So it was one of my big goals this year to go to more shows. For reference - I went to Destruction/Overkill/Testament last week. This week I went to BI/Emperor, and then I'm seeing Helloween this Friday.
So with Blood Incantation I liked Starspawn and Hidden History. When I heard Absolute Elsewhere - I didn't really get it. I have gave the whole record maybe 5ish attentive listens but I couldn't dig it for a number of reasons - the death metal material (the riffs, the hooks) was their weakest of any of their releases by far and the proggy bits... have nothing to do with the death metal bits - it is not blended well at all together... it's just abrupt stop into some FL Studio loops kind of stuff, IMO.
But anyway I persisted on and was like "well, maybe it will make more sense live, you know - maybe it's meant to be experienced" and even though I was aware they likely would not play any of the material I am REALLY into and would play all of AE, I was still excited.
So I get to the show and really... I don't know guys like... yall are into this? I find it so goofy, in all honesty - they have some decent albeit not great death metal bits, then as soon as I am getting into it.... it goes into this lame electronic stuff that 100% kills the vibe for minutes at a time. And tbh they are not the caliber of players to be doing prog, I'm so sorry. The lead guitar playing is not it. The synth has some good leads but like maybe 2 in a 35+ minute set is not that good imo.
So many people say "oh it's like Pink Floyd" but I think that is a massive insult to Pink Floyd, in all honesty - David Gilmour is a fantastic lead guitar player (albeit not "Mr. Shred") with highly memorable and evocative leads that REALLY took you on a journey. The BI 70s prog material... is not that. To me it comes off as really amateurish for a number of reasons.
And here while I'm here shoveling shit I'll go one further - the BI fans there were kinda insufferable. Keep in mind that when Hidden History was out I would say "I am a BI fan". I saw their tour with Morbid Angel in 2019 and I liked what they were doing then... but now they have a much huger fanbase. And that's cool man - but hearing conversations around on the floor it was like such lame vibes.... a lot of dudes were doing these weird dick-measuring contests for like "how kvlt" they are or how underground they are. I heard folks namedrop Kite String Pops literally 4 times I mean that is fucking insane how locked in these fans are on "what's hot right now" and I don't mean it as a compliment... not one interesting or "I did my own research and have my own tastes" sort of take among them. I know I'll get crucified for it but like... yeah... idk man I'm like "these folks are posers". I didn't realize it was a hipster band like this...
What got me thinking is considering the contrast of the vibes at the Destruction/Overkill/Testament show. First off, that show was CHOCK FULL of insane riffs. Destruction is a riff machine of a band. You couldn't help but move when these bands are playing. They were at the absolute top of their game and hitting you nonstop with tasty riffs, tempo changes, etc. Take a song like Overkill's Ironbound... it too, has a slower more sentimental section in the middle... but the difference is that it is done really well in a cohesive and cogent way that collides with the heavy parts in a worthwhile way. They don't just pause the entire song and then start playing "baby's first melody". The fanbase at the thrash show - the vibes were immaculate - folks were there to have a good time and conversations were about bands we all love. Hell even the pre-show music was shit we all love like Priest, Sabbath etc. whereas BI show it was some electronic stuff.
TL;DR contrasted BI show to Destruction/Overkill/Testament and I found BI extremely lame and also their fans are "not my people" at all. Which is a shame because I saw BI in 2019 and thought "hey man these guys are pretty cool"
P.S. Emperor was cool though for sure