So after AT Nu Udra dropped and with savage omega being out for a little while I wanted to make a post basically just discussing how I feel about every weapon, this will mainly be based on my own experience and how the speedruns are looking. If I don’t have much to say about a certain weapons it either because I know too little or its power level is relatively known already.
Longsword: Has consistently been at the top of the rankings since the release of wilds, always one of the first weapons to release in speedruns. I wouldn’t say there’s anything wrong with LS but I would like to see a power shift from your 3 button spam combo to your helmbreaker since basically nobody uses it anymore.
Dual Blades: DB has felt incredibly strong since its last buffs and again has consistently been one of the top speedrunner picks. I can only see this weapon getting stronger due to elemental damage being so good in wilds especially with the newer monsters weve gotten, also your build is heavier on armour skills over weapon skills so you’ve got more wiggle room.
Charge Blade: I think this weapon has been the dynamic of every weapon since it’s always been one of the top runners however every time it seems to have changed its play style. Axe mode was SO strong when wilds first released, and now the meta has shifted towards your phials where you’re dumping them out one by one. I do hear some complaints about how CB plays in wilds, and although I think this is one of the best adaptations of CB I can see that there should be more focus on the blocking. Charge blade is so heavily reliant on weapon skills it can’t afford to run guard skills plus it’s shelling skills, this makes the weapon awkward to run with sometimes against block heavy monsters.
Sword and shield: SnS has more so been a very middle of the pack kind of weapon which is understandable but I still feel like it’s one of the weakest weapons by design and a lot of speedruns using SnS will use buffs to compensate for its lack of dps. Again I think a power shift is needed for its full rush combo like in world, like LS, most SnS gameplay is just spamming a combo on repeat using corrupted mantle.
Insect Glaive: What a nightmare this weapon is… I’m gonna be honest I feel bad for all IG players, the weapon just feels clunky when you’re not fully charged up and half of the time you’re not because you DPS relies on it. The choice is clear, give a huge power swap, makes its normal combos feel stronger, or even just shift that power into your Ariel attacks, also just making ways of getting essence more consistently would be nice. IG is still a really strong weapon but a majority of that comes from the one move it has to spam, leading to a really boring gameplay loop.
Switch Axe: Much like the glaive, Swaxe suffers from the same gameplay loop of dumping your big move on the monster over and over again. Swaxe is still a really strong weapon and you’ll see it with some really short clear times of speedruns, the problem is that the gameplay is interesting but also pretty bare bones. I’ll say it again but a power shift is probably the best thing for this weapon.
Hammer: I’ll keep it short and sweet but hammer is becoming sneaky good, with damage numbers high enough for a greatsword main to feel intimidated I’d say hammer is in a really good spot. I’d also say that hammer is one of the highest skill floor weapons in the game atm, it’s simple on the surface but holy hell you’ve gotta be good if you wanna maximise your output.
Hunting Horn: It’s crazy how good horn is in wilds, probably one of the best states it’s ever been in and can finally keep up with damage on its own and sometimes outperform. The only change I would make is for your offset attack, if you dodge cancel out of your offset animation you shouldn’t lose your offset, for a weapon with no counter attack after performing an offset it feels silly to punish the player like it’s actually worth using. You could even argue that offset melody should just be a button press like echo bubble but it’s not a very strong option so I’d go either way with it.
Lance: From what I can tell lance is doing ok, it’s not completely abysmal but it does seem to be one of the weaker weapons atm. Kind of sucks to see because lance is another one of those simpler weapons but it’s got a huge skill ceiling, you’ll see a lot of speedrunners rocking the usual corrupted mantle to compensate for damage. I think the damage on your normal combos is fine but as for your big counter strike I think a flat damage buff on that would be nice, I think more importantly tho lance needs ways to keep up with the monsters so possibly some movement tweaks? Lmk
Gun Lance: I don’t have much to say on GL but it’s another weapon that feels very strong, I know it was one of the best on the release of wilds but I haven’t kept up to date on it.
Light and Heavy Bowgun: I’ll keep these in the same spot because they’re mostly the same, spread ammo or elemental is mostly what you’ll be rocking on these two weapons. I’ll give the edge to LBG for solo speedruns but for Co-op speedruns HBG takes the win on that. The bow guns are oppressive as always like in most of the MH franchise but they find themselves in a much more humbling position in wilds I can’t quite put my finger on it. I think the numbers are fine and don’t need tweaking, however I would like to see the use of other ammo types like slicing and Wyverns fire, even cluster bomb builds would be cool to see. The biggest change would be for HBG, it’s offset attack feels mostly useless and contradicts the kind of playstyle you want, making it more fluid to go into would compensate for this but like HH it’s pretty weak so why would you want to use it anyways.
Bow: Pretty sure bow is a bit on the lower end of things nowadays, which sucks because it’s a really difficult weapon to use, practically being a glass cannon that isn’t exactly a cannon anymore? Jeez how far we’ve fallen. I think the dps on bow is actually fine but the main issue is because of the new weapon decoration system, bow needs to be able to slot in its spread ammo boost for maximum output and it simply just can’t afford to with so many skills in needs from constitution and stamina surge, to the shear war of weapon skills like ballistics, tetrad shot, coating functionality, elemental, critical boost (you get the idea). I’m not sure how you’d go about changing bow without changing the decoration system.
Greatsword: (my main) I’ve saved this one for last because obviously it’s my favourite weapon and I have a lot to say about it. I’ll start by saying this has been the funnest I’ve ever had playing Greatsword of any of the monster hunter games, offsets have been my favourite new feature so it’s no surprise Greatsword is still my main weapon of choice. The issues with Greatsword is that it’s been falling behind in the speedruns a lot, as big as Gs numbers are, they’re only that powerful if the monster you’re fighting has good hit zones. Greatsword and hammer probably have some of the biggest damage drop offs due to hitzones and can make a powerful weapon feel really inconsistent and weak. a LS player can hit a monster 5 times and get out of the way in about 2-3 seconds and deal about 300-400 damage, Greatsword can hit a monster once and deal a good 600 damage, so what’s the problem? Take that same scenario but instead you’re hitting a monsters leg or arm, LS might get about 100 less damage or so but Greatsword will have it’s damage drop from 600 to anywhere between 300-400 depending on the monster. Now as for the gameplay loop I feel like Greatsword has a good flow, however the main way you wanna play Greatsword isn’t the strongest way you can play it, much like swaxe, your best move is just sitting Infront of the monster and going max charge without using your brain, except… greatsword can’t really ignore damage without cancelling its attack of wearing a mantle. The best way you can play Greatsword is by being an offset machine and constantly toppling and ignoring a monster, obviously it’s very strong but offset attacks aren’t very powerful themselves so it’s more like you’re dealing decent damage but you’ve got a lot of empty space of you just doing nothing. For speedruns this matters a lot because the less consistent your weapon can be the more luck you have to rely on over skill, wilds has gotten too fast for some weapons to keep up with their old playstyle, Gs being one of them it can’t really run around and position itself like in previous titles. Start by tweaking hitzones, making slower weapons like Greatsword take less of a percentage off worse hitzones, change the damage output of offset attacks so that normal upswings with no offset deal less damage, but when countering a monster you deal much more significant damage. The extra damage obviously helps fit Greatswords playstyle and makes that downtime when you’re not attacking less punishing.
Welp there’s my rant, I probably didn’t discuss everything about every weapon but if I missed something lmk. How do you feel about your main weapon? Does it feel too strong? Too weak? (Without being bias of course)