r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Nov 29 '24

Discussion Can everyone please stop complaining about the new edition?

31 Upvotes

It seems many players are losing their minds over the leaks. Everywhere from Reddit to Discord to Facebook, players are already suggesting changes to an edition that almost none of us have had the chance to actually play. Everyone has models or an army that was either delegated to the upcoming Armies of Middle Earth books or Legacy. I hate GW as much as the next guy but can we all just be a little patient?

We should all try to give this new edition a fair try before dumping on it for being problematic or worse than the current edition.

Could the new edition be absolutely terrible? Yes.

Could the new edition be vastly superior than this edition? Yes.

Will we know for sure how good or bad this edition is until we actually get to read the full rule set and armies lists (including Armies of Middle Earth and Legacy) and get in some actual games? No.

Please try to be a little less doom, gloom, and depressed please.

Thanks.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • May 24 '25

News Games Workshop to hand out £20m to staff after significant profits

Post image
0 Upvotes

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DJ_61TOsg2a/?igsh=MWwzdDNiaTR2ZW4zdg==

Whilst I’m glad staff are being rewarded…how about put some of that money into more machines so we don’t have to wait months for made to orders? Or make sure you have sculpts made BEFORE you release the supplement and not years later.

I’m mostly joking but a little serious 😂 Can’t be acting like a small, overworked, understaffed company when you are rolling in cash.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Oct 20 '25

Hobby 6 more real horse inspired horses via Uma Musume

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Mar 22 '25

AI making Easterling minis come to life!

71 Upvotes

Messing around with some AI and thought I’d share the cool result!


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Jun 22 '25

Hobby Frodo Mines of Moria

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Dec 02 '24

Shoddy quality from GW :/

Post image
5 Upvotes

After being told my order would arrive after 180 days, I was surprised that these only took 3 months to come. Normally I buy recasts or use 3D printed models, but I thought metal pikes would be worth it…

This is the worst quality pewter I have ever seen though, the pikes bend so easily and are definitely going to break at some point. I buy a lot of metal miniatures, and comparing these to other companies, older GW metal models, and even recasters, these are by far the worst. They are so bendy, covered in a crazy amount of flashing, and it’s even obscuring some of the details.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Dec 15 '24

Question Did they completely remove Khazad-dûm?

0 Upvotes

I bought a new book and am a little shocked. Did they completely remove Khazad-dûm?

I bought and printed myself a whole bunch of dwarfs to play in the new edition for Khazad-dûm, but in the end I can’t even find warriors.

Is there any information, and when will GW release at least some kind of sheet with rules for the dwarves of Moria? Of course, I hope that they will update their lineup along with this, but I want to play now...


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Sep 24 '24

Rings of Power content?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I realise this question might have been asked before, since I've only been following this reddit since the latest box set anouncement.

But is it likely we might see some Rings of Power miniatures like Adar or Numenorians? I realise if that would be the case it would most likely be Forgeworld releases.

Edit 1: Thanks for all the helpful replies. It was quite interesting to learn this is a licensing based situation where GW doesn't have the rights to the amazon produced LOTR media.

I'm quite hyped by the recent reveals for MESBG and if they manage to keep up impressing me in the new edition I will definitely consider picking up the game in addition to the other GW games I play.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • May 06 '26

Question Do you ABSOLUTELY have to paint the minis as shown on the box?

0 Upvotes

Hey y'all!

I have just received my first MESBG miniature in the mail (Elrond, Master of Rivendell, to be precise) and I was wondering... Is it absolutely necessary to paint the miniatures as shown on the boxes / in the movies?

Asking cause in 40k you have a lot of freedom regarding your colour scheme, but... I mean 40k is a miniature games at its core while MESBG is an adaptation of a universe in a miniature games format sooo....?


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Aug 05 '24

Discussion Replacement MTO arrived

Post image
0 Upvotes

Replacement made to order arrived for my Defenders of Rohan after I emailed GW

It's in worse condition that the original order


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Aug 07 '26

Mithril Brush Online Live Ceremony tonight at 8:30 GMT

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Jun 27 '25

Discussion This needs to be said about legacy

20 Upvotes

I read plenty of arguments for and against allowing legacy in tournament play, but didn't see anyone mention the impact it could have on accessibility for new players.

MESBG is a niche hobby within a niche hobby. We need it to be easy to enter. The best case scenario for a new player would be to just grab a battlehost box, put it on the table and be able to play with the big boys.

Unfortunately, we live in a world of metal/resin minis on special order that may not even be in stock. But, in my opinion, that's still acceptable to a new player. They will be building their battlehost and learning the game, while they wait for the rest of the army.

But with legacies... imagine going to your first event and finding out that most players use models that are literally impossible to get, other then second hand for inflated prices. I don't know about you, but it would immediately put me off.

It wouldn't be so bad, if it was just a specific list or two (i.e. Khand), but for a lot of armies, it's about small optimalizations. It's just better to play a named hero with a special rule then a generic captain. And that can make it feel a bit "pay to win" (Or rather, be a hobby veteran to win).

The situation might be different in places where 3d printing is encouraged and readily available, but in a general case, I think that fully allowing legacies on every occasion could be damaging to the longevity of the game and I am quite surprised nobody mentions that in the debate.

Do you think I am blowing it out of proportion? Is the majority playing with fully 3d printed armies anyway? I'm curious about your opinion.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • May 19 '25

Gandalf

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Found one of my old Gandalf models needed re painting and the staff and sword needed re fixing with scraps. Used a D&D balor for the Balrog.

Yes it needs a few touch ups but it's based this time


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Aug 03 '25

Hobby Paladin Took and Fatty Bolger

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Dec 11 '24

Discussion I had high hopes

7 Upvotes

But man, what a bummer.

I mean, ok I play armies that got unlucky and will be better covered by the upcoming (Whenever it will be) Armies of Middle-Earth, but there are already some choices that make me lose hope.

Corsairs.

Corsairs cost 8 points, plus 1 for upgrades. That's one point more than before, already.

And they come without throwing weapons.

Granted, one of the upgrades is, for 1 point, light shield and throwing weapons. But the light shield has them stuck at d3. They are, in fact, stuck at d3, period.

So they effectively cost 2 points more, with the same stats an equipment as they had previously.

All of this while losing the options for Reavers and Arbalesters, and while quite some other armies got upgrades for the same point cost (which makes their F4 even more meaningless than last edition).

Random example:

Gundabad Orc end up costing 1 point more than Corsairs (10 to 9), same fight value, +1 strength, +2/3 defence, and they got the side bonus of hating Dwarves and Elves.

I honestly wonder which kind of drugs they took down before approving this kind of balancing.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Aug 27 '24

Favourite model

1 Upvotes

What’s your favourite model? Mine has to be either the metal Grishnak, the metal Moranon orc or maybe the orc in the plastic box set that has a second head growing out of its back. I remember when I was younger none of my friends knew about the second head on the orc because it was so subtle - love it! If you can’t tell I love the orcs!!


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Jan 15 '25

Bonsoir à tous auriez vous une estimation de ce petit bijoux s’il vous plaît ?il y a le socle encore avec la boîte games workshop et les 9 figurines en métal sous blisters

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • May 30 '25

Corsairs are unplayable in the new edition, change my mind.

3 Upvotes

Considering corsairs lost throwing weapons and proper shields but cost more points for light armour. Together with no reavers and the very disappointing lists. Most armies got upgrades with fight value buffs and crazy army bonuses. Corsairs got worse in all points. I don't see how I can field them in a match. What did GW think? How are they remotely playable? Why?


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Nov 21 '25

female rangers of Ithilien?

3 Upvotes

question, are there female rangers of Ithilien? found proxies for them including female rangers but just need to know if there were female rangers? a.k.a lore accurate


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Jun 14 '25

Hobby Sam mines of Moria rebuild

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Had to rebuild the frying pan. didn't go great but better than nothing


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Aug 24 '24

With the new releases and ridiculous prices, I thought I’d post GW last profit statement.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Feb 24 '26

Army List MBGA: Make Barad-Dur Great Again!

0 Upvotes

Ever since I started playing as a kid Sauron was always my favourite model in the game and always wanted to run him. After a significant hiatus and returning to the game I purchased the model, only to realise Barad-Dur is not the most competitive list out there.

I was wondering if anyone has had any success with building a list and what they focus on, i.e. embrace the horde (which I tried but orcs die too easily), or go for a really low model count of elite units which I've seen a couple people try


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Mar 25 '25

Hobby My Proxy Mouth of Sauron

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Just in time for Adepticon as part of my Black Gate list. Hate the offical model, decided to go off the rails.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Jan 19 '25

Actual BAD FAITH Strategies to Look Out For at Events

0 Upvotes

Ok so I made this thread full of harmless movement phase ideas, and got treated like all the strategies were super bad faith cheater tricks, when in reality they are valid, Sun-Tzu style ideas to help you win unfavourable matchups :

Meta-Strategies Bible (aka how to win games at tournaments) : r/MiddleEarthMiniatures

So, in this thread we are going to share ACTUAL bad faith tactics to look out for, the sort of stuff where you should call over a TO if your opponent starts doing this. These are usually different forms of gaslighting... but not in a fun meme way like painting Haldir so he blends in... these are more like actual cheating and petty behaviour.

Please share your own if you have any to add to the list :)

The point of this thread is to give newer players the confidence to call over a TO if someone starts trying any of these on them:

  • Selective Edition Amnesia: This is when an opponent is correcting you on new edition changes, but is also forgetting the changes that affect them negatively. Essentially, juggling rules from different editions for their own gain. For example, attempting an old school hurl, while also being aware of certain characters being F7 now. Or using Bane of Kings on all weapons, when actually its just melee. This is often harmless, but if it happens multiple times in a game don't hesitate to call them out or get a TO.

  • Re-Measuring Your Movement: This is a really really bad one that a$$h0l3s use on new/unconfident players, but never try against established players. Basically, its when your opponent immediately starts re-measuring your moves as you push shieldwalls across the table. Most of the time its not worth arguing about 1 spearman moving a mm too far, so you let it slide once or twice, but the continued effect of this in the mind of a player is that they ought to move their models slightly less than their full movement, so as not to draw the ire of their opponent reaching across the table and correcting their moves over and over again. This leads to you not covering the table in time to score objectives. The best answer to this is to do the same thing to them whenever they move.

  • Tracking their opponents M/W/F... incorrectly: This is when your opponent tracks your heroes M/W/F on a piece of paper as well as their own. Innocent enough in most cases. But then they turn the tables when you call a crucial Heroic and tell you that you don't have any might left to use, even though you most certainly do. This one is especially tricky as they have 'proof' in the form of their own M/W/F tracker. This one is made more annoying by the fact 2 honest players will always be able to backtrack and agree on who spent how much M/W/F over the course of the game.

  • Rules Lawyer 3000: This is when you discuss using an optional rule that relates to rolling dice with your opponent, discuss it with your opponent, and do not invoke the name of the rule after the discussion. let me explain: The worst case of this I saw was a tourney finals in stockport: Eagles vs Fellbeasts. The Eagle player was discussing whether or not to Rend the fellbeast or go for the rider. After some discussion about the pros and cons of rend, they said something to the effect of "I'll go for it" and rolled three 4's... to which their opponent said "No wounds caused." When the eagle player explained that it was actually 3 wounds due to the rend rule, the opponent made the argument that "you didn't use the word rend*, you just said you'd 'go for it'". To my dismay the TO actually ruled in the Fellbeast player's favour even though there were a half dozen people at the table calling him a cheat.*