I got a list. Spoilers Obviously.
The Sylux storyline. Or lack thereof. Seriously the prologue sets up this awesome premise of samus' new rival sylux slinging super steroids at the head of a Space Pirate army. Its sets up this idea of some major conflict thats going to spill over onto an alien world because of some artifact mishap and then it just fucking stops. Sylux and his metroids have almost zero involvement with the events of viewros. That big fuckign explosion that teleported random sections of the base and equipment as well as several soldiers to viewros, Didnt transport a SINGLE Space pirate or their equipment. NOTHING. The prologue was clearly made for a different game and thats the game that was marketed to us.
Its such a fucking bait and switch man. Like most of the promotional material focused heavily on the prologue and the conflict with sylux and he's just fucking barely in it.
Oh sylux is shoehorned in like some b grade dark samus knock off but it just feels like an afterthought, Like they got 90% done with viewros, Realised they didnt have a final boss and added sylux because there was an easter egg about him in a previous game.
I know what you are thinking. "but all the bosses are controlled by metroids the scan logs say so" Are they? Are you sure about that? Cause the bosses just look like they have Green tumors for weakpoints to me. Hmmm.....I wonder if there is some other light green substance that causes aggression and mutation on viewros? Almost like....The game didnt initially feature metroids and they had to alter it for some reason.
The worst part is, That awesome sounding premise the prologue sets up? Yeah its all in Syluxs scan data. Like all of it. A whole games worth of possible story development sidelined into a simple scan log.
And those shitty fucking flashes of syluxs memories! You get his backstory through snippets and its just so fucking petty. Oh he was in a big battle with space pirates and samus was there and his whole squad was wiped out and he blames samus because...........fucking reasons? Admittedly I didnt see the whole thing. I got 99% scan data. Turns out you need 100% item and scan data for the full clip.
2. This feels kinda familiar? To me Prime 4 feels like it was written by someone who hated Prime 2, didnt finish it and is trying to write the plot from memory.
So samus is like this chosen one right and shes um.......gotta collect these keys to get into a temple..and oh yeah shes got like a rival that attacks her occasionally and...oh yeah theres these like......dark versions of the inhabitants that are like super aggressive and attack samus on sight and....oh! The final suit was awesome! All silver and yellow and shit...... -Prime 4 story writer(Maybe)
Which prime was I talking about here? I know lots of things are similar if you break it down far enough but i think from a general standpoint 4 is way too close to 2 for it not to have been at the very least directly inspired by it. Maybe they grabbed pieces from all over the trilogy but Prime 2 got a serious chunk taken out of it.
And from this I feel personally insulted. Not only is Prime 2 A far better game, Its also my favourite Prime. Its the yardstick with which I measure the other primes. Man. Everything great about 1 they just fucking doubled down on it for Echoes. Its fucking beautiful man.
3. Samus is a side character in this game. It almost feels like samus is only in this game cause nintendo put their foot down and told Retro they couldnt make Federation Force 2. No one liked the first one, They have to make a samus game and they didnt like that so they used a bit of trickery to convince nintendo to allow them to move as much focus off of samus as possible.
Hey remember how story driven Other M was and how much everyone hated how samus was portrayed in that? Lets Do the exact fucking opposite! Lets just have her stand there.....and do nothing....... in almost every cutscene......
Joking aside Samus legitimatly does little when she's in cutscenes with the troopers. She's got 1 scene where she stays behind in the volcano and 2 scenes where she does a flip oh and in that assault outside the mine she shoots like 3 grievers. While the marines kill dozens and the robot carpet bombs the area
Look at the Breaking the Shield on crono tower cutscene. Samus is in the back while all the troopers are up front. The Robot and the engineer do all the work then sarge and the robot do that arnie "Son of a bitch" hand slap from the predator movie. It even zooms in on it. I like metroid not just because they're great games but also because samus is a legit badass and I like seeing her absolutly tear the asshole out of her enemies. Even when Her greatest enemy was herself In Prime 2, 3 and fusion Samus was still king of the fucking hill at the end. In this she's just....there. Standing still....Ignoring the troopers. Like I wish i could.... She doesnt even beat the final fucking boss!
4. Escort Quests! And the final bosses they ruin. Hey you know whats important about bosses in a metroid prime game? That you dont take your eyes off them. Because if you do they are gonna cheap shot you! You know whats a terrible idea? Forcing the player to stand real close to an unmoving ally so they can be revived to avoid a game over while a boss with wide area attacks smacks you in the ass cause you arent allowed to look away from chuckle mcfucknuts!
Keeping your eyes on the boss is so fucking important that several bosses from previous games literally have mechanics designed to juke out of your line of sight and force you to find them again lest they smack shit out of you or regain a large portion of their health before you can stop them. At least for them, the player can actively search for them to prevent damage. Not in 4. You gotta give myles his colonoscopy or its game fucking over! Speaking of npcs and final bosses.
5. I reject your forced Empathy. So, How many of the troopers back stories do you know? Its just 1. Yeah, If you want 100% item completion and why wouldnt you its fucking metroid, You've got to watch 4 unskippable cutscenes where takabi tells you his backstory. Why you ask? Well for the noble sacrifice at the end of course. They wanted you to feel sad about samus running away while the troopers hold back sylux, They wanted you to tear up when she hangs takabis religious icon from the tree at the end. This is so fucking ham fisted. Like maybe it would work if you slowly learnt about the troopers as you spent time with them, you know actually bonded like real fucking humans but no its just takabis. They literally had to hide item upgrades in takabi's pockets because they couldnt figure out a way to make it more organic. They had to shove it down your throat.
Look im gonna be honest here. A fair amount of my complaints here can be summed up as, Why is samus in this? If you played as a generic trooper and it was called federation force 2, I'd probably be pretty okay with it but because its Prime 4, And because Samus is in it, I judge it against the previous metroid games that feature samus and in this regard its absolute dogshit. I've seen a fair few people say it feels more like Halo and yeah I see that. It only makes sense though. Retro studios is mostly the cast offs of 343 these days apparently.
Im not saying the gameplay is bad. It plays like fucking prime. It looks like a fucking prime game but the level design and the writing are worse than any other fucking metroid game. Even the broken english at the end of the original metroid is better written and more entertaining then this shit!
6. Dishounerable Mention and the PTSD it caused!
You know what goes here but i'll repeat it anyway.
Have you been to the volcano yet?
Hey if you are lost you can always call me on the map screen
You know you can check your map if you are lost
Are there any unexplored areas in the volt forge you havent been to yet?
Maybe your new beam upgrade will let you open up some new areas?
DONT FORGET TO GATHER GREEN CRYSTALS!
DO YOU HAVE ENOUGH GREEN CRYSTALS? YOU SHOULD GO TO THE ALTAR IN FURY GREEN!
HEY SAMUS DO YOU HAVE EVERYTHING? COME BACK TO BASE CAMP WHEN YOU ARE READY!
All these lines. I heard multiple fucking times. I was actually kind of excited to explore the big desert area on the motorbike you know. It was new. I was excited. But the developers seemed to believe that anyone who spent more than 5 minutes in the desert must be lost and needed some help from good ol myles to point them in the right direction.
The best part is, If myles mentions a specific place, Like that STUPID FUCKING ALTAR WITH THE BIG GREEN MARK ON THE MAP! Well then the next time you open your map you lose control of it while it travels to and zooms the fuck in on the place he was talking about. I've been shown the way to that altar so fucking much. Because Theres this whole section right at the end where you have to scour to desert for green crystals AND NO ONE AT RETRO THOUGHT IT WAS A GOOD IDEA TO TURN OFF THE MYLES FLAG THAT CALLS YOU IF IT THINKS YOU ARE LOST! WHICH IS ONLY ACTIVE IN THE FUCKING DESERT! EVEN WHEN THE DESERT IS EXACTLY WHERE YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO FUCKING BE!
You know what annoys me the most about this? The gaslighting. Theres so much fucking gaslighting about myles not being that bad. Took me 15 hours to finish Prime 4, Those several hours I spent in the desert listening to myles every 5 minutes were a fucking hallucination were they? FUCK YOU! HE IS THAT BAD!
You know, Adam annoyed me in fusion at first but at least he didnt call you every second fucking room and repeat the objective. You know what thats a fun idea. Lets get a Metroid Fusion, Mackenzie cut. Where every other room it brings back up the map and repeats the objective. There will of course be no option to turn this off.
I have finished almost every metroid multiple times for better clear times, gallery unlocks, on harder difficulties, just to say I did and this is the first time im not going to do that. Prime 4 has no replay value. There's no reason whatsoever I should put myself back through this.
I hate this game. With every fiber of my being. And thats just not something I ever thought id say about a metroid.