I’ve been testing the same icon prompt across different AI image models for mobile app icon work.
Screenshot:
Left → Grok 4.1
Middle → GPT 5.1
Right → Nano Banana Pro
All three use this exact structured prompt:
{
"style": "full-frame soft 3D minimal illustration, no borders, no frames, no rounded-square shapes, no icon container, no outline, no box, no card. The artwork must fill the entire canvas and float freely on the background.",
"concept": {
"topic": "{topic_name}",
"primary_shape": "{primary_shape}",
"secondary_shape": "{secondary_shape}",
"interaction": "{how_they_interact}"
},
"resolution": "4000x4000",
"colors": {
"symbol_main": "{symbol_main_hex}",
"symbol_highlight": "{symbol_highlight_hex}",
"background_start": "{background_start_hex}",
"background_end": "{background_end_hex}"
},
"composition": {
"aspect_ratio": "1:1",
"camera_angle": "straight-on front view",
"primary_scale": "60-80%",
"secondary_scale": "20-40%",
"layout": "primary shape centered, secondary shape positioned meaningfully relative to primary shape",
"padding": "minimal, shapes fill the canvas without touching edges or being clipped",
"background_style": "smooth radial gradient from background_start to background_end, no texture"
},
"shapes_style": {
"geometry": "smooth rounded edges, soft forms, no sharp corners",
"lighting": "very soft subtle lighting from top-left, no harsh highlights",
"shadow": "extremely minimal and soft shadow, almost invisible, just enough to separate shapes from background, no dark edges, no deep ambient shadows",
"material": "premium matte plastic with faint gloss"
},
"constraints": {
"no_text": true,
"no_frames": true,
"no_containers": true,
"no_borders": true,
"no_rounded_square_shapes": true,
"no_extra_objects": true,
"full_frame": true,
"consistent_style": true
}
}