r/modguide • • Nov 25 '19

Discussion thread What makes a good mod?

22 Upvotes

I’m sure we all have varied ideas of what the ideal mod is, and there’s no perfect answer, but here is some food for thought.

These are comments from one of my anonymous surveys, I have edited the comments into a list and removed repeats.

(Note - this is from a small group of users who replied to my survey on mod help subreddits and samplesize, it was not a requirement to be a mod to answer, but the vast majority of respondents were mods)

The results so far:

A good mod...

  • Is active on the sub

  • Knows the rules and is ready to discuss and explain them when necessary

  • Doesn't necessarily rule with an iron fist but can be firm when needed

  • Is fair and calm

  • Has the same rules for all/Is consistent and transparent enforcing of rules

  • Is willing to learn

  • Puts the needs of the community before their desires

  • Puts personal opinions aside and go by the facts of the situation

  • Is a decent human being

  • Has clear rules

  • Good communication with mods

  • Good communication with users

  • Able to work with others

  • Responsible/ "with great power comes great responsibility"

  • Helpful

  • Posts relevant content

  • Considers ban reversal appeals

  • Is someone who is open to the community

  • Practices “servant leadership”

  • Does mod tasks

  • Doesn't consider themselves any different from a user of that subreddit

  • Has a passion for it

  • Tries to communicate with a user first before banning

  • Answers their messages within 24 hours unless they are away from home

  • Make sure all the information is in the sidebars of both the old and the new designs

  • Is a logical person

  • Is patient

  • Is kind

  • Owns up when wrong

  • Is diligent

  • Obeys all the subs rules and general Reddit guidelines

  • Keeps the sub clean of spam

  • Answers questions

  • Is respectful

  • Hears both sides before decision making (unless they did something clearly wrong)

  • Is nice

  • Not overly strict

  • Encourages conversation

  • Helps members with any issues that arise

  • Finds new ways to help grow the sub

  • Depending on the topic the subreddit covers, tutorials and helpful guides put together by the mods makes them amazing.

  • Regularly reviews activity

  • Gently guides individuals that fail to act according to standards

  • Listens

  • Tries to understand different views

A bad mod…

  • Is a power mod/hardly puts anything in

  • Abuses their power/privileges

  • Uses banning as a prevention method

  • Has favorites

  • Uses the position to abuse other people

  • Has a God complex and believes that their views and opinions have a place in their mod actions

  • Ban for no reason

  • Very emotional

  • Has unclear rules

  • Inconsistent rule enforcement

  • No/poor communication

  • Not active

  • Is overbearing and just throws out all sorts of attacks and bans etc for minor infractions

  • Doesn’t listen

  • Is inactive/absent

  • Is corrupt

  • Has poor judgement

  • Doesn't care for the community

  • No communication with the community

  • Never answers their messages

  • Bans without communicating first

  • Neglects either the old or the new design

  • Is unhelpful

  • Is rude

  • Is toxic

  • Is racist

  • Too strict

  • Sees (all/most) users as a burden

  • Is not open to good faith criticism about the subreddit or its moderation team

  • Doesn't care about how people experience having mod action taken on their post/comment

  • Is biased

  • Tries to profit from modding

You can see our surveys here


r/modguide • • Oct 21 '19

General Ban appeals

22 Upvotes

Having a clear guide set out for how your members can appeal bans can increase transparency and trust and help to assure members that bans will be fair and evenly applied.

I suggest having your ban appeals process in your wiki or available very quickly to anyone who requests it as well as in your ban message to the user. If your team has a google drive, discord or other location where you store templates and other things in there will be great.

Appeals can range from someone not understanding how they broke the subreddits rules, to a user thinking they were unfairly banned, to someone using an appeal as a way to bash the moderating team. What you require as part of a ban appeal is down to your sub but things to consider including are:

Do they know why they were banned?

Do they now understand which rule they broke?

What can they do in future to not break this rule again?

Are they sorry?

A specific title to the message eg Ban Appeal or Formal Ban Appeal (this helps you to see them easily)

How long they have to appeal

Do you want a delay before allowing an appeal?

Appeals should be sent by modmail

The more of these you can include and the clearer you make the instructions the less debate users will be able to have with you about it.

I like requiring a standardised message format so it is much easier for the mod team to process it in a fair and equal way. If they all look the same then following the same process is much easier and roughly the same amount of time can be spent on them. It also filters some out as if they cannot be bothered to use the template required then their appeal is not going to be assessed.

Example of an appeals message format

  1. Set title - Formal Ban Appeal

  2. Link to the post or comment that they were banned for

  3. Explain their understanding of the rule that they broke

  4. Explain how they will avoid this infraction in future

  5. Apologise

Reddit insists that all subs must ACCEPT ban appeals not that they must APPROVE ban appeals.

Have a process agreed with your team to discuss these appeals before they are approved or rejected and make sure that this is stuck to. I find it helps having a different mod to the one that issued the original ban reviewing the appeal so that you can show that multiple people agree with the decision. Have set responses to reply to the appeals with eg

Received

Thank you for your Formal Ban Appeal, this will be reviewed by the team within the next 48 hours and we will reply to you within that time.

Accepted

Thank you for your patience while we reviewed your Formal Ban Appeal. As a team we have decided to remove your ban due to X Y and Z. Please note that any further misconduct within the sub will be an immediate and permanent ban.

Rejected

Thank you for your patience while we reviewed your Formal Ban Appeal. As a team we have decided to uphold your ban due to X Y and Z. Please note that any alts you create to continue using this sub will be immediately and permanently banned.

The best defense against ban appeals is to only ban when required, have a fair and consistent enforcement of the rules and to not let personal feelings about people come into play when considering a ban.


r/modguide • • Jan 20 '23

Mod news/updates Reddit’s Defense of Section 230 to the Supreme Court

Thumbnail
self.reddit
21 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Sep 09 '21

Mod news/updates Mod Certification programs are open for testing!

Thumbnail self.modnews
21 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Jun 15 '20

New subs/mods Moderation tools

21 Upvotes

Mods have several tools and settings at their disposal to help keep a subreddit on topic and safe.

Native tools and settings:

Communication

Good communication lets users know what is expected of them. Clear rules and a community description in both new and old reddit should be added at a minimum.

Rules - set out what is not allowed on your subreddit.

Removal reasons - provide a quick way of letting users know how they can do better.

Distinguishing comments and posts - allows you to let users know when you are speaking officially as a moderator, it adds a little weight to your words.

Warnings - some subs may issue warnings or reminders, these give you the opportunity to to guide users to improve their content (in the future, or to edit their post - automod can help here) or behaviour before you take any further action.

Ban appeals - Having a clear and universal ban appeals process lets your users know what to expect and how you prefer they appeal their bans (you can write this up in your wiki).

Community settings

You have some control over the content you allow on your sub via your communities settings. You can limit post types for example.

Crowd control - This is an opt-in beta at the time of writing, you can find the announcement here. Crowd control collapses comments based on a users relationship with your sub - you can turn it on and off, and set how strict it is. Chat posts also have crowd control.

Locking, filtering, and removals

Locking posts - prevents any new comments from being added. You can do this when you remove a post because the post can still be access by the OP and anyone who has commented, or if the comments have been derailed.

Locking comments - can be done for much the same reasons, but it only locks the specific comment.

Removals - when you remove posts depends on your sub, but generally any post breaking site-wide or subreddit rules should be removed. This can be in combination with locking, removal reasons, a mod comment etc.

Spam - any post that is spam should be spammed. Using the spam button instead of the remove button helps train the spam filter.

Automoderator (AM) - can be set up to filter or remove posts that meet or do not meet certain criteria. It can also comment, message, or modmail too.

Banning and muting

Muting - prevents users from modmailing for 72 hours. You can use it if a user is bothering the mods (report harassment) or as a cooling off period before someone can appeal a ban.

Temporary bans - are when you ban a user for a set amount of time. They are unable to participate on the sub until the ban runs out. Users are informed when they are banned.

Shadow bans - that moderators can do are not true shadowbans, only admins can do that. Mods can use automod to automatically remove posts of certain users. This does not directly inform the user and is controversial.

Another option is to use a similar AM code to filter, instead of remove, a user’s post. This way instead of going into spam, the posts go to the modqueue for you to review.

Permanent bans - are what they sound like. A user is banned indefinitely and the only way it will be reversed is if a mod lifts it, perhaps after a ban appeal.

Reporting

If you come across a post that breaks reddit’s rules you should report it and remove it.

---

Non-native tools:

Bots

If automod can’t do something you’d like automated, you can try a custom bot. These can limit posting and many other things.

---

Related guides


r/modguide • • Nov 29 '19

Design Adding menu tabs

21 Upvotes

(Edit: Images for redesign in this guide will look a bit different to what you now see on your sub - reddit made some changes to the look of redesign in January 2020)

Adding menu tabs helps users navigate your subreddit, and you can use them to make important information easy to locate.

Here on r/modguide our menu tabs (in redesign) take you to (at the time of writing):

  • Our index - this contains links to all our guides just like our sticky post, but more useful stuff too.

  • Our surveys - we'd love you to take these if you haven't!

  • The reddit mods help centre

  • And a link to message the mods with a topic suggestion.

All things we'd like you to pay attention to and be able to find easily.

We also have these links in our sidebar, but the menu tabs could be used instead of the sidebar for certain things in order to keep your sidebar short, it's your preference.

Menu links/tabs on r/modguide redesign

Here is our guide on how to add menu tabs in redesign, including adding the wiki tab.

You can view the links made in the guide on my test sub (I'll try and remember to keep them there!) https://new.reddit.com/r/SolariaHues/

In old.reddit the wiki tab automatically appears when you enable the wiki.

Wiki tab shown on old.reddit subreddit

I don't know if it's possible to add additional tabs in classic reddit, but you can use css to rename the wiki tab if you need to, to FAQ for example:

#header-bottom-left .tabmenu a[href$="wiki/"] {
    font-size: 0 !important;
    content: '' !important;
    padding: 0 !important;
}
#header-bottom-left .tabmenu a[href$="wiki/"]:after {
    content: 'FAQ';
    font-size: 12px;
    background-color: rgb(239, 247, 255);
    padding: 2px 6px 0px 6px;
}

Source

Intro to CSS


r/modguide • • Oct 02 '19

Engagement A guide to AMAs

21 Upvotes

Intro to AMAs

An “AMA” is a common event that takes place both inside and outside of Reddit. “AMA” stands for “Ask me anything”. It is an event where creators, celebrities, public figures, or regular folk with interesting experiences or specific knowledge, and the like can answer any questions the general public has within a certain timeframe. AMAs are a great opportunity to have users both old and new participate more in your community, helping it grow.

AMAs can be from content creators, those behind the scenes or celebrities who have a tie in with your sub. For example an artist may do an AMA for r/music when they release a new album or an actor for r/AMA when they release a new movie. Scientists might AMA for r/AskScience and so on.

On r/modguide we will be having AMAs (or AAMAs - Ask a mod anything!) from experienced mods so that you can put your questions to them.

**Can I and should I host an AMA on my sub?**

Yes! AMAs are most commonly hosted on r/AMA or r/iAMA, but many smaller subs have hosted AMAs in the past. r/gardenwild has hosted a couple https://www.reddit.com/r/GardenWild/wiki/amas - the guests were a hedgehog rescuer and Prof Goulson, Professor of bumblebees!

Make sure your guest has valid proof to avoid impersonation. For example, on President Obama’s AMA (link below) he verified himself *three times*.

Most common verification methods are Twitter, photo with a username sign and other social media such as instagram or facebook. This can help with being an advertising tool as well if your AMA guest is happy to post ahead of time to let their fans know when and where to be.

Definitely check out this article https://mods.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360002086132-What-is-an-AMA-and-why-would-I-host-one- written by Reddit themselves which will help you understand what an AMA is and why you would host one, and also how to prepare for one.

**Examples of AMAs**

Here are some of the most notable AMAs that have taken place on Reddit:

I am Barack Obama, President of the United States -- AMA https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/z1c9z/i_am_barack_obama_president_of_the_united_states/

Hi, I’m Mr. Koizumi, Producer of Super Mario Odyssey. AMA! https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/6h9s6l/hi_im_mr_koizumi_producer_of_super_mario_odyssey/

I’m Woody Harrelson, AMA

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/p9a1v/im_woody_harrelson_ama/

I Am Astronaut Chris Hadfield, currently orbiting planet Earth. https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/18pik4/i_am_astronaut_chris_hadfield_currently_orbiting/

Keanu Reeves. Ask me, if you want, almost anything https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1ouqge/keanu_reeves_ask_me_if_you_want_almost_anything/

The best AMAs are the ones where the answerer is actually happy answering (almost) anything and spends time to respond to as many questions as possible. Please see the Rampart AMA for an example of how not to do it. AMAs should not be solely about self promotion.

**How to set up an AMA**

You will need to get in contact with the person you want to do an AMA - if they are a redditor this is pretty easy, just drop them a message. If they are not a redditor you can try other social media, on r/IamArequests, or by reaching out to their agency or company directly. AMAs can be in the process of being scheduled for years especially with bigger celebrities but they can be absolutely worth it not only for sub traffic but for advertisement. Sometimes those wanting to do an AMA will reach out to you.

**Preparation is key**

Especially if your AMA guest has never used reddit before, and/or hasn't previous seen any AMAs.

It's a good idea to chat with your guest and gain an understanding of their prior knowledge. Link them to past AMAs so they know what to do and expect. If they have never used reddit before you will need to either take some time and help them learn before the AMA, or be on hand early at the time of the AMA to help guide them though. Check this list https://mods.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360002086292-Are-you-ready-for-the-AMA- to make sure you have everything you need prepared.

It may also be a good idea, especially if your sub in relatively small, to prepare some questions for you guest in case you need to help get things started.

Make sure to **notify users** ahead of time about the AMA. You can use stickies, the sidebar and sidebar calendar widget, and you can make your announcement post an event post and put all updates in a collection.

If you are wanting to advertise in other related subs, make sure this is OK first. Cross post the AMA itself to r/iAMA if it is within their rules.

**During the AMA**

You should be on hand to help your guest if need be, and make sure the comments are moderated especially for any controversial topics.

You can make a sticky comment to provide any necessary details to users during the AMA.

**After the AMA**

Remember to thank your guest, help them update the post to say it's over if they need a hand, and if you record your AMA's - add it to your wiki.

Written by u/MaybeTomorr0w u/no-elf-and-safety u/solariahues


r/modguide • • Oct 20 '22

General 🎙 What can Reddit Mods learn from other social media platforms' experiences of state-sponsored propaganda and content manipulation?

20 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Jan 10 '21

Mod news/updates Don't panic!

20 Upvotes

Reddit is having some issues right now, so if your subreddit design is funky or missing at the moment, wait a couple hours and see if it's back :)

Status | Twitter

Edit- I think it's fixed, looks better for me now. I was a bit late :'D


r/modguide • • Aug 10 '20

Chat thread ModChat - What's on your mind?

20 Upvotes

Hi mods, let us know what's on your mind mod-wise right now!

What problems are you tackling? What are you working on? What is going well?


r/modguide • • Jul 13 '20

Chat thread ModChat - What's on your mind?

20 Upvotes

Hi mods, let us know what's on your mind mod-wise right now!

What problems are you tackling? What are you working on? What is going well?


r/modguide • • Nov 22 '19

General Dealing with the rapid growth of a subreddit

20 Upvotes

Reddit has an official guide to rapid subreddit growth however some of the suggestions are vague and lacking in practical applications. It's a good place to start, but I hope to fill in a few of the blanks.

The best kind of subs in my opinion are niche subs that are allowed to grow organically far away from the unwashed masses at r/all. Subs that are allowed to grow organically have time to develop a strong culture. Of course subreddit growth is important. But what happens when it comes faster than expected or faster than you can deal with it?

What are you going to do if a breaking news event, or a viral moment happens, or your sub gets name dropped in a top voted r/askreddit comment and it brings thousands of subscribers? The sub could also be featured on Reddit's trending subreddit feature. What if those subscribers come in and change the entire complexion of the sub? How do you deal with issues like that?

From my previous posts you'll note that I use extensive infrastructure on a sub with automoderator and toolbox. Familiarity with those tools will allow you to use them effectively if a massive growth spike happens and help prevent things from getting out of hand. You can find those posts [here] (https://www.reddit.com/r/modguide/comments/db2gfy/automoderator_what_it_is_and_how_to_set_it_up/), and here.

Nearly every mod will tell you that one of the biggest problems with reddit is making users read and follow the rules. New users who find your sub through the trending feature or any other breaking news type event are not going to read your rules, and they may not care about the prior subreddit culture.

What kind of sub you're on, and how much you want to preserve that culture for the users will determine what steps you'll take.

I'm also going to assume that you have enough mods to handle duties if a spike happens. Reddit has initiated a new program called Mod Reserves which provides relief in the form of temporary mods, but I've not heard reports of anyone using it yet.

You could preemptively reach out to mods on similar themed subs and ask them for help should you need temporary mods to help with a traffic spike. Another route is to always have a few quality contributors to your sub that you might consider for modship. It's entirely up to you as to who you choose to add as a mod, but investment in quality content for the sub is a good indicator that a user could be a good mod. Of course there are other factors to consider but the point is, it's good to have a few people in mind that you could reach out to in the event of an emergency.

The most drastic thing you can do is take your sub private. Unless you have an extensive list of approved users, you might face a backlash from your frequent users if they can't access the sub. If you try to mass add approved users you'll run up against a rate limit and it will become unworkable. You could add approved users in advance of an event like this, but there are other ways to control the sub and provide a forum for users while at the same time helping make your work easier.

You could set the subreddit to restricted so that no one but approved users can post, but that might turn off users as well.

Here is my recommendation based on being involved in about a half dozen of these events.

I leave the subreddit open, but set the spam filter setting for links and text posts to 'all'. I never even knew what this setting did until someone explained to me that it's "much easier to approve than remove" a post. Setting your subreddit spam filter setting to 'all' will allow users to post but every new post will show up in your mod queue where your team can review them and approve them as necessary. The goal is not to choke off the sub entirely, but not to get overwhelmed as users post the same link, story, or question. That way you can keep discussion focused and centralized.

The spam filter settings are accessed through your mod tools on your sidebar. It can currently only be adjusted in the old site. Go to Community Settings -> Settings for the old site. You will be then taken to the subreddit settings on the old version of reddit. Look for Spam Filter Strength about halfway down and set the radio buttons for links and text posts to 'all'.

To provide an outlet for discussion, I make use of an index thread, or a collection on new reddit. An index thread can link to all the various discussion threads taking place on the sub. As quality posts are made to the sub, you can approve them and link them to the index. For any question spam posts or other low effort posts you can remove them and direct them to a general discussion thread.

The users who were on the sub before the event should appreciate your efforts at directing traffic in order to keep the quality of content high and the new users will find out right away that there are parameters to posting. You can't really blame new users for not understanding reddit so it makes sense to take steps to try and onboard them smoother.

You could use an automod rule that tells the user their account is new and link them to various threads to get them up to speed. For more on this, see here.

A sub I was on recently hit r/trendingsubreddits and nearly doubled in size. We were getting swamped with new posts that were seriously low effort. I modified the above plan and made a sticky post alerting users that the sub was on 'manual approve' for a little while to preserve the sub and turned it into a discussion thread. After about 2 days it calmed down and I opened the sub back up. I was left with incredible subscriber growth without affecting the complexion and culture of the sub.

It also pays to be active in comment threads during these events because your warnings or guidance are being seen by thousands of lurkers who might post or comment at any time. Most problems can be solved with good communication and setting expectations so that everyone is on the same page.

In conclusion there are several aspects to dealing with rapid growth, but the main decision you'll need to make is what restrictions you'll make regarding posting. If you provide a release valve in the form of discussion thread(s) and quality link posts, you'll keep the quality of the sub high and provide focused areas for discussion which will help keep your community healthy and onboard new users faster.

Good luck!


r/modguide • • Oct 29 '19

Engagement Community Awards

20 Upvotes

These have been depreciated

https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit/comments/14ytp7s/reworking_awarding_changes_to_awards_coins_and/

What are community awards?

Community Awards are like the usual reddit awards/gold/silver/platinum, however Community Awards are unique to each community. Mods can set them up to suit their community (including in-jokes) and their members can award them to each other.

  • Only public, non-banned, non-quarantined, and SFW, communities can have Community Awards)

  • Only mods will full permissions can edit or add community awards.

You can currently create up to 16 Community Awards:

8x Awards at 500 Coins

4x Awards at 1000 Coins

1x Award at 2000 Coins

1x Award at 5000 Coins

1x Award at 10,000 Coins

1x Award at 40,000 Coins

You can also have up to 4 mod awards, which are awards that only the mods can give out (full permissions) and that gifts months of reddit premium.

As users give awards to each other, some of the coins go into the community pot. This can be spent by mods giving out the mod only award, these are useful for competitions.

Mod awards can be at 1,800 coins (1 month premium), 5,400 (3 months), 10,800 (6 months), or 21,600 (12 months).

Reddit explains them at r/ModNews here, and on the Reddithelp page on awards

Example awards - Community Awards on different subs

Awards for anyone to use

Making Awards

Award width and height should be equal, and 512px. File size is limited to 2MB.

Awards can display really small, just like reddit gold, silver, and platinum, so your designs should be clear and simple.

I tend to attempt to draw awards, but you can also make them by removing the background from an image you'd like to use (please keep copyright law in mind).

Resources:

Image / Drawing Editors

Paid:

Free:

r/bannerrequest - request graphics for your sub if you meet the requirements in the rules.

How to upload awards

(Edit: An image or two in this guide will look different to how your sub looks - reddit changed the look of redesign in Jan 2020)

Our guide | Reddit guide

There isn't a way to test awards that I know of, but when you upload you see a preview and I assumed the smallest preview was what they might look like when given out.

Adapting how Awards display in old.reddit

Awards display very small. On redesign you can hover over them and see a larger image and description. This doesn't happen in old.reddit. Here is a snippet of CSS you can add to your stylesheet to make them a bit bigger and even larger when hovered over with a mouse pointer.

/* Award sizing (based on code from r/nba) */

.awarding-link[data-award-id=""] .awarding-icon, .awarding-link[data-award-id=""], .awarding-icon-container {

height: 20px;

width: 20px!important;

}

.awarding-icon {

max-height: 20px!important;

max-width: 20px!important;

margin: 5px 5px -5px 0;

transition: transform .5s ease;

}

.awarding-icon:hover {

transform: scale(2.5);

position: absolute;

}

---

Thanks to u/juulh for the resources, and r/nba and u/buckrowdy for the CSS snippet.


r/modguide • • Sep 02 '22

Bots Modguide Script Library: Be notified when a user gets X number of toolbox usernotes in your sub.

Thumbnail
github.com
19 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Jan 01 '22

Discussion thread Happy New Year mods!

19 Upvotes

Hope you're all having a good start to the new year!

Any new things planned for your subreddits, or any tips for those getting into modding this year?

Is there anything you'd like to see us do this year?!


r/modguide • • Jun 02 '21

Tools Controlling post types on your community

19 Upvotes

Our How to change the post types allowed on your subreddit guide has been up for some time now, but what it's always lacked is how you can have finer control over what can be posted.

Thanks to the wonderful u/001Guy001, there is now a wiki page with instructions on how to tailor what can be posted to your community, not only using community settings, but content controls and automoderator too.

SEE THE PAGE HERE

The wiki page is linked in the post types guide and the index's.

Big thanks to 001Guy001


r/modguide • • Feb 10 '20

Bots [VIDEO] Adding rules to automoderator (redesign)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Jan 22 '20

New subs/mods Recommended subreddits for mods

19 Upvotes

Edit - updated version https://www.reddit.com/r/modguide/about/wiki/index/helpandsupport

This is admittedly a bit of a low effort guide, but I have seen a few mods surprised by the changes to redesign lately, so I thought a list of recommended subs might help, especially for new mods finding their way.

As far as I know, following some of these subs is the only way to keep up to date with changes to reddit, with the exception of being involved with beta testing or focus groups.

Follow, or stick these in custom feeds, and check them when you can, especially r/modnews

Recommended subreddits to follow as a mod:

Reddit News:

r/announcements - Keep up to date with announcements from reddit admins; rolled out features, competitions, and more

r/changelog - Info on minor updates and fixes to reddit

r/modnews - News and updates that affect mods

r/OutOfTheLoop - "A subreddit to help you keep up to date with what's going on with reddit and other stuff. "

r/bugs - Report bugs on reddit, also r/redditmobile for app updates and bugs

r/blog - Reddit's blog (edit: now with fortnightly round-ups of changes on reddit!)

r/redditsecurity - Information on security on reddit

r/reddit - has replaced announcements and changelog. Is a hub for news, lore, and more

Mod help subs:

r/modhelp - Mods helping other mods, a good place to ask if you need a hand

r/modsupport - This sub is more for mods who need help from admins, though mods help too

r/needamod - Place to ask for new mods

r/modclub - Chat with other mods

r/askmoderators - Ask mods questions

r/automoderator - instructions in the sidebar, ask for help

And us ;) we do guides to assist all mods.

Official mod training - r/ModCertification

Design:

r/csshelp - Get help with css

r/themes - Get ready made CSS themes

r/redesignhelp - Get help with designing your sub in redesign

r/bannerrequest - Request banners or icons

Take over/start a sub:

r/adoptareddit - Place to adopt or give away a subreddit

r/redditrequest - Request to mod abandoned or banned reddits

r/AvailableSubs - Abandoned subs available for request

r/substarters - Discord community where you find help started or reanimating subreddits (on hiatus)

r/subredditideas - Ideas for new subs

Other:

r/ideasfortheadmins - Post ideas for improving reddit

r/TheoryOfReddit - " for inquiring into what makes Reddit communities work and what we in a community can do to help make it better. "

r/redditmobile - announcements and discussion about the official apps

r/beta - for reddit beta testers

r/community_chat - feedback on subreddit chatrooms

What would you add?


r/modguide • • Jan 17 '20

New subs/mods Community settings in redesign

19 Upvotes

Guide to your community settings in redesign

This guide is on Imgur: Click here to view the guide

!!! There have been a number of updates to the new reddit settings since this guide was written. Including the archived posts option, and new post types !!!

Further notes:

Following on from #5 - Type of community in the Imgur guide, here is our guide on Private, restricted, or public subreddits

And if you're sub is set to restricted you have a couple more options:

You can set what approved users have the ability to do (post only, comment only, or post and comment)

You can also set whether users are able to send you modmail requests to ask if they can have the ability to post/become an approved user, or not.

There are individual guides on:


r/modguide • • Oct 22 '19

Mod Pro Tips Strategies for dealing with bad faith users, harassment, and stalking on reddit.

19 Upvotes

I would like to preface this post by saying that harassment, stalking and bullying is a serious issue on reddit and there are users who have had a far worse experience with these issues than I have. This post describes my experience, what I have done to address these issues, and the knowledge that I have gained by reading what others have done. I hope that other users will add their thoughts and ideas in the comments below if they have anything to add.

Notes:

  • This is part 1 of a 2-part series. The second part will approach these issues from a female perspective. I hope any readers who see this series and have something to add that was omitted will do so because better approaches to these issues are always welcome.

  • This post does not discuss the type of harassment that needs to be reported to law enforcement authorities. That's a separate category altogether and should be reported to the proper authorities if it happens. Some reddit harassment may fit that category or quickly move into that category.


The internet can be a great place but it can also be tedious and comes with various pitfalls. There are a lot of users out there with bad intentions and this post discusses how to deal with bad faith users, trolls, stalkers, and serial harassers.

In my last post I told you that reddit had recently updated their bullying and harrassment policy and that it remains to be seen exactly how this policy will be enforced. Early reviews are mostly positive which is good because reddit is a platform where it is very easy to harass other users. This change should make it easier to deal with these issues going forward.

It's been well documented that moderators receive more harassment than other users. This post will discuss strategies for mitigating these issues from both perspectives since there is significant overlap.

The best way you can prevent harassment as a mod is to utilize one account for modding and a separate account your other reddit activity. Many users find this inconvenient which is kind of the thing about security: it is inconvenient. And that is why so many people are lax with it.

Using separate accounts is ideal but if we always did the ideal thing then posts like this wouldn't even be necessary, so let's assume you're like most users and you use one account for everything. You probably have a comment history, you have all your RES settings perfected, you've subscribed to hundreds of subreddits, and you feel more at home in your main account. That's perfectly normal.

Harassment on reddit as a user consists mostly of being sent messages as PMs, comment replies, or chat requests. It's a good idea to have a plan for what you're going to do when someone decides to start sending you harassing messages or following you around the site.

While there is no perfect solution for dealing with bad faith users, sometimes it's just about putting as many obstacles as you can in the path of the troll so it requires more effort to keep up the behavior long term. Keep in mind a determined troll will still find a way around most of these obstacles.


As a user:

There's a reason discussion forums have been so popular for so long. It's because they give users a way to learn, discuss, and connect with like minded users around a common interest. Whenever you put your opinions out there you open yourself up to criticism. There's two broad categories for this type of criticism: valid, and ad hominem attacks. An ad hominem attack is when a user attacks the other user themselves instead of the argument being made. In my last post I linked Graham's discussion pyramid. The bottom 4 levels are disingenuous arguments, and the bottom few are outright bad faith arguments. Bad faith users have bad intentions and can't be trusted to do the right thing and it's important to have a plan in place for when you encounter them.

In my opinion, the gold standard of education on interacting with bad faith users is a video series called The Alt Right Playbook. This series, despite the political title, outlines bad faith user behavior better than any single source that I've come across. It just so happens that most bad faith users are political-minded. Watching this series will make you infinitely more prepared to deal with these types of users in the future. In the meantime though, keep in mind you are never under any obligation to ever respond to any bad faith user if they try to provoke you or for any other reason.

If a user responds to your post or comment with a rude reply, you are under no obligation to respond. I know it can be hard to resist the urge, but it really is the right thing to do. You can stop any argument or fight immediately by simply choosing to not reply. Too often users fail to recognize bad faith commenters and get engaged in a back-and-forth, become angry, and get into a fight causing a mod to have to take action. Always remember that you hold the power by simply choosing not to engage with a bad faith user or troll. You don't owe anyone a response.

It's also important to understand that many users do not come to discussion forums to have their mind changed, they come to argue. In any exchange with a user it should be clear within 2 comments if that user is being receptive to the argument you are making. If they're not being receptive, it makes little sense to continue to attempt to persuade because it quickly becomes tedious.

The maxim "don't feed the trolls" has been criticized recently in some circles, but there's a reason it's been around for so long. Ignoring a user who is bothering you below a certain threshold can only be mitigated by refusing to engage with them at all. Above a certain threshold the behavior can only be mitigated by site admins and it should be reported. One report does not give admins enough context on a user so you should report the behavior each time you see it, keeping in mind not to veer off into spamming reports.

Reddit's block feature can be used but is not ideal for every situation. The block feature prevents users from messaging or replying to you. You don't see their comments in a thread (unless you're a mod of that sub), but this strategy can be less than ideal because a user might be saying something about you that needs to be reported and you're not able to do that if you can't see it.

The idea that you should have to sanitize your comment history of any identifying information that could be used to doxx you is one that many users endorse. It is a good practice not to have too much identifying info in your account, but this entire proposition shifts the burden onto the user instead of placing blame squarely on the harasser. Users shouldn't have to live in fear that someone will doxx them or otherwise harass them.

A friend of mine puts it this way:

I’ve noticed a common attitude on reddit where people seem to think harassment is deserved if you do something wrong or something to piss someone off. There’s also a common attitude that if you’re on the internet, you deserve whatever you get, because “that’s how the internet works” and “if you don’t like it then leave.” I personally find this attitude ridiculous. Why should I have to stay off the entire internet just because I don’t want to be harassed for my opinions/online presence? How about you not be a jerk and learn how to have a civil conversation?

If you're concerned with reddit account safety, enable two factor authentication on your reddit account (and really all your internet accounts).


As a mod:

As a mod, you should absolutely be using two factor authentication on your account.

Everything that applies to you as a user also applies to you as a mod but there are other wrinkles. As a mod you have access to third party tools to help you mitigate abuse and harassment. Learning to utilize these tools and having infrastructure in place via toolbox, RES, and automoderator will help you be ready when harassment via a banned user happens. Other tools can be used such as masstagger, or reddit pro tools to help you keep track of users.

Bad faith users can find your community in any number of ways. If your sub hits r/popular, or r/all it will be subject to an influx of non-subscribers that don't know the subreddit culture and are a much higher risk to be rule breakers. Bad faith users can also be inadvertently created by you as a mod if you are required to action them. It's best to use a calm, consistent, fair, and firm approach when dealing with problem users. This will lessen the chances of converting a good user into a bad one, but sometimes it happens anyway despite your best efforts.

Unfortunately reddit makes it easy for banned users to create new accounts to evade subreddit and site wide restrictions, but placing more obstacles in their path makes it that much harder for a user to continue harassment so it's good practice to have automoderator rules in place to prevent banned users from immediately coming back to the community to continue their behavior. Depending on the severity of the attack such as brigading, it's wise to have a robust mod team in different time zones. Other posts on the sub discuss this.

There are sites for user research that can help you further analyze a user's history, but many of the accounts will likely be new or won't have enough comment history to parse. Toolbox usernotes and RES tags are helpful to identify users to keep track of them. Third party bots are also available which can offer more help but that are a topic for another post.

Automoderator provides the ability to shadow ban a user which will silently prevent a user from posting to your sub. Savvy users will be able to figure it out quickly though so it's not a perfect solution.

A blocked or shadow banned user's comments will still display in subs you mod and if this bothers you toolbox offers an option to completely hide those comments. If just the sight of a username bothers you, this setting can come in handy. Putting a troll out of sight out of mind may help you ignore him, depriving him of the attention he seeks, but more importantly lessening the chance you'll be provoked into a reply. CSS can also be used to help hide auto-removed comments. Other options include setting your subreddit spam filter to all, blocking all new posts from being made, restricting your subreddit, or taking the subreddit private. Some of these techniques are a better fit for brigading, a subject for another post.

It's important to note that for reddit to consider ban evasion, you must ban at least one account. Ban evasion is easy on reddit because of the low bar required to create new accounts. Many users and mods find themselves in situations where a determined user will carry on harassment over a period of months or even years utilizing as many accounts as necessary to continue the behavior. IP bans, also known as (global) shadow bans are controversial due to false positives and the ease in evading them by savvy users, but they can be useful in certain circumstances. Again it can be worthwhile to place as many obstacles in a troll's path as possible requiring more effort to continue the behavior. If the effort outweighs the return on investment, usually the troll will find another mark or will get bored and move on.

Users who create a series of accounts to get around an account suspension are harder to deal with. It's a good idea to keep notes on these accounts so that when you report it the full scope of the issue can be understood, but keep in mind that links are the only evidence admins will accept. Screenshots will fall on deaf ears. Once a user shows they won't stop creating new accounts they could be subject to an IP ban.

IP bans are an admin level action that is said to be an abandoned practice, but there are still certain circumstances where it can be effective. Those circumstances are set by the admins and all you can do is report and let them take action. Reddit has made it easier and more convenient to report harassment and they are increasing response times but response times are not immediate and may be nonexistent on weekends and holidays.

Building up good faith with the community and gaining consensus of the sub will help you head off some of these issues before they even start. Indeed if you're using a calm, consistent, fair, and firm mod style you should experience less of these issues depending on the sub. Having the consensus of the community and being known as a level headed, fair person who won't jump to conclusions or take knee-jerk actions will pay benefits when you need to intercede on the sub. When you action a user in public via the comments section keep in mind the vast audience of lurkers. Distinguished comments should be addressed to both the user and the subreddit at large. If a user goes sideways on you and you remain calm then the rest of the community will see and understand that and gain confidence in you.


So that's about it. While it does appear that reddit is stepping up efforts to mitigate the type of harassment that users have endured for years, the techniques discussed in this post are still valid and should be used.

I'd like to reiterate that this post details only my point of view on this issue, and I know others have dealt with these issues on a far worse scale. I hope that users of r/modguide will share their experiences with any of these issues and the mitigation strategies they use in the comments below.


Footnote: Because I mentioned 2FA and because this happened to me last time I changed phones, I think it's important to point out the process for maintaining two factor authentication on your account through the act of getting a new phone.


r/modguide • • Mar 08 '23

Mod news/updates [r/RedditTalk] Sunsetting Reddit Talk

Thumbnail
self.reddittalk
18 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Dec 30 '22

Discussion thread Happy New Year mods!

18 Upvotes

I hope you're all having a great holiday season and have a happy new year!

Has/is your sub doing something different or special for the holidays?

Any new things planned for your subreddits, or any tips for those getting into modding in the new year?

Is there anything you'd like to see us do this next year?!

Let us know :)

Happy New Year from r/modguide!


r/modguide • • Apr 10 '22

Mod Talk Join us on Saturday, April 16th at 1 PM EST (1hr earlier than usual) for a live Talk - Handling rule violations and bad actors

18 Upvotes

If you're not familiar with Reddit Talk, click here for a helpful page.

The talk will be hosted by u/PrettyOakTree of r/OrangeTheory and some other r/ModGuide writers will be around too!

This talk will focus on handling rule violations, removal reasons, and bad actors.

Please note, the start time is 1hr earlier than usual. 1PM ET.

If you are new to the community, r/ModGuide is primarily a collection of resources for moderators, the majority of which are guides written by moderators. You can find our guides and other resources listed in our index. And our list of help and support sources for mods is here.


r/modguide • • Mar 30 '22

Mod news/updates TLDR - A look at Reddit's Moderator Programs and Spaces

Thumbnail
self.modnews
18 Upvotes

r/modguide • • Feb 15 '22

Mod Talk Join us on Saturday, February 19th at 2 PM EST for a live Talk on building mod teams and fostering community!

18 Upvotes

If you're not familiar with Reddit Talk, click here for a helpful page.

The talk will be hosted by u/PrettyOakTree of r/OrangeTheory and some other r/ModGuide writers will be around too!

This talk will focus on Building mod teams and fostering community.

If you are new to the community r/ModGuide is primarily a collection of resources for moderators, the majority of which are guides written by moderators. You can find our guides and other resources listed in our index. And our list of help and support sources for mods is here.

You can click follow on this post to be reminded, but you'll have to load r/ModGuide to find the talk then - on New Reddit or mobile. Also, if you follow r/ModGuide, you should get a notification when the talk begins! See you then 👋