r/ModernTwin • u/AcademyRuins • Aug 18 '15
Choosing the right variant and flex slots [x-post ModernMagic]
Twin has defined itself as a dominant force in Modern ever since Patrick Dickmann took down GP Antwerp using an innovative Tempo Twin list with a beatdown plan A. Florian Koch details more of the history well in this article but here I'll be talking more about fine tuning your mainboard and the advantages of each variant.
I'll start off by saying there is no best Twin variant. And the 75 that took down the latest GP? It's probably not ideal for your local PPTQ. The good news is that Twin is the type of deck that will just always be good; its gameplan is not linear, its matchups are mostly even, and it can be tuned to beat anything. Twin rewards skilled pilots who know the deck and the anticipated metagame well, everyone has tested against your matchup and is prepared to beat you. You may skirt by on free wins with casual players at FNM but you'll need to get plenty of reps in to compete at a large event.
Over the past few years, a core has shown up time and time again. If you're looking for somewhere to start, approximately 50 cards are shared no matter what version you'd like to play. While many have had success deviating from the following, this is fairly typical to any Twin list.
10 Combo Pieces
4 Deceiver Exarch
2 Pestermite
4 Splinter Twin
6 Pieces of Counter Magic
4 Remand
2 Cryptic Command
Cantrips
4 Serum Visions
Burn
4 Lightning Bolts
Tempo Creatures
4 Snapcaster Mage
1 Vendilion Clique
Fuck your X/5
1 Roast/Terminate/Dismember
3 Mana Value Spell
1 Electrolyze/Kolaghan's Command
23 Lands
The real decisions with lands comes down to how many basics and what utility lands you'd like to play. It's hard to go wrong with Tectonic Edge or Desolate Lighthouse, but Cavern of Souls, Ghost Quarter, and man lands in RUG and Grixis can all work. It'd be easy to write another thread just on Twin mana bases, but in the end it's important in the end to think why you want 2 Lighthouse over any Tec Edge, or on that same note why Ghost Quarter might be better than Tec Edge presently; cater your mana base to your metagame.
For UR Twin, you'll want Misties and Stomping Grounds. Deltas/Strands and Breeding Pool can work, but it comes down to you'll have less protection against Choke and you'll often have to shock yourself an additional time against Affinity.
The remaining 6 or so slots in the maindeck are important and determine really how you're building your list to beat the anticipated metagame. When cards are cut from this 54 card core, they are most often Vendilion Clique, Electrolyze, one Cryptic Command, one Twin, a combo creature, a land and for whatever reason we see a list with only 3 Snapcasters running around occasionally. Clique, Electrolyze, and Cryptic all can rot in your hand at times, Twin's curve can actually be pretty high at times so opting for more early interaction or specifically metagamed hate like mainboard mana disruption in Blood Moon or Spreading Seas or a trump card for fair matchups like Vedalken Shackles, Keranos, or Batterskull can all make sense.
Going to eight combo pieces is pretty typical in RUG and it's common in Grixis too. It comes down to deciding that answers and flex slots are better than the combo. A flash 1/4 creature with a disruptive element is a slow clock and a subpar blocker in an X/5 format. Splinter Twin is the most narrowly useful card in the whole deck, it's only a card when you have sculpted a hand capable of combo'ing or in the extreme late game on Snapcaster. While I am playing devil's advocate here, it's often right to shave combo pieces, but you should start with the core, add flex slots, then shave the combo if you feel necessary.
With that said, before you decide how to dedicate your flex slots, it's important to determine what flavor of Twin you'd like to play. Below is a brief description of each variant.
UR Twin is the best option in an open meta or one with lots of linear aggro and combo decks (Burn, Affinity, Infect, Storm, Bloom Titan). You're essentially a control deck that controls the tempo of the game by threatening the combo. This version is weakest to disruption and 4/5s. Against any green fair deck, you're unfavored but you typically can be more 50-50 post board with Blood Moon and bomby win cons. Your last few slots are often filled with Grim Lavamancer and cheap utility spells like Dispel and Peek. Lavaman is the worst card for a low to the ground aggro deck to see and the extra utility adds a lot ways to tune your maindeck. These extra Dispels, Spell Snares, Peeks, etc give you a cheap way to interact, whether it be protecting your creatures while comboing or beating down, or countering key spells like Collected Company and Goroyo's Vengeance. You have on average about five-ish extra one drops which gives you more to do early on and it makes your Snapcasters more useful than your opponent's. Your Blood Moon in the sideboard are better against midrange than the three color Twin variants, but you also lack a beater to fully take advantage of the potential tempo swing in these same matchups (in the 3 color variants, sometimes playing a Blood Moon even when it hurts you more can enable wins because it acts like a Rule of Law or locks out your opponent's removal for your Goyf/Tasigur ).
RUG is best when your meta is skewed more fair but reactive, so you hope to play against lots of Blue decks (Twin, Delver, UWR). Since Goyf comes down early, it's also helps against aggressive decks like Zoo and Burn because you're able to gum up the ground early, then you have a beater already on board once you've taken control. It's also worth noting the biggest weakness to UR and Grixis Twin is that they lack a proactive two drop so they can fall behind in the midgame, it only makes sense to splash for the best two drop in the format. Your deck operates more streamlined and is overall more aggressive than the other Twin variants because you curve out and actually tempo your opponent with board presence before you threaten the combo. A game where you can Probe, Bolt a creature, fetch and play an unboltable Goof then hold up either Remand or the combo for the rest of the game will leave your opponent's feeling frustrated and confused why they're behind if they can't immediately answer your Chillwind Yeti. They blow their removal on Goyf and now they can just lose to the combo, you attempt the combo and now Goyf is a 5/6 to swing past Tasigur or Angler, these two angles of attack compliment each other greatly. This version does gain some points against green decks but overall can feel like a half measure and disappointing because you lose the more controlling parts of UR while lacking the end game of Grixis Twin. This variant appeals most to a playstyle more than anything, you play a lean, efficient, more tempo oriented deck that punishes weak hands and loses a lot of the durdliness that the two variants sometimes have.
Grixis Twin is best when you want the less conditional removal and a powerful threat that excels when you're both in top decks against BGx heavy metagames. This version is similar to RUG in that you're weaker to some linear and combo strategies, but you gain a good amount against fair stuff. A misconception is that Tasigur is just a black Tarmogoyf and this couldn't be farther from the truth; Tasigur is a more late game win condition than a clock for your tempo deck. Goyf on turn 2 sets a clock that non midrange decks will struggle to get rid of early. Outside of a hand with Thought Scour, Tasigur has to come down on turn 3 or later, and Twin has plenty to do on turn 3+ whereas twos are normally a hole in Twin's curve. The power level of this variant is likely the highest of the three, Kolaghan's Command and Tasigur should enable more wins in the end game, but at the cost of the some disynergy with Snapcaster, saying no to Grim Lavamancer, and having mana requirements like T1 U/R, T2 BR, and T4 1UUU or 2RR.
To sum it up: if tempo and value is better, play a splash; if control is better, go straight UR. Green is best against Blue decks, Black is best against Green decks.
On to the flex slots. Decide on your variant then add some of the cards you see below These cards are not to be considered weaker than the rest of the core, but make up remaining pieces that act like glue which holds the deck together. I'd remind everyone that just because you sideboard a card out a lot, does not mean it should be removed from the main, and just because you bring a card in for nearly every matchup does not mean it should be in the main.
Additional Countermagic
Dispel/Spell Pierce - These two serve a similar role, but Spell Pierce is more versatile at the cost of being more conditional. These two will typically be used to stop removal or help stop problem cards against linear decks like countering a Summoner's Pact against Bloom Titan, a Boros Charm against Burn, or a Become Immense against Infect. Spell Pierce has the ability to counter Liliana of the Veil which Twin typically has difficulty dealing with, along with other hard to answer permanents like Choke, Karn, or Hive Mind. These are powerful when you expect to be playing against other draw go decks, fair decks with a limited number of ways to interact with combo, or any combo deck.
Mana Leak - Typically not very common, it serves a similar role to Remand, but it's better suited against midrange when you need to stop their Siege Rhino, Liliana, or Tasigur from ever reaching the board since they steal most of your tempo and can win the game on their own.
Spell Snare - Spell Snaring something on the draw defines an up tempo play and certain decks are very soft to this card. Snare can feel like the best card in your deck when you anticipate a lot of Affinity, Burn, or Storm, but it also rots in your hand against decks like Elves, Tron, or worse, Living End. UR typically likes to play 2 because they're so soft to Goyf, but recently it's gotten slightly better with BRx surging in popularity. Targets against Grixis Twin are Remands, Terminates, and Snapcasters and Jund has Scooze, Bobs, Goyfs, and Terminates. You're able to resolve the combo much easier now that people depend on Terminate as their catch all removal spell.
Additional Creatures
Grim Lavamancer - This guy dominates the early game and just win games against certain decks all on it's own. You want one in your opening hand against any aggressive creature deck and even when he can't kill anything, he needs to eat a removal spell or any excess red you have lying around is Shocking your opponent every turn. He's a staple in UR Twin, but Grixis and to a lesser extent RUG use the graveyard more so it's hard to run more than one in their 75.
Vendilion Clique - UR Twin nearly always has 2 in the 75, but it's often correct to play 2 main. It really does it all, but it's typically best in the blue mirror or against combo. The reason Clique is so powerful outside of the disruption is that flash often sets up a Catch 22 situation. You're fine with running Clique into a Remand if it then lets you resolve the combo or a powerful threat like Blood Moon or Keranos on your own turn. If they do let it resolve, then you get to bottom their answer to your threat. Seeing your opponent's hand also lets you map out your gameplan similar to Peek. All around, V Clique is just one of the most efficient threats you have access to, the only downside is the fragile body.
Huntmaster of the Fells - This guy rarely shows up in RUG, but it's just card that can easily run away with the game while mucking up the ground in the process. Huntmaster has a high ceiling but also a low floor, getting him Bolted is awful and when flipped he can be easily answered by Abrupt Decay or EE. Then again, if you get to flip him once, Snapcaster makes for an easy way to flip it back. He's great with a Twin on him. Reid Duke describes it best, if you top deck a Huntmaster and your opponent top decks a land, you probably just win. Consider him if you anticipate a lot of burn or non-red creature decks.
Scavenging Ooze - He's fallen slightly out of favor, mainly just because people have preferred more slots and less commitment to green, but Scooze is great both in the mirror, against BGx, Burn, and is okay at trimming a graveyard to stop early Tasigurs and Anglers. Overall, Scooze is a better fit in the sideboard to slot in if there's a lot of graveyard decks running around.
Tasigur, the Golden Fang - Sometimes in Grixis we've actually seen the 2 Tasigur pushed to the sideboard for a more traditional UR approach mainboard. Basically, you're now playing the black splash for better removal (or a less painful Dismember) and better alt win cons in the sideboard. This is a build you can opt for if you think the more painful manabase is worth it for unconditional removal and losing Ancient Grudge, but still feel the full combo a slew of utility blue spells is the best approach in the main.
Bounding Krasis - A really interesting option for RUG Twin that I've seen replacing Pestermite for an extra power and protection from stuff like K Command and Electrolyze, or replacing Exarch to go on the max tempo plan. This one feels up in the air presently, but a 3/3 body matters a lot against decks like Burn, Zoo, or anything that doesn't want to interact or present blockers. There are certain metagames where this card will just perform better on average than the other Twiddle creatures, I recommend trying it out and see what you think.
Spellskite - Another creature that's rarely seen mainboard but has its merits. Best suited in UR Twin in a metagame full of linear aggressive strategies like Infect,GW Build Your Own Emrakul Bogles, Burn, etc. Spellskite swings from two axises in this deck, it's a reactive answer to these more combo oriented aggressive decks or just a wall against decks like Zoo, and it proactively protects your combo.
Utility
Peek/Gitaxian Probe - Both are powerful in this strategy because they allow you to cycle, letting you see more of your deck more quickly, see if the coast is clear to combo or not, and most importantly develop a gameplan for what answers should be used against which potential threats. Peek is preferred in UR and Grixis to keep the deck at instant speed and preserve life, plus it gives Twin something to do end of turn with Snapcaster. Probe is better for RUG mostly to up your Sorcery count, fetch plus a Sorcery Bolt proofs your Goof, but you're also the most aggressive of the three so Probe allows you to use more of your mana for proactive purposes over the course of the early game, plus you can have some nice plays were you Probe to see if your Spell Snare is good enough backup for your Twin on five lands. Peeks are great when you expect a lot of other fair decks, but mainly Blue ones.
Blood Moon - Maindeck Blood Moons get people all the time, but it can also be mostly dead against faster decks. This comes down to personal preference as a way to cater to your playstyle, but if you have a great read on the metagame then go for it. Twin only has a few flex slots so be careful not to dilute your answers.
Vedalken Shackles - Pretty mediocre now that people are playing a bit of maindeck artifact hate. You really want this card against decks like CoCo Abzan or non-Grixis Twin (though it's not as good as you might think against Pestermite). I say if you want this card in your deck, you might be better off playing Blue Moon, but it is a lot of fun to play.
Izzet Charm - A very versatile card for UR Twin that excels against linear aggro decks like Infect, Affinity, and Burn. Spell Pierce is clearly a card that's very playable in Modern, and shocking a creature is killing everything that Bolt would. The loot mode isn't great, but allows you to draw two cards late game when you're flooding or you need to dig for a specific card. A good test is to imagine you have an Izzet Charm in your hand every turn two and you'll find a good use for it whether it be killing a Goblin Guide, Bob, Scooze, Delver, or Steel Overseer or countering a Liliana, Summer Bloom, Karn, Cranial Plating, Boros Charm or Wild Defiance. They all combine together to make a card that's slighty overcosted, but the options make up for it.
Electrolyze - Playing with 2 Electrolyze is very common given the abundance of X/1s running around and the potential for a 3 for 1, but a 2 for 1 is totally fine too. It's fantastic against Infect (nice Spellskite), Affinity, Delver, UR Twin, Elves and Lingering Souls. Again, shock kills most creatures in the format Roast doesn't, so playing an extra Electrolyze is a very safe choice, especially in UR.
Kolaghan's Command - Some Grixis Twin lists look to run additional K Commands in their maindeck, mainly just to gain a few more points against attrition based decks. The card is much like Siege Rhino in that it's exceedingly okay, it's probably a little overhyped presently, but it's hard to go wrong when choosing two from: instant speed discard, Disentomb, and Shock. Don't think that running 3 of these in your 75 means you can't lose to Affinity now, this card is slow and you will cry when an Etched Champion resolves and you're not in a position to combo.
Thought Scour - A cantrip without selection isn't really worth the upside of T2'ing Tasigur or giving you Snapcaster or Lavaman fuel. If you're looking to live the dream of a beat stick on T2, play RUG or Grixis Control. You have a very limited number of slots and this is mostly air, answers are going to be more important.
Twisted Image - Literally Bolt you, draw a card for U with Exarch /s. Twisted Image is a cantrip utility spell that plays a similar role to Shadow of Doubt in Control decks. There's a fairly low cost to putting it in your deck given the cantrip, especially at instant speed. If you expect a lot of Spellskites, mana dorks, and Affinity, this is a cheap two for one that should make it into your maindeck of UR.
Simic Charm - I've been dying to try this, almost assuredly terrible.
Discard
Inquisition of Kozilek - Discard is pretty controversial mainboard and most people will tell you it's wrong, but IoK, Snap IoK is great and this card allows you to punch a hole in your opponent's hand that caters to how your own hand wants to play. You have the combo in hand? Take their discard or Abrupt Decay. You have Tasigur and Snapcaster? Take the Liliana and try to grind them out. This will come down more to personal preference, Dispels and Spell Pierces handle combo just fine, but know that your mana will be greedy at this point. Say goodbye to your own Blood Moon and throw some Dragon's Claws or Vampiric Links in your sideboard.
Additional Removal for X/5s
Terminate - Instant speed, unconditional removal is very good. Many lists have been playing extra removal for GBx, but be careful with your commitment to black, BR is a hard color combination to hit without shocking at least once.
Dismember - Similar to Terminate, but this can be played by all three lists. Dismember is best in RUG where your aggression helps mitigate the life loss. UR Twin should opt for a Dismember before the second Roast in the main, playing at instant speed is crucial. Grixis is going to have a hard time assembling 1BB early without taking extra damage anyway, but the flexible cost is great.
Harvest Pyre - This one only belongs really belongs in UR Twin where your commitment to the graveyard is minimal. This is more of a relic to when Twin did not access to Roast, but if you're worried about the life loss on Dismember go for it. If you try this one out, you may need to play Thought Scour if you have 2 Lavamen mainboard.
Go for the Throat - You sacrifice a dead card against Affinity for a slight edge against Burn, rival Blood Moons, and you respect the card Master of Waves. Probably not too worth it but YMMV.
Murderous Cut - Unconditional removal at the cost of being a dud early without Thought Scour. Seems okay in the sideboard if you'd like an additional piece of removal for grindy matchups like Twin mirrors, Grixis, or Jund, but doesn't make as much sense in the main.
So there you have it, I hope this sheds some light on exactly when you want to play which variant, and exactly how you should fill in those last few slots. I hope this wasn't too overwhelming, but I know I was always confused starting out on why exactly Twin had so many one ofs and cards whose power level seemed a little lacking. Feel free to leave any other advice in the comments.