My wife (30f) and I (35m) have been together for approximately 10 years, and we have a 5-year-old daughter. We're currently separated, our divorce is approaching, and I'm struggling with whether I should give our marriage one last chance or accept that it's over.
This is going to be long, but I really need some outside perspectives.
Our marriage before everything happened
For most of our relationship, I genuinely believed we had a reasonably happy marriage. We had arguments, like most couples, and there were difficult periods, including financial struggles and living with my parents.
I wasn't a perfect husband. I made mistakes, and I recognize that some of our circumstances and conflicts affected her happiness.
My wife was never particularly expressive emotionally. She rarely initiated affection or difficult conversations, but she showed care in other ways. She looked after me when I was sick, remembered little things, and did thoughtful things for me.
Our sex life was never particularly passionate. She was usually passive during intercourse and sometimes complained of pain or said she didn't feel much. She could orgasm through other stimulation, but almost never through penetration.
I knew our sex life wasn't perfect. What I didn't know was how she actually felt about me.
The crush and everything that followed
At some point, my wife developed a strong crush on another man.
She admitted that they repeatedly flirted through eye contact. He approached her and offered her his phone number, and she continued exchanging flirtatious looks with him afterward.
She insists that nothing physical happened and that they never texted or had a relationship beyond those interactions.
I have no proof that she's lying about that.
However, during this general period, several things changed.
She started buying lingerie, including crotchless underwear, which she'd never previously bought or worn for me. On two occasions, I found lace underwear in her work bag. The first time, she said our daughter had put it there. The second time, she denied it was there, even though I had personally seen it.
She also became more concerned with her appearance and grooming, started taking photographs of herself in the bathroom, and became more protective of her phone. She changed her phone password and refused to show me her photo gallery when I asked.
Individually, I understand that none of these things proves infidelity. But together, and considering the timing, they left me suspicious that there might have been more going on than she admitted.
I still don't know.
What she told me about our marriage
The most devastating part wasn't the crush itself. It was what she told me afterward.
She said she'd never been sexually attracted to me throughout our entire relationship.
She said she'd experienced sexual attraction toward other men and that the crush had made her realize what was missing from our marriage.
She also revealed that she'd had another crush approximately three years earlier and that she'd already realized back then that she wasn't sexually attracted to me. She'd never told me.
At one point, she told me she didn't love me anymore.
During the period of the more recent crush, she wrote a letter that she later read to her therapist. In it, she said she hated me, had never loved me, and had now discovered what true intimacy felt like.
She also wrote that one of her greatest regrets was never having had sex with a teenage ex-boyfriend whom she'd loved intensely.
Later, she said she'd been in a very dark emotional place when she wrote that letter and wasn't in the right state of mind. She subsequently said she had loved me at some point, although she couldn't explain when or how those feelings changed.
She has never given me a clear explanation for saying she hated me.
She also admitted that early in our relationship, she'd considered breaking up with me but stayed partly because of the freedom the relationship gave her and because our families already knew about us.
More recently, she told me that, in her mind, our marriage had been over long before she developed the latest crush.
The problem is that I didn't know that. I was still committed to our marriage.
The open relationship proposal
At some point, she also proposed having an open relationship.
I can't remember whether this happened before or after the crush, so I don't want to present the timing as something I'm certain about.
But it bothers me enormously now, particularly because she says she never desired me sexually.
I wanted a monogamous marriage with a wife who loved and desired me. I never wanted an open relationship.
Her explanations and the contradictions I struggle with
Initially, when discussing the flirting, she told me she didn't regret it because it felt good.
Recently, when I reminded her of that statement, she said she didn't remember saying it.
She also told me that she hadn't considered her behaviour particularly serious at the time.
During another recent conversation, she explained that she'd disclosed all those hurtful feelings because she's simply the kind of person who can't keep things to herself.
But that explanation is difficult for me to reconcile with the fact that she'd kept significant things from me for years: wanting to break up early in our relationship, realizing she wasn't attracted to me, having an earlier crush, and privately considering our marriage finished.
She now says she doesn't know why she said some of the things she said, and she doesn't want to keep revisiting the past.
I understand that people can be confused about their feelings, and I don't expect her to remember every conversation word for word.
But how am I supposed to rebuild trust when the things that destroyed it remain largely unexplained?
My attempts to save the marriage
After everything came out, I spent approximately nine months trying to repair our relationship.
I suggested spending more time together, going on dates, reading books, discussing our problems, and attending therapy.
I repeatedly tried to understand what had happened and whether we could rebuild our marriage.
But I felt like I was doing almost all the work.
We went approximately four months without sex, and when we eventually resumed, she seemed to approach it as something to get over with rather than something she wanted.
There was very little physical affection or romantic intimacy.
Eventually, I initiated divorce proceedings.
We've now been separated for more than six months.
Why I'm reconsidering
Despite everything, I still love her.
And we have a daughter whom I adore.
Recently, the three of us went to lunch together. For a couple of hours, it felt like we were a family again.
I can't adequately describe how much I miss that.
I miss coming home to my daughter. I miss the ordinary moments of family life. I hate the idea of her growing up moving between two homes.
That lunch shook my resolve.
My wife apparently interpreted it as me wanting to reconcile.
We subsequently discussed the possibility.
I asked her how she thought we could address the fact that she says she's never been sexually attracted to me.
Her response was that she hadn't thought about it because she didn't believe I'd ever propose reconciliation. Now that I had raised the possibility, she said she would have to think about it.
That answer bothered me.
After nine months of me trying to save our marriage and more than six months of separation, I had hoped she'd have independently reflected on whether she wanted me back and what she could do to repair things.
Instead, I feel like I'm still the one initiating everything.
To be fair, she may genuinely have believed I'd made a final decision about divorce and didn't want to interfere.
But she hasn't clearly told me that she wants me back as her husband, that she misses me romantically, or that she wants to rebuild our marriage.
My biggest fear
I'm not sure I could ever trust her again.
Even if she came to me tomorrow and said she loved me, desired me, and wanted to reconcile, I think I'd struggle to believe her.
I'd wonder whether she was telling me what I wanted to hear, whether she was staying for our daughter, or whether she was once again keeping her true feelings to herself.
I'd worry that any affection or sex was something she was forcing herself to provide.
And I'd worry about discovering years later that she'd never actually been happy with me.
I don't want to spend the rest of my life investigating whether my own wife genuinely loves me.
But I also don't want to give up on the possibility of my daughter growing up with both parents together if there's a realistic chance of building a happy marriage.
I know I wasn't a perfect husband, and I recognize that this is only my perspective. My wife might describe our marriage differently.
I'm not asking anyone to diagnose her or determine whether she physically cheated. I know I don't have proof of that.
What I want to ask Reddit is:
Given everything I've described, is reconciliation realistically worth attempting, or has too much damage been done?
Can genuine sexual attraction develop after ten years if one partner claims it was never there?
How would you distinguish someone who genuinely wants reconciliation from someone who's merely willing to consider it because their spouse suggested it?
Is it reasonable to expect her to initiate the reconciliation effort after I spent nine months trying?
For those who divorced with young children, how did you deal with the guilt of not being able to give them an intact family?
I would especially appreciate perspectives from people who have successfully reconciled after emotional betrayal, people who tried and regretted it, and people who divorced with young children.
I'm genuinely torn between the family I desperately want to preserve and the fear of returning to a marriage in which I never feel loved, desired, or emotionally safe again.