Let me preface this, my MIL is not a bad person. Just an emotionally draining one.
She’s a huge debbie downer. She complains constantly, has no hobbies, very few friends, and just doesn’t seem happy with her life. Her kids (all boys) have all moved out, and since they were her whole life and she’s never worked outside the home or developed interests of her own, I think she’s struggling to find a sense of purpose. She spends most of her day watching TV while my FIL works, and tbh they don’t have a great relationship either so when he comes home, they don’t really interact.
Since she’s always bored, she has nothing to talk about like nothing new to update on life or anything. But she loves involving herself in other people’s business. She LOVES to gossip about my husbands extended family but disguises it as concern. For example, she’ll call me and say, “You should check on so-and-so, she’s going through a terrible divorce!” Mind you, I barely know the person. Or she’ll casually mention someone’s private medical procedure like a nose job followed by, “But you didn’t hear it from me. I should really check on her.” It’s like she’s spreading everyone’s business while convincing herself she’s just being caring. It’s offputting and also not something I like being around.
Unfortunately, it’s not like I can push back and give tough love because she’s also incredibly sensitive, takes everything personally, and cries over the smallest things. She has this tendency to act helpless, and somehow ordinary situations end up revolving around her emotions or inability to do something. She’ll call my husband saying, “I’m so scared to drive 30 minutes! Do you think I should?” And I’m thinking, girl, you’ve been driving for 30 YEARS. What do you mean?! But because she’s sensitive and helpless - my husband has to give her a whole pep talk like yes you can mom. You got this. Stays on the phone with her for like 20 mins to hype her up. Mind you she has a car and she drives!! Everyone treats her like this incapable 12 year old. I hate to say it, but I find myself internally rolling my eyes at how meek and helpless she acts. I can’t tell how much is genuine and how much is for attention, but regardless it’s just exhausting and annoying.
The thing is I know she likes me and wants a closer relationship. She wants me to call her daily (my husband shut that down bc she started to cry when I’d be busy so he said no more daily calls). She constantly calls me her daughter, loves to show me off to people (takes my pics and posts them on HER socials and it makes me uncomfortable but that’s a different story) and is very touchy and lovey with me (also uncomfortable with it but can’t tell her to stop bc she’s sensitive!). She’s made comments about wanting to spend more one-on-one time together (my husband and I already see my in-laws weekly!) and has called me to ask me to hang out with her, but the thought of one-on-one time fills me with dread. Truly. I would rather go to a dentist. I feel guilty admitting that because she hasn’t actually done anything bad. I just don’t enjoy her company. I feel so tense around her that even my oura ring registers elevated stress during our weekly visits!!!! Luckily, I have a job that keeps me busy during the day and after work hours I have a pretty busy social life so for now I have excuses.
The reason this is coming up now is I am pregnant! We’re super happy but we haven’t told my inlaws yet. I’m worried having a baby will create expectations for one-on-one time because right now my excuse is work and when I’m on maternity leave I’m worried she’ll be like omg you’re free, lets hang out. I’ll drop by.
So here’s where I need advice. She’s extremely sensitive, and I don’t want to hurt her feelings. I want to maintain a respectful relationship, but I don’t want to be her friend, emotional support system, or default companion simply because she struggles to connect with other people.
I’ve tried to gently redirect her and encouraged her to get involved in the community, find hobbies, and make friends, but her personality seems to be offputting to a lot of people. My one saving grace is whenever she travels abroad to see her sisters, it’s like the ultimate reprieve because she forgets us and it’s so nice. Truly it feels like a vacation for us too! I was thinking that could be a solution? Pay for her to go visit her sisters while I’m on maternity leave? I don’t know I’m desperate!!!
How would you gently create distance from someone who hasn’t necessarily wronged you, but whose company you genuinely don’t enjoy? Is there a way to communicate that without actually saying it? I need all the help I can get.
TLDR: MIL is emotionally draining and overly sensitive. I don’t enjoy being around her for a variety of reasons. She wants us to hang out more one-on-one. I currently use work as an excuse but am pregnant and worry she’ll take my maternity leave as an opportunity to come by and hang out. How do I respectfully keep her away without hurting her feelings?