Hi there! I make concept/theory dissection posts on r/straykids, but it was suggested to me that I should share my posts on this sub for other people to learn about how much work and thought go into Stray Kids’ performances, so here I am! (also a special thanks to u/quietkpoplurker !) This post in particular will be analyzing their cover of “I’ll Be Your Man” from the last Kingdom episode. This version of the post has been slightly edited to be more digestible to non-STAYs, but for a STAY-friendly version (with a lot more SKZ-related jokes and hype), you can head over here!
Disclaimer! First off, this post is VERY LONG, as are all my other posts. I go into A LOT of detail, so you have been warned. Secondly, the ideas and connections that I’ll explain here are not all going to be my own; much of the storyline/meaning of the performance has already been dissected by many stays on twt and instagram already. If I could give credit to every single person I’ve learned from, I would. The purpose of this post is to simply gather everything that’s been said by various people/platforms into one place, as well as offer some of my own connections and insight.
*All references have time-stamped links for more accessible visual viewing.
Concept + Storyline Dissection
[Original meaning behind IBYM by BTOB] The meaning behind the original song is fairly straightforward: a man (BTOB) prays to God to bring back his female lover, who is now gone. (The reason behind the lover’s absence is never specified. Perhaps there was a break-up, or the lover could even be dead. Either way, she isn’t here anymore.) The very phrase, “I’ll be your man,” simultaneously expresses a pleading desperation to be with the lover once again, as well as a declarative resolution to be someone dependable to her in the future. There is also a sense of regret, implying that the man/BTOB was either not good enough to his lover in the relationship, or that he failed to protect her from harm. The original MV for IBYM presents these emotions with a unique, cinematic storyline and a major plot twist (I highly recommend watching it). Additionally, both the lyrics and original MV heavily reference religious themes and terminology.
[SKZ’s take on IBYM] As 3RACHA said themselves in the most recent episode, SKZ’s cover of IBYM encompasses the spectrum of feelings that one experiences after losing someone precious, someone who doesn’t necessarily have to be a female lover like in the original. This change allowed the song to be more inclusive, and therefore more widely applicable, even relatable. (*Side note: This step was also accompanied by the removal of all gendered pronouns in the lyrics.) Continuing the religious theme from the original work, as well as their Side Menu performance, SKZ take the biblical concept and run with it, to paint an otherworldly picture of heaven, hell, and the nature of mortality onstage. The phrase “I’ll be your man” in this performance conveys the same sentiments as it did in the original, and the feeling of regret is just as raw; but SKZ’s desperation leads them to make a “forbidden negotiation,” in which they sacrifice their own lives to protect their “precious person.” The cover is a dark rendition that does not compromise any of the deep emotional sorrow expressed in the original; a truly respectful homage that did justice to an iconic song, with its own morbidly imaginative twists. As with all SKZ work, it’s open-ended, multifaceted, and steeped in layers. There’s a lot more happening than what you see on the screen, which is precisely why I will be picking apart all the most significant interpretations of the performance below.
1} The basic performance storyline. This plotline delineates the main story SKZ were trying to tell in the performance. It’s what is visually presented to you on screen, and it’s also only the surface-level layer. The fact it’s already complicated at surface-level though, says a lot. I also know some were confused about it, so I’ll try my best to make it as clear as possible. Lastly, I want to note that the lyrics to this cover match the storyline almost perfectly, so I recommend using them to make the performance easier to follow.
SKZ mourns the death of a little boy who was very precious to them. They present flowers to a statue of the boy in the same way one presents flowers to a grave as they grieve. There’s even a flashback sequence in black-and-white showing how precious the boy was to them. Interestingly, SKZ also took the “baby” referred to in the lyrics of the song quite literally, since the Korean word for baby (애기/aegi) is also used to refer to young children, and we can see them actually use a child in the performance.
SKZ beg and pray to God to give them back their precious child. Changbin, who was walking on a path of light, decides to stray (hehe) off the path to climb the stairs to heaven himself, in an attempt to ask God in person. At the top of the stairs, there is a silhouette of the boy on the LED screen, but just as Changbin gets to the top, it vanishes, and Changbin essentially falls from heaven, as God does not answer his prayers. The fiery nature of the stage during the chorus foreshadows that SKZ will eventually have to turn to darker powers to have their prayers answered.
God has refused to answer SKZ’s prayers to resurrect the boy, probably because it messes with the natural order of life and death. SKZ then enter the gates of hell, in order to make a deal with the devil. Since it is taboo for humans to bring someone back from the dead, the angels of heaven attempt to stop them from participating in this deal. Felix is dragged by two angels, bound in chains. He eventually breaks the chains, and both Han and Changbin outmaneuver the angels to make their sacrifice.
SKZ make a “blood sacrifice” to the devil, in which they sell their souls in order to bring the boy back to life. Heaven and hell are thrown into disarray, because the natural balance of the supernatural realms has been disturbed (as seen by the crumbling pillars). The devil gives them a human heart, and SKZ offer this heart to the boy.
At the song’s climax, we basically see SKZ on the brink of death, actively in the process of dying, as the ghosts/souls from before are dancing all around them. SKZ have sacrificed their own lives to bring back this boy, so they fall dead at the end of the song, with the resurrected boy wrapping his arms around Chan in the final moment.
2} Universal applications. A hallmark feature of SKZ’s performances on Kingdom is their ability to be applied to a multitude of situations, and this one is no exception. (If you would like to know more about how previous performances have achieved this, please check out my theory rambles on the intro stage and for the first round. These are also criminally long.) The performances themselves are never abstract per se, but the concepts and motifs are highly figurative in nature, making open interpretation possible. With this performance, SKZ made it easy for anyone to replace the little boy with whomever is precious to them. They conveyed the universal human experience of emotion–of grief, in particular–with a story that so many could relate to. How many of us have lost a loved one, and found ourselves in immeasurable sorrow and despair? How many of us have angrily cursed whatever higher powers exist in heaven for taking someone away from us, but have turned around, just to bargain and beg for them back? How many of us would do whatever it takes to be with the person we love again?
3} The philosopher’s stone. This may be less of a layer, and more so inspiration or lore. It may not even be what SKZ were aiming for in the first place, but after seeing so many people reference it in relation to Fullmetal Alchemist, I was pretty much sold on the idea, not to mention that it makes sense in context of the performance. For those of you who don’t know, the philosopher’s stone is a magical “stone” formed through the ancient art of alchemy, and it can do a bunch of cool things, which you can read more about on this Wikipedia page. This performance references the stone’s particular ability to revive someone from beyond the grave, which is still taboo btw, so a lot of the angel-devil action still holds up. Interestingly, the colors of the stage correspond to the colors of the stone going through the transmutation process as the performance progresses: nigredo (black), albedo (white), and citrinitas-rubedo (yellow-red; there is disagreement over whether this last step is one step or two separate ones, but it makes more sense for it to be just one step in the performance). If we ignore the fiery foreshadowing in the first chorus, we can see that the performance starts out very dark (nigredo/black), then we’re taken to the white set-up with the angels (albedo), and finally the lights go red (rubedo) when Jisung makes the blood sacrifice, resulting in a red heart that may actually be the philosopher’s stone, which is used to bring the dead boy back to life. Pretty cool, right?
4} RE-BORN. RE-BORN was the theme for this round, and its challenge was for each of the groups to make another group’s song their own. But besides what the assignment entailed, SKZ decided to take the theme very literally, depicting someone who had died being “re-born.” The rebirth of IBYM through this cover stage is demonstrated by a sequence of events that culminate in the rebirth of a precious person. By far, this has to be the most broad and vague interpretation of the performance, so there isn’t much I can say, but it adds another layer of meaning to SKZ’s work.
5} Hyunjin*.* There are several clues that indicate that this performance was actually about Hyunjin, who is the member of Stray Kids that is currently on hiatus, a truly precious person to SKZ and to STAYs, and someone we desperately want to bring back and protect. In the last episode, 4 of the members went to make rings for the group, and they made 8 rings, even though only 7 of the members were competing on Kingdom. In the performance, the statue of the boy was wearing the 8th STAY ring as a necklace, and it was heavily implied to STAYs by SKZ that the 8th ring was meant for Hyunjin to wear. Therefore, we can probably assume that SKZ’s “precious person” is, in fact, Hyunjin, and that the performance was actually about him. Additional hints include the fact that the child actor had an eye mole with a similar placement as Hyunjin’s signature eye mole (this could be a coincidence, but I don’t want to think it is), and possible pictures/videos of his face playing on the LED screens after the blood sacrifice is made (there are comparison pictures floating around on twt). I would also like to add that in Chan’s most recent vlive, Chan said that he was so immersed in his emotions during the performance that he almost cried–and I personally want to think it was because he was thinking of Hyunjin during that entire performance, so perhaps the rest of SKZ were, too. If Hyunjin was the true subject of that performance, then the song takes on a whole, new dimension of emotion. SKZ would do anything it takes to bring him back, and Chan has even said before that he’d seriously die for SKZ. That means that SKZ weren’t acting on that stage; they were actually grieving. And as a STAY, it truly is heartbreaking.
Physical/Technical Analysis
Everything in this performance has a purpose, down to the fake tattoos and LED screens. This has been a consistent trend with their previous Kingdom stages as well, which I also talk about in my other posts. In this particular analysis, I’m pretty sure I’m still missing some details, knowing how intricate these stages are, so feel free to add anything else you noticed in the replies!
1} Flowers. After doing a bunch of research, I came to an understanding as to why flowers were used in this performance. They didn’t play the biggest role, but their presence is very meaningful. Flowers only make two small appearances in this performance: once at the beginning, when Seungmin offers flowers to the statue of the boy as he mourns, and the other in the fake glittery tattoo that flanks both sides of Han’s neck (my apologies for not being able to link a picture 😭).
The flowers that start the performance are baby’s breath, which symbolize a great number of things in flower language: purity, innocence, sincerity, love, compassion, trust, and everlasting love. It’s a very fitting flower for this particular performance because it simultaneously represents the precious nature of the boy and communicates the deep love and yearning that SKZ have for him.
As for Han’s blue flower tattoo, there was a lot of discussion as to what it could be, but I personally interpreted it as just blue baby’s breath. The meaning behind blue baby’s breath overlaps somewhat with the original white baby’s breath, but what sets it apart is its symbolism for abiding trust, loyalty, confidence, stability, and faith. Put this together with the phrase “I’ll be your man,” and everything starts to make sense. With this statement, SKZ are declaring that they’ll be someone dependable, reliable, and trustworthy to their “precious person”; they’ll be someone you can have faith in. And because they are so determined to protect their beloved child, they sacrifice their own lives to bring him back to life.
*Side note: I thought it was super interesting that Han was wearing the blue flower tattoo in particular. If I’m right about the tattoo being blue baby’s breath, then it makes complete sense for Han to be the one wearing it; he was the backbone of the entire performance, and SKZ were depending on him to successfully bring it to fruition. Everything was riding on how he would do. They trusted him to vocally deliver, and to no one’s surprise, he did not let them down. Han Jisung, you’re the fucking man.
2} Stage outfits. SKZ’s outfits also carry some significance within the performance. Navy blue as the main color denotes a somber masculinity (literally, I’ll be your man), and offers contrast to the white ghosts/souls and the angels to depict the flawed humanity of SKZ themselves. The white sash motifs that decorate each member’s tops are all stained with blood, most likely to represent how they’ve stained their hands–and consciences–with a forbidden, irreversible decision. Altogether, very well integrated into the aesthetics of the stage and the overall concept.
3} Stage makeup and tattoos. *I already talked about Jisung’s tattoos, so I will be focusing on the interesting things I noticed for the other members. Not every member’s stage paint had significance, so I will only be talking about the ones that seemed to carry meaning to me.
Changbin. Our dark rapper had the most thematically significant tattoos for this performance. The first was the scar on his eyebrow that was a part of the performance’s storyline (the little boy holds a cloth up to Changbin’s “wound”). The second, and more important, tattoo was the words “NOW LIVE” scrawled across his neck in creepy, messy writing. This is clearly an invocation of revival as SKZ bring the boy back to life, but backwards, the words read “EVIL WON,” to represent that evil forces have now taken SKZ’s souls, at the expense of bringing someone precious back to life. It is a direct reference to Felix’s EVIL-LIVE lip tat from the previous stage, connecting different themes and messages across performances, and it seems to imply that for someone they love enough, SKZ are willing to reverse the cycle of control, from LIVE to EVIL, by surrendering their own lives to the dark powers they had conquered before.
Tear motifs on Chan and Jeongin. These details are a lot less deep and significant compared to Changbin’s, but I did want to point them out anyway. To represent tears, Chan sports smudged eye makeup that resembles how runny eyeliner or mascara looks after crying. Jeongin, on the other hand, wears white rhinestones/pearls under his eye. Obviously, it’s a visual depiction of sadness, despair, grief, etc. It was a continuation of the tear makeup from the previous stage, and they still had the oldest-youngest matching eye makeup thing going for them too. *Side note: On the topic of tears, as well as these two members in particular, that moment at the end of the episode where Chan comforts Jeongin made us all wanna cry a little tbh
4} Biblical references. If you didn’t already notice, there’s a lot of biblical stuff going on here. References to prayer in the lyrics, the angels, and all the hell imagery were some of the most obvious. As someone who was raised in a super Catholic household, I’d also like to point out some more subtle references that I noticed.
Changbin’s path of light: This reference is not the most overtly biblical one, but the correlations are there. In both religious and non-religious contexts, the path that has been laid out for you is meant to represent the “correct” route you should be taking to get to your destination. Stay on the path, and you’ll get to where you want to go without getting lost. To “lose one’s way” means that one has left the direction and security of the path, which is usually accompanied by feeling distraught and experiencing some sort of mental/emotional upset. Likewise, in the Bible, God is defined to be “the Way, the Truth, and the Life,” and not following God suggests that one is being caught up in vice and deceit. The “correct” path Changbin takes, the path of light, is what most people do when they grieve: they mourn their loss, and they move on. But Changbin physically cannot move on, causing him to eventually stray off the beaten path, to walk on a road not taken, up the stairs of heaven to plead his case to God. It’s not what he was “supposed” to do, but it foreshadows how SKZ continuously stray further from God to bring their precious person back.
Fall from heaven/grace: Changbin’s free fall from the staircase brings to mind two similar “downfalls” from religious tradition. The first is the fall of Lucifer from heaven, a rebel angel who turned against God, and was subsequently cast down to earth, from which he became Satan (This Satan backstory is admittedly quite muddled in origin, but it is the most commonly known in Christianity.) The second is Adam’s and Eve’s fall from grace after eating the forbidden apple, committing the first sin against God. They were cast out of the paradisian garden that God created for them, to live the rest of their lives suffering on earth. In both stories, a grave offense leads to a fall from grace, suggesting that Changbin’s fall foreshadows their deal with the devil, in which they lose themselves in the process.
Gates of hell: During Minsung’s part in the first chorus, an image of Auguste Rodin’s Gates of Hell sculpture appears on the LED screen (credit to u/starwen9 for pointing this out!). After the chorus, it opens, and Minsung seem to be walking into it.
To lay down your life for another: The story of this performance reminded me of a very well-known BIble verse (John 15:13) “Greater love has no one than this: to lay down one’s life for one’s friends.” It really put the portrayal of grief into perspective of me, how grief is only possible because so much love is already present. There is also a beautifully paradoxical irony in the way SKZ chose to embody this idea, because they’re making the ultimate sacrifice of love through flagrantly blasphemous means.
Connections to past work: I already covered how this performance connects to both the original IBYM and also to their performance from the previous round earlier on in the post. Through the expansion of religious themes, SKZ were able to string together this performance with their previous one on concept alone.
Instrumental arrangement: Not biblical per se, but there were some elements of the arrangement that did allude to religious themes, such as making the song much more orchestral overall through the addition of more string instruments, and incorporating choir lines (most likely through the use of a synth) in some parts as well.
5} Song arrangement. I know some people did not like this arrangement, but it was very purposefully made, nonetheless. Liberally using more of the orchestral strings upped the drama and emotion of the performance, especially during the climax. Compared to how eclectic some of SKZ’s title tracks are, this song arrangement actually used a lot of space, silence, and the lack of sound activity to achieve the emotions conveyed in the song. It’s very smart on Chan’s part, allowing the audience to focus on SKZ’s vocals, and also showing viewers that SKZ are capable of making music that isn’t absolute sensory overload chaos. STAYs are already aware that they make so many different types of music, but non-fans are under the impression that they only make high-energy, noisy EDM, so this was a great opportunity to show off SKZ’s producing diversity, esp with all the focus that 3RACHA got in this episode. Some great details to note:
The performance starts with a few piano notes, and ends with a few piano notes. Full circle moment. Also, just very sad and eery at the same time.
The simple piano melodic line + the ghostly floating voice during Changbin’s part create a very unsettling atmosphere that is also very mesmerizing, together with how fragile Changbin’s voice sounds here.
Whenever things start to get “darker” in the performance storyline, more bass and electronic synths are heard. It’s almost as if the “holy” orchestra is being corrupted with artificial, synthetic sounds. We hear the first of this during Jeongin’s floor part, and then in Felix’s rap. It intensifies when Jisung does the blood sacrifice, gets even more intense when Felix’s voice gets all distorted, and it culminates in a whole rhythmical EDM dance break after the forbidden deal has been made.
Appreciation Section
This is my small way of making this space a little more positive when both the group and the fandom are going through it rn. I believe that SKZ should be properly recognized, not just because they’ve worked hard for it, but because they have done well, regardless of results. I also hope that this section isn’t going to be taken by antis or other fans as a STAY being “biased” and “overhyping their faves,” when celebration of your faves should be a normal, acceptable occurrence in fan spaces. I only praise SKZ because I think they deserve it, that’s really all there is to it.
Vocals!!! Needless to say, this performance was a vocal storm. SKZ are not, and have never been, just a rap group. We got Jeongin’s emotional delivery, Lee Know’s and Chan’s falsettos, and Seungmin and Han giving us everything we needed and more.
The climax. Han and Seungmin harmonizing the house down. Changbin rapping two people’s parts, and then rapping for another 15 seconds bc he just doesn’t need oxygen. Chan and his ethereal falsetto. That’s it.
Jeongin worked so damn hard, and it broke my heart seeing him beat himself up over a voice crack that was barely noticeable and hardly detracted from the performance at all. The dude sang all of his other parts so well; a tiny mistake will never change that.
I didn’t talk about Felix at all so far and I should. Besides being a charismatic performer, he also had songwriting credits for his rap in this performance, and his lyrics were articulated quite well. Great to see members outside of 3RACHA participating in the creative process!
Han Jisung. All-rounder. Ace. Absolute fucking legend. I’ve been bias-wrecked beyond belief. I have no more words to describe how talented this man is.
A round of applause for how SKZ depicted the supernatural and the occult without being cheap, campy, or cheesy about it (not that there’s anything inherently wrong with those things); the performance feels much more regal and elevated instead.
Everything in this performance had so much emotion in it, from the song arrangement, to the pain you hear in SKZ’s voices as they sing/rap, to their facial expressions as they dance. They were able to showcase the entire spectrum of emotions that are encompassed in mourning/loss; it just felt so incredibly raw and human.
Another round of applause for the fact that SKZ attempted and succeeded at covering one of the most unmerciful, excruciatingly difficult songs in kpop for a boy group. They really had the balls to make it unnecessarily harder for themselves than they had to. Seungmin and Han sang a note higher than the highest note in the original climax. Changbin rapped for a much longer time frame, and for two people as well. A whole-ass rap verse and dance break were added. SKZ also incorporated rigorous choreo and multiple acting scenes. These boys worked their asses off for this stage, and it’s impressive that they also had the talent and technical prowess to make it a success. So many risks were taken–some of which resulted in short-term repercussions–yet the increase in domestic attention that the boys have been getting has proven to be a worthy reward. I also want to thank Melodys for being so appreciative and receptive towards SKZ’s hard work with this song and performance; the interactions between our fandoms continue to be so wholesome and heartwarming :)
The fact that SKZ didn’t completely re-arrange or remix the song the way other groups did may have contributed to their disappointing rankings in the most recent episode. However, I really loved that they retained the original emotional meaning of IBYM, while putting their own musical and performative SKZ twist on it. Maybe they didn’t completely get the assignment, bc it wasn’t completely RE-BORN per se, but perhaps they wanted to interpret the assignment in their own way, by taking the theme literally in the concept, which is so typical of SKZ to do tbh. As long as SKZ are doing what they want, I couldn’t be happier.
It may not be much, but I’m very happy about the domestic attention SKZ are getting. It was what they came on the show to achieve, and it’s great to see some of that goal realized. 😭
And that’s the end of the atrociously long post! I hope you enjoyed or learned more about SKZ from what I had to say about the performance, and I’m always happy to hear any other insights you may have as well! I would also love to see people from other fandoms dissect their groups’ performances on this sub too; I would be more than happy to read about all the thought and hard work each and every group puts into their stages from the fans themselves!!