Hey everyone! I was recently informed that there was a Grixis subreddit, so here's my sort-of tournament report from my top 8 this past weekend at SCG Philly. My team went 10-3-2, drawing into top 8.
Round 1: KCI (W 2-0) - This matchup is basically that they only have so many cards that matter and I have far more answers for them. Surgical is just a beating.
Round 2: Storm (W 2-0) - This is a good matchup, improving out of the board, but it's a pretty difficult one and mistakes are more costly than usual.
Round 3: Affinity (W 2-0) - When the question is "Artifact?", Kolaghan's Command is the answer.
Round 4: G Tron (W 2-0) - So begins the my string of tron matches. I was lucky to capitalize on a bit of a flood and avoid turn 3 Tron on the draw, post board I have a lot of play and the match improves to the point of maybe being favorable.
Round 5: G/R Tron (W 2-1) - My opponent boarded into a Pithing Needle/Alpine Moon pachage to keep me off land destruction, but didnt't see them early and it didn't matter.
Round 6: G Tron (L 0-2) - This was Todd Stevens. He had so much redundancy on tron pieces that I had a lot of trouble keeping him down long enough to establish a clock... and I got turn 4 Ulamoged game 1.
Round 7: UW (L 0-2) - I didn't realize just how bad this matchup felt. I played a lot against Jeskai, but UW I didn't have a ton of reps. So... Many... Planeswalkers. Jeskai has burn spells like me, but where they play Helix and Electrolyze, I play Kolaghan's Command which is better in the matchup. UW just has more Planeswalkers and more Counterspells in those slots. I felt like I had to be the aggro and apply pressure, which I don't generally do very well.
Round 8: Jeskai (DNF) (1-0 when teamates won) - Game 1 was a slaughter where I had 5 cards in hand to his 2 pretty quickly with Kolaghan's Command snapcaster looping nonsense. Game 2 was down to me 2for1ing off a Lyra but I was up on cards, so I felt in the game. chaining Kolaghan's Command is the breaker in the matchup.
Round 9: DNF GR Valakut (was 1-0 and about to win game 2 when teammates both won) - Another "They only have a few cards that matter" matchup. Brought in more counters and surgical and the matchup feels very good.
Round 10: Bye - one of 7 or so x-2-1s into day 2, got the random bye. *shrug*
Round 11: Affinity (W 2-0) - Artifacts. My opponent had Karn post board, resolved it, activated it, didn't matter. Etched Champion is basically the only way to lose the matchup.
Round 12: UW (L 1-2) - This was Peter Ingram. These games were very good. Game 2 I got to execute the "protect the queen" plan with Tasaigur on the play. Game 3 he resolves Lyra, which I answered eventually, but we went to turns and I was trying to answer his collonade to not die and draw. Lost on turn 5.
Round 13: UW (0-1 when teammates lost) - Game 1 was a curve of planeswalkers preceeded by double clique to clear the way. Game 2 felt up in the air, considering we didn't get that far.
Round 14: Grixis Reanimator (L 0-2) - I've played this pilot before. He's very good and this matchup is very scary. As Foretold, goryo's, Kiki Combo, Living End present so many angles of attack. Game 1 he mulled to 5, looted into double reanimate effect. Endstep reanimate I countered, untap reanimate I die. Game 2 I mull to 5 and get Gonti'd to death post board.
Round 15: Drew into top 8
Quaterfinals: Jeskai (0-1 when teammates lost) - Jon Rossum. This match was great. I was on the back foot for most of the game. Eventually I killed Jace and Teferi and chained Kolaghan's Commands and Snapcasters to go up on cards. I put him to one with snap bolt available having every 3 card combination covered except for him having Cyrptic #3 and his last 2 bolts in his 4 cards in hand. He had them, i died. We didn't really get anywhere into game 2.
My thoughts after the tournament are that UW Control is worse than I thought and I need to find a plan that closes the gap on that matchup. This had been some time coming, but I think Tron is actually a favorable matchup post board. Sure you can't really afford to make stupid mistakes without maximum punishment, but the matchup just feels good with my configuration.
Overall my list felt very good against the field and I don't think there's much to change other than fixing the UW matchup post board.
Happy to answer questions. Deck linked below.
http://www.starcitygames.com/decks/122507