Hey everyone, I’m looking to pick up a pair of Scarpa Mont Blanc Pro GTX or Scarpa Manta Tech GTX boots (specifically considering a pair in EU 42.5 / MP 27.5) for alpine use with crampons, and I’d love some feedback on which model and size would work best for me—or if EU 42.5 will be way too long.
My measured foot length is 255 mm (MP 25.5), and I have a high instep and slightly wider forefoot. I actually wore a pair of Scarpa mountaineering boots from a rental kit on Ben Nevis once and they fit me amazingly well, though I unfortunately don't remember what size they were. I plan to wear Injinji liner socks paired with thick merino wool mountaineering socks, and I strongly prefer generous toe room for warmth and comfort during descents.
For reference, in my current footwear I comfortably wear a New Balance Hierro v9 in EU 43 (MP 27.5, standard D width, with generous toe room) and a Decathlon Forclaz MT500 in EU 42 (MP 26.5, wide 3.0 fit). In Loake Aquarius boots (G-fit), UK 7 (approx. MP 25.8) was way too tight across the instep, so I had to size up to UK 7.5 (approx. MP 26.3) to wear them comfortably with thick socks.
Would EU 42.5 (MP 27.5) work to accommodate my high instep and double socks, or would that 20 mm extra length cause too much heel slip? Also, does either the Mont Blanc Pro or Manta Tech fit a higher instep/wider forefoot better? Any insights would be appreciated!