r/MathHelp • u/andreasborgelind • Jan 25 '21
Absolutely stumped by this seemingly simple problem appearing in the material I use when teaching my 5th graders. Thankful for any help.
Hi! I am going crazy trying to make sense of this problem. I think I might be thinking “too far” on it because its difficulty really sticks out when compared to the material we’re currently working on. I really hate when I can’t solve things!
Here it is:
Kevin cleans his entire house in 30 minutes. Anna cleans the house in 60 minutes. How long would it take for them to clean it together?
I’ve been using fractions and piecing together that K cleans 2/3 when A cleans 1/3, stuff like that, but according to the solution key (which conveniently offers no walkthrough of the problem) the answer is 20 minutes. I’m frustrated beyond belief and I just can’t understand how the answer gets to be 20, even less when tasked with explaining that to my pupils.
So thankful for any help! 😊
3
u/somenightsgone Jan 25 '21
Others already gave good answers but here’s a really simple way of thinking about it.
Let’s say there are 60 objects that need to be picked up for a “clean room.” Then K picks up 2/m and A does 1/m.
Therefore, they pick up 3/min together. And thus, only 20 min are required.
2
2
u/A_californica Jan 25 '21
I can't hold back from commenting that the additivity assumptions in this problem do not match the real world at all (although this is not the point of the problem and almost certainly all of your students would implicitly understand that). I don't know how to introduce the assumption of additivity in an grade/age-appropriate way; this strikes me as a significant pedagogical challenge. But it is worth thinking about.
To highlight the point, imagine doing the same kind of problem with 20 people instead of 2 people. Algebraically it could be treated substantially the same, but the result would suggest that the time is only reduced by the more people you add, although obviously a crowd of people cannot clean a house according to an additive model because by some point they would be constantly running into each other. Even two people in a one-room apartment need to spend time coordinating when working together that they do not spend if they are working separately. And that destroys the reality of the model (although not, perhaps, the utility of the abstract practice of reasoning with fractions and rates and proportions).
My favorite version of this problem was in an old algebra book where the task of cleaning the house was replaced with baking a cake. The author of that book probably never even thought about it, but the solution of the problem obviously required a suspension of disbelief as to the real world, in which baking a cake requires a certain amount of fixed temperatures and fixed amounts of baking time, and this time is not sped up even by one second by having more people stand in front of the oven.
This was a very well articulated problem, however, and best of luck introducing 5th graders to these concepts. :)
1
u/andreasborgelind Jan 26 '21
Thanks for your input! It is a challenge indeed. Gearing up for doing just that tomorrow!
1
u/MathwithTav Jan 25 '21
It’s funny this question would appear in a grade 10 problem as 1/30 + 1/60 = 0.05 or 5% of the house in a minute.
Giving 20 minutes to clean entire house.
Way too hard for grade 5!!!
1
3
u/fermat1432 Jan 25 '21
(1/30)T+(1/60)T=1
2T+T=60
3T=60
T=20 minutes.
The time working together will always be less than the time of the faster worker.
1
u/AutoModerator Jan 25 '21
Reminder:
What have you tried so far? (See Rule #2)
Please don't delete your post. (See Rule #7)
We, the moderators of /r/MathHelp, appreciate that your question contributes to the MathHelp archived questions that will help others searching for similar answers in the future. Thank you for obeying these instructions.
(Note that this is an automatic message posted on every submission by default. To add an image, you may upload it to an external image-sharing site like Imgur and include the link in your post.)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
16
u/edderiofer Jan 25 '21
Think of it another way; how much of the house does each person clean in 10 minutes?