First of all, thank you to everyone who replied to my previous post with advice on what to expect, how to approach the game, what to do first, and generally how to get the most out of it. I genuinely appreciate it.
My first and most important takeaway from those comments was NOT to compare Andromeda to the original trilogy. And I really did try to follow that advice.
But after defeating the Archon and watching the post-credits scene, I have to ask:
Is that it? That's the story? This is what everything was leading up to? What the actual fuck?
Anyway, let's break it down.
Visuals and character design
The good:
The game looks beautiful. The colours are vibrant, the environments are gorgeous, and there's a huge amount of dialogue, conversations, exploration and activities. The planets are genuinely enjoyable to explore, and I appreciated the variety of locations.
The bad:
Why does everyone look so cartoonish? It's like a bunch of Disney Channel characters running around the screen.
Humans look short and slouched. Asari are tiny, almost like Minions. Salarians and Turians seem permanently stuck in some weird, hunched, knees-bent posture. And the new Angara? Why is there always some weird wind blowing around their cloaks, hair or whatever those braids and extensions around their necks are supposed to be?
The Krogan were pretty much the only ones who looked decent.
Companions
Cora:
Does she want to fight me or bang me? Her biotics are amazing, and she has great potential in combat, but personality-wise, she became incredibly boring.
It's always something about Alec, her Asari commando general, and how unfair it is that I became Pathfinder through nepotism.
Yes, Cora. I get it. It's unfair. File a complaint. You have my support, lady. Now can we please talk about something else?
Vetra and Drack:
Perfection. Absolutely nothing bad to say about either of them. Their chemistry and banter are probably some of the best I've heard in the entire game. Easily my favourite duo.
Jaal:
He kept talking about his people as if he were Javik. It was initially interesting learning about the Angara, their culture and their position in everything happening around them.
But at some point, his conversations became repetitive, his answers got shorter, and I eventually stopped taking him along.
Peebee:
Quirky kid. Funny comments. Interesting personality. But does she EVER shut up?
I understand she's curious, bored and wants to discover everything, but Jesus Christ, put a sock in it.
And her romance scene didn't help. The zero-gravity sex scene gave me serious Cube 2 vibes. I was not prepared for that.
Liam:
The only companion I genuinely found useless in almost every regard.
During the prologue, he's constantly asking questions:
"Who are they? What are they doing? Where is everybody? What do they want?"
Dude, I've been here just as long as you have. Why the fuck do you think I know more than you?
And when I die, he keeps shouting, "Where are you going*?*"
BRO. I'M LYING DEAD ON THE FLOOR. WHERE THE FUCK DO YOU THINK I'M GOING?
Ryder
I actually liked him. Good dialogue, great voice acting, and the character was brought to life quite nicely.
Every now and then he'd throw in an "I'll kick your ass" or "clusterfuck", trying to establish himself as a badass. I particularly enjoyed the moment when I was ordered to shoot the Kett woman in the back while freeing that Moshae lady.
But why does he have to be such a slut? I swear, I could romance practically everyone. Keep it in your pants, Pathfinder.
The Archon
Typical Disney villain.
We never properly get an explanation of what "the gift" actually is, why he's so obsessed with it, or who exactly is pulling the strings above him.
The random NPC introduced in the post-credits scene doesn't exactly explain much either.
The twist tricking Ryder was interesting, but that's about as far as it goes. The Archon spends most of his time throwing around random intimidating words and making threats, yet somehow never feels particularly threatening.
I was genuinely expecting something along the lines of Harbinger assuming control, even if just as a joke.
Instead, he just drops dead.
I wanted a proper fight. Challenge me. Do something. You're the main antagonist, for fuck's sake!
The story and the inevitable trilogy comparisons
I know I said I wouldn't compare Andromeda to the original trilogy, but the game practically does it for me.
The Kett conversion storyline feels very similar to the Collectors.
The Remnant and their ancient technology reminded me of the Protheans and their influence on the galaxy.
The Nexus is constantly compared to the Citadel through dialogue and codex entries.
And then there's the Genophage. STILL causing problems, even though Mordin literally died curing it. (I'm still crying.)
I understand that Andromeda is supposed to be a new beginning, but sometimes it feels like the writers took familiar elements from the trilogy, changed the names and put them in another galaxy.
The story itself had SO MUCH potential.
You start as part of an initiative whose entire purpose is to explore a new galaxy, establish colonies and build a future for humanity and the other species.
Then suddenly, you're Pathfinder.
Pure nepotism.
Was Alec a moron? Seriously, he knew he was potentially going to die, so he decided to hand the most important position in the Initiative to his kid, who had practically no experience or preparation for the role.
Meanwhile, Cora, who had been training and preparing for this kind of responsibility, gets completely sidelined.
Yeah, screw her, right?
And why is everyone so obsessed with Alec? At certain points, it almost feels like a cult.
I did, however, genuinely enjoy the Angara storyline. Their initial distrust of the Initiative and the process of earning their trust was one of the better parts of the game.
The choice between the Salarian Pathfinder and the Krogan was also a fantastic moment.
The revelation that the Kett were converting Angara was fairly obvious, but I still wanted a much deeper explanation of why they were doing it, how their society operated and what their ultimate objectives were.
There was so much room to explore here.
Gameplay and mechanics
Now, this is where Andromeda actually surprised me.
The gameplay was different, and mostly in a good way.
I loved:
\- Constantly collecting resources.
\- Researching blueprints.
\- Crafting weapons, armour and augmentations.
\- Improving equipment.
\- Exploring planets and working towards 100% viability.
\- Sending strike teams on missions and receiving rewards.
That last feature was a chef's kiss.
The Tempest was also enjoyable. Easy to navigate, nicely designed and comfortable to spend time on.
The galaxy map was pretty good too, although those unskippable cutscenes whenever travelling between systems became unnecessarily tedious.
And I NEVER fully understood the scanner.
It tells me to press L2, Suvi tells me to investigate something, I press R2 to launch a probe, scan again, and then... I can just press X and get the result anyway?
Okay, game. Thanks, I guess.
There were also way too many unnecessary, unskippable sequences.
The elevator rides between stations, the docking sequences, the galaxy map animations...
I GET IT. I'VE SEEN IT BEFORE. LET ME SKIP IT.
Difficulty and combat
I started the game on Insanity from the very beginning.
The prologue was brutal. The early game was genuinely challenging, especially when I had barely any equipment, limited abilities and enemies that could delete my shields in seconds.
However, once I acquired the N7 armour and put together the biotic build recommended by people on Discord and Telegram, things became considerably easier.
I went full Adept.
I mostly spammed Lance, used Shockwave to weaken enemies and Charge to jump around and close the distance. Combined with Barrier and a few augmentations (I honestly can't remember all of them), I practically never lost my shields.
Lance had no cooldown, and I somehow ended up with health or shields regenerating on kills. Sometimes both.
I barely touched my gun towards the end.
And honestly? That was incredibly satisfying.
Meridian – The finale
The Meridian mission was probably one of the strongest parts of the entire game.
It was intense, well executed and kept me on my toes. I actually lost my way a couple of times, but the constant fighting and enemies attacking from different directions made the whole thing quite thrilling.
Unfortunately, the Archon himself was a disappointment.
Apart from being a whiny bitch who kept talking nonsense, I kept forgetting he was even supposed to be the main villain.
And then he just dies.
No proper confrontation, no particularly memorable final battle, no real sense of overcoming a major antagonist.
I wanted more.
And finally... WHERE ARE THE QUARIANS?
Seriously.
Where is their Ark? What happened to them? Why is there practically no proper resolution to that storyline in the game?
Apparently, I need to read Mass Effect: Annihilation to get more information.
I don't mind supplementary novels, but leaving such a significant storyline hanging and expecting players to look for answers outside the game is disappointing.
Final thoughts
Overall, Andromeda gave me strong Mass Effect 2, Dragon Age: Inquisition and even Stargate Atlantis vibes.
Especially the whole "This isn't Meridian, we need to find Meridian, we need to fly this thing somewhere else to find Meridian" situation.
I don't think Andromeda is a terrible game. Far from it. It has some genuinely great gameplay mechanics, beautiful environments, fantastic moments and a few companions I absolutely loved.
But the story? The execution? The ending?
There was so much potential, and I genuinely feel like we only got a fraction of what this game could have been.
I'm going to give it another chance with New Game+, mainly because I still want to collect all the achievements.
But I have to say, once I get that 100%, this probably isn't an experience I'll be rushing to repeat.
So, what did you guys think when you finished Andromeda for the first time? Did you feel the same way about the ending, or am I being too harsh?