This is just my opinion, but I'm on my second watch-through of the entire series, and there's something about Monk and Trudy's relationship that I've always struggled to fully buy into.
I completely understand that Monk was quirky before Trudy died and that his OCD and overall disorder became significantly worse after her death. I also have no doubt that he genuinely adored her. In the flashbacks, they absolutely come across as being very much in love.
What I struggle to understand is what initially attracted Trudy to him, particularly when they were so young.
Trudy was a beautiful, intelligent, sociable college student who enjoyed music and presumably had a fairly active social life. Monk himself has said he had no friends, that he never even liked music and that he didn't really have any defining interests. And presumably, she wasn't short of male admirers.
So what was it about a young man who seemingly had very little in common with her, socially or otherwise, that made her choose him?
If they'd met in their mid-to-late 30s (I'm around that age myself), I think I'd find the relationship a little easier to understand. But imagining a beautiful young college student with the world at her feet actively choosing someone who, at that age, doesn't seem to have many of the qualities or shared interests that would typically attract someone to a partner is where I struggle. It also seems as though she had to somewhat "babysit" him and his idiosyncrasies, even early on.
I know opposites attract, and obviously we only see snippets of their relationship, but I'd love to hear how other people interpret this. What do you think Trudy saw in Monk when they first met?