r/MorbidPodcast • • Nov 29 '23 Mindblown Regret Heartwarming

A diagram of how John Jones was stuck upside down in Nutty Putty Cave for 27 hours in a cave before passing away.

Post image
4.2k Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Mar 22 '23 Bravo

An honest critique of the current state of a once thrilling and captivating podcast. Morbid is sinking and needs help. Here's why:

923 Upvotes

Just to be clear before I start; this is not a troll post. This is not me trying to be a jerk. This is an honest and real critique of how a once captivating hour of story telling has turned into a messy, amateurish, low grade copy of The View. Long time listener, first time poster who is hoping someone over at Wondery sees this and is smart enough to look into it to protect their investment.

I know it is well known that Ash and Alaina have stopped reading this subreddit. Maybe it's time they come back and take their listeners criticism a little more seriously. I cannot see the listener base continuing to grow with it's current state of "content." What was once a race to my car in the morning to hear the next gripping story of True Crime, has turned into a daily quest to find a replacement podcast. Here are my reasons why:

1. Alaina

Something has changed with Alaina. I use to think of her as this super awesome autopsy technician who couldn't wait to get home and sit behind her computer at night in the light of candles, crafting well constructed stories of true crime with mixes of her expertise, to fuel the tales of real life nightmares. Ash was great too, but Alaina WAS Morbid. I used to be "slightly" let down when it was Ash's turn to lead an episode. Nothing against Ash, I just always thought of Alaina as the brains behind Morbid while appreciating Ash chiming in with her fun quirky comments. Fast Forward to NOW...that has changed. Ash knows how to move the story along. Alaina sits there and constantly complains, giving off a vibe of having added nothing to the story.

Here are the things she is doing that is hurting the podcast:

- Degrading every single murderer - We get it, these are bad people. Are they disgusting, pieces of shit, pimple faced, puddles of puke, loser, scumbag, idiots? I'm sure they are, but do we need to be reminded of it 25 times every story? We get it. She repeats this stuff over and over and over...often in the same episode. Then... every victim is the best person on this earth. They are all ALWAYS the kindest, smartest, loving person ever born. How do you know? I get it, it sucks they fell victim to a serial killer, but we don't need 20 minutes on how they would rival Mother Theresa.

- Negative Nancy - Everything sucks, Disney sucks, I hate everything, yada yada yada. I WANT to LIKE her. She is going from being this awesome, interesting, intelligent person to being someone I want to avoid at all cost. A host of a show is supposed to ATTRACT an audience, not push them away.

2. Going Off Topic

Let me start by saying it is OK to have some chit chat at the beginning of the episode. I like getting little tidbits of their "off the air" life. I like hearing about their families and interests....but it is starting to get excessive. I mean like "holy shit" excessive. The show is turning into The View. The off topic banter is being messily woven in and out of the main story at an alarmingly increased rate. It is becoming almost impossible to follow the story.

- Most Episodes I am 25+ minutes in and don't even know what is happening - This isn't a one time complaint. This is starting to become every episode. One moment we are talking about finding a body with multiple stab wounds, then the next moment we are talking about someone getting caught cheating on BRAVO TV for 10 minutes. It is messy. It is disengaging. It is infuriating. I find myself rewinding episodes back 5 minutes because I think I might have drifted off my attention and missed something. Then I realize I didn't. It's just a jumbled messy flow to the story. Everyone that is listening to this podcast is a fan of true crime, but not everyone that listens to this podcast is a fan of some reality show on Bravo TV. They are losing the audiences attention. Imagine watching an NFL Football game and after a few plays, out of nowhere, right in the middle of an exciting play, the quarterback turned to the camera randomly and started talking about his favorite baking recipes for 10 minutes. It's ruining the flow of the story.

3. Special Guest

What is so special about these guest? What do they have to do with the story? 99% of the time, NOTHING. It is annoying. They devalue your show....unless...and hear me out...they ACTUALLY have something to do with the story. Special guest should be...I don't know....SPECIAL?! Maybe bring on a detective that worked on the case, a survivor of the murderer, an author of a book that made the case famous. THINK. What if I had a podcast that talked about Disney movies and my special guest was the creator of Red Bull energy drink. There's no reason for it.

4. Ruining The Story Flow

Alaina has this habit of telling you the outcome of a major plot point in the beginning of a story instead of when it actually happens. There has been quite a few episodes where within the first 10 minutes of the story she says something like "Don't worry, this victim survived" or "They never solved this case."

- I don't want to know that before I even hear what happened- Wouldn't it be more a more compelling story to learn that after all the shit the victim went through, they actually survived? I don't want to know that up front. It removes all emotional impact to the victims story. Wouldn't it be more of a "WFT!!" moment to learn that the killer is still out there and has avoided being captured to this day, instead of knowing that at the beginning of the story? They are removing the emotional impact of their own story-telling. We get it, these are real people with sad stories and NOT just created for our entertainment... but this is what your podcast is about. Real stories. Real people. Real horror. They are cheapening the actual "TRUE CRIME" of the story by not leaving the listener with a gut punch that makes us realize that this is real and horrible and we need to take better precautions so this has less of a chance of happening again.

- Not telling details of the story because it involves kids or is too brutal. Hey, here is a story about 3 kids that were murdered, only we aren't going to tell you anything about it because I don't like kids being murdered. Ok, cool. Then maybe don't tell this story. Maybe this story isn't for you. If I couldn't stomach and didn't want to support products with child labor issues, I wouldn't open a Nike shoe store. If I don't agree with add preservatives and chemicals into my food, I wouldn't open up a junk food store.

5. Hiring Researchers For Stories and multiple new podcasts

It has been mentioned that they hired someone (David?) to research material for stories. The Morbid we all got hooked on was the product of Alaina and Ash crafting the stories from their own personality. Once they went to Wondery they started taking on other podcasts and their time was spread out over several projects. Bad move if you ask me.

- Most times I feel like the girls are hearing this story for the first time, or have quickly browsed the notes and are just reading from a script they did not write themselves. Maybe I'm wrong, but you can definitely tell that the writing has taken a nose dive. There is a major difference in crafting a story from your own research versus telling a story based on someone else's research. Often times the "heart" is just not there. The little tidbits and nuances you gather from putting the story together yourself just is what makes the story your own. Making these stories their own was what MORBID once was and the reason they drew in listeners. Listeners were sucked into Alaina's way of telling the story. Now it feels like Alaina and Ash are telling someone else's story.

- All these new podcasts. I'll admit I've only listened to their horror review podcast SCREAM! I love horror movies and I love reviews of horror movies. This particular podcast is not very good. There is very little flow. Once again, I'm sure I sound negative here, but I am not trying to be. It just seems like they traded in 1 Amazing podcast for 5 mediocre podcasts. Time is valuable and it is obviously being spread too thin.

6. Quality of Listener Tales

Listener Tales were always a much needed "break" from the horrific stories being told through their regular episodes. They were a chance to "breathe" and a way to connect on a more personal level with their audience. Often times giving the listeners the feeling of being a part of the community. The only problem is that the quality of the listener tales turned from really cool stories to utter bullshit.

- Listener Tales started to sound like fake stories people submitted just to get on the air. The stories began as mini tales of crazy and interesting experiences from their listeners that were probably the reason the listener had interest in Morbid's material in the first place. Over time the stories felt like they were made up and complete bull shit. Ash and Alaina had to play nice and made it clear they believed every single thing that happened without even questioning some ridiculous claims. They were like "oh man, it must have been crazy seeing 3 ghost clowns in your room. I would have moved" instead of skipping over the story altogether because the reality of 3 ghost clowns being in someone's room is probably close to zero.

- Limiting listener tales to once a month. This is good. They need to scan these listener stories for ones that actually make for good story telling and use ONLY those. Skip over the ones that sound like a 10 year old made it up on the spot just to get on the podcast.

In conclusion:

Like I said when I started this post, I am not writing this to be mean. I am not trolling the podcast. I an genuinely concerned about the quality of the podcast AS I am a huge fan of the show. The quality of the "current state" of how Morbid is presented is not strong enough to grow the listener base. It's just not. The story telling isn't strong enough to set Morbid apart from other True Crime podcast. Maybe less is good. Less off topic discussion. Less non relevant special guest. Less of having other people research and craft your stories. Less side project podcasts.

Also, I have grown to look forward to episodes where Ash tells the story. She has definitely stepped up and can tell a good story. I think by cutting down on some of the items I brushed on in this post, Morbid can ONCE AGAIN become a focused, enthralling leader in the world of True Crime podcast. But in its current state, Morbid needs help.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Jul 18 '22

*Sigh

Post image
753 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Oct 12 '22

Even though they are frustrating and this sub is a mixed bag, Ash looks nice.

Post image
743 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Mar 22 '21

Accurate af

Post image
690 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Dec 24 '22

me walking into this sub for the first time thinking we were all here bc we’re fans of morbid

662 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Nov 17 '23

Congrats to Ash! What do we think of her wedding dress?

Post image
661 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Dec 02 '23

HOSTS I’m catching up on Morbid and……. What’s up with Alaina?

529 Upvotes

To start, my intention in this post is to not come off as rude/mean towards Alaina. I enjoy this podcast, for the most part.

I’ve been listening to Morbid since 2019. I loved the way the girls told the story, discussed the cases and weren’t afraid to use curse words. Now, I know for some that might seem strange, but it always annoyed me whenever I would listen to a podcast and they would censor a curse word. Like, you have no problem describing in graphic detail how someone was horrifically murdered, but god forbid you say “fuck”.

Anyways, I started a new job sometime ago, and I couldn’t listen to the podcast as much as I used to. Now, I’m finally able to catch up and Alaina seems different to me.

I’ve been noticing for a while that her attitude in the show seems different. I’ll list them.

1: Judgment

My God will Alaina judge the shit out of anyone and everything. Nothing is off limits! The number one thing she passes judgment on is parenting. If you are not worshipping the ground your children walk on, Alaina will be quick to say, “that’s insane to me!”. Now, there are parents on the show that rightfully deserve to be judged, but she’s inserting her own parenting beliefs into the show and it’s annoying. I’ve listened to episodes where she’s talked about her fertility struggles before the twins, and I’m so happy she has her 3 little girls! But it seems that with more recent episodes, she critiquing so many parents. I’m just waiting for the moment when Ash is telling a story and she mentions that a 7 year old had to make his own bowl of cereal for breakfast. I can fully see Alaina responding with, “are you serious!? Why would a 7 year make their own cereal? I cannot imagine my girls making their own cereal especially if John and I are in the home! That’s sinister!”

2: Her catchphrase, “I was just about to say that”.

Were you Alaina? Were you really about to say that? You just know everything? You caught on to that small detail so quickly? You were 5 steps ahead of everyone else in this case you supposedly never heard of? That phrase is starting to become my pet peeve. She says it in almost every story Ash tells. It just comes off at arrogant.

3: Laughing at Ash

I think her laughing at Ash is not as prominent as it used to be because Ash knows how to catch herself and joke about it, but holy shit! If Ash so much as mispronounces anything it’s followed by Alaina laughing about it. It was funny the first few times, but now it’s annoying. Especially since Alaina has messed up saying words, and Ash doesn’t call her out on it. Just move on with the story. Ash mixing the words “Murder” and “Homicide” together to say “Murdicide” should not be 5 minutes of laughing and Alaina repeatedly saying, “OMG that was horrible”.

4: Applying her own life to the cases

If Alaina can’t relate to something in the story, she is quick to point it out. Oh, someone was murdered in their home and their neighbors didn’t know them very well or hear anything? Alaina can’t relate. She knows all of her neighbors! They have breakfast, lunch, and dinner every Monday and Thursday. Also, she can hear everything in her neighbors homes because that’s how much they know each other!!! Oh, a mom in the story took a 20 minute shower while her kids were eating lunch? Nope, Alaina can’t relate. As a mother she would never take a shower while her kids were awake and at home. She would only shower when they are asleep or at school!! Oh, this couple has a bad marriage and sleep in separate rooms? Alaina can’t relate. Her marriage to John is amazing and she couldn’t imagine being married to someone like. Like guys, she can’t even imagine!!! Oh, this mother in the story treats her children terribly? Shame. Alaina can’t relate. Her mother gave her 1000 kisses every night before bed and told her how much she loved her everyday. Now, Alaina does that to her children and she could not imagine if every parent didn’t do that!!

I still like the podcast, but find myself liking the cases Ash tells more. Just my two cents.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Oct 26 '22

Mom shaming

489 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel genuinely sad inside when alaina mom shames? My kids go to sleepovers and play outside. I work a lot because I have no other choice. Sometimes I get home from work but I have to be alone for a while and my kids overwhelm me….I eventually push through but the “what mom doesn’t want to see their kids when they get home” bit really made me feel sad. So just so everyone else knows…. If you have sensory overload and need to be alone after work, you’re definitely not raising a serial killer. The mom shaming really has to stop.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Mar 03 '22

HUMOR Murderous husbands explaining their wives’ disappearances

Post image
450 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Aug 09 '24

HOSTS Just found out Ash’s husband is trans!

421 Upvotes

Hello weirdos! I’m new to the sub, but started listening about a year ago. I’m listening to some older episodes where Ash is joking about being gay, but I had only ever heard about Drew!

I was confused/worried for a second because I was like ‘oh no did she just reverse come out for some Man??’ Then come to find out they were together before Drew came out, and then got back together at a point!! This made me unreasonably happy!! I’m a trans man, and it’s so awesome to know one of my favorite creators not only supports trans rights, but has first hand personal experience on what it is like to love a trans person. Very sweet!!


r/MorbidPodcast • • Jun 24 '23

PERSPECTIVE Please don’t introduce your children to true crime early on

401 Upvotes

Back in the day my mom and I use to watch “I Survived…” (iykyk) and other true crime shows as “bonding”. It was nice to be with my mom but I was terrified to live my life once I started my first job and left for college. Nobody talks about the negative impact true crime has on developing minds, especially when you only hear the bad news that “could happen to anyone” even if you “do everything right”.

Sincerely, a listener and elementary teacher


r/MorbidPodcast • • Mar 23 '23

CRITICISM mood recently

Post image
392 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Jun 16 '23

It's Official. I'm Done with Morbid.

379 Upvotes

I’ve made it no secret that I’ve begun to dislike their latest podcasts, but the one I listened to today – “The Tragic Murder of Grace Millane” – and I’m officially done.

Their take on the justice system is appalling. This specific case took place in New Zealand, a country with a justice more like the United States’ than it is different. Both Ash and Alaina seemed to take issue with the fact that the defense for the murderer, Jesse Kempson, took the position that the murder happened accidentally during consensual sex consisting of BDSM. Is it tasteful? No, not particularly. However, what is even more distasteful is the idea that someone doesn’t have the right to the best defense possible against their crime.

Let me be clear here and tell you that I do not condone Kempson’s actions. But as someone who is interested and savvy with both criminal justice and true crime, I know that everyone deserves the right to defend themselves in a court of law and is innocent until proven guilty. Again, New Zealand’s legal system is not that much different than the legal system here in the U.S.

The idea that they are against a defense strategy, to the point of pinning a petition against the defense in their show notes and social media accounts, is appalling. There are times when BDSM goes too far, and someone is seriously hurt or killed. It is rare, but it does happen. Now, New Zealand can do what they want, but Ash and Alaina are in the U.S. and shouldn’t at all believe they can get involved in New Zealand’s affair and push their American-bred ideas onto another country.

Millane was interested in BDSM, and had this been an isolated incident with Kempson, the defense could have worked. What if it had been an accident, truly? It may suck that Millane’s sexual interests and proclivities were discussed in the courtroom, but how else is the defense supposed to prove that their defense is valid and their client not guilty of intentional homicide?

FURTHER, the fact that Ash (who I believe was narrating the story) was completely ignorant to New Zealand’s laws, as she didn’t once mention that the reason Kempson’s name was originally suppressed by the authorities in New Zealand is because New Zealand allows for name suppression and that even though Kempson was denied name suppression, his defense team appealed the decision which granted him an automatic 20-day period of name suppression. New Zealand is not like the United States where there are little to no protections for a defendant over the age of 18; we do not censor names.

So, how are you going to have a problem or be ignorant of one of New Zealand’s legal system intricacies, yet somehow petition for another one? Girl, no. GIRLS, no. Bye.

Do some research into the case you’re narrating, and I mean DO THE RESEARCH of the time AND LOCATION in which the case took place.

I’m done. I’m out. I know they’ll never see this, but I had to vent this out before I wrote them off for good.

Want a podcast recommendation that circumvents all the problems listed above? Generation Why by Wondery. They can simply list the facts in the case and give explanations of legal proceedings so that you can understand all that goes into a case.

JFC. These girls need to grow up and be taken off the air. Enough is enough.

/rant.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Jul 30 '25

They’re moving to Sirius

Post image
378 Upvotes

r/MorbidPodcast • • Feb 19 '21

Morbid for Middle People?

378 Upvotes

Curious if anyone shares the same opinion as me - personally I do not view myself as a superfan or a harsh critic. I defiantly consume a lot of Morbid media and genuinely enjoy the girls commentary on cases it is why I choose to listen to Morbid as opposed to other more clinical true crime podcasts. With listening to Morbid I understand that

A) There are ads as it is a service that is free

B) There is also not a set schedule and it is just a nice surprise to see a new episode

C) There is implicit bias in all reporting / journalism

D) Added commentary is solely spoken from their perspectives/ opinions and are not facts of the case, akin to speaking to a friend

E) That listening to an hour long podcast does not mean that I understand the case 100% and if it is important to have every detail I must do further research as one source is never adequate

F) That A/A have made errors and will continue to as they are human - not saying that they should not be held accountable for those errors but they will happen

G) That A/A are not responsible for the acts of their fanbase ( Although I personally believe that the horrific attacks from fans should have been called out and shut down to the best of their abilities and it is disappointing that they did not comment on that )

H) That I can stop listening at any point in time - I personally do not listen to the listener tales episodes as they aren't for me

The biggest disappointment in this sub for me is the lack of middle ground, every single post has an "us" vs "them" downvote / comment fight in it.... hopefully this post brings forward others who can relate or at least a civil discussion! Also respect to those affected by the true crime cases spoken about is paramount.

Edit - I personally do not think that the patreon is worth the cost because there are very few extra cases, it may be worth the cost if you really dont like the ads though


r/MorbidPodcast • • Nov 11 '22

Announcement I know this is going to ruffle some feathers, but y'all have gotta calm down.

367 Upvotes

Update; thank y'all so much for the support. Makes me feel like we really could make this into something great. 🥲🖤

Hey folks.

I know a lot of people are disappointed offended and outraged with the podcast and the hosts, particularly Alaina, but there's too much mocking on all sides and it's getting gross. This includes commenters, OP's, and the Morbid hosts. The making fun people, all people, needs to stop. Feel free to discuss and state your disappointment or love to your heart's content. You are all entitled to your opinion and you are free to share it. But, I have been seeing a lot of just plain rude comments. Though they are veiled with sarcasm they're still just petty and immature and they litter this sub. They mar any real discussion or efforts towards positive change that people visiting here might be trying to make.

I would also like to encourage people to state their feelings as their own and not as statements. Example: "Alaina is a bad writer who enjoys victim blaming and setting her fan's money on fire when's she's supposed to be working for us." Your feelings and personal determinations aren't verified facts, even if many people agree with you. A better phrasing would be "I feel/think Alaina is X, Y, and Z because of A, B, and C."

We aren't going to be a sub where people tear individuals down everyday in the comments of every post because it tickles the masses. Being rude isn't going to fix anything. Speak your mind and criticize, critique, vent, say how you feel, but be civil.

I know you're not going to like reading this and I don't like typing it. I really don't want to remove every sarcastic comment where people are having fun with other visitors, but if it's continuously at someone else's expense, I will.

Lastly, I know people are tired of seeing unhappy posts criticisms and complaining² posts, but please keep in mind that most of the time those people are relatively new. The disappointed are thrilled to finally have a voice online, and the contented fans are probably shocked and bummed out to see this sub's amount of criticism and complaints. Both are allowed to talk about how they feel. I know the regulars are banging their heads against the wall at this point, but alas, c'est Reddit mon ami.

Much love from the least fun mod,

-Marbles

sry 4 any misstakes i cant gramer good at nite.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Jan 13 '21

He’s Drew now

360 Upvotes

The guy formerly known as “Annie” is now Andrew or Drew for short. Just thought y’all should know


r/MorbidPodcast • • Sep 30 '25

APPRECIATION Made a thing

Post image
357 Upvotes

I am thinking about sending them to the girls...


r/MorbidPodcast • • Oct 21 '24

CRITICISM The Patreon Situation Explained (to the best of my ability)

350 Upvotes

If you are new to Morbid and/or new to this subreddit, you have probably noticed the intense polarization of a lot of the posts and comments here. Posts complaining about the podcast will get lots of upvotes and then posts complaining about the complaining will get just as many upvotes. In all of the chaos and confusion, you may have noticed references to the "Patreon situation" thrown around. This post is an attempt to explain the events in as straightforward a way as possible.

For full transparency, I was never a member of the Morbid Patreon. At the time I was a broke college student lol.

If you notice any factual errors in this post, please let me know so I can correct them.

Throughout this post, I will be referencing statistics from Morbid's Patreon. I have also linked Sinisterhood's Patreon statistics as well if you would like another true-crime podcast for comparison (especially since Morbid's statistics go private partially in 2018 and fully in 2020).

Morbids Patreon statistics:
https://graphtreon.com/creator/MorbidPodcast

Sinisterhood's Patreon statistics:
https://graphtreon.com/creator/sinisterhood

2018 - 2019

Morbid's Patreon was created back in May of 2018 with the oldest wayback machine archive being from December of 2019. Priced tiers ranged from $3 to $10 to $20 with the brief existence of a $2 tier. You can take a look at the teir listings from 2019 in the link below but here is a summary.

$3 +
_____________________________

- Our love and devotion

- Shout out on a future episode

- Access to patreon donor exclusive bonus episodes

- 20% discount on all merch

- Morbid themed goodies once a year

_____________________________

$10 +
_____________________________

- Access to patreon donor exclusive live Q&A with Alaina and Ash to be announced the week before.
_____________________________

$20
_____________________________

- An exclusive bonus gift
_____________________________

https://web.archive.org/web/20191219155138/https://www.patreon.com/MorbidPodcast

For most of 2018, Morbid's Patreon would remain under 100 members. Morbid's popularity saw increase in the following year and by the end of 2019, their Patreon had over 3,800 members.

In September of 2018, A&A made private their earnings on Patreon. At the time, the average revenue per-member was $7.65 a month. For the remainder of this post, we will continue to use this number as a likely average for their Patreon memberships even though it likely increased.

By the end of 2019, we can safely assume that A&A are making a little under $30,000 a month via Patreon.

2020 - 2021

In 2020, Morbid saw continued increase in popularity. By May of that year, the Patreon had almost doubled in size to over 7,000 members. Around that time, A&A disabled all metric transparency on Patreon. From this point forward, we will have to take A&A's word for how many members there were.

An additional tier was added at $50 and the perks were updated. Note that there was now a release schedule for the promised Patreon-exclusive episodes.

$3 +
_____________________________

- Our love and devotion

- Shout out on a future episode

- Lifetime access to Morbid Private Patreon Facebook group

- 1 bonus episode (30+mins) each month

- 1 monthly interactive & exclusive live stream

- Access to episode notes of every podcast

- Guaranteed pre-sale code for all Morbid live shows

_____________________________

$10 +
_____________________________

- 20% discount on all merch

- Exclusive access to Patreon Only merch

- Access to Patreon only Discord (private chatroom)

- Exclusive morbid news text/SMS updates

_____________________________

$20 +
_____________________________

- Exclusive access to Close Friends on Instagram

- Exclusive Morbid - Live 2020 Tour Laminate

- Guaranteed admission (or streaming access) to the Patreon only annual live event

- Private email address to ask questions, make suggestions and talk directly to Ash and Alaina

- Free annual numbered and limited exclusive Morbid commemorative merchandise item

- 2 free tickets each year to the Morbid live show of your choice

_____________________________

$50
_____________________________

- 2 free annual VIP upgrades to the Morbid live show of your choice!
_____________________________

https://web.archive.org/web/20201108133308/www.patreon.com/morbidpodcast

In 2020, complaints begin to surface regarding A&A failing to deliver on the promised content. A&A consistently failed to maintain the Patreon upload schedule, many of the Patreon episodes that were released were not even true-crime related, and much of the other promised rewards either never arrived or were extremely late. Here is a sample of the common complaints from 2020:

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/jut7vt/patreon_shoutouts/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/jte06r/patreon_gifts/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/kdpfig/looking_through_my_patreon_tier/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/resdoi/perks_overview/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/iyugti/new_network_no_patreon/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/ixnjwc/patreon_goodies/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/k7e5oz/patreon/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/eut0sv/patreon/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/j3gqff/bonus_patreon/

In early 2021, Morbid released an episode on Brittany Drexel. In the episode, Alaina repeatedly accused two of Drexel's teenage female friends via an unfounded conspiracy theory and subtly encouraged fans of the podcast to harass and dox them. In May of 2022 the actual murderer, a 62-yo male, was arrested and pled guilty. A&A never apologized. https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrimePodcasts/comments/lv754i/morbid_podcast_got_backlash_for_how_they/

As a result of the controversy, in 2021, this subreddit fractured into three subreddits. While the Patreon complaints continued, they were almost all posted on the MorbidForBadPeople subreddit. There is a rule against posting links to that subreddit so I will not be linking any of those posts.

Throughout this time period, any and all criticisms or complaints that were voiced to A&A through any of their official communication channels resulted in removal of the comments and being blocked.

2022 - Present

In January 2022, A&A switched all subscribers to a newly created $1 tier with less benefits in a very clear attempt to avoid delivering on the promised content that the higher tier members paid for:
 https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/scfsx4/patreon_is_now_1_for_everyonei_love_this/
In mid-2022, Morbid partnered with Wondery. Around this time in an announcement related to Patreon, A&A reference the Patreon and mention that it had over 35,000 members at the time.
https://imgur.com/a/morbid-wondery-announcement-NSmPjHP

In late 2022, most likely in an attempt to smooth things over, A&A announced that the earnings from the last three month of the year would be donated to a charity decided on via a community vote. The charity that won the vote was announced and the proceeds were said to have been donated though there is no actual receipt of this happening that is available to the public to my knowledge. I don't necessarily have reason to doubt that they donated the money though.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/yptyfu/for_those_who_are_still_patrons_did_they_ever/

In January of 2023, A&A deleted their Patreon all together. To my knowledge, no apology was ever issued to the members, some of who had spent up to $600 a year with nothing to show for it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MorbidPodcast/comments/z90687/morbid_is_removing_patreon/

At the height of their Patreon, A&A were easily making between $105,000 to $267,750 a month (or $1,260,000 to $3,213,000 a year) off of Patreon alone while delivering very little of what they promised. When fans voiced their concerns, they were met with silence and exclusion. The Morbid podcast Discord server and Facebook group were shut down because A&A didn't want to be accountable to their fans.

Many of the people you may call "hate listeners" on this sub are longtime fans who genuinely enjoy listening to Morbid, especially the pre-Wondery episodes, but truly feel betrayed and hurt by A&A. Telling them to "stop listening" if they don't like it is insensitive and is missing the point.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Apr 06 '22

PERSPECTIVE Does anyone else just actually listen to the podcast, and not think anything of the posting schedule, the way the post on IG, the way they talk, the way the tell the story…. Or is it just me?

347 Upvotes

Honestly- the podcast is free on Apple so you aren’t paying for anything. If all of this stuff makes you so mad you have to complain on Reddit, just stop listening.

It’s free- they owe us nothing. No schedule, no IG posts, no specific agenda. Yeah all those are great but society as a whole is so entitled and at the end of the day you aren’t paying a penny so the two cents just sounds snobby.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Feb 11 '24

Wild podcast listeners.

344 Upvotes

Some of yall bitch about the stupidest stuff. “I heard ash breathe in the mic”. Omg she’s breathing. How dreadful. “Alaina is a know it all”. Omg she is an educated woman…crazy! “I hate ads”. Omg they have to get paid some way morons! “Omg I hate the 1800 stories”. You do know crime has been around awhile? “I hate listener tales”. Maybe it isn’t for you. Shut the fuck up and move on. There are a million other podcasts you can listen to that will suit your needs but I’m pretty sure you will complain about them as well. If podcasts trigger you this much then just don’t listen. It’s quite simple.


r/MorbidPodcast • • Apr 07 '22 Regret

PERSPECTIVE Please remember victims when submitting your listener tales.

343 Upvotes

Im one of the lucky few victims that never had my name released to the press, but that doesn’t mean people don’t know my story. In the early 2010s I was kidnapped and raped and it made headline news in my state. My assailant killed himself by police suicide before I could get justice. Without going into a lot of details there’s multiple people in my story and their names are published.

My story has been told on multiple podcasts, without my permission. I would love nothing more for my story to have never been reported. The worst part, people are submitting my story to podcasts to read as “their hometown story” or “listener tail”.

My “sensational” story is not YOUR 10 minutes of fun on the treadmill. I am almost 10 years from my abduction but it’s still as fresh as the day it happened.

Next time you want to write in to a podcast about a “crazy” story you hear or want to binge your next true crime obsessed podcast, please remember the victims and our family. There are extreme fans that take it to the extent of Facebook messaging and adding people who were victims of my abusers just to find out more information or know who I am.

We’re often pushed to the side for glorification of our abusers and honestly it’s like being revictimized every time.


r/MorbidPodcast • • May 26 '23

What's with all the hate?

339 Upvotes

Seriously, guys, what's with the vitriol and disdain?

I love this podcast, and I adore Ash and Alaina. Sure, I get annoyed with stuff sometimes, but I get annoyed by my kids, my mom, my husband, my best friends, and so on. It's not the end of the world.

The Morbid Podcast is not your undisputed overlord. If you don't like it, you can just not listen, right?

I get it that if you've been listening since the beginning and perhaps even donated and now they've gone in a direction that doesn't suit you, it might be disappointing, but that's the nature of relationships. People change. If a relationship with a human went sideways, would you spend time on an online smear campaign?

I even saw a comment yesterday where a person suggested that Ash intentionally misprounces words because she thinks it's a personality quirk when really it's disgusting (or some other choice word).

Really, dude?

I honestly can't even believe I'm taking the time to make this post, but here I am because it bothers me so much to see so much hate in one small space. I'm sure I'll get downvoted into oblivion for this post but eh...

I just can't see any good reason for so much negativity.

ETA: Instead of replying to a bunch of different comments that essentially say the same thing, I'm going to clarify here:

I'm not suggesting that there aren't people who may have legit reasons to dislike Morbid. I'm hearing a lot about people who feel they were ripped off or straight up scammed. Full disclosure: I cannot find anything on a search of the web that supports that, but even if we take that at face value, the original point of my post stands. That point is as follows:

If you hate the podcast and the women who run it, why are you still here?

First of all, I see a lot of shi**y things on the internet and more specifically, social media. It took me seeing A LOT of comments and posts on this sub to want to take time out of my day to make a post about it. I just can't seem to grasp the idea of spending time in a place where you have nothing but negativity to spread.

I am not defending Morbid. I'm not defending A&A. I'm not a superfan. I like them, but I'm also very aware that I don't know them.

I'm defending people having a place to talk about things they enjoy without being constantly trolled and saturated with hate.

Second, I can't help but wonder if the same kinds of things would be said about the hosts if they were males. The vast majority of those above-mentioned shi**y things are directed at females with some amount of celebrity.

In closing, you can feel free to have a grudge. You should feel free to complain (note: I'm not even suggesting to never complain in this sub. I'm not complaining about complaints. I'm complaining about pure hatred). But again, if you have so much hatred towards this podcast and the women, why are you here harshing everyone's mellow?


r/MorbidPodcast • • Feb 06 '22

META New to this sub? Please read!

334 Upvotes

Edit: There is no set schedule for releasing episodes. The hosts announced once or twice that they release episodes on Tuesdays and Saturdays, but this seldom happens.

They have recently partnered with Wondery so it's possible they will stick to a guaranteed schedule in the future.

Welcome to r/morbidpodcast!

A tl;dr is located at the bottom.

We'd like to bring some awareness to any new subscribers or first-time visitors. Firstly, a few quick responses to frequent questions and regular posts seen in this sub.

  1. The hosts of Morbid did not create this sub and have mentioned that they avoid Reddit. Messages posted here that are addressed to them will probably not be seen.

  2. Drew is Ash's fiancé and is often referenced by his deadname in episodes prior to January 22, 2021. Ash has not changed partners.

  3. A&A have pulled a few episodes that needed re-recording and/or editing. That's why some go missing from time to time.

  4. Alaina is Ash's aunt. They occasionally call each other sisters because Ash moved in with her grandparents (Alaina's parents) when she was young. They spent some time growing up together.

  5. Some random tidbits often referenced: Ash used to be a hairstylist but quit when the pod and its Patreons grew significantly. She is engaged to Drew and they live together with their cats. Alaina is an autopsy technician part-time on the weekends. She was also able to cut back due to the pod's success. She raises her 3 daughters with her husband, John. She had a dog, Bailey/Bubba, but sadly she passed away in November 2021.

Please note the following to avoid the disappointment from diving in blind.

First and foremost, this is not a fan group. It's open to the public and the only thing that will get you "kicked out" is if you break any of the rules listed in the sidebar.

While this subreddit does have pro-Morbid leanings, please know that we absolutely allow critiques of the host's podcasting choices and episode content. You will most certainly see diverse posts in this sub and we regularly have posts that express disapproval or critiques of the host's methods and/or the podcast. Though upsetting to some, allowing this is important.

It is important because Reddit is one of the few places fans can come and discuss things that they would like to see improved. Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter have a very low tolerance for negative or even neutral remarks.

While the mods also love the podcast, its hosts, and want it to stay successful, we feel that it's important to offer a safe outlet and a place to speak up about concerns or issues. We will not take action against disagreements between visitors as long as they are respectful.

When people are simply stating observations or grievances, a hollow reply of "just don't listen" or anything rudely low-effort will be removed. It's important to know that even fans have critiques and would like to discuss ways to grow, or even just get something off their chest. Sometimes people don't want to stop listening because they still actually like the podcast. And that is totally okay.

If someone says something like, "God, I hate this pod so much. I think they're total shit." Then, yes, a "don't listen" is completely warranted. The hosts are human. They will mess up. Listeners are human. They will react. Say what you feel, but be civil.

Please report any hostility, repeat instigators, or any rule breaking you see. This includes something you think the mods might personally agree with. Feelings aside, we're here to ensure a safe space for everyone. Additionally, please don't post an entire monologue full of valid arguments towards your point and then include a personal attack. Even if your post is a serious topic with good intentions, if you tack on a directed attack on an individual, deserved or orherwise, It will still get removed. ::attack the topic, NOT the person.::

Lastly, know that complaints rarely do good. Posting complaints about an entire group of people (mega fans, mega haters) isn't going to change anyone's mind. If you want a change, be the change. Post what you thought of an episode, post how much you love whomever, post what you think is wrong, right, funny, whatever. Post what you like, but complaint posts aren't going to wake anyone up or cause a big epic change. Start the change with yourself.

With enough discussion that is reasonable and mature, perhaps positive change could touch the podcast, mega fans, mega haters, and even true crime as a whole.

tl;dr- Welcome! This sub isn't like social media groups you might be familiar with. Sometimes people here question or disagree with the podcast and/or hosts' methods. Please don't be dick. Ash's previously referenced SO has transition to Drew. Alaina is Ash's aunt. Some episodes have been pulled for revamping.

Keep it weird.