r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 08 '24

Spoiler Is anyone else getting bored? Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I was really enjoying the show, but the last couple of episodes feel like they're starting to drag. I was really enjoying the show too. Hopefully, the ending is more exciting.

Edit: I've really been enjoying the show. The action, the historical accuracy, the attention to detail. The production quality is outstanding. I just think the story is slowing down.

Also, I've only seen up to 6. I have not seen 7 yet.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Jan 29 '24

Is it just me, or is this not as intense as BoB?

0 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I love this show, the characters, the storyline, everything. So much so, I decided to rewatch Band of Brothers. In comparison though , the level of visceral intense reaction from watching BoB is way more overwhelming than watching this show. Is it just me?


r/MastersoftheAir • • Feb 28 '24

It's a little thing, but I wish they would addressed the superstitions of the airmen with something besides spilling the salt, or at a minimum have done it without using the "throw the whole shaker" joke.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MastersoftheAir • • Jun 24 '24

Buck & Bucky’s relationship

2 Upvotes

Am I the only one that never really saw the brotherly love/best friend vibes from the two of them?? I feel like through dialogue I can hear them talk about how close they are and other characters confirming how close they are but through actions… they deadass don’t even seem like close friends. Even like the first few episodes… and I’m trying hard to not compare to BoB and the Pacific ofc… but like, I just don’t really get a wholesome vibe, even when they reunited at the German prison camp, there was nothing emotional about it really.

Could it be the acting? Or the fact that the show, at least to me, felt so rushed anyways?

Like interviews with Austin Butler and Callum Turner give more brotherly love than what I saw on the actual show.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 09 '24

Spoiler The unnecessary fillers is low-key degrading the show Spoiler

85 Upvotes

I've been hyped since they've announced the show into production a few years ago. And here we are, March 2024 and I feel like, somewhat unsatisfied. I been telling myself I love the show but I came to terms with my true feelings...I grade it as a C-. The fillers, imo, is degrading the series. Why? Here's my take:

-Crosby and his obsession and fling with Sandra is killing the vibe. What value does it bring to MOTA? The sex scenes and all, who cares. And it's quite disgusting to see him in that manner. My wife admitted she closes her eyes when Crosby is simply shown, even not in a sex scene.

-The episode where Bucky goes to England was a waste

-Too much of the unnecessary bar talk.

-It's a bit rushed. We're going on episode 9 next week and that will be the end of the series.The show rushed to the Fall of 1944. Note: Rosenthal leadership and all is rarely shown. He was very influential for the 100th BG. In the trailer, they show him getting shot down when in reality he was shot down twice and evaded capture twice. This should've gotten more attention.

-The Tuskegee Airmen needs a spin off. I feel they brought the series more flavor. Yet, they were cut short. Lt. Jefferson was very useful for Buck and his crew in Stalag III and they could've shown this a bit more. Again, cutting out unnecessary fillers would've made this happen.

-The episode where Rosenthal and Crosby goes to the R & R place....another wasted episode (and involves Crosby and Sandra)

I'm critical of this show because I (as a big fan of Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg) hold them to a high standard. They successfully did B.O.B and The Pacific where the stories were easy to follow. B.O.B was focused on a group of soldiers, whereas The Pacific followed individual Marines yet still made the show flow smoothly. Maybe a 10th or 12th episode (which they ran out of money) is needed but I think it would've helped a lot. Just my rant. Curious if anyone feels the same way? TIA.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 02 '24

Why were rescued pilots not sent to the Pacific? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In ep8 where the downed pilots return successfully to England, they mention they they are sent home because they can’t risk getting them downed and captured again. It seems like a great risk to rescue valuable pilots just to not use them anymore.
Why not send them to the Pacific theater where they can continue fighting?


r/MastersoftheAir • • Apr 18 '24

Escort Planes

0 Upvotes

Can anybody explain why. I was baffled for the first few episodes that their were no escort fighter planes visible in the series. I believe that there's should be like it's quite irrational to send squadrons of bomber planes without escort deep in enemy lines. Or did I miss that part sometime in the series.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Jan 08 '25

Sanitising death in MotA.

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel that death was fairly sanitised in MotA? Deaths were seen to be quite quick, and fairly painless.

I think of this with the scene of the Ball Turret gunner trapped as the plane fall out of the sky. Once the other crew member gives up trying to rescue Babyface, and escapes, the bomber immediately explodes. It seemed more likely that the poor gunner would be stuck trying to escape for a considerable time until the B-17 hit the ground.

I'd expect that happened very often, and I was surprised that wasn't explored more. I think we saw one crew member falling to their death. To me, this is one of the most terrifying aspects of the bomber campaign. Not a quick death in an explosion, but a long, terrifying fall out of the sky either trapped in an aircraft, or blown out of a disintegrated aircraft. Aircraft falling out of the sky was often seen from a distance in the show.

Perhaps this kind of death in a tv show is just simply too much for an audience, as opposed to a quick death in an explosion.


r/MastersoftheAir • • May 19 '24

Making a 2nd season?

1 Upvotes

On Apple TV, MOTA is labeled as “Season 1.” Anyone know if they’re any plans to make a 2nd season? I’d love to see them focus on naval aviators in the Pacific and then shift over to the bombing campaign against the Japanese home islands from land bases. I know Pearl Harbor already did Doolittle Raid but that would be a great episode.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Dec 01 '24

General Discussion now that it's been a while, can we admit this show really wasn't that good?

31 Upvotes

i've gone back and re-watched BoB more times than I can count. Even Pacific gets rewatches. But MotA? I have not had an urge to rewatch it a single time. The show just feels sterile. Lifeless. I am incredible disappointed to say this was a let down. I could go on, about the lackluster writing, the forgettable characters, the absence of a real story, but that's basically my thoughts.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 10 '24

Weak last few eps, but for me, the show is about cgi.

1 Upvotes

I don’t really watch the show for the story or the acting. That being said, the show has created some great violent suspense such as seen in saving private ryan. Like the interrogations and the vetting in the spy network. But what I really like is the cgi of the first few episodes especially and episode 7s scene of the massive dogfight and bombs just pouring out from every plane was amazing. Just my opinion. It’s tough waiting around an hour for 30 secs of cgi, but mota has the best cgi I’ve ever seen.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 17 '24

The Bucks are villains

0 Upvotes

Had an interesting hot take after reading Wing and a Prayer…

In Crosby’s book, Harry goes up with another group outside of the 100th, but the 100th is on the run with him.

When they hit the IP, the command pilot asks Crosby to look out the window and critique the other formations.

The only group out of formation is the 100th, and it’s badly out of formation. Their position in the air is made exponentially more dangerous by their lack of forming an acceptable combat box. Crosby notices they are the most undisciplined flyers.

The command pilot then tells Croz, “this is why we like to fly with the 100th, the Luftwaffe always goes for you guys.”

This explains a lot. With devil-may-care leaders like the Bucks, the 100th ended up with a majority of dead airmen.

Are the attitudes of Buck and Bucky actually responsible for the deaths of their men?


r/MastersoftheAir • • Nov 07 '25

Why so much filler?

0 Upvotes

So much time spent on partying and drinking scenes, right now I am wastching them race bicycles...

BOB and The Pacific were gripping from start to finish.

Also the English seem to be the bad guys in this show so far (I am on episode 2) 😅


r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 17 '24

Underwhelmed

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one that felt extremely underwhelmed by this series? I’m a huge Band of Brothers and Pacific fan and ever since the rumors of this show started swirling not too long after the Pacific finished, I’ve been waiting for this series to drop. I’ve got to say when compared to BoB and The Pacific this doesn’t come close. I feel like they missed opportunities to show more dog fighting instead of useless love interest stories with Crosby etc. I still feel that the show overall is a decent watch but again isn’t even in the same league as BoB and The Pacific.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Jan 28 '24

Do you guys think the show looks too perfect? That it looses its realism, by looking too clean

5 Upvotes

I saw this from a video, that alot of modern media looks great in quality but in that, looses it's realism.

Everything just seems too perfect. The colors are too on point, it looks better then reality.

Also I noticed this series cinematography looks just like Steven Spielbergs movie "the fablemens". Kinda funny the first show in this series Band of brothers has the same exact look as Saving Private Ryan, also by Steven Spielberg


r/MastersoftheAir • • Feb 04 '24

Bombing of Dresden

2 Upvotes

I wonder if the show is going to portray the bombing of Dresden and if so, whether we’ll see the hell it was from the German perspective and what the POV’s of the main characters are going to be since it’s considered such a controversial mission.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Jan 28 '24

Memphis Belle vs Masters

7 Upvotes

Maybe I’m just an old curmudgeon, but in my opinion this doesn’t even come close to Memphis Belle. Memphis covered all of the same ground in two hours with better dialogue, better character development, and infinitely better (and more realistic) air combat sequences. The CGI in Masters is unwatchable. And compared to Band or Pacific, the non-combat moments feel contrived and forced.

Maybe it will grow on me, but I doubt it. It would have been better under HBO.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Mar 22 '24

Complaint/Rant The portrayal of the German soldiers in MotA compared to BoB

0 Upvotes

Oh yes another comparison! Did anyone else think that the Germans came across as caricatures, filling a role of being evil shouty bad guys barking at the POWs to get in to the train or sinisterly sitting across at the interrogation table smirking? To me it seemed a bit lazy. Other than when civilians attack POWs we don't get any scenes that let us understand the motivations or get a peek at the private thoughts of an officer or typical guard.

Compare it to the few scenes that Germans are featured in BoB - the Colonel surrendering to Winters, the speech at the end when the German officer is addressing his men, the two-war veteran conversing with the American soldier at the road checkpoint. To me the German side seemed more believable in BoB, and in MotA they interact with Luftwaffe personnel, SS, and I'm presuming Wehrmacht so there's some broad experiences to draw from.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Feb 02 '24

History Biggest air armada …

16 Upvotes

Noted that this series seems to not to be fully aware of the facts surrounding the claim, in a recent episode, that the bomb group was leading the biggest air armada of the war. It ignores the many previous RAF raids on Cologne, Essen and Bremen, raids which comprised of many more aircraft - up to 1047 aircraft took place in the first “thousand bomber raid” on cologne in 1942. A shame that the series chooses to ignore these facts and imo disrespectful to the airmen who took part in these missions.

You can find out more about operation millennium here.

https://www.memorialflightclub.com/bomber-command-first-bomber-raid


r/MastersoftheAir • • Feb 15 '24

Why does this series feel so off compared to the last two?

0 Upvotes

This show is easily the lesser of the three. The dialog is very cliche and lacks character development. This feels more like a Top Gun film rather then the documentary tone of the last two series. So many things happening in each episode with no explanation or further development to really help us understand what is happening at that certain point. Example, they made it to Africa, then relaxing and now suddenly they are back in England. We see partying in between missions but not much other then that. I feel as though the show was written in a way that needed 30 episodes to really help us understand what is going on but instead we get 9. I am enjoying it for what it is but I feel like things are being rushed and the story is just bouncing around with no real explanation.


r/MastersoftheAir • • Apr 05 '25

If Masters of the Air was so good, where are the awards?

0 Upvotes

BOB and The Pacific both won multiple awards and received numerous nominations. Masters of the Air received a handful of nominations and only won in sound editing.

Are there going to be more awards later down the line or will this be it for the show?


r/MastersoftheAir • • Jan 26 '24

Oddly dissatisfied..We’ll see how this plays out.

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one who’s a bit dissatisfied with the style, writing, and cinematography so far? I’m not sure what to think. Band of Brothers and The Pacific had such a raw, unflinching quality - no musical frills during combat or tense moments; it was left to you to feel the emotion, it wasn’t spoon fed to ya. So far this feels like watching a modern action thriller, not a historical piece with the gravity it deserves…

I’m optimistic though. Who else ?


r/MastersoftheAir • • Dec 03 '24

Bad CGI for Tuskegee

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one who noticed??? The show was beautiful until…


r/MastersoftheAir • • Nov 12 '23

Anyone else disappointed in the blue color-grading?

0 Upvotes

Blue color-grading really ruins the immersion in a lot of cases. It is a cheap way to make things look more 'dramatic', but I don't think it looks good at all. It isn't realistic and I honestly think it makes it look dated.

Same thing happened with All Quiet On The Western Front.

What do you guys think?