r/MarioRPG • • May 05 '24

Just started playing the remake, why on Earth is Geno so beloved?

4 Upvotes

So I'm currently in the Nimbus Land portion of the game and Geno is a toy that had unbelievably lucky plot armor one night turning sentient and is now trying to track down the Stars? He never really speaks and just feels out of place with the party. Does he even have an Arc? So far only Mallow and Bowser really have.

On the other hand Mallow is an initially meek character with an unknown background that develops into a confident fighter and learns his real identity, and he's infinitely more interesting. Im astonished he's not the fan favorite of the two


r/MarioRPG • • Nov 27 '23

Geno is the players projection in the game

2 Upvotes

Think about it: Geno is up to this point never been in the series, then the mystical otherwordly "higher authority" sends him to Mario's world to retrieve the Star Road pieces. His name "♡ ♪ ! ?" can't be understood by the characters (would it make sense for these people to speak in a real world language? this is mere convention so to them our names sounds just like that) and if you are defined by what is in between your legs then she is canonically non-binary. It helps Mario on his quest to rescue Peach and fix the Star Road just as you would like to. I mean, imagine playing the game and feeling so entangled by the story that you actually wish to join Mario and help him yourself, so you are casted inside the game as a star warrior to fix the wish-granting machine. Once you complete the task you are finally able to leave from Mario's world and go back to yours, our real world. In ancient Greece, a genos (Greek: γένος, "race, stock, kin",[1] plural γένη genē) was a social group claiming common descent, referred to by a single name (see also Sanskrit "Gana"). Geno's genos is our genos.


r/MarioRPG • • Apr 01 '24

this moment is so unfun it’s single handily making me hate the game

Post image
0 Upvotes

who thought this was anywhere near fun or even enjoyable ? platforming is downright unplayable because of the perspective, combat gauntlet is plain boring and the quiz is just impossible. even with the answers in the side you only have 5 seconds to answer so even cheating is not possible. Am i the only one who struggle here ?


r/MarioRPG • • Feb 07 '24

My Mario RPG tier list

Post image
0 Upvotes

I played most of TTYD and PiT, but never beat them, if fact, the two games I have not played yet is TOK and SoH


r/MarioRPG • • Dec 11 '25

Why are we attacking people because of their music opinion?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Dec 13 '23

How to properly use the button for Thunderbolt Remake?

1 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Jan 25 '26

Game Broken Bug?

0 Upvotes

Ok so I got princess peach. The game said to go to grandpa but there's no cutsene? Is my game broken?


r/MarioRPG • • Nov 15 '23

Can you turn off splash damage in the remake?

0 Upvotes

This is the only dealbreaker for me. The game is already easy so Im wary of it becoming mindless. Being able to turn it off would be perfect and would let me play it as the original was.


r/MarioRPG • • Dec 17 '23

How to properly use the button for Shocker Remake?

0 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Dec 02 '23

The Post-game is the perfect extension for Super Mario RPG. And that's the problem.

1 Upvotes

Now, don't get me wrong here. I LOVED the Super Mario RPG remake. I haven't been obsessed with a game like that for a while. And I did enjoy the post-game, but it has some flaws, and it is the perfect extension, because it seems like it was designed the way as the rest of the game.

What I mean is it has the same problem as the Base Game, which is pacing. Conflicts resolve super quickly, the placements of star pieces, and the bosses, while interestingly designed, don't do much to flesh out their character. Especially the Smithy Gang. Booster and Queen Valentina are like the only exceptions, as every other boss doesn't feel memorable or get build-up, at all.

My prime example of this is Claymorton. You get the special Frog Coin back from Croco, return to the Mushrom Kingdom, see its overrun by pogo Shy-Guys, and then fight Claymorton in the Chancellor's room in like, 5 minutes at most. There's practically no build up, and I don't remember what his deal was. That lack of build-up is felt almost everywhere in the game. And the post-game feels just like that.

You find out that Star Hill got new wishes, you fight the new bosses, one after the other, and then the final super boss. You can literally just fast travel around and defeat them. No new areas, no new place to explore. There's nowhere to build tension and show how strong these guys are now. Doesnt help that most post-game dialogue is just:

(Mario shows up) "OH, look it's Mario and Co." (Yup, it's a me) "I've gotten stronger" (Neat) "You wanna see?" (Sure) (Fight begins)

Other Mario RPG's don't do that mostly. They have at least have a cutscene with them doing some shenanigans before they engage, establishing who they are and what they're like and all that.

And also, most of the fights are kinda... cut from the same cloth. Boiling it down to, "this thing instantly kills you." And because of that, all of them feel gimmicky. I'm not saying that you can't have gimmicky fights. This is Mario. I just find instant death a really boring gimmick. There are other ways out there to make a boss harder.

All that being said, I'm glad they added the post game. I just wish they did more with it. I like I said, one new area to explore would be really cool.

Tl;dr: Super Mario RPG is really good. Just has bad pacing and lack of build-up, at least to me. Post-game has that as well. That's why it's perfect as a post-game to this game, but it's kinda mid in the realm of other post-games.


r/MarioRPG • • Oct 12 '25

What's wrong with Toadette in recent RPGs?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Dec 22 '23

How to properly use the button for Geno Whirl Remake?

0 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Dec 15 '23

How to properly use the button for Thought Peek?

0 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Dec 03 '23

I'm on my second playthrough avoiding all optional enemies and it is still really easy.

0 Upvotes

On my first playthrough I played it like I normally would. Fighting all enemies in an area and some extra fights to get frog coins. I bought the EXP Booster from the Frog in Seaside town and used it on each member one by one until they were max level. Every boss was SUPER EASY! I was also collecting all the though peaks to fill in the monster log and was annoyed that I missed the Speardovich clone because I beat him before the clone even showed up! I also did the extra content and it was pretty fun although at max level I didn't find the extra bosses to be all that difficult. The only one I recall having any trouble with was Booster at first with his knockout move but I once I knew how to fight him it wasn't that bad.

So I decided to do another play through only this time I would avoid all enemies and only fight the required ones. I have fought a few enemies that weren't absolutely required like the Piranha Plants at Lands End you have to fight to get into the pipes as I still want to get all the treasure chests. Aside from those I've probably fought around 7-10 enemies that weren't optional. So not enough to really make much of a difference level wise.

I'm currently in Barrel Volcano before the Axem Rangers. Mario and Mallow are Level 13 and the rest are Level 14 and it is still really easy. I beat Culex when everyone was either 11-12 or 12-13 and he really wasn't too much of a problem it just took longer.

I kept track of my level at certain points. When I beat the cake in Marrymore my levels were

Mario Level 6 45hp
Mallow Level 6 37hp
Geno Level 7 53hp
Bowser Level 8 80hp

When I fought Johnny and Speardovich my levels were

Mario L7 51hp Spear L8 57hp
Mallow L7 42hp Spear L8 47hp
Geno L8 61hp Spear L9 69hp
Bowser L9 88hp Spear L10 96hp
Peach L9 50hp Spear L10 63hp

The only one that took me more than one try was the cake. I got it on my second try but all the rest I did on my first try with not much issue. Is it confirmed that the Switch version is easier than the SNES version? I know the second timed hit and splash damage makes it easier but I feel like there is more to it than that. I remember Yardovich being pretty difficult in the SNES version yet in the Switch version I got him first time at a pretty low level.

I'll still finish this playthrough but I know the Axem Rangers are probably going to be pretty easy. On my first playthrough when I was fighting all enemies the bosses were a joke. Usually ending in just a few turns.

With it being this easy with avoiding enemies to stay at a lower level I can't even imagine how easy the breezy mode would be! It seems so crazy that they put an easy mode in a game that is already super easy. Maybe we'll eventually get some DLC content for it like at the very least an Expert mode.

Just thought I'd share my experience. I still think the game is great and am thrilled we got it. It is just too bad they couldn't have added a hard mode since they knew a lot of the players would be old timers who have already played it.


r/MarioRPG • • Feb 23 '24

Underwhelming final boss

0 Upvotes

Did anyone else beat Smithy not knowing he was the final boss lmao?

I legit thought he was just another minion especially since the final bit is basically a gauntlet of mini-bosses. I even avoided using items, and when Gino left I was so worried that my strongest character wouldn't be available for the final fight.

Edit: OK, it was just me, haha. A few things that probably contributed to this:

  • I rushed through the dialogue since I was trying to save right before the final boss fight and turn in for the night

  • I played Mario Luigi superstar saga first (cackleta gives way more final boss vibes and was more difficult)

  • I fought culex 2D before and he obliterated me, so my expectations final boss wise were high

Counterpoint

  • Smithy just looks like a grunt, like his design is not very menacing

  • The minibosses before him like the clock guy were more interesting

  • He's so bland I actually had to look up his name before the first post


r/MarioRPG • • Nov 12 '23

Remake Frame Rate Issues

0 Upvotes

Is anyone else having issues with stuttering and dropped frames in the remake?

Mushroom Kingdom is especially bad. Stuttering in many places. Mostly outside in the middle of town and where there are fireplaces inside.

Kerokero Sewers as well; where there is water.

I don't think it's my Switch.......?

Anyone else having these performance issues?


r/MarioRPG • • Jan 19 '24

My Mario RPG Tier List. Feel Free to Tell Me Exactly Why I'm Right.

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Aug 27 '24

Is this just me or is the platforming in Super Mario RPG really awful?

15 Upvotes

(What I'm about to say only concerns the SNES version of the game, I haven't played the Switch remake yet)

So 2 days ago, I started playing Super Mario RPG and I almost finished it (I just saved at Bowser's keep after getting the 6th star) as I never really got to play it before and I heard nothing but constant praise towards this game and people saying it's the peak of Mario RPG (with some even saying that it's the peak of RPG in general), since I loved every Mario RPG's I've played so far (except for Paper Mario Sticker Star), I decided to give it a shot especially since it served as a foundation for the Paper Mario and Mario & Luigi games which I love so much, but I got really disappointed by this one.

Now I don't think Super Mario RPG is a bad game, however, it isn't nearly the masterpiece people make it out to be in my opinion, and one of my biggest issues with the game is its platforming, while I love the idea of platforming in an RPG conceptually, I don't think it's executed well in Super Mario RPG, it really feels like a 2D game trying way too hard to do 3D platforming. Due to that, it is almost impossible to be precise which is kind of a problem since precision is the most primordial aspect of platforming, and it is made even more frustrating by the d-pad controls which are clearly not adapted for this kind of platforming (and it really baffles me that people keep bashing the Super Mario 64 DS remake for this but are willing to give Super Mario RPG a pass for it, you can't excuse one without excusing the other).


r/MarioRPG • • Dec 12 '23

How to properly use the button for Mario’s Jump Remake?

17 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • May 27 '24

Journey to play all Mario Rpgs, mixed on Super Mario RPG.

6 Upvotes

Now for starters before I begin, I want to say that overall I enjoyed the game and it was worth the 60 dollars.

I have played all the Mario and Luigi games, Paper Mario 64, and the origami King.

Now comparing this game to the other rpgs, there are so many things that it lacks. And while I understand it came out on the snes, I'm comparing them to all the rpgs overall.

But to start with the good. The soundtrack is easily top 3 out of all of the ones I've played. The melody was gorgeous and I'm definitely going to be listening to them again some time.

The cutscenes throughout the game were charming and memorable, as well as hosting amazing characters with unique designs and beautiful worlds. All in a beautiful 60 fps for the most part.

The battle mechanics were simply but effective and pretty straightforward. Also unlike a certain other game I love how you gain exp for battles, and the enemy variety was enjoyable. And the satisfaction for landing perfectly timed hits was so real!

The story while straight forward was really effective and charming, especially the final scene of the game. I now understand why so many people adore Geno.

Now for the negatives, and there aren't that much so bare with me. I really disliked how unbalanced the game is. Despite going in with normal mode, the game was beyond easy and I never onced went out of my way to grind. I'm not expecting dark souls levels of challenge, but even the other Mario rpgs weren't this easy.

There was also a huge lack of variety when it came to customization. Very few choices for equipment, and I hate how gear only boosted attack, and none boosted magic attack. Most of the time it was just better to focus on the attack stat.

Lastly, the game is extremely short. 15 hours beaten the game, and I know I have some post bosses but that wouldn't add that much hours. I was surprised and expected it to be a little longer.

I know all of these complaints are because it was the first, but I'm comparing it to the others. Overall, an enjoyable experience and would probably land somewhere around a B+ in my upcoming tier list.

Please feel free to agree or disagree with me!


r/MarioRPG • • May 06 '25

Made a trans flag from Mallow's color palette.

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Sep 24 '24

Late to the party, but trying the remake for the first time, the animations feel… worse?

0 Upvotes

I absolutely adore Super Mario RPG, it is absolutely one of my favorite games of all time. The game looks pretty amazing overall, but something I noticed is how much less funny the game seemed. Then it sort of hit me; the animations are so fluid, it kind of undermines a lot of the visual humor. Like face-planting, it’s so much funnier when it’s instant, instead of the fluid animation of seeing him fall.

But it feels like it’s something that even carried over to combat; it just seems way harder to time your hits and defense, I think because the animations are fluid, there’s less “impact” to them.

I’m also scratching my head why the renamed Mack and Frogfucious. The first boss I can’t say I really care, but replacing Frogfucious with the generic “Frog Sage”? What’s that about?

I mean, it’s still Super Mario RPG, so it’s still a great game. But if I were ever going to recommend the game to someone who had never played it, I’m sort of feeling like maybe the SNES version might actually still be the definitive version? Which feels super weird to say, as I’m not necessarily a purist or anything. But for a game the oozes so much personality, it just really strikes me odd that “off” the humor feels because of the improved animations.


r/MarioRPG • • Apr 10 '23

Tier list of mario villains

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MarioRPG • • Dec 16 '23

How to properly use the button for HP Rain Remake?

0 Upvotes