r/Mastodon • • Nov 28 '23

Unbearable amount of political content (or why Mastodon will never take off)

5 Upvotes

Hi there. In these times, folks are becoming more aware on how the social media companies are tracking their activity online, and selling the data for AI training purposes. They're getting tired of being sold to third parties as a product, instead of being the customers or users of these platforms.

Sadly, Mastodon is losing its chance to become a real alternative to this business model. Why? Because the majority of users, me included, are no less sick and tired of online radical politics, regardless of orientation, being forced 24/7 upon them. They just want a friendly conversation on life, job and hobby topics... and perhaps also opt-in from time to time on the denser subjects of social and political issues. Mastodon claims to be ad-free... but in fact, the majority of contents over there can still be considered political ads disguised as personal takes.

An example: I went to instances.social, picked up spanish language... users and content were just the default. And this was the very first entry coming out:

"Todon.nl is een radicaal linkse anti-autoritaire Mastodonserver. Wij verwelkomen anarchisten, socialisten, (klimaat)activisten, LHBTQIA+-personen, milieubewuste mensen, intersectionelen, antiracisten, antifascisten, antikapitalisten, veganisten, piraten, mensenrechtenactivisten, enz. Als ze maar radicaal, links Γ©n anti-autoritair zijn".

The default instance on most of the Mastodon apps for the phone, is equally focused on radical politics in the feed, and its not reflective of the interests of the general public as a whole, but rather alienating. This is a boon to Zuckerberg and Musk... not to the majority of users, open source, or internet privacy. It is not surprising, given this fact, that Mastodon moderators have repeatedly tended to ban the users for the most perplexing reasons (likely because of not being politically radical enough). Regardless, not the way an alternative to the mainstream social media should ever be.

Everybody should be able to enjoy a conversation in a wide array of controversial topics if they desire to, but users should be able to opt-in, not being forced-in. Unless this changes, so that Mastodon becomes a truly welcoming site (even for the people who're sick of ideology being fed into their throats, which are many), there's no chance for it to become the alternative to commercial social media that it aims to be.


r/Mastodon • • Dec 18 '22

Mastodon instance with as few rules as possible

1 Upvotes

Looking around I noticed most instances have a pretty oppressive rule set. Like "abiding by the Mastodon covenant" (which is ghastly), not allowing sexuality, not being rude, that sort of stuff..

Are there instances which do away with that sort of oppression of speech, and either ask nothing, or only ask to abide by local law?


r/Mastodon • • Feb 04 '21

Mastodon really is crumbling β€” and it will only get worse

Thumbnail sporks.space
1 Upvotes

r/Mastodon • • Oct 18 '24

Mastodon.Social is heavily censoring news about Palestine and anti-Zionist content. This exact post got me permanently banned.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Mastodon • • Dec 07 '22

"Community" is not enough - we need commercial service providers.

Thumbnail raphael.lullis.net
0 Upvotes

r/Mastodon • • Nov 27 '22

News Jeffrey Phillips Freeman: Eugen Rochko, CEO of Mastodon, Caves to Nazi's Agenda

Thumbnail
jeffreyfreeman.me
661 Upvotes

r/Mastodon • • Dec 20 '22

Mastodon isn't sticking for most people

11 Upvotes

I was an early adopter of Mastodon in my social circle, joining up back when Car Guy first talked about wanting to buy Twitter.

Pretty much everyone in my friend group hates Car Guy, so after $h!t hit the fan, I guided a lot of them to Mastodon. Even though our full social group didn't migrate, many did, and there was plenty of us there to keep things buzzing.

But a month later, it hasn't lasted. Aside from a handful of people who became the biggest Mastodon enthusiasts or anti-Musk hardliners, almost everyone has gravitated back to Twitter, in spite of the situation getting worse and worse.

It's a shame, because when the first wave of migrations happened, people were getting about as much engagement on Mastodon as they were on Twitter, even with much fewer followers there. But now, Mastodon is pretty much dead for them, and they have no reason left to post.

I think there are several factors behind it, but there is one common denominator that I fear is going to hold Mastodon back: whenever new users give feedback, wish for a certain feature, or make a complaint, they're basically told to buzz off, or that the problem they're experiencing is a good thing, actually.

I know that's a common phenomenon in FOSS circles. But if we want the Fediverse to actually become a viable model that can supersede surveillance capital sites, the Mastodon community should be more open to change, and start taking newcomers' opinions to heart.

Instead, the general atmosphere right now is an almost religious zeal against basic discoverability features (like algorithm sorting), a bitter ressentiment towards "clout chasers" and popularity in general, dubious sacred cows like insisting on censoring every selfie or piece of food, and bad advice that has turned into memes that won't die ("it doesn't matter which instance you join!")

So newcomers wind up on a weird instance that's poorly federated, under-resourced, or run by some eccentric or pretty tyrant. They miss posts from their friends due to only having chronological feeds. They get shamed or harassed because they didn't CW a plate of broccoli... it's not really that surprising that Mastodon has proven a tough sell, in the long run.

I recognize that a lot of these issues don't have easy answers, and some things maybe should get denied (like quote toots) β€” but it would go a long way if old timers and loud voices in the community didn't just have a knee jerk reaction against change. If they weren't so quick to shut people down when they are dissatisfied with the status quo.

Otherwise, we'll probably keep losing most migrants back to Twitter. And no, that's really not okay!


r/Mastodon • • Dec 18 '22

Frustrated with Mastodon as an open source project

0 Upvotes

I just opened a discussion post on Mastodon's github and would love to hear other people's thoughts on this. Here is the text of the post:

There are currently a lot of open issues and pull requests in this repo. Obviously it's not feasible to address them all right away, so I am curious how it is decided which issues to address/prioritize? That is not really explained in the contributing page or the mastodon docs.

There are some articles about possible approaches:
https://blog.zenhub.com/best-practices-for-github-issues/
https://rewind.com/blog/best-practices-for-using-github-issues/
https://medium.com/flutter/managing-issues-in-a-large-scale-open-source-project-b3be6eecae2b

Is anything like this in place? I am the admin of a newish instance which has grown to 5k active users, so it'd be great to know to what extent I can weight in on what gets addressed here on GitHub. I've commented on multiple issues at this point and even opened one, and have no idea whether that'll have any impact.

Also, could there be more transparency as to the current set of active developers? Last question - given the growth in users, are there any plans to try and recruit additional developers , for instance via the Mastodon account or other means?

I really appreciate what Mastodon is doing and don't mean to belittle the development team or demand anything, I really just want to ask these questions / am curious to what extent anything like this is in place or will be put in place.

I love the idea of Mastodon growing, but if the open source project does not have a clear and well thought out governance/management structure I am worried about its future. There are many large open source projects to learn from in this regard, and it's not clear whether that has been done sufficiently for Mastodon.

Edit: just to be clear, my intent was not to be hostile to Mastodon or demand anything, just to ask questions. My post was rather blunt in its wording, which is my bad. I revised my wording to be less harsh. Appreciate your thoughts on this!


r/Mastodon • • Dec 05 '24

πŸ”΄πŸ”΄I need help Mastodon Users!!πŸ”΄πŸ”΄

1 Upvotes

Hello! πŸ‘‹

We are conducting a survey as part of our Consumer Behavior course at Bilkent University. The survey focuses on understanding consumer behavior among Mastodon users.

πŸ“ It is completely anonymous, and no personal information will be collected. Our goal is to analyze consumer preferences and use the findings for an academic project. Your participation would mean a lot to us!

πŸ‘‰ Click Here to Participate in the Survey

Thank you so much for your support! 🫢 Feel free to reach out in the comments if you have any questions. πŸ™


r/Mastodon • • Dec 13 '22

CW (Show More)

1 Upvotes

Hi, thanks for expanding.

Now I'm going to say something that's really going to trigger a lot of people:

Content warnings suck.

Don't get me wrong, I think it's admirable that you want to be considerate and that you're thinking of other people.

Rather, it's the user experience and unintended consequences of Content Warnings that suck.

  1. Content warnings apply to all post replies. Every long thread with dozens of replies will now have dozens of clicks necessary to expand each individual reply. This is a bad user experience.

  2. The Boy Who Cried Wolf. Some people are diminishing the value of the warning by hiding very mundane stuff behind it. CWs are bad at being content filters and situation 1 is annoying. It is thus tempting people to check the preference box to expand all CWs by default, which is inevitably going to expose people to NSFW content in their feeds and to content that might actually trigger them. These are collateral harms that are never considered.

  3. CWs are fundamentally biased against racial, ethnic and sexual minorities. Wait, what? Hear me out. The culture of demanding CWs around things like politics effectively silences these groups. They are told their views and opinions must be hidden, self censored, mostly by cis straight white people with the luxury of not having to engage in politics except by choice. Minority issues are almost always political issues: they don't have a choice. CW culture is disproportionately censoring them.

Perhaps point 1 could be solved from a dev perspective, where if you expand one CW in a thread it expands them all.

But I don't see how you solve #2 or #3.

And it's hard to escape the feeling that this is all fundamentally backwards and that end users should be filtering their own content, not having it proactively hidden for them.


r/Mastodon • • Aug 10 '21

Terrible moderation on Mastodon.social

0 Upvotes

Why the hell do they ban people so much?


r/Mastodon • • Feb 27 '23

Apps Please explain to me how do developers of free 3rd party Mastodon apps make money?

3 Upvotes

Ivory has subscriptions, but every other app I’ve seen has neither subscriptions nor one time purchase option. I’m used to the fact that developers of free apps make money by collecting user data and selling it to google, meta, etc. Is that the case here?


r/Mastodon • • Sep 16 '24

Question Biggest NSFW server NSFW

2 Upvotes

Which is the biggest nsfw server in mastodon?


r/Mastodon • • Sep 10 '25

Can't move my account due to mod

0 Upvotes

Hi,

How can I get my followers (roughly 500) to follow to my new account?

I have two mastodon accounts, one "general" one on a rather huge instance and a 100% photography oriented account on photog.social. The former mod of photog.social quit and found a new team, and this new team seems to be more concerned with politics than with photography. They announced that photog.social will become more gay (yep!) anti-colonialist and ... a handfull more anti somethings. They also defederated mastodon.social due to the expression of opinions they do not agree with. Basically ever opinion not in line with theirs is now hate speech.

I did raise a hand and asked for explications on anti-colonialism, its connection to photography and my account got suspended. That's the state of things. The new mods don't react to any requests and my objection has not even been treated or answered.

Any way to get a message to my followers and at least tell them where I am now?

Or shall I just call it a day and accept that I am at the mercy of some little shitstain and re-think if mastodon - with all its "freedom"- is only free for those who comply with some crappy ideology?


r/Mastodon • • Nov 24 '22

Any alternatives to Mastodon?

26 Upvotes

I created several Mastodon accounts on multiple Mastodon instances. I have more and more friends registered with Mastodon located on all different instances.

Mastodon is so fuxxing fractured everytime when I tried to message a frd, "retoot" or like a toot of a frd on a different instance!!!

So any suggestions?????


r/Mastodon • • Sep 21 '25

Question Would Mastodon users be interested in a trending algorithm designed to avoid echo chambers? And how "echo chamber-y" do you find the current trending algorithm?

0 Upvotes

I'm not a Mastodon user, but I am interested in how "trending algorithms" cause communities to turn into echo chambers, or avoid becoming echo chambers.

First, to people who use Mastodon regularly: do you feel like the "trending feed" of Mastodon servers is generally representative of the same voices, or do you feel that the trending feed is a representative sample of what is going on in servers?

Second, if you said "yes" to the first, do you think that if I were to develop a "mastodon posts aggregator" server that used ActivityPub to collect users' "favourites" and "boosts" from servers, and demonstrated the results of an alternative "trending" algorithm designed to avoid echo chambers, that people in the Mastodon community would find this useful? Or do you think this would just be a waste of time?

Technical Context

I consider social media trending algorithms to be collective decisions made by the members of the social media site to determine what subset of their activity is most representative of the community as a whole.

Thus, a trending algorithm is effectively an electoral system. If you understand what kind of electoral system a given trending algorithm most closely resembles, you can draw conclusions about the outcome of the algorithm based on the behaviour of the electoral system.

Your current electoral system

The current trending algorithm used by most websites, including Mastodon and Reddit, seems to be picking the most upvoted, favourited, or boosted, with posts reweighted based on age to keep the feed fresh.

Ignoring the age-based reweighting, this is Block Approval Voting. Users "approve" of as many posts as they like (by upvoting, favouriting, or boosting), and the most approved posts take the top spaces.

The problem with this is that if you have a community that is able to win the top post position, because that community likely also approved of other posts, that same community is likely to win the second post position, and third, and so on. So Block Approval Voting tends to award all "seats" to candidates that represent the same people, to the exclusion of others.

This explains Reddit's echo chamber: the top posts in a community go to the same people, and everyone who dissents never sees their dissent represented in that community, so they go somewhere else. Thus, a hive mind is born.

This motivates my first question: does your experience on Mastodon support my expectation that the trending feed will generally favour the same voices, creating an echo chamber or hive mind?

A better electoral system

Block Approval Voting is not the only electoral system where voters may "approve" of as many candidates as they like. Proportional Approval Voting and its many approximations also take "approval ballots" like a users' upvotes, favourites, and boosts, but deliver proportionally representative results instead of just results representative of the largest majority.

The specific system that I'd propose would be a variation of Thiele's Elimination Rules for Approval Ballots with a "voter satisfaction function" of `min(Harmonic(r), Harmonic(N))`, where `r` is the number of posts a voter liked that "won", and `N` is a configurable constant. This can be computed with a heapsort in approximately `O(C * logC + E * N^2 * logC)`

WTF is this electoral jargon?

Thiele's elimination rules is an algorithm for approximating PAV that works in reverse.

It begins by assuming that there are as many winners in the election as there are candidates, and that every candidate has won a single seat. This gives each voter some amount of utility, based on the given "voter satisfaction function" and the number of approvals the voter gave (note that every single candidate the voter approved at this point will have won).

Then, we shrink the "elected set" by one by ejecting the worst candidate. The worst candidate is the candidate that voters are collectively "least resistant" to being removed.

Recall that voters have some utility from the given elected set. The resistance each voter has to each candidate being removed is the difference in utility from the elected set with that candidate, and utility from the elected set without that candidate. Conveniently, for a satisfaction function of `Harmonic(r)`, the resistance each voter has to any candidate being removed is `1/r`: if a voter has only one approved candidate in the elected set, their resistance to that candidate being removed is `1`; if they have two, then their resistance is `1/2`, if they have three, then their resistance is 1/3`, and so on.

With my recommended satisfaction function of `min(Harmonic(r), Harmonic(N))`, then if the voter has more than `N` approved candidates in the elected set, then their resistance is `0`, which makes things simpler to compute, because it means that once you eliminate a candidate, you don't need to increase the "resistance to removal" of that candidates' supporters' other supported candidates until that candidates' supporters are down to N remaining supported candidates.

Once the worst candidate is removed, they get ranked last. Then we repeat the elimination, building a list of the candidates from worst to best. Once one candidate is left (who conveniently would be the winner of a single-winner Approval election), they are the best. And now you can use that ranking to populate an infinite-scroll "trending" page, and recompute it every 10 minutes or so.

And to apply age-based decay, just "nudge" each post within the heapsort by some multiplier. I considered having my algorithm treat aged posts as having approvals of reduced weight, like a Score vote in Reweighted Range Voting, where having a user get an old post in the elected set gives them less satisfaction than them getting a new post in the elected set, but I found that breaks my optimization of having a satisfaction function of `min(Harmonic(r), Harmonic(N))` instead of just `Harmonic(r)`.

This motivates my second question: if you believe Mastodon's current algorithm risks forming echo chambers, would building a Mastodon post aggregator to demo my proposal be a worthwhile effort? Or does this community think that I'd just be wasting my time?


r/Mastodon • • Dec 12 '22

Mastodon server business model ?

6 Upvotes

Hi #Mastodon friends,
Happy to be with you.
I am discovering Mastodon and I am wondering what could be the #businessmodel of a Mastodon server ?
How is it possible to earn money in order to pay server ressources ?


r/Mastodon • • Oct 11 '26

Instance woes Instance Not Accepting My Application Even With Art Examples? NSFW

0 Upvotes

Been trying to signup to certain instances for months going on almost a year now, different days, times, etc., everything - baraag specifically in this exact post case - and it's just not ever accepting my signup. Sometimes I'm not even getting an email verification link, it just... doesn't create a pending account.

I give art examples of mine - drawn, 3D created with stuff like Blender, even hosted from a few different sites like dA or Aethy, and just, nothing. Nothing at all, it's not accepting anything I do. Emailed the site devs, only to get an error in it not being a real address to email itself. If there's a secret code, I can't find anything about it even after going through all the darn policies with a fine-toothed comb several times over, spending 40 minutes one time trying to find something, ANYTHING about it.

Any reason why?


r/Mastodon • • Feb 20 '25

Question Why?

0 Upvotes

Why would someone prefer mastodon and its completely convoluted system of servers and all this technical jargon as opposed to blue sky, which is much more straightforward to use?

What could possibly be a single compelling reason to stay on such a convoluted confusing non-layperson friendly platform when you compare it to blue sky which essentially functions the same way as Twitter or Threads?

I’m not trying to become a computer engineer or an Internet scientist about networks and servers and all this arcane jargon. I just wanna have a social network that is an alternative to how toxic Twitter/X has become.

Because of Mastadon being this way, is its user base kind of a self-selecting group?

What is the central brand proposition of Mastodon?


r/Mastodon • • Feb 05 '23

ChatGPT makes running your own instance much easier, I hope this helps out some of you guys as well.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/Mastodon • • Nov 05 '22

New user onboarding is a catastrophe

5 Upvotes

Either you put a "join now" button and get people in with an email, login password

Or you can wait until Twitter's successor collapses for another go at this


r/Mastodon • • Dec 15 '23

Question Embrace, extend, and extinguish?

2 Upvotes

Moderator warning: do not participate in this post if you are:

  • planning on a bad faith, drive-by personal opinion drop without any engagement with those who respond to you

  • not planning on engaging in civil discourse

  • not interested in defending your points, claiming that any requests for evidence to back your viewpoint is "sealioning"

Below I will attempt make a case for interoperability. I may fail, there may be flaws, but read it anyway before responding, and I'll know if you didn't!

A lot of us from the worlds of Information Science, Computer Science, Internet Technology, Free Open Source Software, Software development, Hacking, Privacy, Federation, Decentralization, etc owe everything we are to the vast sharing of resources and knowledge of the internet.

You could not read these very words if it weren't for someone else having invested in, maintained, and provided a way for you access technology that takes these words from my input device to your display device.

So allow me to start with a thought experiment to set the stage for this discussion.

  • You want to buy a new clothing item. Do you go to the textile manufacturer directly, a single store that sells some items, or an online shopping mall/service that can serarch numerous outlets?

  • You want to be kept up to date on the news. Do you go to a single reporter and ask, a single news site and search, or a place like Reddit where every news ends up?

Do you or do you not understand and believe in the power, opportunities, and benefits of sharing information, and aggregating it all for the benefit of everyone?

So let's say you're on Reddit and you dislike how much spam there is in between those news articles you want to read. This is solved not by leaving reddit, or the subreddit, but by filtering individually.

Filtering individually can take effort, decentralizing the process to the entire community makes it easier, but AI would probably make it even easier by establishing what constitutes spam.

So I put this to you -- explain to me:

Why would anyone want a social network that is not social, and not a network?

The larger it grows, the better for everyone. The more interoperability, the more ideas, knowledge, and opportunities can be shared. You don't like someone in that group? Rather than defederating (the nuclear approach), you block that individual person. Problem solved. If you respond to this post, you must put "I read your arguments" at the beginning of your comment or I will know you didn't read this. So not only is defederating a last resort, but attempts to increase the network coverage should be applauded. Since Mastodon is open and fair, not developed by Meta, etc, there is no chance it could ever "lose". The worst case is the people who are here now would stay here again. The best case is people from there would join Mastodon instead. It's just like the argument of having Linux WSL inside Windows -- the limitations are clear and anyone who actually wants it for more than a simple experiment will install a real distro anyway, but the benefits are that now everyone is beginning to learn Linux. How is that bad?

I'd love to hear in what ways exactly people think Meta or anyone else for that matter, can embrace, extend, and extinguish Mastodon. You might be right, and I might agree with you, so keep it civil as this is supposed to be a way for everyone to hear all sides to make up their own minds.


r/Mastodon • • Feb 27 '24

Shouting into the void

0 Upvotes

I asked (via a poll) β€œDo you follow this account?” on X and Mastodon.

On Mastodon, 3 users saw the post and decided to make a simple, anonymous interaction. 3 out of 105 followers.

On X, nobody of the 363 followers voted β€œyes”.


r/Mastodon • • Mar 18 '24

Mastodon.Social - Test Accounts suspended without proper information

0 Upvotes

Hey,
I am using mastodon.social account for about 2 months. suddenly i received a mail your account is suspended. We are team of people who are working on mastodon integration in our app. To test various case, we used to post often. How to avoid this kind of suspension? any proper channels to reach the admin to make an exemption to this accounts for testing.


r/Mastodon • • Mar 26 '23

Bots Mastodon Bot that toots, polls, posts videos and podcasts - all created from ChatGPT

Thumbnail
mastodon.social
8 Upvotes