I’m reading the outcry here from fans yesterday after it was announced the Mariners would not be bringing back JP Crawford. Many decried it as another cheap move by ownership but looking at JPs numbers, this is clearly a baseball decision.
I’ll openly admit I’ve never been the biggest JP fan. I recognize he’s been a great clubhouse guy, willingly moving to 3B this past season to make space for Colt Emerson and said he was willing to move in previous seasons of the M’s wanted to go after some of the SS free agents that were available. What he brings to the playing field though has been lackluster the past few seasons.
Hitting wise, he’s patient and can draw a walk but his overall slash line last year was .211/.335/.352. Other than moving the lineup, his walks were largely useless as he’s oddly slow and a bad baserunner for his type of build. He had 1 stolen base in 3 attempts last year. He’s only going to get slower as he’s on the wrong side of 30.
Now onto fielding. He’s bad. There’s no arguing he’s even an average fielder. Yes he can make a flashy play but he’s a major league SS, every major league SS can make a flashy play. But the routine plays he messes up too much. He had 11 errors last year and a not insignificant amount were throwing to 1st. His range is getting worse and he was worth -12 defensive runs saved last year.
Other reasons we need to move on from him not directly related to his performance are we need to get less left handed in our batting lineup, he’s no longer the veteran in the clubhouse as Naylor, Cal, Julio and Donavan should all be looked at for veteran leadership from position players, and he really has no clear spot and he’d be very limited as a utility player to SS and 3B.
JP is going to be playing the rest of his career on 1-2 year contracts for probably $5-$10 mil on teams that probably don’t have a real chance at the playoffs. Teams that want to contend don’t hang on to players for sentimental reasons when production is clearly diminishing.