r/ModelGreens • • Jul 27 '15

Draft Workers Control Act of 2015 - Second Draft

Workers Control Act of 2015

PREAMBLE: Until now our democracy has been severely limited. While people have been able to vote in elections for leaders, they have had no control over the place they spend a vast amount of time, their workplace. This bill corrects that by nationalizing a large number of American businesses and transferring them to worker control under the Workers Councils.

SECTION 1: These companies are to be nationalized.

Sub Section 1: These companies are initially to continue to function as they did previously, and any overseas commerce done by the nationalized companies will continue.

Sub Section 2: All listed companies based in other nations will have all assets and property within the border of the United States seized.

SECTION 2: All natural sources of petroleum, gold, and water within the borders of the United States are to be nationalized.

SECTION 3: All companies nationalized in this bill and all companies nationalized after the passing of this bill are to be run by Workers Councils.

Sub Section 1: These Workers Councils are to be the same entity as those created by the Green-Left Party and will behave according to the rules established with the creation of said Councils.

Sub Section 2: These councils will have full control over the nationalized companies, with the National Council acting in the position of owner for each nationalized company.

SECTION 4: All Workers Councils will have certain amounts of control over the companies under their jurisdiction but must follow the direction of the higher level Councils in doing so. Duties will be delegated to the levels of Workers Councils as follows:

Sub Section 1: The National Council will have control over the general management of the individual companies nationalized by the bill. They will also have the ability to control wages, vacation days, and the distribution of the products made by the various companies towards the State Councils.

Sub Section 2: State Councils will have control over the management of the nationalized companies within the state they have jurisdiction over. They will also have the ability to control distribution of the products made by the various companies towards the various jurisdictions in their state.

Sub Section 3: Town Councils will have control over the management of the nationalized companies in the territory they have jurisdiction over. They will also have the ability to control distribution of the products made by the various companies within their jurisdiction where deemed necessary by the council.

Sub Section 4: Workers Councils will have control over the management of the specific workplaces they have jurisdiction over.

SECTION 5: All publicly traded companies nationalized by this act are to withdraw all stocks within a period of 15 days before to 15 days after nationalization.

12 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

6

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

I am very much in favor, like most of us here. But, as we all probably know, this bill will fail in congress as the other parties obviously aren't a fan of nationalizing industry.

I do agree with /u/bluefisch200 though, this would create good debates in congress.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

Yeah, I don't intend this to pass really. I feel it's necessary for us to assert ourselves and say, "we are a radical party, we will work on more than social democratic bills". If we ever gain a majority or at least a significant plurality this may be able to pass, but until then this is a way of showing who we are and reasserting ourselves as a socialist party.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

Agreed. At the moment we should be doing a mix of Green policies to reaffirm the Green in our name, as well as a slow transition of Social democratic policies with a mix of radical proposals to reaffirm our radicalism.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

Perhaps you should include a definition of "nationalized", just to clarify the process.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

Good idea, I'll add that to the next draft.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

Also this is unrelated but I'd like to remind everyone who hasn't but can to sign up for state elections before noon EST tomorrow.

2

u/anarchitekt Libertarian Socialist Jul 28 '15 edited Jul 28 '15

Unfortunately, I want to express my dissent of this bill. Not only does it conflate nationalization and worker control, an idea that most socialists I speak with have fought for a long time to dispell, it is also unconstitutional, and wouldn't have the support in congress to pass anyway.

I am pro nationalization in very specific industries, but I must express a long held passion of mine, state control ≠ worker control.

That being said, this bill should be submitted in order to initiate conversation, create a baseline for what we want to accomplish, and pull any compromise closer in our direction.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15

I agree that state control is not necessarily worker control. However since this gives all power over the companies to the workers councils it is worker control. The constitutional issues will be worked on in future revisions.

1

u/anarchitekt Libertarian Socialist Jul 28 '15

Not sure if you saw my edited last paragraph there.

But anyway, the language is too open to interpetation. A "national council" will be interpreted as some government agency of people who has no connection to the company (which I'm almost excited to counter with the current model of stock holders). It needs to be clearly defined, that a council of workers is a group of people within the company. There shouldn't be any room for interpretation on this, and then we can have a real debate.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15

Not sure if you were aware, but we passed a motion with workers councils based on the same levels in this bill, where the representatives are recallable by previous levels, which keeps them faithful to the previous levels. You can look at it here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelGreens/comments/38adej/workers_councils_second_draft/

1

u/anarchitekt Libertarian Socialist Jul 28 '15

my point is, i know what you mean by worker councils, but other parties will not, and will waste our entire conversation and debate on defining what it means for us.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '15

I'll work on making the workers council section much more detailed and probably on a press release devoted just to workers councils in the meantime. I want to make it clear that we aren't just giving state officials power over these 100 companies.

2

u/anarchitekt Libertarian Socialist Jul 28 '15

yes. i don't think this bill will pass regardless, but i don't see it as useless. if the language is clear about who is actually in control, and what we mean by worker control, then debates can be productive, and pull the conversation to our end of the spectrum.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

This Bill will fail so hard in Congress. And that is what I love about it, radical legislature will create debates and maybe turn a few minds.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15

I agree with the premise of the bill, but the councils should be independent of the party. I also disagree with the top down nature of the national council. There needs to be an accountability and democratic mechanism added to the bill.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15

They're mostly independent, we mostly just help in setting them up, after that they aren't accountable to the party in any way. The previous Workers Councils motion gives it some accountability, all representatives are instantly recallable by the previous level.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15 edited Jul 30 '15

I think I would be more comfortable supporting this if that was specified in this bill. Another thing I thought of: the list of companies to be nationalized seems pretty random, or just culled off a list of the biggest or most visible companies. It doesn't take into account companies of vital industries, but are less well known; for example, the big telecom companies, like Verizon and AT&T, don't necessarily "control" the Internet. Verizon, AT&T and Sprint are tier 1 providers -- so, they make up the backbone -- but there are others like Level 3 Communications and CenturyLink. I am also wondering why we should nationalize a company like Corrections Corporation of America. Why wouldn't we just pass a bill to make private prison companies illegal? Academi Corporation isn't on the list, but that same bill could apply to them. Just shut that part of the industry down -- private corrections and mercenaries.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15

I agree on the prisons, and I'll make the workers councils much more detailed in the next draft. If you have some good ideas for which companies should go and which should be added I'd appreciate it.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15

I think instead of specifying, the provision should be that all privately held companies be nationalized and handed over to workers councils. If this thing has no hope of passing -- and it doesn't -- then we should go all out.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15

While it has no hope of passing currently, my plan was to propose it every session of Congress. By making it something that could feasibly pass with a GLP majority, or a GLP-ALP majority, we leave it as a plausible option in the future. That's also the reason I'm going to have to find a way to work eminent domain into this, so that it could theoretically pass even if it won't in reality.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15

A GLP majority, I imagine, is going to pass a bill regardless of whether we partially or fully nationalize the economy -- so my thinking is still, why not just go all out and get it done then and there. That's still an argument for eminent domain. While we're at it, we could propose a modification to the fifth amendment, that would strike "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation" from the amendment and add in "personal" before "property" in the preceding sentence, that way we sidestep the whole constitutional issue. But the ALP is never going to go for this, even in a partial form. They're liberals.

This is a revolutionary party and the concern over constitutionality is a bit strange. In the off chance we ever get a majority (hopefully a supermajority), then we can call a new constitutional convention. We should probably do that anyway.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15

There are members in the ALP who would support this. Not the whole party, but there are some.

Regardless, if we ever get a full majority we can just go all out. While we don't have a full majority, we have to at least pretend that we respect the constitution, after all we do have reformist members in the party(though they want to reform to actual socialism and not social democracy).

3

u/xveganrox Marxist | NE State Legislator Jul 27 '15

Super long post, because I think this is important and its goals represent the crux of what we want to accomplish long-term. Like most of you, I absolutely support the goals of this bill. At the same time I think that supporting it would be at best a dead end and at worst detrimental to our goals. The bill, as written, is blatantly unconstitutional and violates the oath our legislators took when they were sworn into office - to "support and defend" the constitution.

If by some act of providence the bill were to be passed it would be immediately struck down by the Supreme Court. Furthermore, support for this bill in congress would show that our party has no respect for the constitution. While privately some of us may have no more regard for it (a document created largely by affluent white slave-owning Protestant men), publicly expressing that view undermines out congressional support and our ability to work with other parties.

I see two ways to further the goals of this bill. The first, and more difficult, would be to amend the constitution to allow for more nationalisation loopholes. I don't think we have much of a chance of doing this without a supermajority or a coalition supermajority, neither of which we had the last time I checked.

The second, and potentially more workable way, would be to use the existing constitution and precedent set by previous federal and SC cases to dramatically edit the bill into something constitutionally viable. I don't think that we could get the congressional votes to pass this, but if we could it would not be immediately struck down by the SC, and even if it doesn't pass we will be able to make a radical statement without undermining our radical goals.

If we're interested in following that second approach, there are already constitutional and legal precedents for nationalising industry. Exhibit A is the Federal Possession and Control Act, which nationalised railroads in 1918, and is somewhat representative of other major nationalisation precedents in the USA:

An Act To provide for the operation of transportation systems while under Federal control, for the just compensation of their owners, and for other purposes.

Important context: this was done during wartime, but the reasoning behind it was that the industry was inefficient due to private ownership and nationalisation was necessary to the public defence. Another important note: private owners were compensated for the duration of the act and private control of institutions was returned post-war. Nationalisation of industry without compensation has, to the best of my knowledge, only occurred in the United States under one specific circumstance and is otherwise explicitly unconstitutional. that specific circumstance brings me to exhibit B: eminent domain.

If you're unfamiliar with the term I suggest you read up on it, because in my opinion it's the single best route we have to progressively nationalising industry. From the Fifth Amendment:

[No person shall] be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

If that doesn't get your socialist motor running, I don't know what will. Eminent domain is used to seize private property (with compensation) all the time. When a private home is in the way of a new highway, this is the justification that the government uses to force a purchase. Two major provisions here: "public use" and "just compensation." For the first provision to be met satisfactorily, we need a case that nationalisation of a private company or industry serves the public good. For most of the private companies on the list, proving this should be elementary: do these companies act against the public good? Obviously (to us) yes; and defining that can fulfil this precedent.

If we can successfully argue the first provision, and these companies are already profitable, the second one is less difficult. Essentially, it requires that we purchase rather than seize these companies. This would make the process less revolutionary and slower, but from a legislative perspective it makes more sense because it isn't unconstitutional.

I think that we have a lot of political capital and goodwill to lose by presenting and supporting this bill as is. On the other hand, editing it to include just compensation as well as a public use justification could fulfil the goal of creating discussion without generating a major backlash. Plus, this approach uses the constitution as a tool rather than pitting us against it. The Fifth Amendment is rather untouchable in popularity - maybe presenting this bill could even force out some reactionary proposals to restrict the Fifth Amendment from our friends on the political right, which would be very politically beneficial for us.

TL;DR: Presenting and supporting this bill without provisions offering compensation and explaining public use benefit could be extremely politically detrimental, and it will fail. Adding those provisions, the bill will still fail, but could create the kind of discussion that we want and will not present us as constitution-burners.

1

u/counterrevolutionary Communist Jul 27 '15

Nicely done :D I also agree with the others responding, that as the radical party, we should propose radical bills to Congress, even though they will most likely fail.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15

So something that also must be taken into account. A few of the right wingers in the leak were talking about how this would drastically affect the worlds economy. While they were largely discussing this as if it were the end of the world they do bring up a valid point.

We need to probably talk about how this will effect the global economy. Whether we want to use this as a way to incite socialist movements across the globe is probably a fairly sizeable project.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15

An Idea for this, how about we establish a new kind of ownership next to private and state ownership? So we would introduce the social ownership as an ownership where the workers control those companies. I know you try to establish this by the worker councils, yet the ownership still is with the state.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

I like this bill very much.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15

I'm not sure about seizing their property if found guilty, but I agree this isn't constitutional. It theoretically could be interpreted as constitutional but the Supreme Court we currently have has no chance of doing that. I think I'll work on making an argument in favor of its constitutionality, but since I doubt this will pass we don't really need to worry as much about constitutionality as we would a bill we believe would pass. I may also work on an amendment that would make this legal, rangerheart and bluefisch made some ideas for that in the past.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '15 edited Jul 27 '15

Please look that this is legally solid. They should try to rip us apart based on the content and not based on the legality.

The easiest way would be to make this an amendment and alter the right of the judges to stop the congress from taking private property.

I found this legal definition for eminent domain: http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/eminent+domain

It is quite well explained. As far as I understand the congress can do what you propose but the supreme court has to allow it in the end.

Edit: okay it is more complicated to make this work. But I still believe that what we want is legal yet we should word it to follow this process

Edit II: The V amendment we are having trouble with here sounds as follows:

No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.

What I have seen so far is that if a state or the federal government exercised eminent domain they sometimes get challenged by a supreme court decision.

1

u/JohnButlerTrain prospective Anarcho-Syndicalist Jul 29 '15

It's interesting that this doesn't specify just compensation for whom. Does it mean the management or the owners? Because technically, if it's still traded on the stock market, the 'owners' haven't had their company taken from them. Could we use that as part of a legal justification?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15

No if you trade something on the stock market the buyer of the stocks actually owns that much of the company.

1

u/JohnButlerTrain prospective Anarcho-Syndicalist Jul 29 '15

Oh, misread the last line. That explains a lot...

1

u/laffytaffyboy Ex Member | Vive la WUO! Vive la Résistance! Jul 27 '15

We could definitely make the argument that any company that makes anything used by the army is an issue of national security. I don't know if that gives us any extra options though.