set up my own server on my computer to host files which I can then view in Cytube, but I've never done anything like it before (aside from hosting a mumble server, which is probably kid stuff by comparison). I was wondering if any of you guys have done anything similar and can point me in the right direction?
r/Movie_Club • u/deeagobiks • Jul 03 '17
I had watched a movie 1 year ago, it was an old movie not the recent one. The movie was about Mom, Daughter & Mom's Boyfriend. They live together, but when Mom goes out for work her daughter and her boyfriend start to romance and eventually have sex. One day she returns home earlier and they were doing things like normally and she caught both playing around. However, instead of reacting awkwardly and banishing him from her home, she takes it casual and also joins the play afterwards. I just can't remember that movie's name after 1 year, please if anybody has watched it share its name here. Thank you!
r/Movie_Club • u/i-var • Mar 07 '16
Ok, I guess this will be done in 1 min. Im looking for a very well known movie, but Ive totally forgotten the name! Its not a mainstream movie, but very well known by movie conaisseurs I guess. Heres the description of the scene i know: Two guys are driving through the desert in a cabrio, one is wearing a fisher hat, pilot glasses with gold bezel and a slight beige tint, while having a cigarette or joint in his mouth. Thats what I know for sure, I dont want to blur it up with things that might be wrong. Its probably the first thing that will come to your mind. Id appreciate it if you could post a pic of that scene too, so I can identify it :) Thanks for saving my movie night with helping! :)
r/Movie_Club • u/DrSpacemanSpliff • Jul 21 '15
Historical Samurai movie that won the best foreign film oscar. Toshiro Mifune is one of my favorite actors, and I have not yet seen this one. Its in color, too, which is exciting. I have it on DVD, but I assume it's on HULU.
r/Movie_Club • u/mselbi • Jan 18 '16
hi I recently moved to Vancouver, Canada im a big movie buff (with a bit nerdy taste) and im seeking a pal to watch movies with (wife isnt much into that stuff). basically someone who has a passion for movies and know about films a bit. im 33/male, so if youre 12 dont answer this thread, otherwise, PM or comment
r/Movie_Club • u/whoanellie418 • Aug 17 '15
I just saw this movie this weekend, it was SO awesome. The actors they chose were basically unknowns, but they look just like the real thing. Also I heard a couple of them were actually their SONS, playing their father. I cried twice as well but I won't say at what parts. again, AWESOME MOVIE (coming from a 24 yo female, who doesn't really listen to that music. My boyfriend and his friend really wanted to go :)
r/Movie_Club • u/ead2000 • Sep 27 '19
So I'm watching movies from the IMDB top ranked movies' list:
It's not like i follow everything that site does and it's not like i love them, but i find the list interesting enough. I've watched up until Saving Private Ryan. I skipped "Seven Samurai" and "It's a wonderful life" (I'll watch em some day) but aside from that I've seen all the movies that go before "Saving...".
Now to the matter of the post; includes SPOILERS:
It all started cool. The D-day war scenes were raw, explicit and bloody as war movies should be depicted. War isn't something funny and kids shouldn't take it lightly. Then the main problematic comes up (saving private Ryan). You know what happens. They finally find him and well... they fight.
It was a nice movie and i didn't feel it was tedious considering its length, but there are some aspects i didn't like.
I'm not from the US and though my country is full of violence, war as it's shown in the movie isn't something i think of when i hear the words "war" or "violence" being mentioned. The context and what war means in my country is totally different to what the US thinks of so that's a factor of how some things of the film affect me. That being said, i found it patriotic to the point i was like "Oh, god! Here comes the 'AMERICA! FUCK YEAH!". It obviously wasn't like that, but i found some things unnecessary.
If Steven Spielberg's objective was to show the cruelty and crudity of war then some elements stained my experience.
For example, the US soldiers were mostly depicted as people with values while others were simply shown as targets. This happens in a lot of US belic movies with americans being the good and enemies the evil as it happened back in the western movies era too (not just modern war movies).
Yes, the movie shows the fear of soldiers and their simple but strong motives to survive. They show us the vulnerability of men and how easy they can break. That, i think, is left behind. Then again, i felt like americans were too good or maybe rivals' lack of context made the contrast stronger. There's this german soldier they spare that later gets back to fight and kills US soldiers without regretting anything.
On the other hand, we have: -The translator (forgive me for not adding the names. My memory is really really bad) for example. He's inexperienced and he forgives and try to forgive enemies more than once. He's scared and couldn't kill anyone but that german he spared once. He's a kind man. -There's this sniper guy who has Christ by his side. -Then we have the guy who is a jew who is rude but at times a nice guy. We have the big fella who tries to help the little french girl and ends up being shot. -There's this guy who survives that almost left the mission but then came back and of course saved Ryan a few times although he didn't want to first. -We have the medic who tells the story of him and his mom (you know, how he faked being sleeping). He always tried to help everyone and actually felt bad for the deaths of others. -The Cap, Mr. Hanks as I'll call him, who i found as a nice character. Has witnessed a lot, has done a lot but completes the mission and dies as a heroic soldier, of course. -Private Ryan well, he doesn't leave his team cuz he's a true american citizen fighting for his country (right?).
Many of the main characters had the chance to say those few last words, those last seconds of life. What about the others? Why others die instantly but our US heroes get to cry and share their last words to make us feel empathy? Why our Cap gets shot once but is not blown like many others? So that he can die dramatically.
I'm not saying they should've shown ALL enemies context and motives too, but maybe give some depth to germans. Not all germans during war were damned nazis. The movie is long enough to show both sides of a fight (well, things are more complex than 2 sides fighting and that's my point).
War is not winning or losing, war is going to a field to fight mostly for political problems everything masked as a "I'm doing this for my family, for my country and for God". If my father/brother/grandfather/cousin/son would have fought in any war of course i wouldn't consider him a murderer, but not a hero neither. I would consider him/her as an unfortunate guy who has to live one of the shittiest experiences "in the name of his Country".
I'll repeat it again, i don't know what Spielberg's intention was, but the depict of US soldiers in contrast with the enemy, the final (literally the last) american flag scene and the poor oldie Ryan in the cemetery leans my opiniom toward considering this a patriotic film with superb visuals but more of the same US pride war movies previously seen.
Thoughts?
Yeah, my english isn't the best. I'm aware of that and it's a work in progress. Don't be rude, please :)
EDIT: I forgot to add the moment where the aircraft support shows up in the specific convenient moment. It felt like "here are my brothers, here's my people rescuing us" rather than "Holy fuck i almost died! Fuck! Fuck I'm saved!". The colors of the aircraft felt more like a patriotic element and not to simply show those are americans.
r/Movie_Club • u/postcg • Jul 24 '15
I think it would be cool if these could line up with any of the actors/actresses/directors/etc. Just a thought.
r/Movie_Club • u/The_Social_Introvert • Dec 05 '17
Hi everyone
The Irishman will mark the fourth time director Martin Scorsese has made an Italian Mafia movie starring Robert De Niro in a major role. I wanted to take this opportunity to have a look at Scorsese’s gangster pictures through the years, and explore The Irishman’s relationship with the previous films. Do we really need another mafia film? What can the upcoming crime film add to Scorsese’s résumé that hasn’t already been done?
My personal hope is that The Irishman is more thought provoking than the previous 3 films. The most interesting thing for me is the 'old man/aging gangster' aspect about Frank Sheeran looking back on his life. It ties nicely with mean Streets being about lowlife degenerates, Goodfellas about middle-of-the-pack hoods, and Casino about made men. This whole thing comes full circle with the aged men looking back on their lives.
I made the below video briefly looking at the relationship between the 3 main gangster movies that Scorsese has done, and what potentially The Irishman could bring to the table, validating its existence:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=O2qnx_S0MTQ
I'd be happy to hear your thoughts and criticisms.
If you prefer to read instead of watching the video, I wrote it up here:
It must say something about how good Martin Scorsese’s mafia movies are when this director of over 25 feature length films is often only remembered by some as a director of mob flicks. In reality he has only made 3, with one more on the way – The Irishman. I wanted to have a look at the upcoming picture, and see how it could relate to Scorsese’s crime resume, and what, if anything, it could add to a group of movies that already have said so much.
In 1973, up and coming director Scorsese cemented himself as someone to watch with the visceral and fierce crime film Mean Streets, about a duo of hoodlums growing up in Little Italy, where Scorsese himself lived his youth in. What we saw on screen had an improvisational feel to it, like all the mundane conversations, date nights and bar fights were really happening, and we just happened to be there. But the chaos was being puppeteer by a future master, suggested by the way this film was shot and edited. Rock n Roll, long takes, ultraviolence and whip pans were just some of the few elements, in addition to themes of machismo and catholic guilt, that would go on to be staple Scorsese trademarks. The film dealt with degenerates and scumbags, and yet they were human. In some cases they were even charismatic, their lifestyle inviting, but ultimately Scorsese would pull the plug on this romantic fantasy that was the mob way of life, and unleash chaos in the final third of the movie.
The film had a dirty feel…gritty and rough around the edges. It had a feel of something trying to burst out and move away from the piss-stained and littered sidewalks, trying to be something different and to stand out, much like the main character and the man behind the camera. Scorsese had poured personal dilemmas and his own internal conflicts into this movie, and it been suggested that we could see the main character as Scorsese himself in his earlier days. Something interesting to note was the movie’s lack of plot. If you had to explain what happens in the movie in a couple of sentences, what would you say? It’s difficult. Scorsese has said that he does not pay a great deal of attention to plot, in fact he claims The Departed made in 2006 is the first movie he ever made with a plot. Rather his attention is fixated on character. And Mean Streets, despite being directed by a no name starring no names on a shoe string budget, has great characters. Characters that feel real. Characters who don’t move or act for the sake of the plot or sequences of events, but rather their emotions and interactions are the centrepiece of the film, a core element without which Mean Streets doesn’t exist. With this movie, it isn’t ‘such and such happens’, then ‘such and such happens’ and because ‘such and such happens’ ‘such and such happens’. Cause and effect is thrown out the window, replaced with an emphasis on what is said, what isn’t said, what is meant, what is this character feeling, how is this character changing, if you put these two characters in a room together and lock the door, what will happen? When the characters are strong enough as they are in Mean Streets, who needs a plot? Let the characters take it away.
The style in which Scorsese directed Mean Streets, the beautiful marriage of music and images, coarse and jagged though admirable, was perfected by the time he revisited that world with the incredible Goodfellas. Again, the mob life feels entrancing and inviting, and again it is shown to be ruthless and ultimately not rewarding. A generation who had grown up on gangster films showcasing mobsters as operatic and tragic figures, almost samurai like, were given a slap to the face and a gun to the head with the captivating but punishing 1990 picture. Nowhere is the essence of this best summarised than Henry Hill’s chuffed explanation as to why the gangster Tommy DeVito being ‘made’ was such a great thing. The movie lures you in through a combination of great acting, a blissful soundtrack and a genuine sense of happiness for these crooks – no matter what they are, and the things they’ve done, in this moment in time we feel their joy. And then – bang. Out of nowhere Tommy is 'whacked'. There’s your gangster life. See yourself out.
Despite the obvious dangerous nature of the mob world, we can’t help but feel seduced at the lifestyle, reconstructed so brilliantly by Scorsese. When Henry Hill peers down from his windows at these mobsters, as an asthma-stricken and bedroom confined Scorsese must have once done atop the streets of Little Italy, we are right there with him, hopping along with him on this doomed fairy-tale. Henry represents us, the ever outsider, looking in on this world but never really fitting in. He’s unable, given his bloodline, but disregarding that Henry is closer to us than we are to any of the rest of the characters. He shares our bemusement when Tommy, after beating a man almost to death, is worried that he spilled blood on floor of the club owned by Henry, or when the crew of gangsters show more concern about digging a hole to throw a murdered bartender in, as opposed to actually murdering him in the first place.
Goodfellas is easier to be immersed into than Mean Streets, not just because of the improvement of the craft, but because of this character of Henry, who acts as our window into this world where bloodshed is an everyday occurrence. And like Mean Streets, though things seems to not be so bad on the whole, the veil is lifted towards the end of the film. Paranoid, tense, and anxious are just a few of the ways to describe Henry in the last half an hour of the film, and the kinetic and coked-up style the film goes in, accelerating to his inevitable downfall, and the ironic ending. Now the fairy-tale is over, he can’t stop thinking about the life, ignorant to the fact that he should be happy to be alive, not spend his time complaining about egg-noodle and ketchup.
The wiseguys in this film are of a different calibre to Mean Streets, a step up. Where those guys were merely hoodlums, street thugs with dead end prospects, the characters in Goodfellas are a step up. They are the money earners, the guys sticking their head out of the water trying to avoid jail time, a bullet to the head, in the hope of being made and officially recognised as part of a crime syndicate. What about those who are actually in a crime syndicate then?
Enter Casino. These guys were certified Mafioso. The bosses. Pretty much as high as you could go, the very people who would be in charge of the level of mobsters in Goodfellas. The income is better, the power more influential, the stakes higher…but the mistakes made by those in the film are just as prevalent as the low level thugs of the previous films, and in the end it topples an entire empire. The technique and style that was used for Casino was very similar to Scorsese’s 1990 Oscar nominated film, which drew criticism from critics at the time, claiming the film was basically Goodfellas in Las Vegas. With that in mind, I think the film was quite symbolic in the sense that some of his favorite themes, mainly greed, are elevated and bought to the forefront. Henry is touching the waters in Goodfellas, sometimes just trying to stay alive, keep his sate constant, but here the primary characters much like Scorsese himself are indulging in their wants to the fullest. Scorsese was at the height of his power here, and it’s fitting that he makes a movie about the mob at their highest peak too. If the question in goodfellas is why would someone want to join the mob, and how does one do so, then the question in Casino is what happens once you’ve made it, and how on earth do you mess something like that up?
Scorsese said about Casino that it is “essentially having no plot, it’s all about character”, another link to the previous 2 movies. Though Goodfellas is almost unanimously touted as the better film, Casino is not to be dismissed. In fact it touches on things that its predecessor does not. As stated the theme of greed is front and centre, and even arguably the greed of the film-makers and studios for entering this world again after only 5 years. There’s something about the film the screams excess, indulgence and in relation to the development of the characters’ lives, the false hope, the dangling bait that is the American dream. Yes, I always felt that Casino had a tragic element to it. It’s difficult to put the finger on what exactly gets me to feel this way – perhaps it’s the church choir the movie’s opening titles are accompanied with, perhaps its seeing these characters waste away such an amazing gift in life as effortlessly as they received it in the first place, or perhaps it’s just the fact that the mob life, on screen at least, always seems to be accompanied by a sense of tragedy full stop. Crime and cinema has always been fascinatingly linked, going back to what was one of the first narrative films ever made with The Great Train Robbery, which is homage at the end of Goodfellas. What is it about these characters, this way of live that is so inviting, attractive and appealing? I’m in no way educated enough to properly articulate just what appeals to me about these kind of films, but perhaps it is this screen, this camera, this barrier which separates us from the violence and death, giving us peace of mind and allowing us to be entertained, to enter a world of crime without consequences for ourselves, a bit like how going on a rollercoaster ride is like experiencing the thrill of a car crash without the danger, or watching a serial killer movie for the excitement without the fear of death that would accompany actually being stalked.
Either way, what is ultimately tragic, for me at least, is that Casino was the last of the great American crime movies. Yes there were some good ones that came after, like Donnie Brasco or American Gangster, but nothing quite touched the level of Casino. Scorsese never made a film as good as, De Niro or Pesci never made a film as good as. The genre came to an abrupt close, with most modern crime films like Gangster Squad coming and going without any real significance. With mainstream movies adjusting to become politically correct, it doesn’t seem the gangster genre is even welcome on the big screen anymore.
This is why The Irishman is so important to me. It’s another film, despite the cast and director, that never really got to the big screen, instead being produced by the streaming service Netflix. But this film, for me, will act as the curtain closer, the swansong of a genre that didn’t really get one before it died. It becomes even more perfect that the golden generation of De Niro, Pesci and Keitel will return, and Al Pacino and Marty will work together for the first time. The old guard will all slip back into Mafioso roles, whilst newcomer Pacino will instead play the outside Jimmy Hoffa, a fitting placement given his detachment to Scorsese compared to the rest of the cast.
It’s a movie that will hopefully be the most mature and though provoking of the four films, focusing on the days after the heyday. What happened to Charlie after the attack on him and his friend Johnny Boy at the end of Mean Streets? What happened after Henry closed the door of his cheap home off a construction site in the middle of nowhere at the end of Goodfellas. Those periods in the men’s lives were never explored, but here with the life of Frank Sheeran we will take a trip down memory lane with him through the highs and lows. But after the business successes and the flourishing mob connections, eventually everyone he would come to know such as Russell Buffalino and Angelo Bruno would die, and we’d be left with a frail old man looking back on his life, a life in which he is supposed to have murdered over 2 dozen people. This, surely, will be where the heart of Scorsese’s film will be. Sheeran’s real life confession was prompted by a wish for attornment for his sins, which harks back to our protagonist Charlie in Mean Streets, and his juggling of his religious dilemma and his criminal lifestyle. We had the lowlife thugs, we had the middle of the park hoods, we had the bosses of bosses, and now we have the film centred on aging, elderly gangsters, past their primes looking back at the glory days of their zeniths. It’s only fitting then, that a selection of actors and a director known for these kind of movies will portray these characters, all of whom which are also past their prime and thus Scorsese’s gangster resume comes full circle.