r/MoneylessFreeLabor • u/eli_ashe • Nov 05 '24
MFLS Theory What Is The Labor Economy, A Moneyless Free Labor Society
Money is a tool, nothing more or less. Money is a tool intended to provide a means for the distribution of goods and services within a society. All goods and services however are actually labor; money, in other words, is an overlay of the actual economy. At best it measures, directs, and distributes the labor that actually creates and distributes all the goods and services of a society.
Moneyless Free Labor Societies (MFLS) is to provide a guide or map firstly for the pragmatics of such a labor-based society, and secondarily for plausible methodologies for its implementation within the world we are currently living in. The principle claim, while undoubtedly controversial, is rather straightforward, so much so that an astute reader could likely derive much of what follows in Moneyless Free Labor Societies from the basic notions already laid out In The Synopsis see here, the Definitions Of Bioregions see here, and Contra Meritocracy see here, as short as they are:
People will work for the rewards of their labor, not just individually, but also collectively.
Among the difficulties involved in organizing a society is how to distribute the goods that one person creates that another does not. In the reductive case there is a solution that largely presents itself, and which ought to be understood as the principal solution that has been utilized throughout the overwhelming majority of the species’ history; rough familial sufficiency.
That is, if everyone in a family has the capacity to produce all the goods that they need to survive and indeed thrive, then there isn’t really much of a need for the trading of goods and services with others.
Understanding that generally historically this has entailed ‘subsistence farming’ as a way of life, and even within that modality of living, trading between farmers was common enough. Such was more of a bartering than a trading via the medium of monies, but nonetheless, the principle, theory and practice is fairly sound, as is demonstrable through the overwhelming majority of the species’ history. This historical point is worth expanding on in generalized terms, as in the current that sort of reality has largely been forgotten or obscured via the modern reality within which we are living.
Most people, throughout most of history, did not utilize money at all, or at the least, not as their primary modality of trade. In all cultures, most people throughout history lived in small villages, wherein there was not a meaningful monied aspect in terms of how basic needs, wants, and desires were met. More pointedly, the overwhelming majority of people lived in a rural setting, not an urban setting. Money as a modality of trade was largely utilized by urban dwellers, as the urban setting doesn’t by itself tend to provide the needs, wants, and desires of the people living therein. In other words, the baker can’t bake the bread predicated upon the land the city is on. Nor again can any of the people within a city live predicated upon the land the city is on.
Hence, city dwellers utilize the mechanism of trade, taxes, governments, etc… to draw the resources from the rural areas in order to provide for the people in the cities. In short, they develop the tool of money as a modality of trade, in order to move resources around. In the rural areas, this kind of trade simply wasn’t necessary.
While the exact details vary in time, culture and place, in general the rural dwellers ‘communally’ produced foods, and gifted them to each other within the villages they lived. They tended to make their own goods and services, rather than trading with anyone, especially anyone outside the village they lived. It is important to note that such systems didn’t generally functionally operate via a government structure controlling the situation. While it is true that governmental structures existed, by and large the actual day to day, week to week, season to season, year to year labor involved was not determined by the local government structures.
Historically speaking, the ‘local lords and ladies’, or the local representative of the larger scalar governmental body was broadly tasked with distributing the locally produced goods to the cities, in essence, as the cities couldn’t produce such goods themselves. They of course served other purposes, but in terms of ‘economics’ such was essentially their role.
It’s a bit of a side trek, but such is important to understand in order to avoid the real horrors involved with large scale government control, and disassociate what is being described here from notions of communistic theory, the latter largely being predicated upon larger scalar systems of control. Though both communistic theory and a moneyless free labor society do draw upon the same reality regarding rural life.
Such is a bit of an over-simplification, but it highlights the point that money is just a tool. It is an agreement between people towards some specific end, nothing more, and nothing less.
The reader ought not interpret this point as necessarily indicative of there being an inherent problem with money, in the sense of cities ‘sucking rural areas dry’. Though it is important to note historically that such concerns were real and common prior to WWII, and underpin many of the current political divides between rural dwellers and city dwellers.
Still, we may very well hold that we don’t all want to be farmers, and there are obvious pitfalls involved with such a modality of living. It is materially poor for instance, takes up the majority of peoples’ lives to accomplish, and as each familial unit is essentially fated to the field, the prospects of creating goods and services that are not of the field are extremely limited. There are, after all, goods and services that are not directly or even indirectly related to the field that societies view as a good, and sometimes a great good.
To be blunt, folks cannot create specialized goods and services, if all the species are more or less fated to the fields.
I don’t mean such as any kind of disrespect to those who work the fields, beyond the mereness of its necessity as a matter of life, or at least as a matter of this life, the life so lived is not something of poor quality. I mean such far more in the materiality and spirituality of the quality of lives that folks can live as a society.
Among the things to understand from this short section is that there are no obvious or unobvious reasons as to why a people cannot do the same kind of thing as it relates to broader structures than plain familial self-sufficiency. In other words, people can, and generally have for the overwhelming majority of the species’ history functionally operated as a ‘community’ predicated not upon money, but upon gift-giving.
That the gifts may have changed, grown more generous even, is no reason to suggest that the same cannot be done.
Farmers used to and to a meaningful extent still do trade the various products of their fields with each other so that folks get a better variety than just whatever they so happen to grow. Indeed, they oft simply give them away without any sense of ‘trading’ involved. Just a simple understanding that others will do the same. In a meaningful sense this Moneyless Free Labor Societies is holding that there are no reasons why any other industry cannot do exactly the same kind of thing.
Those who make clothes give them away, those that make bread give them away, those that make tools give them away, and so forth.
The disposition, that is, the attitude to not do so is one that is primarily predicated upon fear, loathing of others, concern of being ‘taken advantage of’, concern of others ‘not doing their fair share’ and so forth. The relevant ethical, emotive and reasonable upshot thereof being that such concerns are merely concerns, significantly that such are lacking in the reality of how people actually behave.
Much of the point of pointing out the historical realities of people’s day to day, month to month, season to season, year to year lives, is exactly to note that human behavior is not actually the kind of depraved, hedonistic, self-centered, horror show that monied society makes it out to be. Humanity may make a picture of themselves upon the silvery screen to display themselves to each other, but such displays are secondary to the reality, always up close yet such up closeness may not be the relevant perspective of the reality.
There are reasons for understanding the proper framework within which gift-giving can realistically and functionally operate, and there are reasons to examine the pragmatics of exactly how that can be accomplished beyond the basic small-town gift-giving mechanisms. The point again is to highlight that such practices are and always have been normal, and ought not be viewed as anything particularly radical.
The reader would do well to recognize and keep in mind that money is just a kind of agreement between people, a substitute for formal agreements such as bartering, or informal agreements such as communally producing and sharing, or social arrangements. Money is a kind of abstraction of agreements.
In the freeform modality of its use that is capitalism, the reader ought to therefore recognize that people will agree to work for the abstraction of agreements. People do not, in other words, actually require the symbology of money to make agreements to work.
To try and be clear on that point, if people will work for the abstraction of agreements as represented by money, then they will also be willing to work for the abstraction of agreements without necessarily relying upon the representation of those abstractions of agreements.
In this sense, folks can think of money as a tool as being a kind of crutch for a distrustful and craven people. It plays pretend with them whereby they hold that they cannot trust each other, but that trust the illusionary value of money. Illusions as their deity, that to which they can refer themselves to. But it is of course just a symbol for an abstracted agreement to trust each other in matters of trade.
There is a concern regarding if people can trust each other enough to actually do the work they agree to in abstraction. In some sense, and an important sense, this feeling is something that motivates the utilization of money.
Such amounts to a kind of social arrangement, whereby the social arrangement is rather simply put: freely chosen labor in exchange for access to all goods and services provided by everyone’s freely chosen labor.
Again, recognizing that the disposition to not trust, the concern that folks wont do, is a feeling and only a feeling, is something that the reader can utilize and disregard as something that isn’t a valid reason to not trust.
Another aspect the reader would do well to take away from this section is to recognize that by making agreements in abstraction, the species is able to produce a far wider variety of goods and services. Innovation is not, in other words, ‘spurred on’ through money as such, rather, innovation is spurred on through trust in abstract agreements to work together on things.
Trust enough that someone(s) willing to try something new, specifically, something that doesn’t in and of itself produce the necessary goods and services to live, i.e. basically farming, nonetheless enables the production of goods and services that people in general would want and desire, and in a very meaningful sense, grow to need.
In other words, the creative capacity to develop different modalities of life aside from subsistence farming.
Again, no dig on the farmers. After all, Moneyless Free Labor Societies is arguing that the actual traditional modality of trade, that of farmers, rural living, is not only applicable but by far a good in comparison to the utilization of money, and bluntly speaking, farmers produce a great deal of what the species needs to meet everyone’s needs, wants, and desires.
Note how far counter this runs to the story told by capitalistic societies, e.g. innovation is a product of the trust provided by way of the widespread use of abstracted agreements between people, thereby enabling them to produces goods and services that dont strictly meet the needs, wants and desires of them their self. There isnt thereby anything particularly special bout capitalism save perhaps this; its freedom of form is relevant to labor not to money.
Though it will be expanded upon later in MFLS, another introductory point for the reader to have in mind is the sheer abundance that the species has at its fingertips.
The amount of labor involved to produce en masse goods and services is wildly different than at any point in the species’ history. So much so that it is fairly inappropriate to hold to a position that is emotionally predicated upon fears of folks not doing their fair share, when their fair share of labor towards the community is actually rather minimal.
While this of course and importantly isn’t the case everywhere in the globe, the capacity for it to exactly be everywhere in the globe is real. More than the reduction in the amount of labor involved, the abundance associated with the capacity to produce is so great that the very fundamental structures of the ecology broadly and as they relate to the ecologies of the species has changed. The economics, and ecological of scarcity is simply not the same as the economics and ecological of abundance.
Moneyless Free Labor Societies is an economic of abundance.
Some Musical Accompaniment: Lyla June - All Nations Rise
and