r/MaterialDesign • u/disabledquarter • May 19 '15
Material Design = bad grade
Hi all! I made a website in material design using some stuff from materialized. My professor said it was okay as long as I didn't use a template. All I used was their css and jscript. I designed everything else and such and when I presented, I was told material design was boring and too simple and cookie cutter of a design from Google. Anyone disagree? This really discouraged me.
5
u/CuriousCursor May 19 '15
Imagine if you just picked up bootstrap and put some text in it. That's what your website is essentially, but with MD.
1
2
u/themichaelcook May 19 '15
I think that's a good comparison. Though it still seems like an acceptable approach for an intro class.
2
u/CuriousCursor May 19 '15
Doesn't say what class the website is for. Could be a web design class lol.
1
3
u/f00d4tehg0dz May 19 '15 edited May 19 '15
OP, just some nitpicking to help you out!
This page http://toolkit.cs.ohlone.edu/~gen3/Material%20Blog.html
Doesn't display correctly on mobile. If you move the page a little, the header is cut off.
The circular navigation arrow is cut off to the right. Second, its not obvious that, that is a navigation arrow. Typically you see that as a "scroll to top" arrow. You could swap out the icon with a more clear and concise version.
Aside from that, I'm not sure why your teacher said that. Best guess is they aren't familiar with Material Design. Secondly, material design at its basic form is a simple looking template. Looks similar to how sencha and many other frameworks look. Thirdly you said you used materialized? Not 100% familiar wih it. Looks like a material design framework. Which is a framework, she may be confused about that. Have a talk with them. I'm not entirely sure if your class is based on design. Or based on basic website developing.
Honestly I wouldn't suggest using a framework again until you are way more advanced. Building from scratch teaches you way way more.
Good luck! And don't let this discourage you!
3
u/disabledquarter May 19 '15
Wow! Awesome feedback! Thank you!
1
u/f00d4tehg0dz May 19 '15
Sure thing. I edited my comment to add a little more. If you are serious about web design. There is a ridiculous amount to learn and be prepared to constantly be learning forever, as new concepts, frameworks etc. Come and go. Enjoy it!
2
u/Hoogyme May 19 '15
It's hard to judge based on only what you've described, do you have a link to the website or something?
My teacher for Multimedia actually used material design as an example for good design principles and animations.
1
u/disabledquarter May 19 '15
Yeah I have a link. It's very basic. And plain because all we needed to do was show that it resizes. But she said that just because it was material made it bad and if I were to do the same site but not material, would be better. This is for "intro to Web design" We aren't supposed to know anything other than html and css
toolkit.cs.ohlone.edu/~gen3
2
u/Hoogyme May 19 '15
Are you given a rubric for the assignment? If so I would look that over and see if there is either something you missed, or if not, then bring it up with the teacher.
2
u/disabledquarter May 19 '15
No rubric. Just that it had to have media queries. Her specific words were "I doubt anything here is original"
5
u/Hoogyme May 19 '15
Well then she thinks you copied most if the assignment. It has nothing to do with the design.
1
u/themichaelcook May 19 '15
I'd recommend trying to get her to clarify what you are being graded on. Teacher's should explicitly state how they're grading, even if it's just subjective.
1
u/conRRAWWRR Jun 10 '15
A big problem with material design, isn't actually a problem with material design, but instead with how people use it. A lot of material design apps and websites tend to all look very similar, which is a big problem. Google Design wrote an article about this. Take a look at the article to see what you can do with material design to make your brand stand out, without having it look just like every other material design app out there. http://www.google.com/design/articles/expressing-brand-in-material/ . My favourite app from there is Abisko
7
u/themichaelcook May 19 '15
I think there is some validity to the 'cookie cutter' issue, but it is not unique to material design. I think it's important to distinguish a design philosophy from particular implementations of it.
She could just be over simplifying her thoughts to you. She may be concerned that your interest in material design will limit your exploration, which I think is legitimate. I've encountered good artists with signature styles who make continued efforts to practice and explore techniques and styles outside of their own.
She also might just have a subjective bias against the style, in which case there probably isn't much you can do if you want to get a good grade except not do 'material style'.
Though, she could consider the principles and guidelines of material design to be a template. That cloud be something to clarify if you haven't already.