r/MedievalEngineers • u/cyrvster • Jan 30 '15
Structural Integrity Preview
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpS5XGjb3jg10
u/chaosfire235 Jan 30 '15
Awesome! This is a day one buy for me, no doubt!
One thing I am wondering though is if the game will ever treat the destruction based on the material in question. The towers in the video fell apart like glass or styrafoam. Would it be possible to have say, wood splinter, metal deform, or stone crumble after taking a solid few hits?
31
u/NMO Jan 30 '15 edited Jan 30 '15
Well, I can't say I've masturbated to game physics before, but hey, don't knock it 'til you try it.
-8
8
6
u/CosmackMagus Jan 30 '15
I am glad they found brilliant ways like this to separate it from SE. Can't wait to see what else they come up with. Release can't get here soon enough.
3
u/buster2Xk Jan 31 '15
I think structural integrity will make its way to SE, but it will present itself differently as we'll be dealing with forces like thrust rather than gravity.
8
u/CrazyFaced Jan 30 '15
I would like to see them integrate shear stress. Right now only the vertical weight seems to cause failure. Seeing that sideways T get built and it only falling due to the weight of the material above it is really offputting. Looking forward to the game though.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shear_stress http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bending
4
Jan 30 '15
This. Also it feels like a collapsing structure should break up a bit more, or at least differently before it actually hits the ground. Instead of falling to the ground completely intact and then shattering just the bottom as it touches the ground. Like, the force of impact should damage the entire structure, it’s not all concentrated on the bottom block.
4
u/kingzope Jan 30 '15
This kind of preview makes my day! Thank you so much! I welcome additional videos to keep the hype up.
4
u/retroly Jan 31 '15
PSA: Incase you missed it laststandgamers has a video on his channel with new extra footage and a breif glimpse of the load baring physics.
3
u/retroly Jan 31 '15
Anyone else hope that the debug view will exist for normal players? I don't want to be building a huge castle for me only to overdo it and it all come crashing down.
5
4
u/alaskafish Jan 30 '15
What's to stop people from just making their walls out of the rock bellow? In the trailer, it shows the player making a little area flat. What if they just get stone, and make a giant wall? I don't think the terrain will be effected by damage, will it?
16
u/TheGallow Jan 30 '15
I don't think you'll be able to terraform as easily in survival as you can in creative.
4
u/Lil_Psychobuddy Jan 30 '15
They're planning on adding structural integrity to the terrain aswell.
0
u/alaskafish Jan 30 '15
Source please?
Because I remember reading that they won't.
3
u/Lil_Psychobuddy Jan 30 '15 edited Jan 30 '15
Did you even watch the developer interview?........
Structural integrity should also work with voxels and terrain in the future. Right now it doesn't, if you dig a tunnel it won’t collapse which we feel breaks the realism so later we’ll add structural integrity to voxels.
http://forums.keenswh.com/post/developer-interview-transcript-7253120
2
2
u/Turdicus- Jan 30 '15
It might depending on what you throw at it, explosives for instance.
More importantly making a castle out of dirt has a number if problems; there's a reason people use stone.
Dirt cannot be built straight up without it collapsing pretty quickly, so a dirt wall has to have slopes. It might stop a cannonball, but an attacker could just waltz up the gentle angle of your dirt wall.
Stone walls support more weight and can therefore be built straight up and down and much much higher.
3
u/ChopperHunter Jan 31 '15
Historically "stone" walls were usually filled with a core made of rubble or dirt. Only the outside was stone.
2
u/Ezian0 Jan 31 '15
Really cool since I'm studying civil engineering (2nd year), and it is similar to how concrete and wood fails mechanically, but I feel like the materials are a bit too weak since normal concrete can withstand up to 38 MPa and wood can withstand up to 11-15 MPa and they don't fail that easily especially within that short of a time period.
2
1
u/NapoleonTheCat Jan 30 '15
Just from these examples it seems like it would be really easy to destroy a large castle... I mean castles are engineered to be extremely strong. The mega forts of the day. A symbol of power, wealth, and strength. Here we see 5 or 6 stone balls bring them to their knees... The walls should be stronger but the concept is great and I like where it's going.
9
Jan 30 '15
I'm hoping the object they're firing is a debug object designed to apply more force than usual... Time will tell I guess...
4
u/blackether Jan 30 '15
It does seem to be a different kind of projectile than the one in the first gameplay trailer. It looks like it has quite a bit more force than the rocks shot from the catapult or trebuchet.
Regardless, the walls in the video seem like they are very weak and shatter like glass or porcelain, where a real stone wall would be much harder to break (even if it was a hollow piece).
3
u/buster2Xk Jan 31 '15
Well I don't think building catapults and trebuchets is going to be quite as easy as launch debug cannonballs from your face.
1
u/NapoleonTheCat Jan 31 '15
Yeah but but the looks of it a single catapult can rape a castle. All I'm saying is that large castle walls should be damn tough to penetrate.
3
u/buster2Xk Jan 31 '15
You'll need to set it up outside the castle and then get three to four projectiles out before someone notices you and stops you, and that's to take down one bridge or turret. And I think we can also assume the physics right now for testing aren't going to be the physics we get at the end. I'll bet stone walls will put up much more resistance than what we're seeing.
2
u/smiskafisk Jan 31 '15 edited Jan 31 '15
It´d take a hell of a lot of time to destroy a castle though if it is properly built and supported. And in the meantime the enemy player can sneak up on you or fire back.
I think the biggest challenge trying to bring down an enemy castle will actually be accuracy. Its relatively easy to bring any structure down if you can freely fire cannonballs with pinpoint accuracy at their structural weakspots, but with e.g a trebuchet you´ll be lucky to hit consistently within a 20 meter area.
Walls can actually hold up pretty well, look at 5:20 in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOX0Hx1SkYw
8 cannonballs and the wall is still standing. Its the placement that is crucial
1
u/retroly Jan 31 '15
By the looks of it the force of a catapalt wont be anywhere near that of that debug.
1
u/tidder112 Jan 30 '15
When the square blocks break, do they break into predetermined piece sizes?
2
u/Matthewbal Feb 06 '15
They use havok physics, so pretty much that's how it works. It can be randomised with a few different ways to break and stuff though so it shouldn't be noticeable
-5
u/MoistCigar Jan 30 '15
While I appreciate he is probably being paid to give these video previews or equivalent. I find it a bit annoying him constantly saying how beautiful it all is, stop telling me and let me appreciate it myself
2
2
19
u/brotherofbother Jan 30 '15
This looks amazing! Although they might need to improve the algorith a little. Some of the crashes happened a little too easy i think. Then again, firing a stone from a catapult or a trebuchet would probably be very inprecise and slow, so it might just be 'balanced'