r/ModestMouse • • Feb 27 '24

Isn't Strangers to Ourselves the best MM album?

1 Upvotes

I've only been a fan since Float On but that's still like 20 years. I'm familiar with every album past and most of what came before. Am I alone in thinking Strangers to Ourselves is their best work?


r/ModestMouse • • Jul 27 '26

I cannot in good faith continue to support this band if Isaac doesn’t remove Simon

40 Upvotes

Huge fan for about fifteen years. My favorite band. Seen them multiple times. Went on the cruise. I own multiple copies of every album.

This is a red line for me. Predatory behavior cannot be normalized. I’d Isaac doesn’t speak out about this, I can no longer support any of the project. No streaming, to going to shows, no buying merch, no wearing their shirts/hoodies. I refuse to support a band who doesn’t speak out against this kind of behavior. Especially when it’s from a non-original, totally replaceable member.

The tour is next week, and I’m ready to tear up my tickets. I really, really hope Isaac talks about this and didn’t defend Simon’s actions or half-baked rationale.


r/ModestMouse • • Aug 08 '26

Finished My Deep Dive On the Band. Here's My Ranking

Post image
17 Upvotes

I'm going to see them live soon, and so I decided to listen through all their studio albums and rank them!


r/ModestMouse • • Jul 28 '26

The scandal

0 Upvotes

How am I supposed to feel about this? I get the overall grossness, but this is not really a sexual predator story. Best I can tell, it’s an immature idiot who probably knew he was talking to a younger person but probably didn’t know he was talking to a minor. Even if you don’t buy his excuse, what was the endgame? He didn’t initiate the conversation and he didn’t seem to be trying to pursue or solicit anything. Is there a theory other than trolling? Sending nude pics to a stranger imo is always disgusting, but it wasn’t even him. It wasn’t a “look at me” picture. So we’re left to decide… should this guy be cancelled forever? Assuming, there is no pattern or other evidence I lean towards no. He’s a rockstar, not an algebra teacher.


r/ModestMouse • • Dec 10 '15

I write Modest Mouse lyrics in my notebook for fun, I like the way this one came out.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Jan 07 '25

When you nut but she keep suckin

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Oct 04 '19

All of these “character designs” are fucking stupid.

0 Upvotes

That’s all.


r/ModestMouse • • Jun 06 '26

Song/Album Discussion The album theme of An Eraser in a Maze

0 Upvotes

Would it be correct to say that the album is literally saying, "I don't have anything lyrically meaningful to say anymore, but here I am and I will use remnants from my older work and past selves to fuel parts of the art. If you still have an open mind you can still come along but if not that's okay too. Also, here are different fragments of the past that I am trying to erase and edit and come to terms with."

If so, the idea of the theme of an artist having nothing to left to say and telling the listener directly is an interesting one and has its own depth in its own right even if Isaac isn't trying to be deep. With him admitting he killed his previous artistic self in Absolutely Necessary Never that just made the album even sadder to me because its basically an artistic identity crisis. It also goes along with the titles like "Song About Nothing."

I don't know why but the album being a reference and admittance to itself and to its fans that there is nothing to say and no meaning is kind of empty and tragic in its own right. Like sad on just a different level that might not be quite as nihilist as say M&A but sad from what it is intentionally lacking and what has been erased. As if the whole album is a meta reflection of where he is as an artist.

I feel emotionally gutpunched right now realizing the lack of meaning is what he meant. Maybe that makes me kind of an MM simp or overanalyzing it but damn. Ouch.


r/ModestMouse • • Nov 02 '23

When did this community get so sensitive?

1 Upvotes

Everybody has their opinions. And yes, some share them in a toxic way. However, I've seen so many people express their dislike for a song or album respectfully and get silly angry responses. Like on the other thread where the guy asked people's thoughts on STO. Even people actually articulating reasons why they didn't like something were accused of being stuck in the past or not "maturing" with the band. Just really cringe infantile responses. I though the MM community was better than that.


r/ModestMouse • • Nov 20 '23

Was the album design of LCW antithetically inspired by Led Zeppelin IV?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

City vs country, palette nod, pure rock thinky album…


r/ModestMouse • • Jul 15 '20

He kinda looks like issac

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Apr 27 '19

Created this absolute train wreck of a comic.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Mar 11 '25

Was screwing around on Chat GPT and asked it to make a MM tribute album. I’d buy it.

0 Upvotes

A Tribute to Modest Mouse: Various Artists Cover the Classics

A mix of indie legends, punk energy, experimental takes, and country grit—all reimagining Modest Mouse’s best tracks.

  1. IDLES – “Shit Luck”

(A blistering, chaotic punk assault)

2. Fugazi – “Doin’ the Cockroach”

(Tight, rhythmic, and intense post-hardcore groove)

3. Queens of the Stone Age – “Bury Me With It”

(Heavy, desert-rock fury)

4. Sturgill Simpson – “Cowboy Dan”

(A fiery outlaw-rock explosion with killer guitar work)

5. The National – “Gravity Rides Everything”

(Melancholic, orchestral, emotionally heavy)

6. Wilco – “Trailer Trash”

(Dreamy, country-tinged heartache)

7. Arcade Fire – “Ocean Breathes Salty”

(A grand, anthemic rework)

8. Built to Spill – “The Stars Are Projectors”

(Spacey, guitar-heavy jam session)

9. Spoon – “The View”

(Tight, groovy, minimalist swagger)

10. Yo La Tengo – “Gravity Rides Everything”

(A hazy, dreamlike version)

11. Interpol – “Dark Center of the Universe”

(Brooding, hypnotic post-punk rendition)

12. Brand New – “Bankrupt on Selling”

(Raw, stripped-down emotional weight)

13. Coheed and Cambria – “Life Like Weeds”

(A sprawling, proggy epic)

14. Nine Inch Nails – “Tiny Cities Made of Ashes”

(Dark, industrial rework—pure chaos)

15. Animal Collective – “The Stars Are Projectors”

(Psychedelic, abstract, and weird as hell)

16. King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard – “Spitting Venom”

(A long, jammy freakout session)

17. MGMT – “3rd Planet”

(A psych-pop spin on a Modest Mouse classic)

Bonus Track: Orville Peck – “Baby Blue Sedan” (A haunting, cinematic country ballad)


r/ModestMouse • • Jan 18 '24

is modest mouse a small band?

2 Upvotes

i rarsly ever see of them anywhere... throughout all of their career... very little mainstream attention.. of course their biggest hits have it... but ive always thought they are treated as a one hit wonder.... no one talks about modest mouse


r/ModestMouse • • Jun 18 '24

Does anyone else view modest mouse as 2 completely different bands?

2 Upvotes

I’ve seen them live twice in the past 2 years, once for the lonesome crowded west tour which was awesome. Then I saw them with the pixies, and honestly I can hardly even recognize Isaac compared to in the 90s. He doesn’t even really sound the same at all to me.


r/ModestMouse • • Feb 22 '26

My MM tierlist

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Apr 09 '24

90’s movie kids when they see a cookie jar

0 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • May 11 '24

Day 19 Of Eliminating Songs Until A Winner Is Chosen!

Post image
0 Upvotes

The most votes I've counted thus far, but the Rat fans stand strong! Trucker's Atlas will begin crossing those great state roads..

What is your favorite song to hear live?


r/ModestMouse • • Feb 26 '13

MODEST MOUSE PROBLEMS

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Aug 09 '25

Describe a Modest Mouse song very very poorly

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Mar 09 '25

do you think issac brock/MM is selling out with the cruise?

0 Upvotes

i’m personally pretty mixed but i’d like to think not. it’s not like i’d be able to go anyways i got 10 dollars in my banking account lmfaoooo


r/ModestMouse • • Jul 20 '22

Worst song from each album?

5 Upvotes

Im curious, what do you guys think is the worst song from each album?

My list would be this:

Long Drive: Might

LCW: Jesus Christ

TMA: What People Are Made Of

Building Nothing: This one is really hard....probably Sleep Walkin

Good News: Blame It On The Tetons

We Were Dead: Invisible

Strangers: Pistols...probably their worst song ever...

Golden Casket: Lace Your Shoes

Some of these songs are really not bad, just the worst of all of these other brilliant songs.


r/ModestMouse • • Aug 18 '26

If you have ICP here are my designs for the shirts. If you like please go give it an up vote. The Cowboy Dan isn’t 100 done so I posted the rough draft

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/ModestMouse • • Mar 23 '24

Just got married, our favorite band is modest mouse. We're seeing them in a smaller venue soon and I'd love to have them give my husband a shout out or something. Help!?

3 Upvotes

EDIT: I copied and pasted my replies to most comments because it was easie. In the long run I didn't get him to give a shout out but I did get to shake his hand and my husband got to talk to him face to face.

I later told my husband that I made this post and he got emotional and was like why am I just now finding out about this?? I told him I had been keeping it a secret in hopes I could get us some sort of interaction with Isaac. Well, we did and it was beautiful, highlight of our life, and our first concert as husband and wife. Thanks for all the sweet comments and congratulations y'all are incredible.

So my husband's favorite band is Modest Mouse, when we met I knew of them but didn't know they'd end up being my favorite band as well.

Well we're seeing them soon and have VIP tickets and I'd love to try my best to contact someone or their fan mail to see if they can say something to him. Hed absolutely lose it, and absolutely deserves it. I know this is a stretch and may be odd but if anyone knows an email or anything it would mean the world to me and hopefully my husband too.