r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • May 14 '23
r/MetaEthics • u/butchcranton • Jan 08 '22
Moral Realism is incoherent
Suppose there are objective moral facts, facts like "X is [objectively] wrong".
Knowing moral facts can (is likely to?) change how someone chooses.
I choose based on what I care about: what I don't care about (by definition) doesn't affect how I choose.
One need not care about any given moral fact. For example, I don't care about any given (alleged) moral fact. It attaches the label "wrong" to an action, but that label has no teeth unless it is related to something I [subjectively] care about. If sin isn't punished, why not sin? Just because it's called "sin"? No one has any reason to care about "moral facts" unless something they care about is involved.
Thus, it doesn't affect what I (or anyone) have any reason to choose differently than we otherwise would. Thus, it is not in any meaningful sense a moral fact.
I don't think moral realism is tenable. Frankly, it seems like a lingering remnant of theism in secular philosophy.
r/MetaEthics • u/Imaginary_Dog_266 • Feb 13 '22
The absence of god creates god
The absence of god creates god
So that humans may feel superior to other humans.
Because how else would one human feel superiority over his equals if not through divine approval.
Material goods can be compared but don't necessarily prove superiority because of how quickly wealth fluctuates. Even if you are the richest man in the world (in properties, animals or family) nothing is greater than divine approval. If you claim/believe that the divine favors you over your fellow human beings, no one has the power to refute your claims.
The more powerful your god is the more superior you can feel. The more believable his story, the less likely people are to argue with you. It goes even further the scarier your god's punishment can be and the better his paradise is supposed to be, the harder it is for the human mind to justify arguing against him. This means that the firmer your belief in the divine, the less influence your peers can have on you and the more you allow yourself to look down on lowly human behaviors. Even though it is that lowly human behavior that made you turn to the divine in the first place.
It is a battle between comparing yourself to others and comparing yourself to the divine entity. Humans look to follow the most powerful entity they come across or can come up with. That explains why there are barely any new religions developing because what is more powerful than an all-powerful, all-knowing and all-good god. It is humanly impossible to come up with a greater entity which is why human civilization has reached a stagnant state where most of the world's population still follows religions invented millennia before.
This reminds me of a parable in the Quran (18:32 – 18:45) that goes like this:
There is this one guy who has it all (Two lush gardens with a river flowing between them and a big family). He's having a conversation with his friend who is poorer and has a smaller family. The rich guy starts boasting about his wealth and when he enters his own gardens, he starts exclaiming that he doesn’t think his wealth will ever perish. This shows that he is arrogant because of the wealth he has. He also states that he doesn't think there will ever be a judgment day and that if in fact there is, he will only be wealthier there than he already is on earth.
So, his less privileged and more religious friend starts invalidating the rich guy's beliefs by asking him “How come you disbelieve in the god who created you from dust and made you a man”. Then he gives him some religious advice about how he should give thanks to God every time he enters his garden and acknowledge that only god has the power to grant anyone this wealth.
The less privileged friend also turns the tables on the wealthier guy by boasting about how god's power is infinite and how God at any time can give him something better than the other guy's two gardens. Not only that but that God can at any time send a storm that turns the lush gardens into barren lands.
Here we see that the supposedly good guy of the parable stood up to the arrogance of the wealthy friend with even more arrogance but this time based not on earthly wealth but on his belief in God.
And guess what, the parable ends with God exerting his power and turning the lush gardens into desolate lands and the once rich guy is let wringing his hands and wishing he hadn't underestimated God's powers.
I would say that there are two main points the Quran wants you to take away from that parable:
If you are wealthy, you owe it all to God. This teaches people humility and that humans are still equal in spite of material wealth, which is actually the basis for a functional egalitarian society.
If you don't believe in God, you are not deserving of wealth and if you are wealthy, you should know your wealth won't last.
This established that religion doesn't really aim for an egalitarian society where people are only judged on their morality, like some religious leaders want you to believe. But it designs a society where piety and your closeness to God makes you more or less deserving of good things, even if you have worked hard to achieve them. This is all because it is only God who has the power to grant people riches.
r/MetaEthics • u/gonzophilosophy • Oct 18 '22
Bioshock - a thought experiment into objectivism
r/MetaEthics • u/Moral_Philosophy • Apr 06 '21
The Implications of Consciousness - Morality from First Principles
r/MetaEthics • u/epistemicmind • Mar 01 '19
Moral Relativism Explained Simply
Hi guys, Im new to this subreddit. Thought Id share a video related to moral relativism and the basic rationale behind it. Let me know what you think and whether you believe it is a plausible theory!
r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • Jun 06 '23
The Life-Goals Framework: How I Reason About Morality as an Anti-Realist – Lukas Gloor
r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • May 31 '23
Intuition and Reason – Brian Tomasik
reducing-suffering.orgr/MetaEthics • u/StochasticNetizen • Feb 05 '24
Why Sentio-centric NU, AN, EFILism?
Re: religion, philosophy, evidence, logic, science, ontology, reality, truth, biology, axiology
The truth will set you(r mind) free, but not without cost.
Brutal cognitive clashes challenging memes in your mind and sometimes - parting with your most dearly beloved or deeply guarded views, beliefs, attitudes, frameworks, etc.
Recommended: ensure you're stable and supported, educated on emotional and neural self-regulation (broadly, #SelfCare), and proceed with caution. Though this largely lays bare - the vital truth - the path to the light is dark and dreadful.
#Sentience derives axiology, is at the denotational root of all connotation, and entails the basis behind WHY you #ValueYourLife or #value anything at all, in fact. This critical finding is a key parameter that informs a valid vantage point of #intelligence. #Ignorance will result in our destruction, if left unchecked. Granted, such intellectual deprivation runs on a spectrum, as does advancement. Beware, and make the ascent, if you can.
r/MetaEthics • u/sirkn8 • Oct 15 '19
A history of western science , as it bears on ethical attitudes toward Ecology
r/MetaEthics • u/bgrunna • May 05 '23
Compatibilism and Neuroscience: Reconciling Free Will and Determinism
r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • May 02 '23
Moral realism and AI alignment – The Universe from an Intentional Stance | Caspar Oesterheld
r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • Apr 11 '23
Mathematical versus moral truth – The Universe from an Intentional Stance | Caspar Oesterheld
r/MetaEthics • u/FranklinSeven • May 16 '18
Defining Morality - An innovative approach
Morality and Society
Cooperation: the Foundation of Society
The foundation of society, the ability for different individuals of the same species to work together in order to accomplish tasks, is the result of cooperation. All animal societies are based upon survival and cooperation. Without cooperation there is no society. The reason for morality as social necessity is clear: in order to counteract the intense survival needs and/or instincts of an individual creature an evolutionary mechanism must be enacted (e.g.-a moral conscience, a hive mind, etc…) in order to gain social benefits. There has to be some sort of evolutionary mechanism involved that gets individuals to cooperate.
Evolutionary social survival strategy necessarily must enact rules and enforce them and does so through evolutionary equipping and/or limitations and through conscious enforcement. For example, many limbic brained social animals exhibit a sense of fairness and outrage at injustice as well as compassion for the suffering of others. This is the product of having a limbic brain which enables a new, more sophisticated set of emotional responses. The only way for two individuals to cooperate is to be able to communicate and to follow rules (esp. regarding fairness). Lizards and crocodiles don’t cooperate and have no limbic brain. They are amoral. There is no society that they belong to. They have no need for morality. Morality is not something that exists as a ontological reality other than as an evolutionary device that enables cooperation amongst individuals.
Fairness: the Basis for Morality
Therefore, I contend that empathetic sensibilities which lead to a basic sense of fairness between individuals is the basis for a moral structure. Either we have access, entitlement and/or protection of our needs and give the very same to the other party or we fight and end up in an exploitative situation, at best. Violations of fairness cause us to exhibit outrage and/or disgust. When ourselves or others are wronged we feel sadness. These are some very basic moral responses that we have as humans. But cats and dogs have these responses as well. Does this mean there are evil cats and dogs? I believe that is the wrong question to ask. Evil and good are relative human terms. Now, if you asked if a dog or cat were as culpable or responsible as a human being the answer would be no. Their morality is much simpler because their brains are much simpler than ours. Like a child they need to be treated differently than an adult human who posseses theory of mind amongst other cognitive abilities that most animals do not apparently possess (it is hard to prove theory of mind in an animal- we can’t talk to them about their inner states, but dogs and cats are not in the running; dolphins, pigs, ravens, grey parrots are the more likely candidates).
I want to point out that you can have a society without morality. Insects are considered eusocial creatures. Their brains are very different. I think that we would be surprised to find that they have what we would consider a morality. They certainly have rules but a consciousness that makes value judgements? Is it a concern for the welfare of the species, group and/or individuals and how it affects each individual that makes us different from say, ants?
The Complex Nature of Morality
Theory of mind is the ability to comprehend mental agency in another being. It affects a persons moral choices and seems to be located in the Right Temporo-parietal Junction (RTPJ). The medial prefrontal cortex, the posterior cingulated, angular gyrus on the left and right sides and the ventral prefrontal cortex are also involved in making moral decisions. All have different neurological and cognitive functions. You can see that the whole issue of morality is actually quite complex from a neurological perspective. The brain is a modular instrument and therefore morality is going to look confusing to us if we think of things along a spectrum or a line. And yet this is what we do when we moralize. We think in dualisms and ask if it is right or wrong and how much so. More sophisticated questions we might ask are how and why it is so. Not all animals or even children have the capability to make the same moral judgments as adult humans due to neurological differences. We may even come to find that some species of animals may need to be regarded as morally more sophisticated than others. I believe that ultimately neuroscience will have a primary role in defining human and animal morality and in shaping our philosophies around morality as we discover more about how the brain functions.
The Neurological Nature of Morality
Words like intent, decision, volition or agency seem to be, upon initial consideration, necessarily differentiated aspects of morality. Upon considering animal morality it becomes clear that this is not necessary so. Crocodiles make decisions, have volition and intend things but cannot be considered moral creatures because they have no apparatus for morality. To exacerbate problems, we might consider crocodiles to have agency depending upon how we define agency. Therefore none of these aspects of mental reality actually have anything to do with morality. Morality is not a set of principles or a thing, it is a set of brain functions. Morality does not exist out there somewhere and it certainly isn’t a set of words. It is our brain using information and performing neurological functions. That’s the reality behind morality. There is a nuerological basis for regarding what is good for our well being and what is harmful or toxic to us, but these might just be good, convenient ways to categorize the world around us.
Good and Evil?
Our most basic neurological functions are binary in nature. A neuron either fires or it doesn’t. Just like in a computer, things are either a 0 (good/beneficial) or a 1 (evil/harmful). Our basic fear reaction is fight or flight. A binary reaction is the best one suited for survival because it’s the most efficient solution. No wonder we see things in terms of good and evil! Is this because that is the way reality is or because our brains are created this way? If reality does not come in some grand duality then what does this say about how limited we may be as far as our ability to perceive reality is concerned? Does the type of brain you get determine what type of reality you are able to witness? The scary answer is yes. We may never know if the universe really exists as a duality or not. The actual universe might be very different and may come in all sorts of possibilities beyond a mere duality. We may be ‘constructing’ a binary universe because, 1) it is possible to do so and 2) it is all we can comprehend.
Society and Morality Defined
This leads me to a very general definition of morality:
Society being defined as merely a set of rules that two or more individuals adhere to, we must conclude that any system of rules dictated by emotional responses to beneficial (good) and harmful (evil) outcomes regarding the well being of the group and/or the individuals in the group can be considered a moral system.
In this view morality is the foundation of society itself. From this point of view our individuals must possess a sophisticated enough emotional apparatus to care or have some stake in the well being of the group and/or other individuals in the group. This view also supports the idea that good and evil do not actually exist as absolutes in any real sense. These are relative terms. We use the terms good and evil because our value judgements are wrapped up in things based upon real, sometimes traumatic outcomes.
A Compassionate View: A Relative World
Societies can look very different and so can the rules about what is beneficial (good) and harmful (evil). We need to understand this about each other. People all over the world have different values about what they see as being good and evil. Oftentimes seeing things in terms of good and evil leads to a warfare stance between people, in my opinion. It is usually not the best way to look at things. I believe we need a more compassionate and inclusive way to look at problems of cultural moral differences that does not compromise our morality but defines it and clarifies the issues for us.
Morality: A Dilemma
We use a hueristic symbology we call words and attempt to describe our mental states with it. Unless you are a neuroscientist (and even they don’t know much about the brain) you have no other means to really approach mental states than to talk about them. The problem with this whole arraignment is that our descriptions are confusing because they probably don’t accurately describe the reality of what is neurologically happening. This is why we cannot adequately describe morality using words that attempt to describe mental states. And yet this is exactly what we must do because we have no other choice. As discussed, we can’t make spectrum generalizations when it comes to the actual mechanics of morality because we don’t really know what they are yet. Nuerology decides what the mechanics of morality are. Still, our brains seem to be designed to react to the world in a dualistic manner and we can’t help but speak of things in terms of good and bad. And so we continue to make spectrum generalizations when we moralize. I feel that it is useful to see that this process; the generation and sustenance of a moral framework, involves a somewhat arbitrary process of collective trust. When we explore morality as currency we shall discuss this process in more detail.
Culture
Culture Defined
Usually when we talk about culture we are talking about social norms, customary beliefs and social behaviors found in societies. I define culture as any expression of a society. If such expression is done either passively (i.e.-psychologically) or actively, then it is a cultural expression. In this view merely thinking is a cultural expression. Thinking is a cultural expression for the following reason; we are psychologically dependent upon others for a sense of self. This flies in the face of what we are usually taught about ourselves. We are taught that we are psychologically independent and therefore our psychological health is dependent upon only ourselves. This is pure fantasy. Consider that there are no ideas without symbols and no such thing as a ‘self’ without ideas. We use the symbology of language itself to create meaning. There is no self without another to teach us language. Therefore, there is no way to create a human self without another human self being involved. This is an inescapable conclusion. This indicates that relationship and society is of critical importance to our self identity and therefore our mental health. This is a new area of psychology being explored by psychotherapuetic relational theories. Dan Siegel is at the forefront of this new approach to defining the self as a social creature by nature.[2]
Even though thinking itself is an expression of culture it does not necessarily create culture. If thinking is an expression of culture, then any private thought is also cultural creation as long as it is expressed to another. Culture must be created between two or more people. You can’t create or have a society by yourself. Culture happens when society happens, that is why the two seem synonomous. Culture is the expression of society.
Institutions Defined
Culture is by its nature a social phenomenon. This means that even in our most intimate relationships we create culture. If we share any of this information with the world (like say, nude selfies!) and a group is interested (like viewers of a channel on TV) and this group therefore consumes this information, then we say that it has become a part of that group’s culture (the group that viewed it on TV, those talking about it because of someone’s viewing, etc…). If only your family is interested then it has just become part of your family culture. The power of the experience will decide whether or not you will all recall it, consider it significant and therefore call it culture in the traditional sense. Once they have become an established part of our culture and we have created artifacts around such practices we call them institutions. I define an institution as being a social practice that is established and considered significant to a community.
Power Shapes Culture
Power is what mainly shapes culture over time. Power in relationships, the lack of power, the power of an experience (including personal cognitively powerful experiences) are what determine whether or not we consider it to be culture. Usefulness, significance and meaning are all expressions of power. Consider that things have meaning when they have utility associated with them more than when they do not. For example, my broom in the closet becomes more significant if I actually use it a lot. If I never use it or need it then it becomes insignificant. When we need and engage with things they become significant to us. Usefulness or significance could be termed value and/or meaningfulness. Meaningfulness is of particular interest in defining power because we don’t typically think of meaning as being a form of power. Meaning has power to a mind. It has the power to make us feel, believe, think, interpret and dictates a person’s intent and responses. Usefulness reflects a more pragmatic approach compared to significance and/or meaningfulness which both imply states of mind. All involve an assessment of difference in states. We assess when we find something (anything – an idea, thought, feeling, experience) more significant than another thing (anything that can be imagined and or experienced).
Culture – A Discreet Process
Some people may not feel satisfied with this general definition of culture since I consider merely conversing to be culture. They may feel that there are certain things which we call culture and certain others which we don’t. Consider that everytime you speak to someone it is significant to that relationship. Every piece of information that is shared, whether that be verbal, emotional or physical is important to the relationship. Whether or not you or I or a million other people remember something or not is not a matter of whether it is culture or not; it is a matter of whether or not that particular bit of culture is significant enough to survive and how important it becomes to society over time. That society can be a society of two. It only takes two people to make a society according to my definition. What we usually consider to be ‘culture’ is really just an evolutionary process of how society and our social expressions develop over time. That is why contemporary definitions of culture seem so arbitrary. Consider that nearly anything can become significant over time with repetition. A noise, a saying can become significant. Who can say when a social expression becomes culture? What kind of expression? When does this happen? What size group does it require? For how long does the tradition need to exist for? How important to the society does it have to be? You can see that there is no way to answer these questions. I agree with the conventional description of culture when we apply it to large groups (and their institutions) that have existed over a long enough period of time to create culture. But I believe culture happens discreetly in pairs as well.
Morality and Power
Usually when people think of moral systems religion comes to mind or a grand philosophical tradition. When we consider the vast differences in moral systems across the planet and the ability for people to adopt several norms as their own, especially as the world has gotten smaller and people come into close association with other cultures, we must consider questions as to the hierarchical importance of different moral systems. Moral systems often co-exist as layers superposed on top of one another. Therefore societal norms and moral traditions do not necessarily constitute a fundamental system. If there is a fundamental system that exists it will determine the nature of a systemic order and will define all morale systems operating under its influence as well.
Relationship Power Dynamics
Being that society is two or more individuals in a relationship, relationships are of the utmost importance to the nature of morality itself. Since culture is shaped by power morality must be shaped by power and its expressions as well. Being that relationships, power and its expressions are so important to the nature of morality, this indicates that the dynamics of a relationship are what determines the fundamental nature of morality itself. The term ‘relationship dynamics’ implies a concern with the difference in power between parties. If it was static, there would be no difference in power. Therefore relationship dynamics are of utmost importance in defining a moral system. This becomes profound when we consider that there are only two fundamental types of relationship paradigms: either you are equals or you are unequal. There is no third option. This means that relationship dynamics consist of a party being either a peer, a dominant or a submissive in relation to another or others.
Fundamental Moral Systems
This clearly indicates that there are two distinct ways of expressing power. One is in a peer system the other is in a dominant/submissive system. These ‘systems’ are the fundamental moral systems of their respective societies. These are the two different types of relationship paradigms; equality, or peer to peer relationships and the dominance/submission paradigm. These relationship paradigms determine the nature of how two people will relate to one another and even can determine whether or not they will form a community together. Thus this clearly constitutes a fundamental moral system.
Once again, there are three basic types of relationship dynamics. Either you are a peer, or you are submissive or dominant in relationship to another or others. These are the basic rules, or relationship dynamics which constitute the basis for society itself. These dynamics play themselves out in the arena of our lives through four main avenues of social power; military, economics, ideas/knowledge and society itself or culture. We will explore these four avenues of social power in more depth below.
Moral Character Revealed: Wielded Power
Because culture is formed through the influences of powerful forces (experiences, thoughts, ideas, sensations, feelings, etc…) morality is based upon powerful experiences as well. The rules inherent in morality will be shaped by the power of an experience and the expressions of power in society itself. Since moral values are the rules upon which society is based the way power is expressed in a society will be a direct expression of that societies’ morale values. Whether or not we share, exploit, manipulate, coerce, allow or enable others defines us as a member of our society or as a society as a whole. These are all ways in which we exert power. This is what it means to act in accordance to your moral principles: you show up in the way you express power.
Therefore the way we wield power has everything to do with our morality. Wielding power has everything to do with the process of accumulating power as well. How one gets their power is just as important as how it is expressed. Was it obtained honestly through hard work, easily, dishonestly, bloodily, etc…is the power through someone else, is it tied to a resource? These are all questions regarding power accumulation and therefore determines how one wields power.
The fact that power is the main shaping force in culture may not be an metaphysical reality but rather an issue of perception because we have lived under despotism as a social order for thousands of years where power rules every aspect of life. This is so ingrained that we perhaps can’t see it. It may be that culture can be primarily driven by other factors than power, like information. A culture based upon negotiation where information is highly valued might create members that remember things based upon their data value more than on power value in their relationships.
The Four Powers of Society
Economist Ravi Batra theorized that there are four ages of human development (warriors, intellectuals, acquisitors and laborers) based upon the teachings of his mentor P.R. Sarkar in which he utilizes social cycle theory. This theory is based on an analysis of four classes of society that claims that people are historically motivated differently. Batra believes that these are due to different types of people and that these patterns show up as historical cycles. I believe that these are types of social power, not people. Batra’s theory is similar to the Strauss–Howe generational theory, which also describes history recurring in a generational cycle.[4]
William Strauss and Neil Howe see four archetypes of people (Prophet, Nomad, Hero and Artist) that repeat sequentially throughout history. There is a striking similarity between this and Ravi Batra’s theory. I believe that both theories are correct in describing rotating cycles of history based upon human motivations. These four cycles of human motivation are merely the dynamic expression of four realms of social power rather than kinds of people, classes or motivations. Each realm of power creates a class of people associated with its power so it naturally seems like classes or types of people. Power dynamics in relationships are what truly defines us as a civilization.
Unique Powers per Realm
Each realm of power has unique characteristics associated with it, that it affects all other powers with:
The military trumps all other powers. Killing destroys all other social powers by killing off the (members of) society.
Economics sustains everything else. All of life, including thinking depends upon economics (you have to eat and expend calories to think which means that thinking is economically dependent). Nothing in society goes without the sustaining influence of economics.
Knowledge changes and adjusts all of society. New knowledge can be so powerful that it can and has changed the social order of humanity. It is common for new knowledge to create adjustments in society.
Culture is the expression of society itself. It is a subtle, irresistable force. Culture forms beliefs which allows us to know who we are as individuals and as a group. New ideas, spontaneous inspiration, robust institutions all come out of a vibrant culture.
Morals are the rules or systems of society itself. Morals determine the social order and expression of all four realms of power. The power of morality expressed is the worldview of its consumers. Worldview determines everything about a person and a society psychologically, culturally and morally.
The Unique Power of Culture
Society and its expressions which we call culture, are like gravity. Irresistable, subtle and infused throughout our lives. In the realm of ideas we find another powerful social force. Ideas are powerful. Ideas charged with emotion (like a social movement) are potentially explosive. Such movements can become explosive forces of change. This is why when social movements take off they are often unstoppable except through means of a trump card – threatening violence or death often can suppress such movements.
The Search for a Fundamental Moral System
This all clearly indicates that we are searching for a Fundamental Moral System that operates in all four realms of power. This Fundamental Moral System will be show up as a systemically ingrained feature of all four realms of power. It will not necessarily be a set of norms, traditions, values or assumptions although these will all be aspects of our paradigm. The paradigm we seek must demonstrate a Fundamental Relationship Dynamic that is fundamentally different than a dualisticly opposed paradigm which is the cause of the psychological and cultural rift we see happening on the political stage. The discourse between right and left find their origins in these two paradigms that we seek.
r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • May 31 '23
Why Realists and Anti-Realists Disagree – Lukas Gloor
r/MetaEthics • u/KKirdan • Jun 08 '23
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Value — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
plato.stanford.edur/MetaEthics • u/Filter_Feeder • May 26 '23
Could someone identify this idea I had?
I'm really not that versed in ethics, but I think a lot about it and once in a while I take in some professional opinions. I was struck by some kind of realization a few days ago, and I felt that it helped me a lot when thinking about human nature and ethics. I'm not sure if it's an original idea, probably not, so I thought I could describe it and maybe there's someone out there who recognizes it and could point me to other reading on the topic.
My idea centers around the realization of the fluid and somewhat arbitrary and highly subjective nature of our values. This is in contrast with ideas of universal goodness or evil, or other ideas that there's some actual truth or material reality to our values. While this is rarely consciously expressed, I think there is some sort of psychological mechanism where people realize the importance of their values in guiding them through life, and therefore want to cement them somehow as being eternal or discretely defined by some ethical reasons, not to mention money. But I'm going off on a tangent here, let's look at an example.
Let's think about something we don't want to have in the world. Let's go with starvation. Why don't we want starvation? Because we believe it's bad. But then, why is it bad and what is bad about it? You may answer this question by making a case for empathy, or for the sanctity of life, or for the opposition to human suffering, or the hedonistic urge to make ourselves feel good about ourselves by helping others. All of these are however, principles we've invented to cement our values into something definable while I believe the answer to this is that the primary reason we don't want human suffering is because we simply don't want it. This is a value that we have come to embrace, and while the acquisition of this value is an extremely complex thing, which involves ethical analysis through more traditional models, the value is a thing that's completely constructed by our minds.
Let's take an example where this can be implemented. Let's think about destruction of wildlife. Why is the loss of the amazon rain forest bad? When people answer this, they typically answer it from the typical ethical models, often being based on how the destruction of the amazon will lead to human suffering (by some long chain of proposed events), and how the protection of the amazon will lead to the alleviation of human suffering (people sometimes argue for eco-turism, herbal medicine of rare plants, etc.) However, I think the truth here is that we've simply come to value the amazon for whatever reasons. Personally, I simply value nature, not because of any ethical principle, but because the natural beauty, the evolutionary history and the ecology of something like the amazon is far more interesting and appealing to me than wide-spread farmlands and the economic growth that the exploitation of the amazon would undoubtedly generate. I guess the distinction here is that while some people believe you can make a cost-gain calculation of replacing the amazon with pastures, I would point out that the gains such as economic growth and tasty glorious beef are not real values that actually exists, but are just as arbitrary my acquired value of the gains of protecting the amazon.
Here's another example, space travel. Why would we bother with interstellar travel, colonizing other planets etc? Most people say that it's because we need to secure our species survival, or harvest economically valuable minerals which may be abundant on other planets (now that's one heck of a way of solving the semiconductor crisis), or that we humans have a innate urge to explore. The truth here again is that it's simply something we've come to value for many reasons. When we think of our place in the universe, where is it? What do we want to be as a species? Do we want to be a apes wallowing in our own disagreements or do we want to be capable of cooperation and achieve something truly remarkable?
Another reason I like this perspective, and why I think it's useful, is that sometimes when we try to search for what the "right" thing is, we invent principles and use that to make cost-gain analysis on choices. It's a very comforting concept! However, there are many cases where this goes wrong. One example I can think of is a professor in ethics that I heard on some podcast, (sorry I can't remember who) who argued that having a lot of kids was a good act because you were creating life which is something that is good according to this logical ethical framework that this person constructed. This person claimed that the climate impact of reproduction did not outweigh the benefits of creating life. I might be misrepresenting things here but I run into these cases a lot, where people seem to trust too much in their ethical principles and try to use them in situations with really contradictory results. Another example is vegetarianism, or animal suffering. We seem somewhat unable to draw a conclusion on what the costs are of eating meat, because we don't really know how to measure animal suffering. Are cows conscious of their suffering? For me the decision is quite easy and based on quite different reasons (The following sentences are a bit spaced-out and I'm sorry if it's confusing). Domestication is a beautiful and interesting co-evolutionary event, which has been ongoing for thousands of years and has happened for several different species. In the last hundred or so year however, the rise of a new organism has emerged, what we sometimes call corporations. Some of these great cybernetic super-organisms have enslaved the domesticated animals and appropriated them into their system, using them to make what all corporations survive off of, profit. Not only are the animals cramped together, genetically refined so as to maximize profit, but humans fall as slaves to the corporations as well. Poorly paid workers are forced to dedicate their time to do the bidding of the corporation, slaughtering the animals as soon as they are grown enough to produce enough meat. Not only that, they also brain-wash people into preferring their brand of meat, in a massive industry known as marketing. Sorry, this was a rambling section but I think you see my point, it's these kind of arguments that people respond to, not cost-benefit analysis of animal suffering or any of that.
Another reason why I think that this idea is good is because it helps us to focus on how to efficiently make real change in the world. If we realize that people are not going to stop casually doing weekend trans-continental flights, or throwing perfectly functioning electronic equipment out without recycling it, people won't change their behavior because some researcher may find a frog in the amazon that produces the next great anti-cancer drug. In reality, people have fluid and arbitrary values that are not governed by divine or ethical principles, but are something highly fluid that we acquire based on a lot of different experiences. I believe that if someone gets to interact with a gorilla, they are much more likely to want to protect them, simply because they are fascinating and that they realize that it would be a shame to see them go extinct. This principle I'm proposing turns focus away from economic interests, and legitimizes our emotionally based values, while also opening up or emotions to new possibilities and new perspectives. What you value today, you may have completely different opinions on tomorrow, no ethical principles has changes, no other logical argument have been presented to you, you simply felt differently about it for some other reason.
There are more sides of this, and one more thing I've been thinking about is; what happens if we can take away human suffering? What happens when we get so good at genetic engineering that we can completely change the basis for human nature. Traditional ethical models will completely collapse (at least from my understanding) under cases like this, but the way I see it, by arguing from my perspective, nothing has changed. That's a whole discussion in of it self that I will post another time.
r/MetaEthics • u/kiwi0fruit • Feb 06 '22
An article that summs up meta-ethical conclusions that can be derived from Universal Darwinism taken to extremes
The style of the article is a bit provocative but in essence it's about meta-ethical conclusions that can be derived from Universal Darwinism taken to extremes.
Abstract
This article sums up meta-ethical conclusions that can be derived from Universal Darwinism taken to extremes. In particular it 1) applies Universal Darwinism to evaluation of Terminal values, 2) separates objective meaning of life from subjective meaning of life using notion of Quasi-immortality. That means both moral nauralism and moral non-cognitivism are right but in different areas, 3) justifies the free will as a consequence of the Universal Darwinism, 4) comes to the conclusion of Buddhism-like illusion of the “Self” as a consequence of the Quasi-immortality, 5) as a bonus gives Universal Darwinism a hypothetical and vivid Cosmogonic myth from Darwinian natural selection.
r/MetaEthics • u/_eudaim0nia • Feb 10 '22
Philosophy Discussion Discord Server for Academics, students, autodidacts, and general learners
I would like to invite you to a philosophy discord server. For teachers, students, and autodidacts.
The purpose of this discord chat is dedicated to the engagement of philosophical discourse and the exploration of ideas in the history of philosophy. Our main goal is to become more knowledgeable about historical thinkers and ideas from every philosophical domain through interpersonal dialogues. We are not a debate server. Argument is a method used by philosophy, but this isn’t to be confused with debate. The latter is competitive in nature, whereas the former is a cooperative endeavor. Philosophy is a group project that aims to determine what is true, and this server is a place for this activity. Here is the invite link for those who are interested in joining: https://discord.gg/BHzbXDVwHR
Invite link is hopefully permanent, so you won't have to worry whether the link is working if you're reading this sometime in the future.
See you all there!
r/MetaEthics • u/KazisKripaitis • May 17 '21
What is Metaethics? How is it different from Morality and Ethics?
This is the best answer I can give:
"Ethics covers questions of normative ethics, morality, and metaethics. Normative ethics answers the question, ‘what should we do?’, (e.g., ‘should we have the death penalty?’). We derive ethical principles from our morality, which answers the question, ‘why should we do that?’, (e.g. ‘because God says so, that’s why!’, or ‘because compassion compels us to be kind to all life forms, that’s why!’, etc.). We extrapolate moral principles from our metaethics, which answers the question, ‘why do we have these moral principles?’, (e.g., ‘the fact that God exists, and commands thus, that’s why’, or ‘because life is suffering and our own suffering steers us to be kind, that’s why’, etc.).
Among other things, metaethicists debate whether the good exists as a real thing, or the alternative, in which moral ideas are culturally relative accidents or logical contrivances. Metaethicists are concerned subsequently with the possibility of the existence of moral facts and truths, and the modalities and mechanisms by which we arrive at conclusions about knowledge."
How would you improve or change this definition of Metaethics?
r/MetaEthics • u/sammorrison9800 • Jun 18 '21