One popular Marathon criticism is that it's just too niche. Many players have concluded that, despite the gunfeel or design or lore, it's just "not for them" because they'd rather not play a hyper-sweaty, PvPmaxxed extraction shooter.
And to be clear, it's super fine for a game to just be "not for you!" People are allowed to have preferences and to pass on whatever they want. My concern, however, is that Marathon is getting labeled as one thing, but in fact has a feel, style, and gameplay loop much closer to something else.
If you were to browse my Steam library and look for PvP games, there's a pretty consistent story: I often play for 10-20 hours, then dip. It's mostly...just not for me. It happened with CoD, with Valorant, with Apex. I don't get enough of a thrill out of the same PvP arena fights over and over (I also kind of suck, in the spirit of full transparency).
But with Marathon, I have 130 hours. And my path to that 130 was eerily similar in pace and gradually growing enjoyment to, say, my first time playing Dark Souls or Hollow Knight. Initial skepticism. Early frustration. Dozens of punishing deaths. But little by little, things would click, I'd go deeper, and eventually, I'd realize it was one of my favorite games ever.
I wrote this point already in a broader thread a month ago, but I think the single-biggest question for whether someone will like Marathon is:
- NOT do you like extraction shooters
- NOT do you like sweaty PvP
- BUT INSTEAD do you like the learning process of dying many times in a row on the way to overcoming something that seemed impossible, like a Dark Souls boss?
Gradually acquiring map knowledge, balancing your kit for the contract or team at hand, understanding when to engage vs. disengage, customizing your looting plan, intentionally playing for stealth over conflict...these are all super satisfying things to learn that have nothing to do with "did I click on the other guy's head faster and more times than they did?"
I have a feeling that 80% of players would still answer the "dying many times" above question with a "no." But I think 98% of players would say they don't want "hyper-sweaty PvP extraction." That 18% gap, in my opinion, is one big area where Marathon could do a lot better if somehow it were able to shift perspectives on which sort of player would actually enjoy the game.