r/ModelTimes • • Sep 16 '18

London Times [Op-Ed] What a Shambles the Government is in

1 Upvotes

The following opinions are strictly the opinion of the author of this article and the Model Times organization as a whole does not openly sponsor the opinions of the author.


What a shambles the Government is in. What an absolute shambles the Government is in. No plan, No leadership, No Economic skills.

I often say that the House in politics, the Parliament in politics, is a bit like the heart. Everyone knows that if their heart's not beating too well, they're not well. Well, the heart of this Parliament is not beating well, and this Government is in very bad shape. They have no plan!

One of the problems, quite clearly, and quite evidently demonstrated in the last two days in this House, is that the Government still hasn't formulated a plan for how they want to run this country. He has reversed his party’s economic policy that was outlined in the Queen’s Speech. So we had a economic speech from the chancellor outside the PM’s home on Downing Street following intense pressure from us, the Conservatives. This speech — is a speech that will not benefit you, or your family. Firstly, the Government states that they want to raise income tax, following a Queen’s Speech Pledge that said that the aim of the Government is to keep the burden of taxation for all. It does not end here. The Speech also states that the Government is planning to cut VAT down to 17.5%, while our Budget last term was able to cut VAT all the way down to the minimum rate legislated by the European Union, 15%. Furthermore, these changes do not ensure we are running a surplus. Anyway, it's been through Cabinet, it’s got the tick, but the Deputy PM said the complete opposite in response to a question I gave in the House. He says ‘pull on the brakes! we’re maintaining our economic policy’. Unluckily for him the Chancellor said they would be completely U-turning on their economic policy. It goes on and on and on. They have no leadership, no guts, and NO PLAN. And anything that resembles a plan — they are backtracking on!

After such revelations, I cannot wait to see the news footage of the Deputy Prime Minister in the house, listening to the budget. The Chancellor talking about their ambitious plans for the massive increases in tax and debt. Then qualifying it all by asking, "Did you know this was the Plan Deputy Prime Minister?."

This Government is laying the groundwork for a fiscal bomb.

A fiscal bomb that will detonate eventually and someone will need to clean the mess this Government will be leaving behind, following them having no plan on how to pay for it all.

This Government is in shambles. They are in a utterly disgraceful mess! It does not end here. It does not end with economics. This mess is visible with Brexit as well, which will define our nation’s future for the years ahead. This Government is making a shambles out of it. They have no clear plan. So we’ve been seeing the new “European Relations and International Trade” Secretary, talking about the new referendum on Brexit. He was also talking about the Government’s commitment to holding a final deal referendum. However, there is one one problem — one major problem. A few months ago, before he was made the Brexit Secretary, he was asked about the final referendum in Question time on the MBBC he proudly stated: “MP’s and ministers are not doing their jobs when there is a referendum.” So I ask him, will he be taking the warrant, taking the salary, taking the car, taking the house, all the drama when the referendum comes, because I know I won’t. Now, their handling of the referendum is not shambolic, you tell me what is. It is also a complete u-turn. If a Governing party is u-turning on this much, how can the voters trust them anymore?

So here the cabinet is, putting on the spectacle or the picture of a united Government, knowing full well that they don’t have even a spec of an economic plan, a spec of leadership or a spec of a plan at all and to be fair, of course, the general display that the Government knows what it's doing. Well, I would ask a simple question: if the Government knows what it's doing, that's one thing, but if it doesn't know where to come to answer questions, as was the case this yesterday and Monday, how can anyone believe they know what they're doing? How can anyone believe they had a plan when they went into Government?


Written by Sir /u/toastinrussian KG, the deputy leader of the Opposition.


r/ModelTimes • • Sep 05 '16

New York Times /u/Comped's Individual Predictions for US State Elections

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ModelTimes • • Nov 14 '16

Montreal Times Residents Still Angry After Chaudiere Flooding | Résidents en colère après Chaudiere inondée

3 Upvotes

This article has been published for both official CMHOC languages.

PrancingSkeleton, Montreal Times (Francais)

Environ 150 Québécois de la petite ville de Saint-Joseph-de-Beauce et les alentours manifestent devant l'hôtel de ville suite à l'inondation de la rivière Chaudière.

Malgré les avertissements de la ville vers le gouvernement fédéral avant les inondations, les fonds d'urgence n'étaient pas alloués jusqu'après le désastre s'est déroulé.

Le Ministre de la Justice Zhantongz a informé aux membres du gouvernement fédéral que les fonds ne pourraient pas être donnés à cause des lois concernant les fonds de secours.

Les inondations ont touchés les 5000 résidents de Saint-Joseph-de-Beauce. La ville a été colonisé en 1736, la faisant une des plus vielles et historiques au Québec. Les inondations on empoisonnés la majorité de l'eau potable local, à cause de la mercure et fluoride.

Les résidents manifestant à l'hôtel de ville décrient l'inaction du gouvernement. Ils ont brûlé des pancartes portant le photo du premier ministre canadien, en criant «Justice pour le Québec!». Il y avait aussi des pancartes lisant «INDÉPENDANCE QUÉBÉCOIS MAINTENANT».

Les experts du Département de l'infrastructure estiment que les inondations ont causé 100 millions$ de dommages. La plupart des dommages ont affecté l'agriculture et la pêche.


CourageousBeard, Montreal Times (English)

Approximately a hundred and fifty Quebeckers from the small town of Saint-Joseph-de-Beauce and other neighbouring towns are protesting in front of city hall following the flooding of the nearby Chaudière river.

Despite locals warning the federal government well in advance, emergency funds were not released until the disaster had actually occurred.

Justice Minister Zhantongz said to members of the government that the funds could not be released due to the current laws surrounding disaster relief funds.

The flood has most affected the 5,000 residents of Saint-Joseph-de-Beauce. The town was settled in 1736, making it one of the oldest and most historic villages in Quebec. The flood poisoned large parts of the local water supply when it introduced mercury and fluoride into the village’s wells.

Residents protesting at the town hall decried the lack of action by the government. They screamed and chanted, “Justice for Quebec!” Some held signs that said, “QUEBEC INDEPENDENCE NOW”.

Experts from the Department of Infrastructure estimate that the flood caused $100M in damage. Most of the damage was to local agricultural and fishing.


EDIT: In this response during a press conference, Justice Minister Zhantongz had this to say, providing some clarify on the incident.

"I advised the government the DFAA is the best course to fund the prevention, mitigation and recovery of the disaster as it is clearly defined and has no upper limit. The Minister of Finance then advised the Parliament and the provincial government that a financial credit under the DFAA is being provided and the province is assured to be reimbursed for any eligible expenses, including prevention measures, evacuation, emergency personnels, repair of residents' homes and more."


r/ModelTimes • • Dec 06 '21

Sunday Times Times Exclusive: Free Britney and PWP leader looks at defecting

7 Upvotes

Accusations have been levied at the Progressive Workers’ Party Co-Leader, /u/model-eddy, this past week: first coming from Mx Frost_Walker2017 reporting: “Eddy threatened to defect”, causing press responses from both Mr Eddy’s fellow co-leader, Mr Lokan, asserting “Eddy never threatened to leave the PWP” and from the Prime Minister, Mr YonedaStan, asking Mx Walker for an apology if they did not have “evidence that he threatened or pursued defection” or that they release the evidence themselves. Mx Walker had since made a clarification in their initial publication that Mr Eddy had not made such a threat in cabinet nor a threat was made. Mx Walker also went onto say that it was not their “intention to suggest that the Home Secretary had used this threat against the Prime Minister”

Matters are not resolved however, with the Prime Minister’s call leaving it open as to whether the Home Secretary had pursued defection, and the topic has not left public eye during recent Minister Questions to the Home Office. Mr TwoBoys has approached the issue, asking whether Mr Eddy sought “to defect from his party due to unhappiness with the Acting Home Secretary arrangement” a notion rejected by the Home Secretary. Clarification has been sought as to whether Mr Eddy had attempted to defect within the question period, but The Times can reveal a set of exchanges with both Coalition! Leader, Mr Barnaby, and Leader of the Opposition, Mr Chi, whom Mr Eddy had approached about defecting to.


To Mr Baranby, Mr Eddy approached regarding dissatisfaction with the Acting Home Secretary arrangement, suggesting making representations to his party on whether they are to collapse government over the Acting Home Secretary series of events, and also raised the possibility of a VoNC in the Rose Government. The choice of wording is notable, Mr Eddy describes the situation “like a Free Britney situation”, drawing comparisons to the alleged lack of consent in appointing Mr Lokan as Acting Home Secretary to the situation faced by Britney Spears and the conservatorship held by her father, Jamie Spears, which ended just last month. When interviewed by BNoC, the Prime Minister spoke on the Britney Spears case and how the arrangements were “deeply unjust and troubling” , this discussion playing out on U.K. screens some 2 days after the parallel made by Mr Eddy would raise suspicion whether the defection discussions had been an open secret amongst Westminister and press bubbles.

The Times spoke with Mr Barnaby regarding why he came forward now, and noted how the Acting Home Secretary appointment was “constitutionally murky” to begin with, but comments from Mr Eddy has added “a whole new layer of confusion.” To serve as Home Secretary, a person must be sworn as Privy Council, which as First Secretary of State and attending cabinet, is something Mr Lokan already met. However, no true precedent exists at Westminister for a Secretary to be acting - their duties may be discharged by their other ministers whilst they were busy with other matters (a point raised by Mr Lokan and Mr YonedaStan in response to the original accusations). Mr Lokan was not made a minister under the Home Office until after the exchanges with Mr Barnaby took place (22nd November) and Mr Eddy returned as Home Secretary full time. Mr Barnaby also emphasised how they hadn’t “wanted to go on record about what was said”, but the “falsehoods uttered in public had forced his hand.” This is in reference to the answers given by PWP and Mr Eddy, responding to questions saying they never threatened defection. Mr Barnaby did feel that the entire situation had left him feeling uneasy, given the accusations of being called a liar (albeit implicitly). This was not the first time this has felt slighted during talks, noting the initial confusion over his work with outgoing labour Leader Mr Kyosanto, where Mr Lokan misunderstood communications and make the accusation that Mr Barnaby has gone behind Labour’s back. This had left Mr Barnaby now calling those who had been strongest in their condemnation, to apologise. The quote provided by Mr Barnaby is found below;

Barnaby: The home secretary was clearly very unhappy with arrangements made regarding who would act in his stead for the period he was unavailable. I have always been clear that the whole situation is constitutionally murky but this adds a whole new layer to the confusion. I hadn’t wanted to have to go on the record with what was said to me but accusations levelled at me and colleagues in the press, as well as downright falsehoods being uttered in public, have forced my hand. I would also ask that those who boldly accused me and others of being dishonest - well in fact a complete liar - whilst knowing all of the grisly details of this business, publicly apologise.


Speaking to Mr Chi, Conservative Leader, it was also established that Mr Eddy had floated the idea of defecting to the Conservatives too. Mr Chi then went further to say in addition to the acting Home Secretary situation, Mr Eddy cited a general unhappiness about at the way government was handled. Mr Chi has consented to his exchanges with Eddy , as presented here. (M: ignoring irl commitments, which has been censored). Whilst not making the strong comments to Mr Barnaby, Mr Eddy does make the point of believing Mr Lokan is power hungry and will cooperate to maintain that power.

The transcript of discussion regarding other allegations going around are as follows:

The Times: Eddy suggested to our other source that he would suggest VoNCing the government, would the conservatives thought there was grounds to do so

chi: I am not sure what grounds Eddy thought a Vote of No Confidence in the government was a viable option on the 22nd November and I would not have been prepared to pursue one given that I myself am completely unaware of any reason which necessitated one

The Times: And Eddy also compared the situation to the Britney conservatorship - does you think this was an appropriate remark?

Chi: While one with a very liberal interpretation may be able to draw some very light parallels I do not believe that they are of a similar nature and to suggest so is insulting to those who find themselves in a similar position to Miss Spears.


The Times reached out to Mx Walker to see if they could shed light on their informants on the matter. They made clear that they were not privy to conversations directly and may have misunderstood at the time (and has since apologised for any misrepresentations), just their own experience on the matter. The transcript of discussions is included below with Mx Walker’s consent.

The Times: The Times has received sources saying that the Home Secretary did in fact approach people about defecting. Would Mx Walker be able to comment on whether Mr Eddy approached liberal democrats in defecting too, and what the extent of their knowledge was on the Home Secretary’s plans?

Walker: I am unaware on whether or not Mr Eddy approached the Liberal Democrats unfortunately, as it is more likely he'd have approached our leader directly rather than going through somebody else. As I was made aware, Mr Eddy was unhappy with the arrangement of Acting Home Secretary, a position which does not constitutionally exist, and wished to return to the role full time, but when this was not initially agreed to he sought to speak to other parties in opposition on defecting. I did not hear the discussions directly, but instead through a trusted source, and so I may have misunderstood they they relayed to me, but this is as I understood the situation


Given the severity of the accusations being made against government leadership, we have approached the Prime Minister for comment. We clarified that our source (Mr Barnaby) was not prepared to release the screenshots publicly but could be shared with the Prime Minister because of the accusations. Our discussion was held bearing that in mind. The Prime Minister went on to say that the comments made by the Home Secretary were “deeply hurtful and personally upsetting”, citing that his actions were to give Mr Eddy time to tend to personal matters and did not expect to be repaid by being compared to a situation that was “exploitative and an abusive legal agreement.” The future of the Home Secretary remains uncertain, no doubt the revelations have left serious conversations to be held in Rose Leadership chats and in the PWP, noting that the PM cannot see how he and Mr Eddy can both continue to serve in this government after such a “deeply hurtful comparison.” Mr YonedaStan has made it clear that the comments made are beyond that of his capabilities of a leader, Mr Eddy had made comments on his personal character too.

On the point of such words being a betray, the Prime Minister has made it clear he has personally been betrayed and that if the floating of a VoNC in the government whilst serving in cabinet and not immediately resigning to declare those intentions, was not a betrayal, then he is not sure what it is. On the final point regarding an apology, Mr YonedaStan, on this occasion noted that he owed C! members an apology in this case.

The transcript for the conversation is detailed below:

The Times: The Times has received exclusive leaks regarding the Home Secretary looking to defect to certain parties. In them, he has claimed that yourself and his fellow co-leader have treated him in such a way akin to the recent free Britney trend. Would the prime minister be able to comment?

KYS: I find this deeply hurtful and personally upsetting. Having stood up for the Home Secretary on numerous occasions, including the recent rumours regarding defection, I can not help but feel betrayed. The Acting Home Secretary arrangement was intended to give the Home Secretary time to deal with personal matters before returning to their role, during a time where they were borderline unreachable. To compare an act of what was frankly generosity on a political with an exploitative and abusive legal arrangement... frankly I don't have many words other than hurtful to describe it.

I am sure the PWP will have an internal discussion about this flirtations with serious defection regardless of who it alienated, and I will have my own conversation with coalition leadership on this matter.

The Times: I understand this occurred whilst Eddy was returning and was arranging this with yourself on resuming his role (as indicated it occurred on the 22nd). If that does change anything do let me know. Does this make the Home Secretary’s position tenable and would you anticipate any disciplinary action given the Home Secretary has avoided answering questions on communications during this week’s session?

KYS: Consultation with Government leadership will be absolutely necessary before any hard action is taken, speaking candidly, I see no way in which the Home Secretary and I can both continue serving this Government after the deeply hurtful comparison that was made. The Rose Coalition, and PWP membership in it, is absolutely essential to the well being of so many, but comparing me to an exploitative conservator is an indictment in me not only as a leader, but as a person. It either holds water or it doesn't.

The Times: That’s understandable, thanks for your response. The Conservatives have revealed they received a similar suggestion from the Home Secretary to defect to them, and the source provided shows that the Home Secretary would look into VoNCing the government. Do you have any idea on what grounds the Home Secretary would have achieved this and whether this would suggest a much wider betrayal of government by a key component of government leadership?

KYS: I have absolutely no idea on what grounds this could have been achieved, and can only assume this lack of grounds was why it was not attempted. If 'betrayal' can not be used for the seeking of a VONC from within the Cabinet without immediately resigning or stating of one's intentions, then there really is no use for the word at all.

The Times: Mr Barnaby approached other people regarding the information, and claims to have done so more because of the point of being accused of lying implicitly in press. Whilst it was originally reported as a threat to resign, and it would appear later clarification on Frosty’s part would suggest they misunderstood (correct me if I’m wrong), and thus mr Barnaby feels that he was treated unfairly on this point. Does the Prime Minister have much to say on this point in retrospect or should the evidence been published sooner?

KYS: Its a difficult situation given that Frosty's article had so many other clear errors that warranted retracting. It was not even particularly apparent on face which party the defection was for, given the discrepancy between the comments and the articles author. That being said, I do believe I owe C! members an apology for heated words during this dispute - I try my best to stand with those I think are my friends, and in this case it was completely misapplied.


The Times has also approached Mr Lokan on the issue, and Mr Lokan declined to comment.

An anonymous source messaged The Times regarding the ordeal and has simply said “People should be upfront and honest about their issues, needs or desires, and work constructively to meet a solution.” Communication often plagues governments of all colours, and this is perhaps one of the most damning in how things can escalate if issues are not communicated on the offset.

As a result of these revelations, Mr Eddy has tonight been sacked as Home Secretary and replaced by his co-leader Mr Lokan. The information presented here was written and accurate before the knowledge of any sacking would occur.


r/ModelTimes • • Sep 09 '18

London Times The Wagbo_ Conversation- AnswerMeNow1 sits down with the newly anointed Chancellor

4 Upvotes

Today, AnswerMeNow1, a writer for the Times, sat down with the Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrats and the brand new chancellor, /u/Wagbo_, at his modest cottage in rural Montgomeryshire.

A: Good morning! As your government does not command a majority, how will you attempt to pass legislation?

W: As a group of Liberals, whether we had a majority or not, our belief is in co-operation and compromise. Modern democracies across Europe have a governmental system that is based in working across the house to find solutions to the problems that the nation faces. That is what we will be pursuing. There is no use in a government with barely a quarter of the house trying to force through an agenda that the majority cannot agree on - so we will make legislation a collaborative process, and try and use our time in government to pursue reforms that we have a strong enough case for to win over the house.

A: Are there any specific groups you'd prefer to work with?

W: Moderates and liberals can be found in all parties, save perhaps for the NUP. Last term, I was part of a team of Liberals that worked with the Tories to get a budget through the House, when they were in a comparable situation. We've worked and served in government with Labour and the Greens before. It is hard to ignore that the Classical Liberal side of the coalition share some heritage with the Libertarians. As someone on the centre-left of British politics, in a government of the centre, it would be foolish to say that we are going to go it alone - who exactly we will go with will depend on the stances of the other parties more than our own.

A: What if your government can't find support among parties?

W: If the rest of the house were to refuse to work with us, what can I say? We would fall, that is democracy. I would find that rather saddening, as I feel that our democracy has come on leaps and bounds since adopting proportional representation, and a more consensus based system has worked well when it has been operated to the fullest. That said, I think it is very unlikely that none of the other members of the house would be willing to work with us, especially given much of our agenda is, as will be revealed in the Queen's Speech tomorrow morning, quite agreeable for the vast majority of members.

A: What do you expect to come out of the declaration of the Working Peers?

W: In truth, I'm not quite sure, it would be good to have a more proactive House of Lords, though, should they wish to justify their continued existence (perhaps a debate for another day). My hope is that the members of the Welsh Liberals who I am aware have applied, and I have taken enormous pleasure in working with over the last few years, will be able to do their best for Wales by earning their peerages. Wales needs a bigger voice at Westminster, that has always been a cause I have stood behind, and for - it would be good if we could play a part in that.

A: Speaking of Wales, what do you think of Plaid Cymru and the possibility of an independence referendum?

W: The last election was very troubling for my nation. Wales had two Liberal MPs, two Plaid Cymru MPs, and a Labour MP, before it - we now see four Plaid MPs sit alongside me, the solitary Liberal. Whilst that may seem grim for the union at a glance, we must remember that they are hugely overrepresented, having polled under 50% of votes across the constituencies, and only nabbing the seat that I contested, Mid & North Wales, by a hair.

I doubt that Plaid would pursue an independence referendum until they were to have a First Minister, and lead a government in Wales, which they are yet to do. That said, they are strong, and the independence movement is more mobilised than it has been in a very long time. We need a united liberal voice in Wales as soon as possible, and we need to put the case forward for a reformed union, not a broken one, in more evocative and poetic terms than we have had to before. Rui is doing a very good job as Leader of Dem Rhydd at starting that process.

A: What's one of your key goals in this government?

W: As Chancellor, my philosophy is going to be simple - get our economy moving. We have had years of financial restraint beyond that which has been necessary. We need to spend again! Britain suffers from weak wage growth and productivity in no small part due to chronic underinvestment post-recession. I'm not going to go out of my way to criticise past governments - my priority is getting to work on getting a sensible consensus across the house that will allow us to pass a budget that focuses on growth, on our issues with productivity, on a fairer tax regime, and on making life better for the vast majority.

Being at 11 Downing Street is a great challenge, but an even greater opportunity to do real, genuine good for the people of this country. That is a huge privilege, and I want to be sure that my time at the Treasury isn't wasted.

A: Is there any specific colleagues outside of government you're looking forward to working with?

W: I've got a very worthy opponent in my Shadow Chancellor, Toast - it's been quite heartening to see a set of reasonable economists be appointed to be their party representatives on finance overall, actually. My time in the house last term was useful for building those sorts of bridges, and I hope that I'm taking a good working relationship with parties as diverse as the Libertarians and Plaid Cymru into this government.

A: Finally, how do you think the independent groupings (One Love, New Britain, People's Action) will fare? All have parliamentary representation, I understand, in one form or another?

W: I've got a lot of admiration for the independent MPs in parliament, as I always have, having been the sole Futurist in the house before. Perhaps I still see myself as somewhat of an outsider, despite where I've ended up. I was sad to see One Love not manage to win Hampshire North last time, having given them a Lib Dem endorsement, but they have a very worthy MP down in Sussex. New Britain are a spot more concerning on Europe, though seem to be a voice worth having. The PAP are one of the more intelligent and academic independent groups that have had any success, so they're the ones I'm keeping the closest eye on.

A: Thank you very much for this.

W: Diolch yn fawr iawn!



r/ModelTimes • • Aug 20 '16

Europe Times [Op-Ed] The lengthy explanation of the motives and truths behind the former PM of Sweden, /u/Wakerius

6 Upvotes

The lengthy explanation of the motives and truths behind the former PM of Sweden, /u/Wakerius

Dear readers,

In all this aftermath, I've been trying to get my side - my point of view - to the public. By now you've certainly both heard and know that I've been replaced and I've quit the modelworld. But I truly want you to understand what happened and why I did it. You see, I already ruled Sweden. I already achieved my personal goals. And in real life, things have been looking up for me greatly, thus reducing my time with projects like these. So at first I wasn't even planning on being the prime minister next term - my plans were to have maybe a small position on some council but nothing of magnitude.

Trough my achievements I also got bored because I realized that in my way to power in Sweden I had gathered very strong alliances that'd keep me and those who allied with me in power - most likely secured even though we'd have elections.

I wanted to challenge myself, because everything was starting to feel boring to me - the simulation - because IRL I'm climbing politically (even president of a local party) and then it gets a bit dull to simulate it - I hope you see where I come from.

So I said to myself - fuck it, ride or die. Conquer the modelworld or get pushed into retirement. I actually wanted the latter, make no mistake.

The New Wake Order, the plan was called - had two phases on a global scale. The first one was, through democracy and work of coalitions, bring together a smoother mEU - what I mean by this is that in a simulation and the number of people we are - we are but a fragment of the real EU and thus cannot work on the same level as the EU in it's bureacracy. We desperately needed an overhaul there - a simplification of due process - and again underlining a democratic one at that.

The second phase would be to try to now turn this new mEU, built upon a better foundation - into an autocratic empire. However - this phase hadn't begun and wouldn't begin for a good while.

I got caught and by all means that's not really a surprise, something I expected along the way. After all, I wanted out. And a "Here's my resignation"-card isn't really my style.

However, some people, yes I'm looking at you, JerryLeRow and SabasNL - are trying to shadow their own shit under the Wakegate. What I mean by that is that SabasNL is trying to achieve a story that the mEU in it's current state is due to me - not because he was a failed and powerhungry (ironic coming from the would-be-autocratic-emperor, right?) and biased fool of a head mod.

Do not blame the mEU failures we've had thus far on my little event, because I played no part in trying to make anyone's life in mEU harder. ModelSweden has a large support to exit the mEU but even though I could have done it, I never did Swexit. I even stated in an interview, with sdfghs (https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelTimes/comments/4rztmw/interview_with_the_swedish_pm_uwakerius/) that I would not exit Sweden from the mEU or cause the mEU any turmoil whatsoever. Again, the NWO Phase One was always - to save the mEU, by the power of democracy through coalitions on a national level - nothing more, nothing less.

That's the story, the truth of the matter, as people try to play the nice guys now that they have a scapegoat to blame everything on. Yes, you have the right to see me as a villain, but don't forget the rest of the monsters out there - using my villainy to make them look innocent and harmless. This is however, my final input on the matter - and as such, my final post in the model world. Good luck to you, the player.

Sincere regards, Wake


r/ModelTimes • • May 06 '20

London Times Times investigation reveals The Telegraph's illicit offers of payment for leaks

6 Upvotes

A Times investigation discovered today that a journalist at The Telegraph, /u/Friedmanite19, routinely offers substantial sums of money to whistleblowers in order to receive confidential leaks.

The investigation revealed that in two instances The Telegraph was prepared to offer sums of up to £45,000 to Labour MPs in exchange for privileged information from within Labour headquarters.

In journalism it is generally seen as at best bad practice, and at worst extremely unethical, to offer money for information. This is for a variety of reasons, not least of which is to avoid accusations of bribery and the contamination of information should the matter ever reach a courtroom. Furthermore, paying for information may result in a scenario where the informer will provide information they think the journalist wants to receive, instead of providing leaks in good faith.

After receiving evidence of one offer of payment for information, The Times engaged Labour MP /u/rexrex600 to help with the investigation. During the course of a conversation with /u/Friedmanite19, /u/rexrex600 was almost immediately offered £25,000 for information on a non-existent vote of no confidence in the Labour leader. /u/Friedmanite19 then upped his offer to £40,000 “if [the leak] is good”, before settling on £45,000. When /u/rexrex600 added more flesh to the bones of his ‘scoop’, /u/friedmanite19 said it “sounds like I’m getting my money’s worth”.

This further highlights the trap of offering money for information, because at this juncture this Labour MP would be incentivised to embellish and perhaps even to mislead the journalist in order to receive a substantial monetary reward, therefore corrupting any public interest justification for publishing the leak. Whether or not an organisation that offers money for information would then conduct due diligence on any leaks is unclear.

This investigation shines a light on The Telegraph’s recent media activities, having received a substantial leak themselves yesterday in order to break a story around a Labour Party discipline inquiry. Senior sources within the Labour Party suspect that an as-yet-unidentified Labour member was persuaded with money by The Telegraph to leak information about the inquiry.

The Times contacted /u/Friedmanite19 to ask him what he makes of the result of the investigation, and he immediately dismissed the allegation as “irrelevant”.

Update (12.11pm):

The Telegraph refused to comment on this report.


r/ModelTimes • • May 01 '20

London Times The good, the bad and the ugly or why Britain needs to be honest with its history [Op-Ed]

6 Upvotes

When I was growing up I used to spend a significant amount of time travelling to my grandfather's house in Liverpool, and during those family trips, I remember that he always had an extensive library filled full of non-fiction books spanning various historical periods, and also a large collection of quality historical documentaries that I used to watch with my father.

It was through these readings and viewership that I first gained an admiration of history, first through the gaze of documentaries detailing the Fall of France and the horrors of the Great Patriotic War but then through books detailing the saga of the Roman Republic and the Roman Empire, an interest that was sparked through a visit to Colchester Castle and the Roman exhibit that still exists underneath it, a nice nod to the fact that Colchester was once considered to be the capital of Roman Britain.

It was perhaps that rich connection to a large supply of informational material on a wide range of historical subjects that led to me becoming incredibly disappointed when I returned to primary and later secondary school education, as the history lessons of both subjects tended to be restricted to the history of the monarchy and both the First and the Second World War, and while these are valid moments of history took together I believe that focusing on these points entirely was a massive mistake.

While I believe that the sacrifices of those that fought in both the First and the Second World War shouldn't be forgotten, and we should certainly learn more about the struggles that were endured on the Home Front I believe that we are doing a disservice to current and future generations by focusing on the positive moments and not also reminding people that Britain has not always been a force for freedom and good in the world.

If more people understood the violence that the United Kingdom orchestrated against the indigenous people of Australia and Aotearoa New Zealand, the number of people killed during famines in Ireland and what was then called British India or the role that the British Empire played in the establishment and continuation of the slave trade then would they continue to hold the rather incorrect viewpoint that Britain has always been a shining example of good?

In the past, I have heard people say that teaching people about the negative elements of our history is somehow anti-British, as if by informing people that we committed atrocities against the people of Aotearoa New Zealand that the role we played in the development of space flight would be simply forgotten. I take the opinion that when we inform people as to the negative parts of our history that it brings those good parts into context, for example, while Britain was involved in the establishment and continuation of the slave trade it was also instrumental in its dissolution, and the role of the West Africa Squadron which captured some 1,600 slave ships is far often overlooked and its positive contribution to world history is something that would be a welcome addition to history classes.

By refusing to recognise that Britain has not always been a shining example of freedom and human rights, these people are not just insulting the memory of those who suffered under terrible acts committed under the British flag but they also do a disservice to those that have done our nation and people proud, as it is only with the context of our mistakes that we can truly recognise our honourable deeds.

ARichTeaBiscuit is the current Leader of the Labour Party, Leader of the Opposition and the MP for Merseyside.


r/ModelTimes • • Apr 11 '20

Tory Leadership Special: The Times meets _paul_rand_

1 Upvotes

The penultimate candidate in our Tory Leadership Special interviews is /u/paul_rand, the Education Secretary. Formerly a Libertarian Party member, he rose to the position of Party President before he was expelled from the Party in January 2019 over allegations he attempted to coup leader /u/Friedmanite19. Having subsequently joined the Conservatives, the MP for Northumbria has been a mainstay in Tory Cabinets ever since. But is the leap to the top job a bridge too far for /u/paul_rand? The Times spoke to him earlier this evening.

UH: /u/paul_rand, thank you for joining me. What are your core ideological principles?

PR: My core ideological principle is one nation conservatism. Some people might consider that just to be a soundbite but when we look at what it really is, it’s a comprehensive ideological framework.

For me, one nation conservatism is an ideology where the core tenet is the power of the individual, it then considers how by empowering the individual we can empower the community and vice versa. We, as one nation conservatives, support equality of opportunity as expressed through the free market with minimal state intervention. And we always take a long term, pragmatic view on the key battles of our age

UH: What’s the most pressing issue facing the party at the moment? How are you going to solve it?

PR: Lack of vision, plain and simple. It’s lack of vision that has lead to every single problem we face, lack of activity? Because we don’t know where we stand. Lack of accountability? Because no one is inspired to hold key figures to account. Lack of coherence? Again from a lack of vision.

The way I’d solve this is simple. I’d use myself as a model. If one looks at my work as education secretary they can see that I have clear agendas I work on, there is always an end goal in mind. I don’t pick policies and fit agendas to them, I start with the agenda and I fit policies to them. That’s what’s been missing, in my manifesto I’ve provided details on a process that will help us to develop agendas in each policy areas which could allow us to deliver a coherent and comprehensive vision.

If you want to know what that’d look like I’d refer you to my time as education secretary, curriculum reform for breadth, depth and rigour, equality of opportunity through a reformed schools budget and hopefully we can see accountability reform by the end of this term, and of course ensuring that schools are properly staffed and resourced. You can see evidence of all these themes in my work as education secretary and I’d seek to apply this to every policy area. Multi term projects with a clear end goal

UH: What - if any - reforms would you make to the internal party machinery?

PR: When I joined the party, I was in awe at the machinery we had, it’s had a bit of wear and tear and it’s slowly grinding to a halt. It’s not too late to fix it.

I think having a functioning and sustainable press office is vital, and I think that would be a Major first port of call for us, press can very quickly set the narrative, and it’s important for us to dominate the narrative if we are going to maintain our position as the premier force in British politics, announcing and supporting a new press officer who has the experience, commitment and consistency to deliver the coherent press strategy I’ve outlined in my manifesto would be one of my first ports of call.

Secondly, once we’ve devised our agendas for each department we are going to need a policy platform to back it up so the chair is going to have a big job In ensuring we have the long term policy strategies (likely over multiple manifestos ) to deliver our end points. That’s going to be a big job and we should make sure the chair has everything they need to do that, whether that be a vice or just support from leadership.

UH: Who are our natural bedfellows in coalition?

PR: Well I think the plural in the question gives it away. We have two natural partners as a centre right party.

To the centre we have the Liberal Democrats who have proven themselves to be immensely reliable, productive and amicable partners in coalition. I think any leader would be fatally unwise to alienate them in anyway. Whether we win or lose the VoNC, they must remain close partners.

And to the right, we have the LPUK. Relations have taken a hit sure, but it’s nothing that’s irreparable. If we look at the noises out of the LPUK, it’s our lack of vision that has put them off, they don’t know what we stand for and thus they feel as if we abandon them and then use them. That’s why I, as I expressed in my manifesto, a key element of repairing relations must be being clear about what we stand for.

I’ve been part of a healthy relationship with the LPUK firsthand in Scotland, and that was predicated on us being open and clear with the LPUK about what we believed, none of this “we’ll agree to it only to repeal it a term later”. We lose respect, principle and anger our natural partners when we do that.

UH: Who are your greatest political inspirations?

PR: From the time before the events that lead to the current state of the House of Commons, I’d name Liz Truss, Michael Gove and David Cameron as some of my key inspirations. Liz Truss especially for me showed how one nation conservatism can be combined with a solid influence of both liberalism and libertarianism, and how conservatism is as principled as it is pragmatic. Obviously Gove’s effectiveness as a political operator and his views on education have enticed me. And Cameron would be a model for me to follow if I were to become Prime Minster, of how a vision based in the principles of one nation conservatism can deliver no matter the political climate.

Since joining the Conservative party I have had the great privilege to see real figures who will be remembered in British history for their monumental impact up close and personal and their impact upon me and the inspiration they give me is immense. Figures like u/InfernoPlato and u/DrCeasarMD who have a wealth of experience under their belt and are as firm as they are fair when providing guidance, but also more recently figures such as u/eelsemaj99 and u/model-mili who are also monumental figures and who remain as candid with me as others when they provide guidance. I am privileged to consider some of my greatest inspirations as good friends.

UH: You were expelled for plotting against your leader in your last party. Don’t we need a leader who will be rowing in the same direction as his colleagues, not trying to coup them for personal gain?

PR: That question is unfortunately based on a faulty base. There are three problems with this:

1 - It was by no means for personal gain, there were dangerous individuals in the party who threatened to drag the LPUK to a dangerous place, I’m sure if you look at the full screenshots you would be able to see that in reality I was more concerned about getting the dangerous individuals in question out of an otherwise sound party, These individuals were damaging to the party and were given too many chances and me and the other individual implicated wanted nothing more than the stability of the party

2 - The evidence that was used by the party leader had been cropped to rig the vote, something confirmed by senior LPUK figures to me privately at the time as you would be able to see on the old MTwitter, I voluntarily released the full screenshots to the public for scrutiny as I personally had nothing to hide

3 - I’d deny that we were at a stage where it could be considered a coup, we were just making sure we had our hand right if the party leadership was not willing to take action against divisive individuals who were harming our party repeatedly.

Do I think the issue was regrettable, absolutely. Do I want to move on from it, absolutely. Has progress been made on moving on from it, once again absolutely me and Fried [/u/Friedmanite19] have worked together in 2 Westminster governments and a Scottish government.

I am a leader who is more than capable of rowing in the same direction as my colleagues that’s exactly why I’m one of only candidates who is repeatedly emphasising the collaborative nature of the formation of a vision, it’s not for me to decide, it’s for the party.

As leader, my interest will only be that of the nation and the party.

UH: What’s to stop you betraying your new party in the same way? Can your deputies be confident that you won’t try something underhand like you did in the LPUK?

What’s to stop anyone betraying their party that way? The fact that they know me as a person and that I haven’t actually ever done anything underhanded whilst they’ve known me, I’ve always been loyal to the party line and leadership. Not only can my deputies be confident, but the whole party can be confident that I will continue to behave above reproach as I always have, the incident in the LPUK, when dealt with in a nuanced manner amounted to nothing more than two party members discussing how to remove dangerous members (reminder that this was within my remit as party president at the time), what would happen if the party leader revoked power granted to me by a clear democratic mandate and life after Friedmanite retires. While my rhetoric may have been regrettable and there was times my temper was inflamed with Friedmanite, I hold that what I did was not a coup attempt. But fundamentally I think everyone involved would like to move on since my clear track record of loyalty to the party speaks more volumes than an incident which attracted the LPUK, notably not me, more criticism

UH: You’ve spoken a great deal about one nation conservatism, as have a lot of candidates. Aren’t you being a bit disingenuous given that until last year, you were a Libertarian?

Well that’s an interesting question. When I was in the libertarians I was definitely considered a significantly more moderate leaning member, to the point the term “liberaltarian” was more appropriate.

Now that makes the question more about what the difference is between a “liberaltarian” and a one nation conservative and I’d argue it’s more about the lens through which one views the same ideas. Libertarians tend to view things through a more ideological lens, and that’s totally acceptable and I did used to view things through a more ideological lens. But now I would argue that serving in government and seeing the places where real change happens, seeing how real change happens, makes your views change. It forces you to consider practicality, and that makes you more pragmatic naturally.

So no, I don’t think that’s disingenuous. Of course everyone’s views shift slightly as the climate changes and due to increasing personal experience but the only fundamental change I’d argue has happened is that I see the issues through a more long term and pragmatic lens.

UH: So this sudden change to a more centre-right ideology isn’t you pandering to Tory members, then?

If this was sudden and unexpected you could argue that, but I don’t think anyone would realistically argue that I haven’t become more pragmatic and willing to compromise since I’ve entered into government. Tory members who know me personally will know that I hold my principles dear and will always strive for them with vigour. If I was pandering members would see through it.

Having said that, I do think a degree of ideological flexibility is required, and I can appreciate that, as with any leader, at times my views may differ from the parties on a specific issue. If elected, it is my duty to be a leader that follows the vision as decided by the party.

So no, I don’t think there has been a sudden change, I think it’s been a gradual shift and I think it finished many months ago, as I’m sure my recorded positions will show

UH: You spend a whole page talking about the LPUK and a potential coalition in your manifesto, relegating the Lib Dems to just one paragraph. Isn’t that a bit of an insult to the party we are currently in Government with?

Without meaning any offence I’d argue that’s an incredibly misinformed question. It completely ignores the political landscape that we find ourselves in. There are very significant problems in our relationship with the LPUK that need to be rectified and I had to make proposals on how to do so. That’s very different to the situation with the Lib Dems where all I have to say is that they have been brilliant coalition partners and we must keep them close and not alienate them, as some would do, with their approach to relations with the LPUK by not being clear with them when it matters.

If anything I’d argue the Liberal Democrats should take it as a sincere compliment.

UH: Your manifesto talks about a more active press strategy, but aren’t we already doing that? We have The Spectator, /u/Yukub writing in The Times, InfernoPlato producing posters - what’s missing here?

Once again, nuance. A more active press strategy. I’m not saying there’s no press, and I’m not saying that it isn’t improving. Luckily the rises in labour polling, VoNC and this Leadership election have motivated us a bit and the next leader will have some energy to work with. But let’s not let good enough become the enemy of better. We need more reactive press statements setting out the party narrative directly, the last press release was 80 days ago, in 80 days a hell of a lot has happened. And if this VoNC means we become the official opposition we will need to be the dominant force in the press holding the government to account and showing a way forward that is better than the coalition of chaos that labour will cobble together.

There’s once again one key thing missing: direction. There’s no direction, we are trying to cobble together a press strategy and individuals are doing their part but we need to have a clearly directed and orchestrated strategy otherwise we will lose control of the narrative.

I think any leader who wouldn’t want us to do significantly better than we are doing right now would be leading the party on a bad path.

UH: Shouldn’t you practice what you preach? /u/BrexitGlory has been very active in the press, even before this leadership race, Yukub as well - when was the last time you posted in the press before this leadership contest?

Well before this leadership contest I’d started work on a detailed press piece on the VONC that will be finished and promptly come out before the vote commences as the intention is to sway the undecided. It’s something we’ve all had our problems with, but I’d argue that it’s not necessarily individual press activity that is the problem, which is what I’ve just said. It’s the lack of direction, it’s the lack of coordination. I have experience with the press, transparency and accountability is something I took personal responsibility for as deputy first minister in Scotland and it was a key plan of my administration as leader of the Scottish conservatives, I know the benefits of a solid press strategy and direction is how you achieve one

UH: But you don’t know when you last did anything in the press?

PR: I’m aware of the last thing I did in the press yes, As CEO of the Financial Times I provided detailed analysis of our electoral fortunes based on constituency polling back in January, we were working on a comprehensive piece on Brexit after the issues with u/vitiating but that collapsed with the change in government.

UH: What I’m getting at is the idea that you simply aren’t active enough to be leader. Former PM and party leader eelsemaj99, whose judgement I’m sure we both respect greatly, gave you just 2.5/5 for activity in his assessment of the candidates. 4 months since your last press post, regarded as inactive by your colleagues - do you really have the commitment to keep us at the top?

PR: I don’t honestly believe that I am regarded as inactive. If you once again deal with the nuance of what my good friend said, he said he was worried about the consistency, not the quantity. So let’s look at that in the run up to this campaign, historically yes it’s been a problem due to my well documented struggles with mental illness, but as these issues are being ameliorated you can see the consistency increase.

Just before the last election, I produced an extensive, and heavily researched white paper to allow the commons to debate on it, I’ve heeded the concerns raised and I’m now working on an improved version. Around and During the election, there was a one off family emergency unrelated to the problems that have been regarded as a cause of my inactivity, this has been the only recent blip . As a senior member of the Scottish government I have been focused significantly on the infrastructure and green investment strategy which will be presented to Parliament in the new few weeks and even after considering my extensive commitments in Holyrood, which would be reduced if I were to be elected, I still score third in terms of Commons word count as pointed out by none other than BrexitGlory. So I’d argue that if we are really actually worried about commitment, you can see an extensive and recent track record before this election of activity and commitment.

So absolutely, I do have the commitment, I have the energy and importantly I have the ideas with the most detailed manifesto of any candidate. Furthermore, if we are to consider the specifics of the article in question, the endorsement was given to someone who has a lower Commons word count since the QS than me, and had a marginally higher activity score due to his longer presence, I don’t think my activity is at all a problem for people to get behind me and trust me to lead them

UH: Do you have anything else you’d like to say?

PR: Well I’d like to give a summary of what my responses are to the issues you’ve raised. Can you trust me as your leader? ask yourself and I’m sure you’ll find the answer to be yes. Have I shown ideological consistency? Absolutely. Am I active enough? Hell yes, I’m active enough. I think the manner in which I’ve been able to competently deal with every possible flaw that you could have drawn attention to, shows that I can be your leader.

But I’d like to remind people that it is not just my skills as a leader that make me the right choice, it is my comprehensive strategy that I have set out in my manifesto. I am the right choice to reignite the flame of conservatism and I urge every member of my party to heed my call to arms.

UH: /u/paul_rand, thank you very much.

PR: Thank you for the opportunity.


/u/UnexpectedHippo is a Conservative MP, as well as being Executive Director (Operations) at The Times. This is the fourth in a series of interviews, which aims to sit down with all leadership candidates before voting opens on Monday 13th April. You can see the previous interviews in the series with Yukub here; /u/MerrilyPutrid here; /u/model-willem here.


r/ModelTimes • • Jun 23 '20

Churchill and Travelers: LPUK's Week

1 Upvotes

In this confusing week for Libertarian politics, I decided to sit down with former LPUK member Geordie and talk to them about recent events that lead to the aforementioned former label being affixed to their title. They came with an entire binder full of documentation, extensively laying out their perspective. The following is a hybrid interview/report interspersed with the images and documents provided to the Times. The interview questions are italicized, the answers in quotes, and in bold will be Friedmanite’s responses when asked to comment.

Let’s go from the top. Why’d you join LPUK?

“I was involved in frequent messaging calls from Friedmanite during my time in the NUP. It was after the election scandal about the manifesto, and the subsequent rebranding back to the NUP that it was time to leave the Loyalist League to mark another fresh chapter. This was about a rebranding to become the NUP again, which prompted the decision.”

Relevant links here

“It shows he was pressing for it for a while.”

So you joined LPUK for a fresh start. Did you find it different than LL? Positively?

“I was more involved in the LPUK the first time than I ever was in the LL. The LL for me was sort of a retirement home where there were no obligations - like-minded people could do as they pleased, put as much effort or as little into politics and enjoy a relaxing time together. I was Leader of the Lords in term 11 and loved the question sessions, the questions were always so jovial and designing manifestos and graphic work for press was exhilarating too. It was a fresh start and I'd like to have thought it ended on a positive note like last time.”

So in this most recent stint within LPUK, what sorts of things did you do?

“Very little! I was asked a few times to provide graphic work for the Press sub, which I was hesitant to do due to issues with the software but leadership were forgiving on that front. It was around the time when the need for press evolved from posters to press articles, so my services were less needed. Apart from that there were no obligations on my end so I could debate as little or as much as I wanted. I rarely did - the traveller bill was the first main instance I expressed myself since leaving the Loyalists.”

What did you think about internal LPUK culture during your tenure?

“They're entitled to their view and for the most part I wasn't engaged enough to care about how they conducted themselves. The LPUK has a known reputation amongst various parties for being outspoken and it's a quality that can be good for opposing the government, and to their credit moderated themselves whilst in government. There's nothing I can criticise about the internal culture, they're a highly active bunch and are passionate about reforming Britain in the name of libertarianism - or however they'd define themselves.”

You mentioned them being moderate in government. Outside of government, is this different?

“They're more outspoken as I said in opposition since harsher words are more effective when your role is to oppose a party in power. It makes them appear more electable if they're so resistant and have a strong backbone to matters, whilst in government the focus shifts on implementing their Queen's Speech and minimising attacks from their opponents.”

What are some examples you think of harsher words?

“I'll go look for specifics, but the fear of consequences is certainly submerged. The best places to find them are on controversial bills and the Queen's Speech though, since attacks can really be felt there.”

They proceeded to read out one of their examples

They have come for the statues of Winston Churchill, one of our nation's greatest leaders and a man whose role in the defeat of fascism has earned him honors across the world. They have come for Lord Baden-Powell, a man whose positive legacy in the form of international scouting has touched the lives of countless boys and girls. They will not stop with those whose legacy includes slavery, they have already come for those who are outside of it." + "This is an assault by radical ideologues on the very history and culture of our nation."

“ [This] is quite telling. Though in that debate Friedmanite took a balanced approach to things saying he sympathised with some of the points raised.”

“The pulled Churchill statue motion was unbalanced, it took a positive approach to his actions without consideration of the darker truths to his past. That's a legislative example where they pulled a bill after extensive worries from opposition groups.”

“It's all strategy I feel, they can adapt to supporting more or less if they need the support of “another party later down the line. Mending relations with the Conservatives for instance would hint at future ambitions for government and a toned down approach would conceal any hidden conflictions about their relations.”

They then proceeded to discuss their clashes with Friedmante over moderating the Scottish branch of their party.

“Discredits what I said about mending relations, but it shows he's outspoken and consequences are of little importance whilst in UO. Their choice to act as they please: it was my moderating as Scottish Libertarians leader which was the catalyst for moderating the national party in June 2019. Substantial moderation to the point I was happy to work with anyone if they wanted. Break down the political divide and build together policies to transform Scotland - I allowed a TLC deal to be put to vote before Friedmanite was told. I do things without telling people, one of my biggest weaknesses!”

Friedmanite responded with, “I reject the notion the party "moderated" in June 2019, geordie had little influence over the writing of the national manifesto and national politics.”

They then noted Friedmanites response to their attempts to moderate, in which they advised a resignation.

It was at this point they moved back to the topic of Churchill, and I was given a copy of the Churchill motion added to the order paper then withdrawn. I was also provided a copy of what Geordie claims was the initial draft of the opening speech, which they claim was written by Friedmanite, as was the opening speech contained in the Churchill motion. When asked for comment, Friedmanite claimed that the opening speech on the motion was written by Jman, and what Geordie claims was the original opening speech was instead their own personal remarks on the matter that he intends to deliver in the house of commons when the party retables the motion, with the speech indeed including a reference from them thanking the author of the motion.

The original document, which describes Churchill as one who “shaped a modern Western World that recognized discrimination and segregation as an abominable practice,” admits that “while commonplace, his views were racist based on contemporary understanding, and his actions during the Bengal famine were flawed.”

On the subject of potential controversy of the speeches contents, Friedmanite replied “the Churchill motion is still being tabled, the author submitted it before we could add further amendments to it. This is really a non-story, the LPUK will be submitting this motion to the House of Commons, we are building on a draft motion to ensure it takes into account history and is nuanced.”

The opening speech is noticeably different from the disputed draft, which at the request of Friedmanite will not be published here in full, which contains the assertion that.

“there was no deliberate murdering on Chruchill’s part and he did eventually send the necessary relief.”

Additional attacks were made on the left, claiming:

“what’s interesting Mr Deputy Speaker is that people who have gone after statues of Churchill have been quiet on statues of Karl Marx and Engels who were racist and antisemetic. Will the same Left-wing MP’s rush to destroy Engels statue in Manchester or will they seek to protect them? It would be nice if violent protestors had a consistent agenda but I believe I’ll be waiting a long time. I’m also keen to see the Labour view on this given they were parading around this place expressing disgust that Donald Trump was allowed to speak in the same area as Churchill.”

These contributions were not in the final version, a fact noted by Geordie.

“The more balanced comments were added afterwards, if the history can be viewed then it'll show that.”

What do you think about the current Scottish libertarians? Do you think they are going to have the same challenges?

“I haven't paid much interest in devolution, but the party did wonderfully in the election and I think formed/or are forming a government with the Conservatives again, judging by the fact both are right-wing parties and the LPUK aren't standing a candidate. I don't think their challenges are on a wide a scale as the national party and for good reason, there's less interest in what happens in Scotland or Wales than what happens at Westminster. I wish them well, the Scottish wing was a pleasure to lead although at times it felt a little lonely being the sole representative bar 1 or 2 to do things”

We then move onto the most recent controversy, the debate over new legislation introduced by LPUK that would tighten laws related to trespassing, increasing the repeat offense window, and empowering police to enforce new laws against usage of public highways. Critics noted the negative impact of the bill on the traveler community, while advocates such as Greejatus insisted that the bill impacts everyone regardless of life background.

So let’s get to the meat and potatoes of why we are here today. Already, you had expressed criticism of the drafting process of the pulled Churchill motion. This new traveler bill comes out. What was the process of it being presented to the party before submission?

“The first I knew of the bill was it being read in Parliament, that's the extent of how disengaged I am with things. The opposition to the traveller bill had 3 key opponents, Vit, Trev and myself. It was always going to be divisive and I don't think the leadership saw it coming. They certainly didn't see my opposition coming, to the point where I was told by the leader I was undermining the party by expressing opposition to the bill, in a rather defiant fashion I'd say. However with bills they are shown to the party before submission where concerns can be read, it's how I was aware of the Churchill motion (that day I checked that particular chat). It had been submitted by that point since I saw a discussion on it so I asked what is was all about, and said it needed to be made more balanced... as everything should be.”

When asked about Geordie’s opposition to the bill, Friedmanite claimed ”the travellers bill was posted in the legislation and policy chat prior to its submission as our all of our bills. The fact he did not see this bill, shows how inactive and out of the loop he was.”

Any thoughts on the author of this bill, Mr Tarkin15?

“My past PM experiences with him has been very limited but cordial - the last message there was back in October. I hold nothing against any LPUK member since they are passionate for their version of a utopial society and will do whatever they can to achieve it. A relentless bunch they are. Unless he's been out in public being critical to me then I'd say I'm on good terms with him and everybody in that party. (Though he might've been the one who "absolute rubbish"ed my ‘I'm so sorry’ speech. I replied with a nice comeback to that).”

It was at this point that Geordie provided me with a copy of the Libertarian Parties code of conduct.

“There was no investigation, it was an immediate expulsion with no chance to defend myself - that said, there was no doubt it broke conduct rules ‘2. Comments harming the reputation of the party can result in a warning, investigation or suspension.”

Was this three strikes policy Im reading in here followed?

“I wasn't on any strikes before so that would be a no.”

This wouldn't have been the first time a row occurred over whether or not LPUK had followed disciplinary practices. The expulsion of now Conservative Party member Rand met similar contemporary criticism.

What motivated you to give the speech you did on the traveler bill?

“The feeling amongst the majority of the party was that the traveller bill would affect only those who were camping on unauthorised grounds, stressing that those who legally camped wouldn't be under any scrutiny if the bill was enacted. My speech was in reply to another made by a traveller who knows first experience the persecution that demographic has had. And maybe I'm being a bleeding heart and acting too compassionately, but we all want this utopian society and we should help resolve problems and not create them. Everyone has the same aim and it's the way we implement it that defines an ideology. I wasn't alone - in a band of 3 against the bill within the LPUK.”

Of the three, BigTrev publicly announced in the ongoing debate that they opposed the bill, the Times reached out to Lord Grantham, who as always, was succinct in their verdict, declaring the bill “disappointing, to put it nicely.” He added “if we aren’t listening to the police when they say they don’t want these powers, what’s the point?.”

Do you believe your expulsion was in part due to your opposition to the traveler bill?

“If it solely was then other expulsions would have swiftly happened. The expulsion was for placing the party into disrepute so to say.”

For your conduct on the travellers bill?

“I guess so.”

In response to these claims, Friedmanite asserted ”Geordie's expulsion had nothing to do with opposition to the travellers bill. We are are inclusive party with a broad range of viewpoints. The member for South Yorkshire is still an MP and a highly valued colleague of mine. Geordie was expelled for leaking internal party chats, we in the LPUK have a great community and support network and undermining that is intolerable. This expulsion had nothing to do with the legislation and everything to do with the fact he was a leaker.”

What would you say to members of your party wavering on this bill? Should they resign?

“I said actions speak louder than words in my speech and I'll reiterate that. That said, I didn't think the action would come from the party to expel me! Whether they do it privately or publicly it doesn't matter, the freedom of expression is a right everyone is afforded and should therefore be treated with the respect it deserves.”

As events develop around the most recently introduced LPUK bill, the words of Geordie will be noted by the political class as they observe the internal identity divides seen by their expulsion, and the remaining members of LPUK who may oppose said legislation will be paying particular attention.

Edit: Update was made to the article reflecting past expulsion criticisms faced by the party

Written by jgm0228's press persona


r/ModelTimes • • Jun 01 '20

Where Labour fail to oppose the LPUK step up [Op-Ed]

1 Upvotes

Recent opinion polls show my party, the Libertarian Party, sitting on 21.74%.For the first time in several terms, domination of British politics by the main two parties seems to be coming to an end. According to margin of error, we are within the reach of the Labour Party who, despite having a victory lap on a singular poll a matter of weeks ago, appear to be in crisis. Now presents a huge opportunity for our party and those who want to end the traditional two party system: we are within touching distance of challenging the ‘big two’ parties for second and indeed first place. It is becoming apparent that whilst Labour protest, bicker and shoot themselves in the foot, the LPUK are standing up and providing constructive opposition to this minority Conservative government,

Over the last few weeks, papers such as the Telegraph and Spectator have taken the Labour Party to the cleaners, and so Labour’s focus appears to have been figuring out how to stop the next gaffe or gain PR credibility. The Leader of the Opposition is often present but not involved. They were present but not involved in taking action when the member for Clydeside called a party led by a BAME politician pro-white and a racist. They were present but not involved in taking action when one of their members questioned whether a person of colour could be a billionaire. They were present but involved in taking action when the Shadow Chancellor attacked the free press and used sexual imagery to decry his opponents. They were present but not involved in taking action when their Shadow Defence Secretary defended fatwas calling for the deaths of British authors. Let us be under no illusions, the Labour party is not capable of opposition. Instead of focusing on the government, and finding ways to provide strong and sensible opposition in the national interest, they are focused on finding new and improved ways of putting their foot in their mouth at breakneck speed.

In the last week, the Leader of the Opposition had a chance to prove they were serious and could protect Britain's interests on the global stage. Instead they decided to virtue signal and protest. The Labour Party attack dogs rushed out to call the President of the United States a white supremacist and a fascist. These same attack dogs who, during Sunrise planned a visit and banquet for President Trump, and in the case of the Shadow Chancellor agreed to attend in order to avoid controversy and indeed asked for a good spot at the dinner.

I was very pleased to meet with the President of the United States to discuss several matters such as building a global coalition to stand up to China on human rights abuses, getting Ukraine into NATO - an organisation the Shadow Chancellor opposes - and a future trade deal. It’s clear that where the Leader of the Opposition has failed I have decided to do their job for them and the LPUK have taken the role of the opposition. The Labour Party leader abdicated their duty so my party proudly proudly stepped up to the plate.

Whilst the Clegg coalition was in office, the LPUK were pushing for transparency on Ambercare costings. Labour’s response was not to vote for scrutiny or the figures produced by the OECD. They were too busy celebrating this scheme to care about the costings. The LPUK led the way when it came to holding the government to account on childcare. I can guarantee if Sunrise found out that Ambercare was a poison pill the shadow chancellor would be the first to point it out and attack the tories.You saw Sunrise do the same with VAT. As always it's not credible opposition that Labour are interested in; instead, the Shadow Chancellor is busy batting for the government budget and doing a victory lap whilst those on the government laughed at him in surprise at how easily he rolled over.

The LPUK have set the narrative on foreign policy where Labour have followed, for example on Duterte. Whilst we met the US President, Labour protested. While we wish to get a comprehensive deal with Iran on ballistics, Labour wish to stand up for Tehran and question whether Iran that has killed British citizens is really a threat to us. Whilst Labour talk about the Satanic Verses and justify Iranian human rights abuses we are working with this government to stand up for human rights in the Commonwealth.

Every single government defeat this parliamentary term, bar justice devolution has been led by the LPUK. The LPUK understands how to build a cross-party coalition across the house, and we know how to be constructive and provide scrutiny. We understand that we won’t always agree with the government or foreign leaders on every issue but that it’s key to keep dialogue open. Labour are in crisis with weekly press scandals, they are a national disgrace and resort to gutter politics. Governments without a strong opposition are bad governments, and a strong opposition is required to ensure good governance. A good opposition needs to be taken seriously by the government and by the public and at the present time Labour are a national laughing stock. Whilst Labour bicker, u-turn and deal with their internal crises, the Libertarians have delivered the strong and co-operative opposition this country so desperately needs. The LPUK will be there fighting for the British people, while Labour continues to fight shadows.

This article was written by /u/Friedmanite19, Former Chancellor Of The Exchequer and Leader Of The Libertarian Party


r/ModelTimes • • Dec 11 '16

New York Times Wampum's World Volume 4: On the State Elections

1 Upvotes

Hey folks, I'm back! Sorry for the long absence. I figured it was time for a new article, so I decided I ought to write my opinions on the newly elected state governments and what we can expect from them.

Atlantic Commonwealth

Governor: RLP

Lt. Governor: Vacant

Legislature:

5 RLP

4 Dems

I'm a native New-Englander and it pains me to see the Commonwealth slip into a massive state-wide gulag. We can expect plenty of far left legislation coming into and potentially passing in the state that created S.A.I.C.A. In conclusion, RIP birthplace of American Democracy.

This State will be left-leaning to far left

Commonwealth of Chesapeake

Governor: Green Socialist

Lt. Governor: Vacant

Legislature:

3 RLP

3 Dems

3 GOP

The Eastern State has always been somewhat of a tossup, but it's clear that it's starting to lean left. The Democrats have an interesting opportunity here, since they lie in the center of the legislature. I imagine the leadership will end up being an alliance of the RLP and the Dems, but it'd really make me happy if we had a centrist coalition between the Dems and the GOP, I dunno, call me crazy.

This state will probably be center-left.

Dixie

Governor: GOP

Lt. Governor GOP

State Senate:

3 GOP

1 Lib

Legislature:

5 GOP

2 Lib

2 RLP

Oh Dixie, you haven for conservatism, I love thee so. Not much will change in Dixie. She'll continue to be firmly in the hands of the Republicans, with some backup in the libs and a minor opposition in the RLP.

This state will lean center-right to right.

Great Lakes

Governor: Lib

Lt. Governor: Lib

Legislature:

4 Lib

4 RLP

1 GOP

My state. In case you didn't know, I was one of the four Liberty legislators elected. While tight, this state will remain in the hands of Liberty and its ideology.

This state will be center-right

Midwestern State

Governor: Dist.

Lt. Governor: Dist.

Legislature:

Dist: 4

GSP: 4

/u/Cincinnatusofthewest: 1

The Midwest will probably remain under the leadership of the Distributists, since they control the executive and will likely have leadership over the Legislature. Our one independent legislator has an interesting opportunity here.

Expect center-right to right wing legislation here.

Western State

Governor: Dem

Lt. Governor: Dem

Legislature:

3 Dems

3 GOP

2 GSP

1 Dist

The Western State has always been a tossup, even though it's leaning left now. This state is in the same boat as chesapeake, but has one more right-leaning seat.

While it has a Democrat Executive and a left-leaning majority in the legislature, I predict the state will be centrist.


r/ModelTimes • • Dec 07 '16

London Times Duncs11 slammed in revealing UKIP interview

2 Upvotes

In a recent article for The Times, I asked a senior UKIP source for a quote on libertarianism on in MHoC. The comment I received has drawn attention from across the community. Under the promise of anonymity, the source agreed to speak to The Times today about the state of UKIP. The following replies are word-for-word accurate, with the source named E for anonymity:

UH: Thank you for agreeing to this, we recognise the risk you are taking by giving this interview. Without revealing too much, could you give us an idea of who you are?
E: Without giving too much detail, I am a senior party figure, MP and a member of the Shadow Cabinet.

UH: You are a member of UKIP. May I ask why you originally joined the party?
E: I joined UKIP because I believe in the core, traditional principles of the party: fighting for our independence from the European Union, an end to uncontrolled mass immigration and putting Britain and the British people, all of them, first.

UH: What has changed in the party since then to cause the harsh criticisms we heard previously?
E: In short, /u/Duncs11. The leadership of /u/Tyroncs stayed true to the Faragist policies that make up the real party – the party that people overwhelmingly join for. When Duncs took power, it all started to slowly change. While, at first, he seemed to also stay true to the founding principles, however, when I presume he became more confident in the throne, it became clear that he did not. Duncs openly supports complete freedom of movement—a completely contradictory policy to the real party and to the party that we advertise as. How can I justify, as a conservative and ‘Kipper, this policy? How can I defend it? It’s impossible, I, or maybe I should say we, must speak out more. What’s more, the slightest opposition to Duncs is seen by him as an NUP plot, or spies from the banned Vanguard members. For all intents and purposes, it is a dictatorship.

UH: Have you been tempted to defect? There are several non-libertarian right-wing parties - you could even stand as an independent. What is causing you to stay?
E: I have been tempted to defect. But I'd say I'm dedicated to the party and I've met too many good people, and made so many good friends in MHoCUKIP to leave. Maybe it is time to leave. We'll see.

UH: Would you say your view is one that is shared by your colleagues?
E: You might very well think that; I couldn't possibly comment.

UH: What do you think needs to change to make the party as attractive as it was when you joined?
E: A new leader. New ideas, new policies and a new manifesto. A complete reform of the party is needed. As a party, we should be trying to attract energetic, active members and giving party members more of a voice in decisions and policies.

UH: How likely do you think that change is? Is there anyone in the party you could see delivering that change?
E: 90% likely. I don't think it would be wise to say who could deliver it, however.

UH: UKIP has 13 seats, a leading place in the OO. Duncs11 was PM (albeit for a very short period) - he has taken the party past the Conservatives into being the biggest right wing party in the MHoC. Is Duncs not giving you more success than you would have without him?
E: It may be that way. But the Labour Party is successful , and so is the Green Party, and so is the RSP; but we do not follow their views. We are UKIP: the party of Farage and British independence, not the the Eurosceptic Liberal Democrats. What is more important to me and my fellow like-minded MPs than gaining high office - although I contest the suggestion that a traditional UKIP wouldn't be successful - is staying true, like I said before, to our core principles and the beliefs that this party was founded upon.

That concluded a very revealing interview with our UKIP MP. This will of course raise further questions for UKIP’s leadership. E stated that it is “90% likely” that change will happen in the party - is there perhaps a leadership battle ensuing behind the scenes in UKIP? Whatever happens, there seems to be at least one member of the party who is not happy with the direction of the party.

The Times will keep you updated on this story as it develops.


r/ModelTimes • • Nov 29 '16

New York Times [OP-ED] Comped's December State Election Predictions

2 Upvotes

The following opinions are strictly the opinion of the authors of this article and the Model Times organization as a whole does not openly sponsor the opinions of the authors.

The US State elections results are to be released on December 4th, or approximately 5 days from now. With all the coalition drama, one might have forgotten about that. I've taken the liberty to details what's up for grabs, who currently has what, and the possibilities...

Dixie: One of three states with a Governor up for grabs this time around. It will be a competitive race, as the new Liberty party is no longer working within the Sunrise Coalition. While /u/SolidOrangeGangsta has an incumbent advantage (and a large base of Republicans to vote for him in the state), his win is not as assured as in the past. It remains to be seen if we might see the first Liberty Governor of the state, assuming enough AJA Coalition members reside and vote in the state. It is certainly not a lock for the GOP by any means. Undecided.

Dixie also has a new upper house. This is certainly an experiment, as it is the first of its kind. Candidates include Dixie Supreme Court Justice /u/Lordfowl and longtime Assembly member /u/Trey_chaffin on the Republican side. On the Liberty side, they include /u/WIA16, the current nominee for Secretary of Defense, and /u/BroadShoulderedBeast, currently nominated for Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. GSP is also running 3 candidates (and the RLP is running 1). No party is running in all 4 districts, so there will be some sort of minority in the State Senate. Assuming the Republicans reelect their Governor, conventional wisdom says that they'll gain a majority, with a unknown, probably Liberty, minority. If not, then anything goes, and we could even see the GSP or one of the two independents (perennial candidate /u/theSolomonCaine, and former head mod /u/DidNotKnowThatLolz) gain a seat.

In the Assembly, it is a 3 party race. The GSP is not running anyone for the Assembly, however the RLP is running 2 candidates. Both the Republicans and Liberty are running 5 candidates. If the RLP wins a seat, it marks the return of the Broad Left to the South, where they haven't had any representation since the 5th Government. It is unlikely that only Republicans and Liberty will win seats, especially if the Broad Left turns out in numbers - they won a congressional seat during the federal elections here. That could transition to at least 1 seat in the Assembly. However, I predict a Republican majority.

Chesapeake: Governor /u/Oath2Order has decided not to run again this term, leaving Senator /u/MaThFoBeWiYo to head up the Democratic ticket, and in all honesty, becoming the likely winner of the race. Both the RLP and Republicans are running tickets here. While the Republicans are the second largest party in the Assembly, their Gubernatorial tickets have never had nearly as much steam as the Democratic ones. In the last election, the Republicans lost by over 20 votes, roughly 33%. The RLP hasn't run a Governor since the May election, and their possible results are unknown, given the massive changes in the political landscape since then. However, a Democratic Governor is still most likely, especially with Liberty support.

The Assembly is also not a wildcard. We can expect a Democratic majority, as the Democrats have enjoyed since the first sitting of the state's government. A Republican minority and RLP minority are also expected, although which will take more seats remains to be seen. With Eastern having been a major focus of the Republicans in the past, it is surprising they only ran 3 candidates. RLP has, except for the last assembly, always held more seats then Republicans however. That is why the minority of the Assembly is simply too close to call.

Atlantic Commonwealth: One of three states where there is no Governor running. The Democrats are running 8 candidates, and the RLP is running 5. With the turmoil the state has had politically (they've had at least 4 governors over the last term, it could be anyone's guess. Technically the state has no Governor, as /u/classeouvriere is now a Congressman (and the Lt. Governor's position is vacant as well)... The state is far too close to call, although the Democrats are assured 4 seats simply by running more then the RLP did. Anything more verges on being far too close to call with the history of the state. Certainly a state to watch.

Great Lakes: The last time there was an election in this state, the Civics still existed. Let that sink in for a moment. 4 parties (Liberty, Republicans, Distributists, and Radical Leftists) are running on Gubernatorial tickets. It certainly raises questions on why the Republicans are even on the ticket here, as they've never even won a single Assembly seat in the state's history. Of the 10 inaugurated Governors, 7 of them have been Libertarians. We can expect them to win the race once again, if history is anything to go by. RLP should put up a good showing however. Another note is that Liberty was the only party to run anyone for the elected post of State Attorney General, so they win that automatically.

Libertarians, Democrats, and Socialists (of either the GSP or RLP kind) have always split the assembly. We cannot expect anything other then that to happen, unless there is an upset of some kind. For example, a Republican winning a seat, which is extremely unlikely- a win by them or the Distributists would be a huge surprise. With the Democrats supporting Liberty in the state, it is possible that the RLP may be able to grab whatever seats the AJA does not in the state, making it into a 2 party state like the Atlantic Commonwealth and Dixie. The exact split is to be determined, however it is is morel likely that Liberty attains a majority then RLP.

Midwestern: One of the three states not running a Governor. GSP is running 8 candidates. Distributists are running 5. Former Secretary of State and former Republican chair /u/CincinnatusOfTheWest is running as an independent. By simple calculation, this means the GSP has at least 2 seats right off the bat, /u/CincinnatusOfTheWest is likely to grab Republicans off the Sunrise Coalition (or what's left of it), leaving how many seats the Distributists will get an open question. The GSP has had a majority 2 of the 3 times the Assembly has been elected, however with an incumbent Governor, the Distributists have a small advantage. Still, I think the GSP will probably get a majority, especially with RLP backing in the state.

Western: No Governor's race. If you thought the 4 parties would be an interesting election, Western does one better with 5 parties running in the Assembly. This race pits Distributists against Republicans, GSP against RLP, and throws in the Democrats for good measure. It is a true free-for-all. Republicans are more then likely to gain at least 1 seat in the state, as they have had for most of the Assembly's history. Democrats will get at least 3 seats, as they have for the past few assemblies. GSP and RLP might cancel each other out for seats, ending up with less then expected, especially with neither running a large amount of candidates. Distributists will more then likely end up with smaller then expected seats, as they don't have the Republican base to bump up their numbers. Anything other then the Democratic seats is far from certain however.

To recap:

Dixie Governorship is a tossup, with the State Senate being a wildcard. Assembly will have a Republican Majority. Chesapeake Governor remains Democratic, with a Democratic majority in their assembly. Atlantic Commonwealth is a Democratic minority at the least, with more then that being uncertain. Great Lakes is Libertarian for a Governor, and most likely assembly - although we cannot rule out the RLP. Midwestern is a GSP lock, despite a Distributist Governor, and a possible independent. Western has at least 3 Democratic seats, and otherwise us a wildcard. Republicans have a majority in 1 state, and a minority in 1 or 2 more. Democrats have a majority, or a near majority, in 3 states. Libertarians capture 1, most likely.


r/ModelTimes • • Jun 08 '19

Stormont Decides - The Leaders: Trev speaks to Alliance leader Estoban06

2 Upvotes

In the last of our series of interviews with Stormont leaders, ModelTimes co-founder /u/Trevism speaks to Alliance Party and Liberal Democrat leader, /u/Estoban06…


This term has been a real mixed bag for Alliance. You seemed to stagnate as part of the Executive, producing no legislation in the early part of the term. However, the recent "AllianceFest" has indicated that the party is on the road to brighter days. How crucial is it that you keep this momentum going into next term?

Estoban: It's absolutely vital. An important thing to note is that for over a year I've been operating as a one man party, so to remain in the Executive and retain my seat in each election was an achievement in itself.

In the latter half of the term the Alliance merger with CLibs happened. I can honestly say this merger is one that worked well, with a new life breathed into a party, and AllianceFest beginning and continuing well into future.

Obviously we'll get onto the merger a little later on, but for now we'll move onto the topic of policy. With Alliance quickly establishing themselves as a party of policy once more, are there any pledges in your upcoming manifesto you'd like to tell us about?

Estoban: Of course. One major manifesto pledge of ours is to modernise our infrastructure. Roads, rail and other transport are in dire need of investment. Projects such as A6 dualling, Belfast Light Rail, a rail link to Belfast International and rail electrification are just some of the policies we commit to in our manifesto.

Another major goal of ours will be to negotiate a new devolution settlement with Westminster. We hope this will include corporation tax, as well as income tax powers in line with the other devolved governments. This will allow NI to operate and set tax rates that attract businessses and are fair to the people of NI.

On a personal note, you've had a bit of a topsy turvy term, ending up moving around positions due to circumstances both in and out of your control (more on that later). Has it been at all difficult to compose yourself legislatively with your brief altering so often?

Estoban: It has indeed been a topsy turvy term in comparison my others, without a doubt. Being moved to a different cabinet department without being informed also didn't help matters, with such a radical change in portfolio.

Speaking of the radical change in portfolio, Alliance saw itself bring the Classical Liberals into the fold over the course of the term. Do you feel this has been a positive move on the whole?

Estoban: I do. We've made gains in the polls, our legislative output and activity in the Assembly is better than ever. While we took some flack early on, we have recovered well and I'm very happy with the results.

Speaking of the flack early on, some comments made by Alliance members towards members of Sinn Fein resulted in the collapse of the Assembly. Do you still feel that this collapse was unjustified in hindsight?

Estoban: I do. I do understand the feelings and concerns SF had, indeed I shared some of them in the beginning.

However, the fact that I found out of my (what basically was a) sacking, on Twitter is very poor form. Likewise, to collapse what already is a fragile assembly, without even giving us a chance is unjustified and offensive.

I had served for over a year as dFM yet all that came to a halt within the space of an hour.

Do you harbour any resentment towards your former Executive members regarding their behaviour towards you personally?

Estoban: I wouldn't say I resent the other exec members, but I certainly lost respect for them during that particular event.

Obviously you were replaced as deputy First Minister by Cenarchos, the leader of the SDLP, the only party from the Other group barring yourselves. What do you have to say to Alliance voters unsure of where to place their vote?

Estoban: *For the last 1.5 years you've put your trust in me each election. Now, there has never been a better time to vote Alliance, with an invigorated membership, new bright ideas, and the right attitude to power sharing. *

The comments made by the SDLP leader that came to light during the Labour leadership elections are well known across the country at this stage, and I won't dwell on them, but ask yourself: what would you prefer to represent you in the NI Executive those comments, or someone who has worked tirelessly for NI in the Assembly, Executive, Westminster and Government, with a team of hard working MLAs who strive to make NI a better place.

(And lastly, to end this interview on a lighter note, what is the one thing you'd change about Stormont?*

Estoban: I'd like to see more independence for each devolved party, let them evolve with their own policies to suit the region rather than what satisfies the policies of the national party.

Also the name of the Stormont pub, I'd like it returned to the original.



r/ModelTimes • • Sep 23 '19

London Times “A government not for the workers isn’t a government at all” - The Times meets the new W&W Secretary!

2 Upvotes

The Times catches up with the new Secretary of State for Work and Welfare, jgm0228, ahead of their new Zero Hour Contracts Bill being read on Monday. Only joining the party less than 3 weeks ago and quickly replacing the former Secretary of State for Defence, Padanub, in his South Yorkshire Seat, and becoming a frequent debater over this short period of time. From speaking out against the Conservative calls to rule out a deficit of any kind to speaking on Government policy to bring an end to selective admissions within Grammar Schools

With Work and Welfare now taking on some of the responsibilities formerly taken by the Business portfolio, jgm0228 will be in charge of bringing forth the Government’s new policy on Trade Unions and reforming employment rights.

The transcript of the interview can be read below:


The Times: Hello, from the Times here. Congratulations on your appointment as Work and Welfare Secretary.

jgm0228: Thank you so much, it’s wonderful to be here. I am happy to have been appointed this job and plan on engaging with it to the best of my ability.

What are your plans for the department this term?

We are looking at exploring reforms to TUFBRA, protections for workers under zero hours contracts, continuing protections for union members, wage policy, and overall wish to take a evidence based, devolved administration friendly, approach to policy that includes all stake holders in the business and welfare process but with an emphasis on making sure the the every day citizen of the UK sees a government that fights for them.

Could you elaborate on your plans for ZHCs? Last term Labour voted against legalising ZHCs so would banning them be off the table?

Labour isn’t the only party in government. A good coalition enacts consensus based policy. I have worked tirelessly with our coalition partners to craft reforms to zero hour contract policy, and more specifics will likely be soon to come, but I will say that a ban would have a difficult time getting through parliament so that certainly isn’t my focus.

Could you reveal any part of your planned protections for those on ZHCs?

I think the public will find these reforms focus on ensuring transparency in this sector of work, as well as making sure workers have the flexibility they need to engage in these jobs while also balancing their need to be able to schedule and perhaps potentially advance beyond ZHC’s if they choose.

And what would that entail? Certain amount of hours over a certain period of time or an option to take a part time or full time contract after a different period?

Workers who have shown sufficient dedication to the company and find themselves working a certain amount of hours would be entitled to submit a formal request for a contract. The employer of course can’t be forced to comply or else these things wouldn’t be zero hour contracts, they would be delayed hour contracts, but they would have to consider the request.

Additionally, employers would likely need to provide summaries for employees about potential work offered, to make sure the transaction of labour between the two is fair.

How would this be enforced and would employers be charged if they don’t comply to considering the request? Along with this, what would be the requirements of hours over a certain period for this request to be Considered?

Employers would need to consider the request and provide a rationale for why a rejection occurred, but again, if they were forced to accept a contract request, these would simply be delayed hour contracts.

The amount of hours required will be seen in the bill once it comes out. It is a number that reflects a worker who has put in enough time into that job that they would reasonably be considered a part time worker.

Is there any mechanisms for employees to bring up disputes on whether a contract and rationale was provided? I get of course they cannot be forced to accept but is there a mechanism and charge should there be evidence to say this was not considered?

The department of course accepts complaints about worker issues, complain lines through our website, referred up through the relevant channels depending on the nature of the complaint, exist. The UK currently enforces most of its employment laws through employment tribunals, and workers will of course be encouraged to seek all legal recourse necessary to get their rights.

Additionally the law will likely require documentation for the request’s response, so whether or not it was given due consideration will be plainly clear.

Thank you and what changes would you like to bring with wages policy?

Well as the new head of the department I will be analyzing levels of minimum wage to see whether or not they provide a living wage. We must make sure our workers are paid adequately.

I’m also open to potentially investigating new avenues to crack down on stolen wages, and other forms of worker exploitation.

Could you elaborate what you define as stolen wages and how you would crack down on that?

Employees not being paid what they were agreed to. As for cracking down, this is just a potential idea, we will be considering all avenues to make sure employees are aware of their rights and how they can best exercise them.

And are employees not being paid what they agreed to a common thing in your research and where is this most prevalent?

Certainly. We have seen reports from places such as Middlesex University and the Trust for London that measure unpaid wages in the billions of pounds. As for where it occurs, I think it’s hard often in entry level jobs to stand up for what you are worth, but again, we will be looking further into this.

And on another point, how exactly will you pursue a policy that included all stake holders in business than currently is?

We would of course make sure to craft policy that balanced out the interests of business and workers. We would make sure that all their interests have been considered when writing legislation. This is a government for all the people, and we desire to keep up to that pledge.

And is there anyway this will be addressed specifically in legislation compared to previous government attitudes?

I will say that I as Secretary am going to make myself as open as possible to all public comments on legislation and will seek to engage in all relevant debates to make my views clearer and to allow people to present their views to me whether they disagree or agree. It’s a personal pledge.

Thank you, is there anything else you’d like to say before we finish?

I feel incredibly honored to be entrusted with this position. My commitment is simple. I will be an advocate for the everyday Britain who feels that past governments have left them behind. I will make sure to be a voice for them in cabinet, and will do my best to reflect their will in policy and in action. A government not for the workers isn’t a government at all.


This interview was conducted on Friday and released now ahead of the Zero Hours Contract (Regulation) Bill.


r/ModelTimes • • Aug 16 '18

Europe Times Controversial left alliance holds press conference in attempt to resolve criticisms

2 Upvotes

The VLP (alliance of leftist parties) has sparked controversy since their existence became known through a press leak. After the leak the VLP was quick to publish their official announcement which failed, however, to answer the most pressing questions surrounding the point of the alliance. FDP whip u/kraal42 criticised the intransparency and lack of clear goals. SPD-leader wutzibu and his fellow social democrat u/StratorDE who has taken on the role of VLP-leader denied any implications that the VLP would compete as one unit in the winter elections while Linken-leader u/Nuntawa did not want to deny this at first, later saying it’s something he desired but was not on the immediate horizon while hinting at a possible cooperation between KPD and Linke should the SPD not want to join forces.

Following another leak that revealed talks from a day before the initial press report where VLP-leader u/StratorDE said he didn’t think his coalition partner, the technocrat TPD, would mind the alliance and that they wouldn’t speak up in fear of losing the government power. Further in the conversation they stamped of the conservative Union (consisting of CDU and AfD) as a joke and named the liberal FDP as the alliances biggest rival citing their rhetoric talents. Both u/Nuntawa and u/StratorDE refused to comment on the conversation and instead chose to question the legitimacy of leaking internal conversations. SPD-chancellor u/wutzibu’s announced he had brought up the matter with their coalition partner and that they were solving the issues internally. TPD whip u/Fifatastic was visibly shocked by the publication and criticised that the VLP was attacking the press instead of apologizing.

Given this PR-nightmare the VLP announced a press conference two days later in which they wanted to clear up any unclarities and concerns that were still surrounding the alliance. In this press conference they confirmed their stance that this alliance did not change Linke’s and KPD’s influence on the government and that it was purely an ideological and symbolic alliance. Given the big frame of the alliance this was doubted by all present parties. Other than that there were no major breakthroughs for the VLP and the main concern that this alliance’s intransparency and damaged relation to the press hinted at something bigger than “just” an symbolic alliance. Hypothetical scenarios surrounding future coalition formations were categorically denied and stanced as “unprofessional”. The only other notable result of the press conference was all three members involved in the chat logs backing their opinions in labelling Union as a joke and FDP as rivals thus somewhat contradicting themselves from earlier, when they said their goal was to decrease the gap between left and centrist and conservative parties.

The full press conference is available in text form here.


r/ModelTimes • • Jul 01 '18

Europe Times Piraten leaving coalition talks leads to minority government between SPD and TPD

2 Upvotes

After a turbulent weekend SPD-leader u/Beaufort1371 has announced the failure of the coalition talks between SPD, TPD and Piratenpartei. In a press release he wrote that a minority government without the Piratenpartei will be formed.

This weekend started off with the beginning of the election period of former vice-chancellor u/wutzibu of the SPD. The election began with uncertainty whether the coalition would work out following a press report of a heavy conflict surrounding a Piratenpartei demand to abolish copyright altogether.

On the next morning long-time Piraten-leader u/doogie120673 announced his resignation following party-internal controversy regarding the copyright-issue. Further he let others know that his party colleague and delegate u/num3r0ph0b14 would not participate in further negotiations but would support a minority government.

Without this support u/wutzibu would have to get one opposition vote to achieve the required majority in the traditionally uncontested race for chancellor to reach the required seven of thirteen votes. This sparked uncertainty in the social democrats who began rallying in the opposition for support. They were able to exhale however as u/leftyandzesty announced the three KPD-delegates would support the SPD-candidate making his election almost certain. As a result u/wutzibu crowned himself the “grand uniter” and announced every party would be welcome to work together constructively.

At the point of writing SPD and TPD have yet to release their coalition agreement which lead to heavy criticism from conservative CSU-delegate u/Linksversifft regarding the intransparency from both parties during the chancellor elections. According to the designated chancellor they were waiting on approval from TPD-leadership before finishing up the negotiations.

A draft reached the press and unveiled a focus on social politics including more money for social housing and an increase in minimum wage. The refugee policy strives for a european solution with wide-ranging deportation protection of recognized refugees. Alcohol, cigarettes and junk food will see an increase in taxes in an effort to tackle obesity issues.

Stay with the Times to hear the outcome of the chancellor elections which is expected on monday.


r/ModelTimes • • May 22 '19

New York Times [OP-ED] The Untold Leftist Critique of The GuiltyAir Administration

2 Upvotes

This piece is the opinion of the author and does not necessarily reflect the view of the Model Times Group.

OP-ED: The Untold Leftist Critique of The GuiltyAir Administration

By /u/Jakebox

​ President /u/GuiltyAir has been subject to a fair number of criticisms since he’s taken office. His critics almost always tend to be to the right of him though, coming from the GOP and BMP. His record leaves a lot to be desired from the left, from aggressive foreign policy to questionable supreme court appointments.

One of the most encompassing criticisms of President GuiltyAir is that he has not gotten much done. Besides advancing LGBTQ rights pretty thoroughly in federal departments and some prison reform- his administration fails to get much through Congress of consequence. A prime example of this is that the American healthcare system is not working and little has been done to fix it. The President knows as much, and in his first executive order established a taskforce that has done nothing is likely to do nothing. He’s been all talk and no action.

On the topic of talking, he sometimes slips up and delivers some embarrassing somewhat classist rhetoric. When signing H.R.042: Financial Literacy Education Act, he couldn’t seem to resist his classism and taking pot shots at the American people. “...not everyone had the chance to learn as I did”. “Many go into the adult world with a basic understanding of how finances work.” Disappointingly, the President continued to build the longstanding narrative that people are responsible for the position they’re in- not a system that is clearly rigged against working people. His tone of looking down on people is also not uncommon, such as when signing a bee protection act, he wrote: “Most people don't know..” The American people are smarter than the President gives them credit for, and regardless, his pompous tone surely angers many Americans.

It’s not just about inaction or tone though, there are a lot of cases of more conservative policy that American Democrats, Socialists and the left, in general, should take issue with. President GuiltyAir nominated a seemingly conservative justice to the Supreme Court /u/JJEagleHawk. Although the man hardly has a record on how he’d rule on certain cases- his strict constructionist approach contrasts with what would be expected of more liberal justices. This is not the only case of conservative policy. Although the GuiltyAir administration was emboldened by law to release prisoners convicted of marijuana offenses but choose not to take it. When bold action to free thousands of prisoners could have been taken- GuiltyAir took the lesser road. This is despite the fact that the administration itself argued that it might have been able to take bolder action. Perhaps the most aggressive and somewhat conservative domestic policy undertaken by the administration was its proposed budget. The President's budget request did not go far enough to address the wild income inequality in the United States- with a top tax bracket of only 45%. Furthermore, his proposal seemed to target the middle-class disproportionately with taxation. His continuation of ridiculous military spending of over 650 billion dollars did not go unnoticed- despite that this ridiculous amount has frequently been decried by the left. The President still found room to vastly expand the space program in his budget. Maybe, the President should focus more on welfare and working people than the military and fun space adventures. To be fair the President’s Welfare Reform Working Group has been formed with Democrats and the moderate BMP, but it remains to be seen if that group will do any good or meet the same fate of his seemingly disbanded healthcare taskforce.

It would be lightweight just to critique GuilyAir’s domestic policy in which, to be fair, he is largely constrained by Congress. Some of President GuiltyAir’s most egregious actions to the left have taken place concerning foreign policy. His intervention in Nigeria was heavy-handed and concerning. His eagerness to send American planes to commit airstrikes was too much. Aiding the African Union is fine, but making it an American endeavor when this country has no appetite for unrestrained interventionism is absurd. This kind of willingness to intervene was also seen in the Azov Sea crisis when the President openly threatened war against Russia, which is a nuclear power. One reason for this aggression may be that President GuiltyAir’s policy was guided by the BMP’s /u/Reagan0. Despite calling for the outlawing of abortion /u/Reagan0 was appointed the Secretary of State. The President himself stated that “The people who’ve signed their name in support of this bill should be ashamed of themselves and will go down in history as the perpetrators of the most brazen attack on the rights of women in American History.” While the President may claim that this appointment was based solely on foreign policy, a man who shows such astonishingly bad judgement domestically should not have been trusted with our State Department. Furthermore, the State Department should seek to promote safe access to abortion and the end of draconian laws around the world- something /u/Reagan0 cannot be trusted to do. If this was not enough, the President halfheartedly embraces a moral approach to diplomacy. While there are arguments to be made for realism, the President should really pick an approach. At the same time, as condemning Saudi Arabia’s human rights abuses, it strengthens relations with Afghanistan through an extradition treaty. To be clear, in Afghanistan, same-sex activity is punishable by death. While a gay man may not be extradited to Afghanistan, the moral outrage of the administration is clearly selective.

The President’s flirtation with the right does not end with his Secretary of State or Supreme Court Justice. The decision by the administration to award former President /u/Nonprehension a medal was not a good move. It bestowed honor upon an unpopular president with a history of supporting intervention on the world stage. Similarly, he called former President George H W Bush, “one of our countries finest presidents.” The President did do some noble things but invaded numerous countries and most importantly, spearheaded NAFTA negotiations that hurt American workers tremendously.

Through most all of this the President has gone uncritiqued from the left. The Democratic Party has been cheering on the President and criticism is far and few between. GOP Senator /u/ChaoticBrilliance when interviewed knew right where the often lacking criticism from the left should lie, “What two big weights the left placed on President GuiltyAir that were the heaviest, I believe, would be an awkward silence on economic topics like workers' rights and trade, and the seemingly inevitable trap of interventionism that seems to have befallen every American President since the U.S. has become a superpower, both of which I predict are the sticking points that had some part in the creation of the Socialist Party”. Meanwhile, U.S. Attorney General /u/IamATinman’s counselor, /u/CariboftheDead (BMP), takes a different view towards the rather moderate presidency of GuiltyAir, “Guilty’s work is consistently left of center but is also practical for Americans above all else... Democrats and BMP members allied in during this past election is I think a sign of our healthy national politics, regardless of criticism”. It’s hard to dispute that GuiltyAir’s work is practical or center-left, but it’s not inspiring. It’s the kind of politics that the centrist BMP rejoices in. It’s the kind of politics where not much changes. It’s the kind of politics that does not put working people first. It’s a broken system that the Democratic Party seems to not only endorse but unquestionably support.

​ When contacted by the author, neither President GuiltyAir or Democratic Party Chair ZeroOverZero responded for comment.

​ Author’s Note:

For transparency, the President and I have been in a few spats over the drinking age and infrastructure funding, however, both issues are not addressed in the article. Furthermore, I endorsed GuiltyAir in the Presidential election a short time ago and believe this to be an objective leftist critique of GuiltyAir’s presidency.

​ The Times welcomes a response to all op-eds. If interested, please contact the staff.


r/ModelTimes • • Nov 06 '17

Europe Times Budget crisis in Ireland

2 Upvotes

After the Labour - Sinn Fein government failed, the Irish state stands in front of a potential budget crisis. It started after Fiachaire complained about the 80% budget cut on Education and Social services.

As the Dail had been closed shortly after this event due to a VONC led by PD against the government. The potential creation of a new budget can be seen as a difficult topic in upcoming coalition tslks that will be led by Labour.

Model Times will continue to report on it

Edit: We apologise for the old incorrect version


r/ModelTimes • • May 15 '20

London Times Much Ado About Labour - Six Weeks of Scandal - Part One

10 Upvotes

16th April 2020. History was made as the Conservative Party were knocked off the top of the polls for the first time in 38 months. The beneficiaries? /u/ARichTeaBiscuit's Labour Party, seemingly resurgent, and fighting hard just four months after the collapse of Sunrise had left them fighting for their lives. It appeared that nothing could stop the roses in red - they were a freight train ploughing on, to Destination Victory.

Four weeks and a day on, the picture couldn't be any more different. The front pages of broadsheets and tabloids alike are adorned with stories of Labour scandal. Talk of coup d'etats and backroom spats seem to be everywhere at the moment, and it all seems to be coming from Labour HQ. Such adjectives have been brought to mind as the Iannuccian classic "omnishambles", and Labour really do seem to be in the thick of it.

But where did this begin? How did it happen? You've all seen the leaks, you've all read the front pages, you know what the story is. But today, I go a step further. For the first time, ModelTimes speaks to those at the heart of the most rapid fall of grace in recent political times in our exclusive: Much Ado About Labour.

In person, the Lord Houston, /u/jgm0228 is every bit the energetic and passionate debater who has taken the British political arena by storm over the last six months. Their talk is sharp, and their words aren't cheap, surprisingly for a politician of his stature. Of course, we aren't here to hand out compliments on a silver platter, and it must be noted that the first major Labour scandal of the term came at their party conference. This was where the aforementioned Lord Houston put forward a motion urging the party to adopt the aims and objectives of the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement. This movement, abbreviated to BDS, refers to the boycott of Israeli-produced goods in protest at the Netanyahu government's policies in relation to the West Bank and Gaza Strip, but has been met with controversy due to a catalogue of associations between the formal group and those with antisemitic beliefs.

This motion met with absolute furore, and is still fresh in the mind of many a political insider to this day. Former Defence Secretary, and Deputy Leader of the Libertarian Party, /u/seimer1234, spoke about the incident frankly in an interview with ModelTimes, saying:

"From a geopolitical standpoint, its a deeply deeply foolish move. Israel is our strongest ally in the Middle East, and co-operation with them is vital on so many issues. When I was Defence Secretary, we needed to have that relationship with Israel, that close bond, that line of communication to deal with the Iran crisis which came up during my tenure. I think when you look at that move from that national security standpoint, all it would have served to do was weaken our relationship with Israel, which is a foolish move. Those are the reasons why I was against that plan put forward at their party conference."

Seimer, when prompted, also made a point of hinting at a wider culture regarding Labour's stance on foreign policy, saying:

"Look, this is a party that wants to get rid of our nuclear deterrent. They had MPs last term describe NATO as a vessel for American imperialism. This is a party that can not be trusted on these matters, its as simple as that."

Another critic of this policy within Labour ranks is current frontbencher and former SDP bigwig, /u/HKNorman. HK kindly took time out of their day to speak with us, saying that whilst they had just returned to the political arena after a break period, they were "not at all surprised" by the reaction to a policy they described as "controversial both on the right and the left", adding that the external response was "only natural", in their humble opinion.

Both inside and outside of Labour, the consensus seems to be that the party got it wrong. Former Labour deputy leadership candidate, /u/ChairmanMeeseeks, described the situation as "utterly horrendous", but equally added that they were impressed by the "courage" of those involved in coming forward to admit personal wrongdoing, adding:

"[It is] pretty rare in this day and age to see someone offer a total mea culpa. [I] would rather it not have been a thing at all but I’m thankful that it was resolved quickly."

The controversial but irreverent Conservative Party chairman, /u/BrexitGlory was, on the other hand, steadfastly aghast at the actions of the Labour Party surrounding the BDS motion, saying:

*"Well obviously I was pretty shocked at Labour's oversight, but I was more disappointed with how they handled it. Instead of recognising their mistake, holding their hands up and apologising; they went out of their way to justify their actions and direct blame. My personal belief is that consumers should be able to choose which goods they buy and they should be free to boycott produce from any country if they want to. But I think for a British government to boycott goods from one of our allies, would be a strange and rather stupid thing to do.

At the time, the Leader of the Opposition, /u/ARichTeaBiscuit, apologised publicly for the fiasco, removing it from the docket, and stating that they personally endorsed the BDS movement as a whole, as opposed to the group, and when questioned by the Times this week, they were not prepared to give a fresh statement, saying that their clarification had taken place when they had spoken about supporting Occupied Territories measures similar to those proposed by Fianna Fail in the Republic of Ireland, and delivered a condemnation of the BDS organisation.

When presented with criticisms of the motion, and questions from ModelTimes, the Shadow Chancellor remained supportive of the statement their leader had made previously, stating that they shared the sentiment and adding:

"As I have made clear recently it is the associations people have with the movement that are problematic, not actions taken to further the peace process as a concept. It was Fianna Fáil, the center right major party in Ireland, who had spearheaded probably the most prominent international effort to boycott illegal settlements. This should not be, and in places right next door to us, isn’t, a left right issue. It’s a human rights issue."

The next fiasco to hit Labour involved the Queen's Speech, a matter of weeks after this initial incident, when then-Labour frontbencher /u/SmashBrosGuys responded to an argument about the relationship between race and capitalism by asking an LPUK member to "name a single minority billionaire", drawing accusations of racism from across the political arena. This then led to SBG's removal from the frontbench, however /u/Gren_Gnat, who had initially supported these remarks, was not removed from the frontbench until a number of days later, when they accused the Liberal Democrats of being "tinpot liberals" in response to their earlier decision to enter a coalition with the Conservative Party. The first person we contacted regarding this affair was the Leader of the Liberal Democrats, /u/thechattyshow, who professed his profound shock at the remarks, but would not be drawn into any speculation on internal matters within the party:

"I was shocked. I've always tried to be nice to the Labour Party, and generally they have been good people. I've worked with them during my time as leader in both Government, opposition and opposing each other. Each time I've tried to treat them with respect, and I think they've been pretty respectable as well (for example in negotiating a budget!). The comments were a shock, but I was happy to see the swift action being taken by leadership in dealing with it, and I don't have anything against the party. I've seen people speculate on the internal culture of the party, and honestly I do not feel as if I am qualified enough to give a proper answer. The one thing they've always been known for is their internal culture of leaking, and that is true. They do seem to be more leak prone than others. But is Labour an inherently toxic party at core? I don't think so, but I am not qualified enough to say for certain."

ModelTimes reached out for comment from SomeBritishDude regarding this incident, but it appeared that he had quickly scattered through his home and had fled the country when we sent a reporter round to door knock (M: read as sudden canon resets do journalists' heads in). However, we did question /u/redwolf177, the editor of the Model Jewish Worker, on the veracity of the remarks, to which he said:

"The Model Jewish Worker believes all accusations of racism should be taken seriously, however we are not sure of the merit of these particular accusations. Although we are not inside the labour party and do not have all the facts on the issue because of that, we can not see clear evidence that either of those members are racist. They made comments which are inappropriate, but beyond an apology I do not personally believe any action is warranted. However the comments they made were not against the Jewish community, which means they fall firmly beyond our area of expertise."

Another prominent figure to cast a view on those remarks was /u/Captain_Plat_2258. Well-noted for her committed support for indigenous rights, the artist most commonly known as Kate to her friends, pointed to a lack of nuance in the remarks as opposed to what others have seen as bigoted malice, saying:

"This is a topic I have particularly strong feelings on, in my country of birth and in my current country of residence and citizenship I have seen the effects of capitalism on minority groups and it is not a positive one.. However I have many problems with the way those members tried to describe this, and believe their removal from the front bench was justified."

She also placed a great deal of thought towards discussing the fact that leading newspapers had, in the days following the fiasco, hailed those who had been removed from the frontbench and subsequently formed their own party in what appeared to be a u-turn, based upon their formation of a rival party to Labour, the People's Union Party:

"I do also think it is mighty ironic that the newspaper outlets that called their comments problematic instantly turned around and called them whistleblowing heroes the second they left the party. It is clear some people are willing to use social issues in a partisan manner. Well as someone who is actually affected by those issues I say shame on anybody who would back up on their stance that someone has said racist things the second they leave the Labour Party."

/u/BrexitGlory also took an opportunity to wade into this debate with a slightly leftfield remark, stating that enough focus had been placed on the comment and not enough emphasis had been placed on the reaction internally to it:

"Politics is hard and it's often emotional, in the heat of debate mistakes happen, things are said that aren't meant in a malicious way, I get it. I think enough focus has been on the ludicrous comments made and their authors. Our attention should now be on Labour leadership. They did nothing on the racist comments until their shadow cabinet reshuffle, where they sacked SBD to save face, for PR reasons only.

When confronted with the sum of parts in this instance, /u/ARichTeaBiscuit spoke of a similar feeling towards those who had attacked Labour in the press, but equally admitted that leadership had acted wrongly in their approach to the incident:

"I believe that our response to the incident could've been better communicated with the membership, and as of this moment we are implementing a series of reforms that includes means of bettering communication between the Leadership and the members."

"At the same time I think it is important to recognise the opportunism of those opposed to the Labour Party during this incident, as those that had previously complained that we weren't acting quickly enough and that had accused us of racism proceeded to not only blindly accept the opinion of the individual that made these offensive remarks in the first place without question but frame them as a whistleblower."

All in all, the eye of the storm had very much veered into Labour's direction, due in part to leadership's own failure to approach matters as they admit they should have in that scenario, and in part due to circumstances that they had not been able to predict, but at this point, Labour were still holding onto their polling lead by the skin of their teeth. In Part 2 of this feature, we'll look into more recent events that have transpired against the background of Labour sinking into second place in the polls as we detail how it became Much Ado About Labour!


r/ModelTimes • • May 16 '20

London Times Much Ado About Labour - Six Weeks Of Scandal - Part Two

3 Upvotes

In Part 1 of Much Ado About Labour, we left off with Labour having to defend themselves in the midst of accusations that they had behaved irresponsibly in the process of punishing party members for internal comments regarding the relationship between race and capitalism, leading to a split in the party. This then led onto accusations from Labour frontbenchers, and the party leader, that newspapers and political were using the story for opportunistic purposes, supposedly hailing those they had decried for racism days earlier as whistleblowers. We spoke to the Editor of the Model Telegraph, David Seimarsson, about these allegations:

"I don’t fully understand their line of logic. You can simultaneously say that those members did bad things while also talking to those members to see how Labour responded to those members behaviour. The attacks on the Telegraph from Labour have been continuous, and they are disappointing. I have given Labour opportunities to share their side of the story in my interview with them, and we hope to continue to do so, however it is not conducive to a good press-politics relationship when our journalists are berated for a past indiscretion when asking for comment on an unrelated story."

Of course, the relationship between the press and the Labour Party was only just heating up at this point, as the party was set to fully engage in a flame war of sorts on the press front. It all began in the aftermath of the PUP split, when accusations were made about the Labour Party trying to disparage dissenters in private, following a story put out by the publication known as Saltcon about Labour internal spats. This led to Saltcon editor, /u/Padanub, putting out a disclaimer withdrawing the story due to members of Labour leadership "acting like the Gestapo". This led to Saltcon receiving accusations of antisemitism, due to the fact that some of those in Labour leadership were of the Jewish faith, given that the Gestapo were the secret police of the Nazi regime. We asked /u/Padanub to clarify those remarks to ModelTimes:

"My remarks weren't misinterpreted, the intent was correct, the labour leadership acted in a manner keeping with secret police forces across the world, interrogating members with no evidence and no basis."

"What was in error is that I didn't know there was a Jewish member in Labour Leadership at the time (because who has the Chief Whip in their Leadership??) So the remark was antisemitic by default, but not by intent. I immediately withdrew it and apologized publically."

However, the situation spiralled out of control and let to members of the Labour Party accusing multiple elements of the political arena of verging close to antisemitism in their remarks. Most notably, Shadow Chancellor /u/jgm0228 decried the choice by Scottish First Minister /u/Duncs11 to describe opposition members as being comparable to Stalin in their approach, citing the acts that the Soviet Union perpetrated against the Jewish community during the tenure of Josef Stalin. When asked about this turn of events, the Shadow Chancellor was frank and honest:

"I think there is a difference between passion and bad faith. I am well known for being passionate in my arguments and my disagreements with others. That won’t change. What becomes a problem is when people begin to have discourse over the discourse, accusing others of using -ism. It’s not always unfounded, but it’s something as a whole we want to move away from. I think the way we educate people about these issues is through press outreach. The reason the whole lewd comments thing came back was because I tried to use the Labour weekly to point out severe issues of problematic comments from the Tories. Instead of people using the opportunity to self reflect in the press, we went into hard whataboutism. We need to as a country and as a discourse realize that it’s not naughty words that are the major issue, it’s the very real offenses that can hurt others."

The lewd comments remark refers to the leaking of what some may refer to as overly explicit comments from the Shadow Chancellor, regarding the behaviour of Scottish cabinet ministers in relation to their stance on the union. This led to accusations from Labour's opposition that the party had become the "nasty party" that the Conservatives had been characterised as for many a year during the 1980s and 1990s. We asked prominent Labour frontbencher, /u/HKNorman, if this interpretation of Labour as the nasty party was fair:

"In all honesty, no, I don't think it's unfair. We have a huge image problem in the Labour Party because our perceived attitude towards our adversaries and those who leave us, driven by individual members of the Party."

Fellow Labour frontbencher, /u/Captain_Plat_2258, provided a different reaction to this criticism, instead saying that the situation had proved that Labour leadership indeed had strength in their actions:

"I believe the Leadership of my party are doing their absolute best to make people feel included and to mitigate problems that may arise. They themselves are clearly not of the opinion they are perfect, and it is now public knowledge that members of leadership have commited to reviewing and improving their response to events that come up under their watch. I think this is not a sign of weakness, but a sign of incredible strength and empathy from leadership who can actually admit 'well hey look we can always improve and we're willing to learn from things rather than say we're perfect all the time'."

One of those who Labour criticised in particular during this period was Conservative Party Chairman, /u/BrexitGlory, alleging that he had made remarks in a newspaper interview citing his admiration for the controversial politician, Enoch Powell, best known for his incendiary "Rivers of Blood" speech. We asked BrexitGlory about this association:

"Me and the Shadow Chancellor are actually very good friends, I admire him for many things, one of which is his remarkable creativity. He's fantastically creative when it comes to manufacturing Labour scandals for us to watch, and his creativity doesn't stop when it comes to interpreting interview answers. I actually said that there wasn't much to like about Mr Powell, and that history has proved him wrong. The Shadow Chancellor should redirect his creativity to fixing the Labour party. "

Indeed, the argument over racism was set to rage on, as the relaunch of a paper alleging to be the Daily Express (please note that the editor of Northern & Steel Media, /u/ctrl_alt_lama, has put out a cease and desist letter regarding the direct association), led to an article being published which described the Shadow Chancellor as a "socialist puppet master", and later publishing a cartoon that led to accusations that the so-called Express were perpetrating antisemitic tropes, and leading to a number of articles condemning the action from the popular Jewish socialist advocacy publication, Model Jewish Worker. We spoke to their editor, /u/redwolf177, about the turn of events:

"We don't have much to say about this conflict between the LPUK and Labour Party. We have only covered it a little bit, with our recent article which was critical of the Daily Express. We think the Daily Express made inappropriate comments and should apologize. Much of what they published seems inauspicious, but when we look at all they came out with today, it seems suspect that they would publish an article one minute with inappropriate red baiting and antisemitic dogwhistles directed at a Jewish labour party member, and then draw a cartoon of a labour member with antisemitic characteristics. The LPUK and Conservatives in the last few days have made some decidely inappropriate comments, and we have called them out and asked for apologies and retractions. The broader engagement between the LPUK and Labour initially had little to do with Judaism, so we do not feel the need to comment on it further."

In response to this accusation, the Deputy Leader of the Libertarian Party UK, /u/seimer1234, denied any wrongdoing in the affair on the part of those linked to the LPUK:

"No. Greejatus’s parents I believe are jewish, and he is without equivocation, not an anti semite. While the puppetmaster phrase was perhaps clunky and left room for negative interpretation, the idea itself of JGM being that power behind the throne, is a common one, for good reason given he is regularly making major party announcements and is arguably becoming the face of his party. I think thats what the puppetmaster phrase referred to, and it was not some form of “dogwhistle”."

"The other cartoon accusation is ludicrous, and is deliberately in bad faith. It was a skit on Labour and TPM being similar, and had no indication within it that that character was supposed to be JGM. RW should have apologised for attacking the cartoon with no reason to but I don’t see that as likely."

*"I think there is a place and a role for the Model Jewish Worker in our media landscape however this type of thing discredits them entirely."

Of course, the events of recent weeks have led to many speculations on what Labour got wrong, and got right. The party now sits in second place in the polls, having began to fall following the catalogue of fiascos surrounding the party. This has led to many in the political arena trying to analyse the behaviour. Labour leader /u/ARichTeaBiscuit admitted that they had got things wrong over the recent past, adding:

"It should be standard practice for organisations like the Labour Party to review its decision making process with the benefit of hindsight, and that is why we are in the middle of instituting reforms to improve communication between the membership and the leadership in order to improve how the party in general handles future incidents."

/u/HKNorman also echoed this sentiment, accusing the Labour leader of failing to step up when they were likely required to:

"As far as operating efficiently goes, I think ARTB is doing the best they can under the circumstances, and has certainly proved themself to be beyond capable of doing the job, there just have been one or two occasions when we've needed them to step up and they haven't."

Former Labour defence spokesperson, /u/ChairmanMeeseeks, were much more complimentary in their analysis, stating that they believed that Labour leadership had done the best that they could have:

"I think leadership have done an amazing job. In the immediate wake of the PUP’s formation and the departure of Trongle, Gren, and SBD, the leadership basically went straight into action. Trongle felt unwelcome and in a hostile environment not conducive to their wellbeing or their ability to contribute to British Politics, and that’s sad to me, and I wish them all the best in the new PUP endeavour because I hope at the very least that will work out for them when Labour couldn’t. Almost the moment the PUP formed, Labour leadership embarked on a series of efforts to make sure that the rest of the membership didn’t and would never feel the same way. That effort is still ongoing and I think it’s a great response. They’ve acknowledged a problem, and sought out a solution through community consultation. My hope is that Trongle is the last person to leave us because of feeling that way, and I think given the stuff Akko’s done, that’s a reasonable expectation."

It is probably fitting that the last word on matters in this regard comes from someone who has never been a member of the Labour Party, but was in coalition with them very recently. Liberal Democrat leader, /u/thechattyshow, could only offer leadership some humble advice from his own time in office:

"A culture change comes from the top. Change the culture of your team around you, and the party will follow."

It remains to be seen whether Labour leadership will react to this sort of statement, but one thing appears to be clear from looking both internally and externally: the political arena agrees that the events of the last few weeks cannot become the norm.


r/ModelTimes • • Jun 11 '18

London Times The Government's 'scorn and ignore' policy must end [Op-Ed]

3 Upvotes

This article is an opinion piece and does not necessarily represent the views of the Times Group Plc.

Half way through its Parliamentary term, the Government is trying to improve its communications. The senior communications officer for the government, /u/WillShakespeare99, is instituting a new system of press conferences so that Government can talk to the press pack and, presumably, get its message out to the public.

This is an admirable aim, of course, but it rather puts the cart before the horse. Why buy a state of the art PA system when you have no instruments or anybody who can play them?

When the Tory-Labour coalition formed, it came with bold promises. A grand coalition promising a well-managed hard brexit, a stable Government that would follow through on its promises, a strong coalition that commands the votes of a majority of the electorate. The rest of Parliament was understandably completely wrong-footed by the googly they just received, so much so that the official opposition was a ten MP outfit up against a Government five times its size.

Faced with an ideologically divided opposition, it seemed that if the Grand Coalition held its nerve, this Parliament would be an absolute doddle.

Forming the Grand Coalition in itself was quite a feat of politics; two parties inherently and almost mortally opposed had formed a coalition of Government, with each agreeing to work with the other. There was no significant fall-out from the negotiations, and no particular scandal to signify that there was any bubbling resentment with the deal. Yes, some of the more left-wing of the Labour Party expressed discontent in private, but one of those ended up being promoted to the cabinet, so it can't have been too bad a deal, could it?

Fast forward to last week, and a significant portion of Labour MPs have been kicked out of the Commons for inactivity. The Labour leader himself managed only to attend 56% of votes, and the Government has to face the embarrassment that its Deputy Prime Minister is no longer an MP.

So what went wrong?

This result is an inevitable symptom of the Grand Coalition's foundational myth. The coalition is morally right because over half the electorate voted for it. Only this coalition can possibly achieve the ends Britain needs. The fact these two great powers have come together is in itself a vindication of the project. This is quite possibly the end of politics. Ideology has been ejected, and pragmatism is taking centre-stage.

In short, the coalition started with arrogance and hubris, and what we've seen in the last few days is the predictable schadenfreude.

Within days and weeks of formation, it became apparent that the Government wasn't going to speak to Parliament. Ministers stopped showing up to MQs. One Tory minister preferred to spend the first two days on a jolly at the Tory Party conference than answer questions on housing policy. When the decision came to bomb Syria, Parliament demanded from the Government, and the Speaker, that a vote be held. Motions were passed after the event. Neither motion has been answered by the Government.

And then came the petition for a final referendum. I have documented the history of the DDEA in this newspaper before, and won't repeat its content here. Suffice it to say, though, that one half of this Government is committing the most heinous kind of political hypocrisy, and is being aided and abetted by their former enemies. The individual who shut down the petition is a senior Labour Party MP, and recent reports from the Red Clydesider suggest this occurred without his consulting cabinet.

Finally is the news from this morning that the Government is intending to stonewall another referendum, this time for welfare devolution in Scotland. In typical Grand Coalition style, the answer is an old politician's trick; listen to the question, than answer as if you'd heard a different one. Only, this time, the Government made its decision not only without consulting Parliament but also, again, without consulting its own cabinet, or what's left of it.

One wonders how the Scottish Tories and Scottish Labour Party will fare in the current Holyrood campaign given these revelations.

So, in short order, we have the Government scorning Parliament, ignoring the people and not deigning to consult even its own cabinet.

Add all this to the Labour Party's absenteeism, and one has to wonder: how long does the Grand Coalition have left? Devoid of imagination, with a predilection for ignoring Parliament and its own cabinet, and apparently losing internal support to inertia, this failing experiment may well be in its death throes.


r/ModelTimes • • Jul 10 '17

New York Times New Independent Grouping Formed, Takes 3 Congressional Seats

3 Upvotes

The Equality Party gained independent grouping status midday from the Triumvirate, snagging three House seats and several key members of the simulation in turn. The grouping of anti-capitalists and leftists who wish declaw the "systems of oppression as they interact", led by /u/DoomLexus, published their full manifesto, quoting documents from Prof. Paul Preciado and the Mary Nardini Gang.

However, the move has been met with controversy with some members voicing their concern about how consistently groupings are gaining their statuses and whether or not they have legitimate platforms; defenders of the Equality Party believe that a protest party, rebelling against the structures that surround them, with legitimate arguments for their being and a manifesto that declares their beliefs certainly matches the criteria set.


r/ModelTimes • • Nov 26 '16

London Times The Times: MHoC Opinion Poll Results

3 Upvotes

The results and brief analysis can be found here.

Please excuse the poor formatting and design, it was quite difficult.