r/Mars • u/simplext • Mar 26 '26
A story about the challenges of colonising Mars
You can find the full presentation at https://www.visualbook.app/books/view/of1soz2ymjh3/maya_on_mars
r/Mars • u/simplext • Mar 26 '26
You can find the full presentation at https://www.visualbook.app/books/view/of1soz2ymjh3/maya_on_mars
r/Mars • u/Ok-Pear-2490 • Jun 29 '26
r/Mars • u/FUCKING_HATE_REDDIT • Oct 11 '25
I used to get very excited about any possibility of ancient fossiles or traces of extinct bacteria. Any news article, any new discovery. Finding a single microbe would be a civilizational change.
But now I just think, if life existed there, it would still exist.
We have plenty of extremophiles on earth that could live on Mars, at least for a few generations. That's why it's so important to sterilize any rover or probe.
So unless the change to mars was extremely fast-paced, or went through an "autoclave" period, there should still be bacteria!
Take our extremophiles, breed them in progressively more mars-like conditions for even a few thousand years, I have no doubt they could colonize the real Mars. No just crevices and underground lakes, they would end up in every dust storm or frozen in every ice sheet.
Edit: it's a bit strange how some people in this sub seem to think it's both possible to geo-engineer Mars with bacteria, and impossible for any of the alledged ancient bacteria to have survived until now.
r/Mars • u/Maximus26515 • Apr 28 '23
Hey everyone, I just joined this because I came across this video about a month ago and I can't stop thinking about it. I also cant debunk it. So I'm am reaching out for some help to figure out its validity/plausibility. Thanks everyone.
If this has been posted here before I apologize.
r/Mars • u/HammadNS • Jul 09 '22
It's surprising to see that in a world full of so many visionaries, only Elon Musk is aiming for life on Mars. Jeff Bezos & Richard Branson joined the race of reusable rockets but they aren't interested in occupying Mars.
I believe there's not much discussion around it. What do you think could be a possible reason? Why no one else is aiming for it?
r/Mars • u/reincarsonated_benzo • Jul 20 '25
They won’t call it a religion. They’ll call it a mindset. Then a culture. Then a “necessary way to live out there.”
I think it’s more of like a “controlled/monetized living”, than a breakthrough of exploration.
r/Mars • u/Tymofiy2 • Mar 13 '25
r/Mars • u/[deleted] • Jun 06 '25
Venus is a better candidate for long-term human colonization.
Not only is it more favorable overall, but its main drawback—lack of water at the cloud tops—could become the first interplanetary trade opportunity, by shipping hydrogen to the colony.
r/Mars • u/Opening-Ad5541 • Jul 05 '23
r/Mars • u/TomaszNowakowski • Aug 12 '26
r/Mars • u/retromancer666 • Oct 22 '25
r/Mars • u/Memetic1 • Oct 09 '25
You would think that an orbiting space station would be just as good especially if it's large enough to have a self sustainable natural ecosystem. You could just take a rocket or even a glider to the surface. It eliminates the long term issues with low gravity completely and simply. Why is it such a piss in some people's pudding to explore other ways to live in space?
r/Mars • u/EdwardHeisler • Feb 11 '26
r/Mars • u/Memetic1 • Sep 15 '25
Let's just imagine that we don't deal with this, and during a long term mission a woman got pregnant and gave birth. Let's assume that it does cause the sort of impacts we have seen in other animals in orbit, because it would be strange if people are vastly more adapted then mice to changes in gravity. The kid is born lives for a few months or even years in agony as their bones are absorbed by their bodies. Would that set us back as much as the Challenger disaster, especially since its really obvious its going to be a bad problem.
r/Mars • u/[deleted] • May 01 '22
There is no way a Martian colony would be worth establishing.
We can mine Ceres for water, Psyche for metals, the atmosphere of Venus for carbon fiber, burrow into Mercury for metals to create a Dyson swarm of solar power satellites.
Mars OTOH doesn't have jack - nothing that would make it worthwhile to settle.
r/Mars • u/KangarooEuphoric2265 • Jun 25 '25
r/Mars • u/Beneficial_Lock6943 • Jun 13 '26
The Absurdity of Mars Colonization: A Costly Distraction or Necessary Deception?
Elon Musk has repeatedly framed Mars colonization as “life insurance” for humanity—a backup plan against nuclear war, climate catastrophe, asteroid impacts, or the eventual death of the Sun. It’s a simple, emotionally resonant idea: if Earth falls, we survive on the Red Planet.
But scratch the surface, and the vision reveals itself as technologically, logistically, and practically absurd for the foreseeable future. A self-sustaining colony on Mars capable of serving as meaningful backup is orders of magnitude harder than rebuilding on a damaged but still far more hospitable Earth. The push for Mars may instead be a brilliant (if deceptive) motivational tool to accelerate reusable rocket technology and space infrastructure that benefits Earth first.
Mars has an atmosphere, but it’s barely worthy of the name: ~95% carbon dioxide, trace oxygen, and surface pressure less than 1% of Earth’s. At such low pressure, liquid water is unstable—it freezes, boils, or sublimates rapidly depending on conditions. Exposed humans, plants, or animals couldn’t survive on the surface. Any settlement would require fully sealed pressure vessels, underground habitats, airlocks, intensive radiation shielding (Mars lacks a strong magnetic field and has high surface radiation), oxygen generation, water extraction/processing from ice, power plants (solar is hampered by dust storms; nuclear brings its own issues), temperature control, and constant life support monitoring.
Growing food would demand controlled greenhouses with imported or manufactured soil, artificial lighting, and recycling systems. Perchlorates in the soil are toxic. Dust is fine, pervasive, and abrasive. Psychological isolation in a tiny, confined population with communication delays of 4–24 minutes one-way (up to 44 minutes round-trip) would be extreme.
For almost any plausible global catastrophe that leaves substantial human infrastructure or population intact on Earth, it would be vastly easier, cheaper, and faster to recover here than to sustain a fragile outpost on Mars.
Proponents note Mars’ advantages over the Moon: 38% Earth gravity (vs. Moon’s 16%), a ~24.6-hour day (vs. Moon’s 27 Earth days), accessible CO2 for propellant and industry, and water ice. These make long-term settlement theoretically more viable.
But the logistics crush the argument for Mars as a near-term lifeboat:
Distance and Access: Moon trips take days; Mars takes 6–9 months one way, with launch windows every ~26 months. Emergency resupply or evacuation? Not realistic.
Communications and Autonomy: Delays make real-time control impossible. Colonies must be far more self-sufficient from day one.
Cost and Risk: Delivering mass to Mars is exponentially harder and more expensive.
If sealed habitats and total life support are required anyway, the Moon is a far more practical testbed and stepping stone—closer, with continuous (if challenging) access from Earth. Many experts and forum discussions argue we should master the Moon first.
Terraforming Mars (thickening the atmosphere, warming it, creating breathable air) is even further out—likely centuries or impossible with foreseeable tech.
You suspect Musk knows the practical limitations but uses the grand Mars vision to rally talent, funding, and public support for reusable rockets (Starship) and related tech. This makes sense. Dramatic, optimistic goals have historically driven breakthroughs—Apollo being the classic example. Reusable systems that slash launch costs benefit Earth orbit (satellites, stations, tourism, defense, science) long before any credible Mars colony.
Starship’s development has already advanced landing tech, heat shields, and rapid reusability in ways that wouldn’t have happened as quickly under a more “pragmatic” incremental Moon-first program. If the Mars timeline slips repeatedly (as it has), the tech still delivers value. Critics see this as hype; supporters call it necessary vision. Either way, the colonization rhetoric sells the engineering reality.
This doesn’t mean abandoning Mars ambitions entirely. Robotic exploration, sample returns, and precursor missions are valuable for science. But treating Mars as imminent “life insurance” distracts from pressing Earth priorities: climate resilience, biodiversity, pandemic preparedness, asteroid defense (better done from Earth orbit or the Moon), and sustainable space development closer to home.
Prioritize:
Lunar bases for testing habitats, ISRU (in-situ resource utilization), and as a refueling/launch platform.
Orbital infrastructure and Earth observation.
Risk reduction on Earth itself.
Humanity becoming multi-planetary is a worthy long-term goal, but pretending Mars is a viable near-term backup distorts priorities and understates the immense challenges.
What do you think? Is Mars the right focus, or are we better served by mastering the Moon and low-Earth orbit first? Share your thoughts—robust discussion is needed.
r/Mars • u/frog9913 • Sep 11 '22
r/Mars • u/Reid89 • Jan 06 '20
Can some one achualky tell me the plans to keep people from becoming psychotic during the trip to Mars? As well as how they are going to stand living the rest there lives on Mars with same people on a dead planet? I think we can solve alot the problems but, we have monkey minds and eventually go full lord of the flies. Even musk star ship is hella small for 6 month journey and possible temp housing on Mars.
r/Mars • u/biohacker045 • Jul 10 '22
r/Mars • u/aroidman • Jun 19 '14
r/Mars • u/usestork • Aug 06 '25
ok hear me out on this. i just read this piece (https://www.legacyvisiontrust.com/blog/posts/interstellar-colonization-vs-mars) that kinda argued that a mars colony would be a huge step in teh wrong direction.
the main point was that mars is basically a resource-poor, hostile environment that could never really be self-suficient. committing to a colony there is like building a house on sand, and it would just suck up all the money and brainpower we could be using to develop tech for true interstellar travel. you know, to reach a planet that could actually support a new branch of civilization.
is mars a necessary first step, or just a huge distraction from a much bigger and more important goal?
r/Mars • u/SingleDigitCode • Mar 14 '22
There really isn’t anyway around it. When we do colonize mars, it will be done on the back of slaves. Even if the deal is work for me and I’ll get you to mars those people are damning themselves and their children and childrens children to slavery.