Please use this thread as a revolving discussion for any topical comments, questions, observations that you feel like offering -- in case it might not be a big enough subject for its own post.
Is the new goBU Oasis Wearable Humidifier mask any good?
Note: I do not have an Oasis mask and have not tested one. They have not yet been released as of the time of this post. I do not know how well they work. They may work really well. Or they may be meh. There is no data I can find on the breatheoasis dot com website showing any actual performance data of the mask.
Now, that being said, behold! The new goBU Oasis Wearable Humidifier mask.
The Oasis humidifier mask supposed to keep your respiratory system from getting dried out. It is not marketed as or intended to be an air purifying respirator. I have to wonder, does it work? Does it work better than just wearing a regular KN95 without an HME disk stuck to it? I have questions... Let's take a look at the mask as shown on their website:
GoBU say the Oasis is the "world’s first disposable wearable humidifier". It appears to be the successor to their earlier clear plastic GoBU humidity mask I wrote about 2 years ago:
The old goBU humidifier mask
The goBU was a non-filtering, uncomfortable (for me) clear plastic mask with a tight coil of blotter paper-like material attached to a port in the mask. That coil is called a Heat Moisture Exchange (HME) disk - it captures moisture from your breath as you breathe out, and gives some of that moisture back as you breathe in.
HMEs are used by other companies in other products, including some existing CPAP masks, to passively retain humidity without requiring a separate source of water or any powered accessories.
The goBu's clear plastic mask funneled all the air you breathe in and out through the HME disk to make it work. But funneling the air that way through a single small aperture and through the tightly coiled HME disk made the goBU as hard or harder to breathe through as some respirators. My testing showed the goBU wasn't much, if any, better at retaining humidity than a regular respirator. goBu offered no data to rebut my test results.
We would like to clarify a key point: the goBU Personal Humidifier is not a respirator, nor is it intended to be used or evaluated as one. Comparing it to a respirator mask overlooks its core purpose and unique design.
[emphasis added]
Ironically, they have now apparently ditched the old design and just attached an HME disk...to a what appears to be bi-fold respirator.
goBU offer no proof the new Oasis mask works
Assuming the goBU Oasis is what it seems from the photos on their website - a KN95 or similar bifold mask - I suspect the HME disk stuck on it will do little if anything compared to that same mask without the disk.
The old goBU funneled all the air through the HME disk, because that's what makes the HME work and allows it to capture moisture from your breath. But on a regular KN95 most of the air is going to go through the mask's filter media, and through gaps in the face seal of the mask.
So, the Oasis could work at retaining humidity, just as the 3M Aura did in my earlier test, because the mask's regular filter media can also trap and release moisture as you breathe through it. It's unclear what benefit the HME disk would provide on a filtering facepiece respirator.
It's possible that even though the mask looks like a KN95 mask that you could breathe through that it may be specially made and impermeable to air, making it more like the original GoBu in performance.
goBU claim that science backs up their mask, but they don't cite any evidence that the Oasis works as well or better at retaining humidity than a regular respirator, or that it works at all. Instead they have a whole page on "The Science" that doesn't have any science, testing or data on the Oasis itself. Instead, they only refer to the use of HMEs in other applications.
Since goBU claim the Oasis to be the "world’s first disposable wearable humidifier," then that means there is no existing prior evidence that their mask works since no other such masks have ever even existed until now. goBU need to provide evidence that their specific new product works, not vague generalizations about other entirely different implementations of HME disks in other unrelated products.
It feels like goBU really don't want you to read their disclaimer, but they want to benefit from it as if you did. It's at the bottom of their webpage. See if you can read it in this screen capture:
If, for some reason, you can't read the tiny, dark-colored text on the dark colored background, it says this:
OASIS humidifies the air you breathe. It is not a respirator and does not filter particulates, allergens, or pathogens. OASIS is a consumer wellness wearable. It does not diagnose, treat, or prevent any medical condition. It is designed to support comfortable breathing in cold & dry environments through passive humidification. Individuals with respiratory conditions should consult a healthcare professional before use.
That's actually relatively reasonable. Not sure why they felt a need to make it so hard to read.
Conclusion
Until goBU provide heat and humidity retention performance data specifically for the Oasis mask I have no reason to assume it works any better at humidity retention than just wearing an ordinary valveless respirator.
I'm a bit baffled that they decided to make an entirely new model of humidity mask and market it without correcting the major deficiency of the marketing of their last humidity mask, which is that the old goBU mask lacked any publicly disclosed performance data.
I'm left to wonder how they engineered either of the two masks. Did they make them based on vibes, just assuming that sticking an HME on a mask makes it work well as a humidity mask?
How do you do functional, performance-based iterations and improvements without objective metrics on performance, such as heat and humidity retention over time, and breathability? Or did they just skip testing or iterating for performance entirely? Maybe they had some quantitative testing, but if they did why haven't they shared the data?
I'd welcome any input goBU would care to provide about how the mask was developed and objectively tested for performance.
Hi everyone I read that readimask had their masks pulled from NIOSH approval. Is this true and are their other masks that are NIOSH approved that can protect against Covid for use in MRI machines? Thanks!
I live in Missouri and really haven’t seen hardly anyone masking any more after the mandates were lifted years ago. However I work in healthcare (TMS and Spravato technician) so I am in close proximity to many patients every day and I also help patients self administer a nasal spray medication, so there’s lots of opportunities for germ spreading. Recently my patients have been getting sick more and more with cold/flu season and it’s making me wonder if I should start masking again. I do care about accessibility and not only my health but for those around me with weakened immune systems. Advice from anyone who did start masking again? I suppose it’s better late than never
Lately I have been trying out wearing the bottom strap on my crown and the top strap on the lower portion of my head which crosses the straps to an X shape on the flo & zimi masks and it feels as if I get a better seal and fit?
I don’t have a way to confirm this as I don’t have access to a portacount.
So I’ve been masking for a while now using mask tape to adhere a Can99 to my nose bridge/upper cheeks. I have a high nose bridge so I tend to have leaks around the nose sometimes.
However, the years of doing so have left a big ol angry red scar on my nose bridge/face. I really want to stop using the setup I have, but don’t know what else to try.
I don’t remember all the masks I tried, but I know champak and auras and the respokare ones didn’t pass my fit test. The problem I always run into is that my face is small and my nose bridge is high.
Has anyone had luck inserting something like another wire into masks to make the nose bridges fit better? Any suggestions for another mask type? I’m desperate so any help would be so appreciated.
I'm thinking about getting the 3M 7502 respirator paired with 3M 6057 multi gas filter and 5n11 n95 pre filters with their 501 retainers.
I'm from Pakistan and can't seem to find the 2 in one particulate and vapor filters here, the ones i do find are way too expensive. I'm an art student and often work with spray paints and sanding sometimes plaster of paris, sometimes wood it really varies but paint is a large part.
The spray paint I'm working with is usually acrylic based cans so it's not oil based thus the N filters.
I want to know if this setup would be adequate for what I'm doing? The p100 2097 paired with a vapor filter and an adapter is a lot more expensive so i figured this setup might just work, it's better to have slightly lower particulate filtration with a vapour cartridge than to only have one of the two installed.
I've been getting the Breatheteq headstrap masks in small for a bit now and wanted to pick up some earloop ones too just because sometimes it's easier to wear those instead, but I'm not sure what the equivalent size would be. I have a short face that makes it hard to find masks that fit my chin properly so I'm always a little nervous to try new masks.
On their site it says the earloop ones run bigger, so I was wondering if anyone knew what the equivalent of a small headstrap one would be ? I looked at the sizing chart on the Canada Strong website and the small headstrap was in between the small and extra small earloop sizes so I'm wondering if anyone has any firsthand experience on which one is closer in size 😓
Need some last minute masks for an event tomorrow, ideally black, and these are the only ones I found from a reputable brand that will make it on time for delivery but I’m wondering if they’re real since I’ve bought benehal’s before and the packaging was different, as well as these don’t have too many ratings on Amazon. They seem to ship from the official benehal store but would like some input from anyone who might know if they’re the real deal, thanks in advance.
Due to my unfamiliarity with frame-style masks and probably something to do with being a US consumer, I’ve never understood the differences among these entities:
Rackmask Zhou Liang Ziga Zimi
Knowing the difference seems important now that there are management changes and quality concerns with one or more of these companies.
Could someone please clarify what each one does? Which of these are selling the same stuff versus fully competing? Thanks.
Hi, I ordered two 3M 9332a+ ffp3 masks but the 3M logo on one of them has a shadow. I asked the seller for a lot and secure code from the box but it only has a lot code on the photo provided to me. Moreover, the 3M safeguard website(https://safeguard.3m.com/Guest#/Validation) says it doesnt cover this mask. So, can the experienced here help me verify if these two masks are authentic or counterfeit please?
I see that the founder of Zimi is going to be launching Ziga masks soon. As someone who wears Zimi masks and doesn't deal well with change, are Zimi masks going to still be produced? Or are they stopping production?
I’m wanting to try the zimi masks because I’ve been having a lot of trouble with temperature regulation lately and have been getting very sweaty when masking. This triggers POTS symptoms for me and makes it even more difficult getting out of the house. From what I’ve read, zimi masks might be a good solution for me, but they are expensive enough to ship that I was hoping to be able to try one out before purchasing a bunch. I’m willing to purchase a sample one, but one mask purchased from the company costs $12 with shipping. If someone local has these masks, maybe I could just purchase one from you?
CC person that's new here and considering using a GVS Elipse for the first time at a rave. Curious if others would feel safe using this in a dance environment where no one else is masking/no airborne precautions are being taken.
I understand that elastomerics like this generally have a higher protection rating than a typical N95, but I wonder if others have done this or would feel confident that they'd be protected using this in a packed crowd for a few hours, especially with covid numbers being relatively high right now.
Grateful for this community and everyone's input!
Edit for clarity: if I passed a fit test in it, as I’d want to use this for raves instead of the Honeywell PAPR I’ve been using due to it being heavy/bulk/a lot to wear.