This one is going to be a big one, but this post will outline the state of Minion Masters in my opinion. My name is Dulcis/Apollo and I have been the top ranked player(1v1) for the past several leader board resets. I have been on development teams for World of warcraft, and Quality assurance(+balance teams) for other gaming companies. I have 1000 hours in this game and I have been active in the MM community, and streamed for a bit. In this post I will be breaking down all the different bugs, metas, controversies, and core aspects of the game that have either brought, or pushed players away. I most likely wont reply to any of the comments since I know this will spark a lot of discussion but you're welcomed to chime in. This post will be mostly critical of the game but I want everyone to know that this game is still worth playing, and I wont be going over the positive aspects of the game. Lastly, I emphasize, these are my opinions.
In some sections I will be adding my advice and some of the things that I think would make the game better.
Congrats btw in advance for reading the whole thing if you did.
(edit) I encourage all BD staff reading this to have an open mind instead of a defensive mind set, like I always say we are on the same team and I apologize if you take offense to some of this, but its how I and many other players feel.
You can always message me at Dulcis#0164 if you think some phrases could be better worded since my wording is harsh and combative; I'd rather not see this post get taken down.
OVERALL
Minion Masters is a great game that brings both aspects of hearthstone and clash royale game play together. It is entirely and completely free to play and does not hinder players from climbing the ladder with common cards. I still believe that this is a great game and will continue to bring in more and more players consistently, but will eventually lose players since there is no player retention. It is very easy to get into this game, then end up quitting because you are bored, don't have the space to try out new strategies, or are just frustrated with current metas with balance changes coming too late. The graphics are incredible and the art team are doing a great job and like I said I do think that this is a fun game and worth my time.
MATCHMAKING
Matchmaking and the current queuing system is the biggest issue in the game. The ques are restricted to ranked modes that very greatly diminishes the thought of testing decks. If you are high ranked, you don't want to risk the rank you have accomplished by using inexperienced decks; if you are too low of rank, you wont be facing intelligent players or quality players to test your deck with. This last point rolls on to the next huge issue with matchmaking in which a majority of "players" until platinum are in fact bots. I would like to see the player rank distribution for a month, but over half of the active player base are either Master or Grand Master. I am not sure if they made this ranked system for newer players, so they feel good about themselves when they climb to such a "high" rank so fast, or if it is just a faulty ranked system. Either way, this severely hurts player retention, and players have nothing else to play for other than #1 GM. In addition, match making allows grand masters to fight diamonds. I can't count the amount of times I have played a diamond while ranked 1... this is putting a very experienced player against some of the lowest ranked players(since player distribution is so fucked up). Now I understand that que times are crucial and very important to keep low, but I have had times where I sit in que for 25+ minutes and get a diamond... which is fine if nobody is queing. But I have also had 10 seconds que where I get a diamond when I know other GMs are queing.
In addition to these points, the 2v2 que is useless. I will keep this shorter, but both premade and random 2v2 are worthless gamemodes. The biggest issue is the fact that the game revolves and is balanced around 1v1, the 2v2 gamemode will always have unfair/broken strategies that will be abused. This month was the first time I played random 2v2s a lot, and it is by far the most toxic, frustrating thing to play. You get teammates that spam ping to play things then afk when you dont listen. You get players who afk the whole game, and with the vast amount of bugs(listed below), you get players DC'd, not connecting and a large percentage of your matches not even being played. Also, you get que'd against premades 2v2s which is just straight up unfair in this type of a game for obvious reasons. When it comes to 2v2 premades, not only are broken combos abused, but you find a lot of players queing with lower ranked accounts either for conquest, or gaining more ranked points. You can get up to 3x more rank points when you que with a lower rank. There is more that I could add here, but those are the big points.
I know there has been a huge debate on wildcards/normal ques and ranked ques which has resulted in a lot of argument and players leaving. I could make a whole separate post on what I believe BD should do. But I want to let BD know that: You don't have to just "add a normal que" or "remove wild cards", its not black/white like this. There are more creative ways to go about your match making to satisfy both parties without increasing que time or removing game mechanics.
My general advice for 1v1s, is to reduce every rank to have 3 increments instead of 5, having a set number of GMs such as 100. WITH GM POINTS(1)! Then reworking the mmr system so that not only is it harder to climb, but that it is more leveled out with increased diminishing returns.
(1) One of my biggest pet peeves is the fact that there is no numerical value on your mmr or ranking in grand master other than your position. So you have no idea how far ahead the guy is infront of you, or behind you. Sometimes causing myself to win 20-30 games in a row without increasing a rank and not knowing when I will get the next rank. This is CRUCIAL for players who break top 10 in any gamemode.
BUGS
These are a list of bugs that I have encountered the past week. This list is not complete and I will be further elaborating on some of the bugs, while leaving others ambiguous. They are in no order.
Volco's auto-attack bug: weapon getting stuck to the ground or flying around the map.
Streamer arena commands: puff management and general stream commands just don't work.
Double Apep totem(2v2): visuals get bugged and oscillate from 1 shield to 2, are not consistent.
Decks wiping randomly: either you keep your master presets or lose everything, this is one of the most frustrating bugs if you happen to have 18+ decks all getting wiped for no specific reason with no way to recover them.
Que master fights: Theres about 20 bugs with this, most of them resulting from the interaction of entering and exiting matches then returning to a que master fight. (FYI you have an option to fight a boss if you wait more than 4 minutes in a que)
Player 1 advantage: In the result of a tie, who ever was designated "player 1" wins. There are also mutliple minion interactions such as stun lancers that will result in "player 1"'s minion winning at no additional cost.
Game freezes when selecting match replays.
Scrat v Illusionary cleaver: When a scrat meets an illusionary cleaver on a bridge they both kill each other, but instead of the bridge remaining neutral, the bridge is captured by the scrat. This may be intended since the illusionary pop is after it dies leaving a brief moment for the scrat to capture it.
Black hole/Reboomer: Reboomer has a delay to black hole leaving it vulnerable depending on what stage it is in. Also if you play a reboomer ontop of an active black hole, it can die.
Match stuck in end-game screen staring at winning master.
Guardian visual bubble size on master, and lagging bubble behind units that were pushed by other units.
Minions continually being pushed back by units that are larger causing them to re-aggro. Such as stun lancers on the face... this gives a huge advantage. They are coded to slowly move to the side but this either happens extremely slow or not at all in some instances.
Past leaderboard are all types of fucked up right now.
Current leaderboard flashing glory, not sure if this was intended... but on the PC version you can also briefly see xbox controls sometimes.
Not having a quit game button until level 7? <-- what the fuck is up with this
"Highest rank achieved this season" In profile menu does not work in GM, instead showing current rank.
LOTS of card descriptions not being accurate or just missing abilities and interactions. I highly encourage the dev team to take an hour or two to review all of the card descriptions. One example is Thelec's mana surge ability. (or w/e its called)
View botters showing up in featured: This isnt as much of a bug as it should be a HUGE incentive to BD to input either a black list or white list to stop this content. But I know that this is and will continue being a hot topic among streamers.
Also having to wait sometimes a month+ to receive streamer incentive packages or a lack of packages for streamers who excel past the set rewards. (we are grateful for the program though)
Featured sometimes showing viewer count, sometimes not.
Discord not accurately showing when streamers are streaming or not. (discord bug)
Chat disconnecting/leaving global: This is usually caused when trying to send a message right as you are joining a match.
Shen sound is still not connected to game volume and is waaaay too loud.
Old/AI cards in loading screens.
Stun visuals sometimes lasting longer than they should or just bugging out in general.
Contrast on the winter map needs to be changed since you cant see hovering minions, or half-way line.
Non responsive guild management menu.
Card descriptions going nuts when opening cards at the power tower or other spots: "sdf gsdf sdgfsgdf ds"
Power tower purple visual bug.
Premade 2v2 rank showing your random 2v2 rank once in GM: "GM17823"
Premade group lag on ready button (most people think its just bugged and reset the group but its just LONG lag)
Premade deck viewing sometimes now showing the right deck.
Premade group not showing them in the group when the invite shows that they are in, and vice versa.
Shop deals not being claimable: Happened once but might as well add it.
You can claim battlepass rewards in que but not quest rewards? Not sure if this is a bug but seems incorrect.
Lag, then rapid buying of power tokens which results in inaccurate purchases when clicking the "buy" button quickily.
Doubled up chat when rejoining, aka, duplicate messages for every message sent by players.
Succubus jumping back even though it was killed on that hit. Not important but ruines MY IMMERSION!
Shieldguard AOE visual showing he has it when he doesnt and vice versa as a result of stuns or black hole: This one is actually really important and game changing for me.
Lets update the wiki -> Soul Stealer Wiki
Killing things through black guardian when timed right with black hole. https://streamable.com/4sang
Werewolf transformation bugged/replaying sometimes when black holed.
General black hole bugs with any minion's timers. Sometimes acting like the minion's timer keeps ticking such as combustion, mind control, divine shield, but then other times resetting timers, or not ticking, such as caelith or shield guard.
Not sure if this is intended, and not that big of a deal but when a wolf is in transformation it doesnt recognize it as a minion on the field allowing you to play an activated lone wolf. Pretty sure it dodges lightning bolt also.
Shield guard charge is bugged applying the damage before actually charging.
ERROR MESSAGES
These are also in-game bugs and probably the most prevalent. You cant go too many games without running into one of these and were the reason I almost quit the game. The dev team have been working on these and secretly been implementing fixes on server downtime, so some of these may be fixed. BUT, the dev team needs to know that they need to communicate this with players. Many players feel like there is no communication and as a result think nothing is being done. The dev blog is not enough and there needs to be more constructive communication with the playerbase. Right now is the most important time to communicate since this game hasnt gone completely Players Vs Devs yet like other games, and we have to remember that we are a team all trying to make the game better.
Anyways.... error messages:
"We haven't received updates from the match making queue for a while..": Causing a "cancelling.." que, but then sometimes results in a match, sometimes resulting in an aborted que.
"Receiving a failed match result"
"Illegal/unknown cards..": This is frustrating because this is a match error that ends a match and sometimes results in a win for you, or a loss. This can severely hurt your rank and its out of your control.
"One of the players failed to join..": This is the most common, resulting in a player having to reque multiple times... BUT its frustrating because you can get it in a match and get kicked out of the match even if all players are playing cards and connected... resulting in a win or loss.
Connection Error: Server/Client connection will cut out randomly, and I have confirmed this is not my internet.
Failed at getting leaderboard, error code: Timeout
Game crash -socket error, Autherntication Failed Already Logged in (1-3) When Relogging resulting in getting locked out of my account.
Extremely frustrating when youre streaming and your content dies for 10-15 minutes.
Error while receiving quest progress: Mid-game again..
Error: Timeour
Profile server unavailavle: This happens while players are still logging in/playing.
Reporting Draft choice failed timeout.
I would be extremely surprised if you could go 10 matches without running into one of these. These are the most frustrating since they are so frequent resulting in unintended set-backs.
METAS (Stormy/priestess/guardian)
I don't have a whole lot of issues with the current meta since there are already notes on what is getting changed such as dragon ball, but I want to take this section to talk about the most frustrating and most misunderstood meta. The stormy/priestess/guardian combo. I have seen players complain about stormy, I've seen the complain about guardian and, which makes me laugh, I've seen them complain about priestess. Calling each one of these cards out as "Broken" or needing a nerf. Although I do agree that guardian needs to be changed, it is by no way the reason this combo is strong. It really scares me that the fact the dev's said that they think guardian is the reason this is strong. And they are using that as a basis to change guardian. Like I said guardian does need to be changed but not because of this combo. Guardian hinders this combo due to the fact of the guardian taking ANY form of damage, the healer swapping to the guardian and the stormy killing itself on face or a tanky minion. This leaves a guardian and priestess alone on your face, which is completely useless. Not to mention that this whole combo is 4+5+6=15 mana, +2 if you are using a black hole to protect it. That is a 17 mana push guys... The only way in which guardian is strong in this combo is when you are playing defensively and have a healing shrine to support it, or you have more than 1 priestess. Otherwise, I cannot say this enough.... GUARDIAN COUNTERS STORMY/PRIESTESS WHEN PLAYED WITH IT. And it is idiotic to think it helps it just because it protects it. You will never see this combo break into the top 1v1 ladder, you will only see priestess/stormy which is a much better combo with bannerman/black hole.
The real problem of this combo is Stormy. Its funny because I have gone back to the stream in which they introduced stormy and the combustion change and I was telling everyone that the meta will be changing because of these stupidly overtuned cards. Luckily they already changed combustion.... which they left bugged for a competitive e-sports tournament, which is a whole other issue(with tournament staff not BD). But lets break down why stormy is an extremely powerful overtuned card. Not only did they buff chain lightning, which stormy casts and stuns for 2 seconds now, but why would you ever run a 4 mana chain lightning when you can run stormy for 5 mana and get 2-3+ casts. This is 100 damage per shot and 150 if raged on KP to all minions in the "jump" vicinity. In addition, the card stuns itself, you may think that this is bad for it... but since it stuns itself, it means that it will re-aggro to any closest minion causing a new chain. This means that one of the strongest defense mechanics of letting a minion hit your face then killing it from behind DOES NOT WORK. Then the fact that it does not do enough self damage to surpass the priestess healing makes this card fucking ridiculous. So in all, you have a card that is constantly re-aggroing, casting a 100 damage spell that JUMPS to all surrounding minions/masters. This also means that it hits any minions that you may have played "protected" on the sides of the master. This usually leaves you completely helpless and unable to counter it in any way, if they are running the proper protection. only 5 mana..
I believe that if any card is good enough to make an entire deck around, it should be a 9-10 mana card. Or even I think that no card should be good enough to make a whole deck around. Your deck should have synergies and strategies to work together.
CONCLUSION AKA STATE OF THE GAME
So in conclusion, I think the game is in the worst state it has ever been in. There are an overwhelming amount of bugs, and balance changes have been second and pushed aside for new content. I understand that Xbox is going live tomorrow and that there will be an influx of new players, but with this come new bugs. I haven't seen positive progress in fixing the bugs the past months and this new release will likely just bring more. It is a very dangerous road to go down where bugs start piling up quicker than you can fix them. I fear that they will be changing guardian soon instead of addressing the issue because they have been listening to inexperienced players constantly complain about guardian. This wont change the stormy meta, but maybe the new cards released tomorrow will. I fear they have pushed out this next release too soon and haven't addressed the real issues. Others have seen this and I have seen most of the old players leave the community because they see this too. These reasons paired with a lack of communication from BD staff will not end positively for this game. There will be an influx of players due to the new release which will result in a rapid decline as players encounter all the bugs and have no reason to continue playing because player retention is so bad.
This is sad to see, since this is such a great game with such great opportunity and potential and it will be wasted. They had a great opportunity to make this game blow up and impress a whole new gaming community, but I fear that it will be short lived.
Lastly, if I don't see positive change in the game quality and communication, I too will be leaving for a more entertaining game.
PS..
Someone needs to go out and purge all of these childish mods. This isn't an attack on the chat mods, but there has been such utterly disgusting actions performed by mods. They have been toxic, they have been inflammatory to other players, and I felt very threatened and attacked when I first joined this community. Before anyone knew me, entering my opinion on discussions on the discord I was attacked by veteran players and mods backing them up. The mods defend older players no matter how toxic and abusive they are. Players attack other players soley based on certain decks the play and its extremely damaging to the game.
On the flip side, they warn and ban players for the slightest rule infraction. The inconsistency and the unclear line of conduct will have you banned one day for saying the smallest thing, then allowing worse toxicity to run rampant the next.
LET ME MAKE THIS CLEAR TOO, this is not all of the mods, some of the mods are level headed, and deserve to be a mod, but a majority of my experiences have been negative.
Ill leave this at this, but somehow this player is still a mod.
/img/84zgd6sh93031.png
(edit), This was this mod's first comment when I posted this for others to see it:
/img/khxzx3fvq2031.png
Once again thanks for reading my post, there are more things I could add and more suggestions, but it isn't really worth any more of my time. I hope that the staff understand the urgency of these issues and I truly want this game to succeed.